Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Shane45

Premier Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Shane45

  1. Big surprise, I agree with HE In my humble opinion, the P90 has a very, very narrow scope of mission usefulness. If I where LE doing a high risk entry on BG's with a high probability of wearing armor, then I might pick it. Otherwise, not so much. IMO the P90 is a pistol alternative, not a rifle replacement. I think many miss that point. On the pistol front...case studies like the one of the bad guy saying to the officer, "can you please stop shooting me with that", don't exactly inspire confidence!
  2. Actually 2Alpha, I think this is my next build!!!
  3. I believe Dover PD used to before they went to HK's. I don't know what they carry today. I believe some officers on Stafford carry a 1911. I CAN see why a department may not want one as the standard, but having the option is pretty progressive. Im betting the choice of a dept duty weapon is directly tied to the percieved minimum amount of rank and file training you can get away with based on the selection.
  4. On the topic of tolerances, a properly built 1911 can maintain tolerance and reliability. An interesting test done by Mr. Larry Vickers: "Sand Test Just had a chance to do a harsh sand test on few different handguns. This test was not scientific but was very enlightening. Pistols tested were; HK USP Tactical Customized 1911 rack grade GI 1911 Glock 21 Test consisted of placing each pistol loaded in a Bianchi GI field holster inside a plastic bag with approx 2 cups of fine/medium grit sand ( North Carolina type). Then the bag was shaken vigorously for 10 seconds while holding onto the pistol butt for safety. The pistol was then taken out and 3 mags were fired through the 1911 and 2 fully loaded mags were fired through the HK and Glock - roughly the same amount of ammo. The sand coverage was very good and uniformly covered the pistols. The pistols were loaded in the mode you would expect in a field environment - condition 3 for the 1911, loaded for the Glock and loaded in DA mode for the USP.A test was done dry and lubed with TW 25B. This test represented EXTREME sand conditions - not normal field use, even in sandy conditions.A brief rundown of the results follow; 1)Carrying your gun dry in this environment is a NO GO despite what some will say. All pistols performed worse dry than lubed. 2)All pistols required some manipulation in order to fire - none would function normally straight out of the holster. 3)Overall the HK USP performed the best - the performance of it dry was roughly the same as the customized 1911 but was definately the best lubed. Overall it performed well. 4)The custom 1911 was second - interestingly enough the trigger track was not a real problem - the sand that went in through the ejection port to the bottom lugs area caused the most problems. Once the sand shifted in this area the pistol functioned better. 5)The rack grade GI 1911 was a distant third - the custom 1911 had an 18 pound recoil spring and that helped with feeding greatly vs the rack grade gun. Swap out the recoil spring and it probably would have done better. 6)The shocker of the day - the Glock 21 FAILED terribly. The big problem was failure of the trigger to reset. Also at times the pistol would not fire due to sand in the trigger mechanism. The dry test could not even be completed with the Glock due to this.This surprised all of us as we expected the Glock to do quite well. Moral of the story; The 1911, even in its customized mode, can get the job done if you set it up to succeed. Lube it right, carry it in the right holster and in the proper mode, and it won't let you down - just like it hasn't for nearly a 100 years. The HK USP series are good guns - well designed and well made - for service pistols. The ergonomics hurt the pistol dramatically but for an out of the box service pistol/field gun, they get my endorsement. The Glock 21 is a dog - always has been. It has the rep of being the worst gun Glock makes. I have a Glock 17 and 19 and like them for what they are - but don't get sucked into the Glock hype - they are not magical guns. Remember what your dad said when you were in 3rd grade; don't believe everything you read. Hope you guys got something out of this - I did." Larry Vickers
  5. Yes Shawn, but the point is your disqualifying logic is flawed. For those with capacity concerns, seriously, if anyone has any links to any civy incidents where capacity played a part, I would truly like to review them.
