Everything posted by vjf915
-
Choice of weapon for home defense - potential legalities
Caliber has absolutely no bearing on a justifiable shooting whatsoever. This is not common sense, this is how the law works. If it was a legal shooting, with a legal gun, then there is nothing wrong with it. As I stated in the other thread, and as some stated here....deadly force is deadly force. If it can kill you, you can respond with something that can kill them. Bottom line, end of story, period. There is no discrepancy of deadly force between a midget with a 2 inch knife, or a 6'6", 300 pound linebacker with a AA12. If your life is threatened, then you can respond with whatever form of deadly force that you see fit. There is absolutely no legal difference between defending your life with a .50 Desert Eagle or a 1911 in .45, or my grandpa's single shot bolt action .22. What you SHOULD be concerning yourself with is making sure you understand the laws surrounding defending your life in your home, and what you should do if the situation arises. Do you know what constitutes as threatening your life? Do you know what a deadly weapon is? Do you know what the distance is that you may shoot an intruder who has a knife? Do you know how to articulate that this intruder was threatening your life? These are just some things that you NEED to know if you ever plan on defending your life inside your home, or outside if CCW ever comes to NJ.
-
No refusal" DUI checkpoints could be coming to Tampa
How does that make it acceptable though? I understand your point, and it is a valid point.....but that doesn't mean we should let it slide. If you let it get to the point that someone is driving with the disregard to the safety of others, then someone is already in harms way. The point is to STOP people from driving under the influence....not have something to charge them with after they already run someone over. And again, I understand where you are coming from....but what you are suggesting would require the laws to be left up to so much interpretation and so much discretion of the officer, that it would be way too easy to challenge in court. Laws that are clear cut, yes and no, good and bad, black and white.....those are the laws that are hard to fight. Here is an example: George is driving down the street with a BAC of .15. He is clearly intoxicated, and it is obvious that his intoxication is inhibiting his ability to safely operate his vehicle. Officer Smith witnesses this, and pulls George over. Scenario A: George blows a .15 into the breathalyzer, gets arrested. During trial, evidence is shown that George blew a .15, and he is convicted. Scenario B: The officer performs various tests on George to determine whether George has a high enough tolerance to safely operate his vehicle. There are two things that can be done, Officer Smith can either arrest George, or let him go. 1) If Officer Smith lets George go, and later that night George injures someone with his vehicle due to his intoxication, Officer Smith will get sued by the individual or family of the individual who was injured because he should have arrested George. 2) If Officer Smith does arrest George, then George's defense attorney will immediately go straight to questioning Officer Smith's credibility, and what training he has to determine whether George was actually intoxicated or not. In a perfect world, your idea would work. We are FAR from a perfect world, and I am sorry.....it would not work. With having a legal limit, it is as close to cut and dry as possible.
-
Challenging NRA Instructor re: NJ Firearms Laws (And PA)
OC is totally legal in PA as long as you obey the laws surrounding it. I know a guy who open carried an AK style pistol.
-
Armed citizen rescues Marine in Florida
Even if you didn't want to get involved with your weapon, that still doesn't mean you couldn't get involved other ways. I have never witnessed a situation where someones immediate safety was compromised.....but I have certainly been the first, and only, to help when someone needed help. So I like to think that I would certainly try to intervene if I could. If there was one guy getting his a** beat by 10 guys, there is no way to help other than be a good witness. But if it were one, maybe two....then I would jump in.
-
No refusal" DUI checkpoints could be coming to Tampa
I agree with you, I don't like the levels either. That's why I think it should be illegal to drive under the influence of ANY substance, regardless of the amount in the persons system.
-
Good to Go
Right now I am using my PAP because it is honestly the best gun I have for HD. It is by no means a good gun, but it is certainly better than my Mosin, SXS shotgun, or .22. What someone should do when it is the first HD gun they will ever have is just get familiarized with the weapon by shooting it. That should be the BARE MINIMUM.
-
Good to Go
I'm sorry, but you are dead wrong (no pun intended). Excessive force is not judged by the caliber bullet your firearm shoots, it is judged by the threat posed on your life. You can legally respond with as much force to combat the threat being posed upon you. Want an extreme example? *I am 6', 200 pounds. I am sleeping, and wake up to hear someone in my living room. I grab my HD gun which happens to shoot 7.62x39. I go into the living room and turn on the light to find a 4', 80lb woman who is trying to steal something. She picks up a letter opener that is 3 inches long and brandishes it in a way that I feel poses a threat to my well-being.* That is the hypothetical situation I will use. Now, a letter opener can cause harm to my body, and even kill me. I can legally shoot her with as many rounds of 7.62x39 as it takes in order to "stop the threat". If I continue to shoot after she no longer poses a threat, that is no longer a justifiable defense. But if I shoot her 8 times with 7.62x39, and she is somehow still standing with that letter opener in her hand.....there is nothing excessive about the 9th shot. As for the topic at hand.....I think it depends on a couple things. What is the users experience with firearms overall? What kind of weapon is it? I think that a semi-automatic pistol needs more rounds down the tube than a revolver.....and a revolver needs more rounds than a pump shotgun.