  6. Shawn, you have to many logic flaws rolling to correct. Like others have said, if you dig the sig, carry on. But your reasonings and assumptions on operating a 1911 are....uninformed. You talk about operation under stress. Are you sure you will remember to decock after you just shot at someone and now have to move and engage a threat in another area? Now you have a cocked gun and now have to point in a safe direction to decock. A lot to think about instead of instictively flicking a safety.... This is why it is a better idea to trust the safety between your ears instead of relying on a gismo!
  7. "I don't like the idea of having to thumb the hammer to decock it." This makes it clear to me that you do not understand the manual of arms of a 1911. This is absolutely the most unsafe way to handle a 1911. "Also when unholstering a gun I'd prefer point and click. The first trigger pull is longer but it's better then messing with a safety." Those that are dedicated to the 1911 have no issues with the safety. But I will concede that a 1911 is not for everyone like a superbike, a Z06, or an Indy car are not for everyone. I don't see it as point and click on a sig. I see it as point, pull, pull some more and eventually it will go off LOL. On a 1911 its clear the holster, two thirds up click off the safety, and end with truly point and click. jrfly, I briefly had the FNX45 Tactical. With the flat backstrap I could make due, but I just couldn't warm up to it and honestly believe someone with small to medium hands would really have an issue. With that being said, if the size does not bother you, rock on! I think it would be a good HD pistol.
  8. jrfly, have you handled an FNX 45? I have fairly large hands and I find it big! I think those with small to medium hands will find it a no go. Shawn, I am truly having trouble following your logic. How is it easier? What exactly is the difference between flicking the safety on on a 1911 vs decocking your sig? A couple of differences I see. A 1911 cant fire from flicking on the safety! So I guess a decocker is not a mechanical device that can fail but a safety is? I wont pontificate on your view your finger on or off the trigger is me being nit picky, but I don't see how you can say the operation of one is safer than the other. I think many that view the operation of a 1911 as somehow more dangerous than others simply do not understand the mechanical operation of the 1911. Dave, a revolver is not infallible. I have commented in the past on seeing an inordinate amount of revolver failures. I see MANY more semi's on the line so the amount of revolver failures I have seen seem high for the # of revolvers I see. My own Python got bound up when the firing pin pierced a primer and stuck and would not allow the cylinder to rotate. I witnessed an empty somehow get under the extractor star on a reload on IIRC a ruger security six. I watched a ruger gp100 get bound up when the hammer block(not sure of the actual part name) got bound up somehow. I watched a firing pin break on a smith. What I will agree to is that a revolver may be less likely to have a shooter induced malfunction within its own capacity.
  9. I dont know of a one stop shop for high end glass in NJ. What range do you shoot at? Currently I have a hensoldt 4-16 and a USO 5-25 in the stable . I hooked Tactical Monkey up with a Steiner 5-25. If fortune would have it that we shoot at some of the same ranges, you could get some hands on. But IMO it would be hard to go wrong with the Steiner, Kahles or S&B. I actually would like to try a Kahles myself! Its one I havent owned yet.
  10. This is anoter debate entirely. "9mm because the terminal ballistics of modern JHPs makes 9mm just as effective as .45". I would take exception with "just as effective" BUT I may accept close enough to only make a difference in some cases. In my mind it could truly be a 6 on one hand, half a dozen on the other scenario. On one hand with a 9mm you may have more chances to cause a hydraulic leak in a vital. On the other hand, a .45 has a better chance of making it to said vital. The question becomes how long are you going to get to try and hit said vitals? Im thinking most people being shot at arent going to wait aroud for 1 of 15 to hit the mark. There is a former city LEO that went on to hold a position performing criminal autopsies. So he collected information from the perspective of effectiveness of pistol calibers. The salient points I came away with from his report was that a)deceased from 9mm always had many more shots in them compared to 45. b)the wound channel of 9mm was deflected, in many cases, away from hitting a vital organ from impacting bone etc etc where the .45 continued on path to connect with the vital. One could infer that, generaly, those hit with a single or few 9's walked away compared to those hit with a single or few .45s who expired. The second inference is self evident that from the perspective of the guy cutting open the bodies on the slab having a look, the .45 is more effective. The author of the report will NOT carry a 9mm. FWIW. In terms of capacity, I have not had much success finding cases of protracted gunfights for civilians. I perfectly understand its application in terms of mill and even police. But there should be an understanding that ALL scenarios and needs may vary. Consider the Navy SEAL's have adopted the HK45C that is in .45 and only holds 8 or 10 depending on which mag is used. I know some departments prefer .45 because they feel there is a real possibility of having to shoot through a windshield. Reportedly the .45 is better in this regard. The point is I would recomend assessing your own needs and considerations as they may be different from those of a department, agency or military. On the topic of reliability. I dont care what it is, it needs to be vetted. For many, 500 to 1000 rounds is the minimum count without issue. The reliability issue with 1911 complaints are an irritation to me. It was designed at a time when labor was cheap and technology was expensive. Today the reverse is true. But the 1911 was not designed to be built this way. It was designed to be built by human hands from quality materials. A 1911 built as designed is an expensive pistol. As would a Luger made in this day and age. But when you have MANY different companies all racing to the bottom, your are going to get crappy 1911's!!! Economy of scale can only account for so much. Consider that I buy parts at wholesale or close to it. It still costs me over $1000 in parts without ANY labor put into the project. So how good can a $500 1911 be? To put it into perspective, how good would a knock off glock be at around the $150 mark? I propose it would suffer the same way. Here is a question. Is there a point to having ANY pistol that can go session after session without lube or cleaning past 1k rounds? My car may be able to go 20,000 miles without an oil change, it doesnt mean I should right?
  11. Training, in my mind is a given. But the issues go a little deeper in my opinion. So seperating the details is likely in order. Who is really clearing their own house? Who really feels qualified to do so? This question raises a lot of specific circumstance questions. Would I clear my own house if I were single? Yeah probably. Would I if I had dependants in the house? If you are the only line of defence and you go down, who is protecting them after? Im sure some have spouses capable, but some do not. Every circumstance is different but I think, generally speaking, if you know you have enemy in the wire, your moving to a protective, defencive position and calling police. If this is not your thinking, I would suggest you reconsider. Conversely, I am of the mind set that less "official" involvement in my life, the better. We have all reviewed the cases of good people calling for help and ending up being the ones treated like the criminal because they had the misfortune of getting an unlucky draw of the officer that responds who, lets just say for example he is the guy the chief had to pull his ticket book because he is so.....overzealus. So I do not want to call the po po for every bump in the night. I WILL call (and have called) if I get the sense I really have a problem. This is why I prefer a handgun because for me, it is a lower risk investigative looksee and I dont want to get caught out in the open on the off chance a real threat emerges. To checker 50's point, a pistol, in my situation, is easier to keep secure out of sight and have quick access to. Teenagers at home and sometimes not all mine. Back to the topic at hand, there is NO reason a 1911 would be inferior in any way to any other type of pistol. It will all depend on your dedication to being proficient with your choice 1911 or otherwise.
  12. It was under the impression this was not NJ legal since it says M14 on the reciever.
  13. Not to turn it into a long arm vs pistol debate but I much prefer a pistol. I concede that for reasons of overpenetration and effectiveness a rifle is a better choice. But for me, I prefer the concealability of a pistol. My view is that in having the ability to conceal the pistol, I dont raise any alarms. I can investigate without triggering a swat team descending on my position should it turn out to be a false alarm. That and I am very confident in my abilities with a 1911.
  14. I guess some guys just have a thing for Lorena Bobbitt
  15. I agree that the weight is similer between a scope and mount vs an Elcan. However, I think there is more to the story. I think the way all the weight of an Elcan is concentrated into a short chunk vs possibly a wider distribution and maybe the lever effect of hanging a scope foward makes it balence much better. However the mass is centralised on a SCAR17 the Elcan balenced well but "felt" much heavier on other AR pattern 308's. It disrupted the balance of the rifle. Even more so then a S&B 1-4 for example. Also, I believe TM's excerpt was from a previous post comparing several optics. So it may not be heavier than a comparable scope, it certainly is compared to an Acog for example.