-
No refusal" DUI checkpoints could be coming to Tampa
No offense but....what the hell does a checkpoint have to do with a fair trial and proper representation? I am really interested in the answer to this question. My opinion depends on how this is played out. If they use this every once in a while, and there is no major wait....I am fine with blowing in a machine in order to make it easier for them to catch some scumbag who could continue on to run over a child, or cause an MVA that kills others. If it severely impedes my way of travel, then I would have a problem with it.
-
Robbed again
It's called victim services. Your daughter should be notified throughout the entire process.......if he posts bail, I think what jail he will be at, when the hearings/trials are, and when he is released.
-
AK buying advice
Who would have ever guessed Joking, I actually PMed PK90 earlier about possibly doing a transfer for one.
-
GSP Drama.. where did all the traffic come from..
That's funny. I thought this thread was about this guy:
-
Knife Law - Two Part Question
Some parts. I happen to like the surroundings of upstate NY very much. I remember driving up there in my dads Corvette, t-tops off. I would be cruising along, next thing you know I'm doing 50 because I was just so captivated by the scenery. It really is a beautiful place.
-
SAF v NJ (MULLER et al v. MAENZA et al)
Wow.....it seems like this bug is spreading across the nation.
-
Knife Law - Two Part Question
I wasn't entirely sure myself, as the wording can be pretty confusing. But I do remember discussing it in another thread, and someone explaining it that way.
-
Knife Law - Two Part Question
Unless I am mistaken....that is the TRUE definition of a gravity knife. Nothing wrong with them "labeling" it as such.
-
Man Arrested at Miami Airport After Bullet Parts Found in Bag
THANK YOU!!!
-
Professional Opinions Wanted
If he is currently making $80k.....I think that is substantial enough that the current employment would be best for him. I don't know how old he is, but $80k a year until he retires is MUCH better than $120k a year for a little while until the company flops in 2 years.
-
AK buying advice
I have two suggestions..... 1. If it isn't a horse, don't call it a horse......don't refer to it as an AK. 2. Don't take an AK variant that is meant to shoot 7.62x39......and get one in .223. That's just my advice, take it for what it is worth. It also depends on what you want. If the original "AK" look is what you want.....then you will be in the market for a different rifle than if you want a "tactical" rifle.
-
Armed citizen rescues Marine in Florida
I would have to agree with this statement 100%. There is a difference between getting in a bar fight, and defending your/your girlfriends life. There is also a difference between disabling the threat, and "overkill". I think a couple factors play in here....just as they would to us defending our homes.
-
Man Arrested at Miami Airport After Bullet Parts Found in Bag
I know what really happened from an insider. The story itself is true, but they will not be charging him not based on the fact that it wasn't an act of terrorism.....it's because they weren't cop killing bullet parts. If they were cop killing bullet parts, they would be charging him accordingly.
-
"Cool" gift for AK fans
Because that is the only way the ice will come out clear.
-
OFFICIAL Brian Aitken Thread
No. The only way someone can take advantage of a changed law or penalty is if the change occurs BEFORE conviction. Also, if a change does occur, they will get the lesser of the penalties. Let's say the law was 1 year per hi-cap mag. Let's say BA was arrested, penalty changes to 6 months per hi-cap mag, then convicted.....he gets 6 months per hi-cap mag because that is the lesser penalty. Let's say he is arrested, penalty changes to 5 years, then convicted.....he gets still gets 1 year per hi-cap mag because the penalty changed after arrest. Neither would change BA's case, as he was already convicted. The only option he has right now is to appeal.
-
Knife Law - Two Part Question
To a trained eye....yes. However, many "security" personnel are bound by rules, and risk their job by bending the rules. I have to say, I feel like you were lucky by getting in with the knife. In that line of duty, I have to assume that many of them will err on the side of caution. Don't get me wrong, I am a firm believer that if someone wants to commit a crime.....they will commit it regardless of what tools they have handy.
-
Armed citizen rescues Marine in Florida
That's the scary part. Even if CCW comes to be in NJ, I would still be scared to use it!! However I would, as I (cliche time) would rather be tried by 12 than carried by 6.
-
"Cool" gift for AK fans
Single stack, 10 round mag......this should work in my Zastava PAP.