  16. I think the weight is deceptive. Because everythig is rearword, when you first hold it, its torquing to the rear making it feel heavy. But when you get into a shooting position, the weight vanishes because its all up against your shoulder making it feel light and maneuverable. Would I have preferred it weighed a little less, sure. I like my rifles to be about 8lbs including my optics etc etc.But itsnot horribly heav.
  17. You sure arent walking away a man! Any man I know would have simply admitted they spoke in error. You would have prefered, by your own admission, to just delete and hide your mistake. It speaks volumes to me about you.
  18. "Actually I would have just deleted it but you can't." Yeah it seems like just hiding your mistake would go hand in hand with your view that finger on or off the trigger is nitpicking.... The women I know dont have an issue admitting their error, so what does that make you?
  19. Way to be a pussy and not just grab a hold of yer sac, make sure you still have one, man up and correct yourself.....
  20. There is no secret decoder ring. Simply put, many times as the group coordinates its efforts with other org's to keep from duplicating efforts or undoing another org's efforts, NJ2AS will often get made privy to an undertaking, but not at liberty to discuss what the other organization is planning or pursuing. In that case, it cant be publicaly discussed. Simple as that. But if what they are doing has merit and is a good actionable item, we are fine with standing down or even assisting which has been the case several times. I suspect all org's involved in this struggle share this dillema. As to CCW, I think thats been covered well enough.
  21. HE, technically he is right! If you reach around and underneath with your left hand and push it you can keep your finger on the trigger LOL! Shawn, there are those of us on this forum that prefer technical accuracy in the discussion and especially in the description on how to manipulate a product or device. Personally I dont run a BAD or otherwise as my AR's have a right side internal bolt release. But just looking at the pic you provided, it would seem clear you need to take your finger off the trigger to operate it. Which is why I certainly feel your statementon how you dont have to take your finger off the trigger is certainly suspect! "Shawnmoore81 Posted Today, 11:58 AM You don't have to take your finger off the trigger Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk HD "
  22. My sarcasm followed your dickie comments. I give some actual experience, you know, what the op asked for, and all you have given is ....what? I asked you for some input on your suggestion, the vortex. Again, nothing useful. How about posting something usefull in this thread... whats your current set up? Hows it work for you. What doesnt work? Use tactical monkeys post as a template.
  23. 2Alpha, looking at some of your other posts, they seem on track, informed, and from a position of some experience. Im not sure why this thread seems to have gone off the rails. Do you have some inner Elcan hatred going on or what LOL! Vlad I think its a one sided argument. the only thing I really contested was the eye relief. I was more in the open optics discussion spirit and really wanted some razor 1-6 intel.
  24. 2Alpha, do you actually own anything the grown ups are talking about? Because after repeated requests for solid intel, all you have provided is keyboard commando internexpert banter. IIRC I did win that match aside from having the best single run. But more to the point that you clearly do not understand, having a faster time and accuracy with a 308 against a field of 5.56 rifles(including my own!) illustrates the advantage the Elcan held. But I'm sure everyone else understood the point.
  25. I agree with those comments. Really that is the hardest thing, getting hands on high end optics. I'm fortunate that I get to get hands on most offerings out there, but when I cant, it certainly is a rough row to drop serious cabbage based on the opinion of others. What I can say is that I do not run an Elcan today. The rifle I had it on it was great. But my current rig feels the weight of the Elcan and doesnt balence as well so I have gone a different route. It is a pretty heavy optic. But it really shines in a environment that has radicle changes in target disposition. I am not a 3 gun shooter. But I have attended some private matches that were sort of like a 2 gun tactical oriented match. Targets where engaged from 5 yds to 100 yds on the move, from cover, etc etc. I posted the best single string score of the match shooting a 308 against a field of 5.56's. No consideration given for larger caliber. I absolutely attribute it to the Elcan. Im fractions of a second off an aimpoint on 1x and gained considerable time over others transitioning to 100 yd targets with the flick of a lever. The sun was foward of the targets and this gave a lot of people with red dots fits, including myself with other T1 micro outfitted rifles I ran that day. But the Elcan's ability to go near instantly 4x made picking up the targets a snap.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.