Everything posted by vladtepes
-
How to Pin Magpul CTR Stock without Drilling
I appreciate you relaying the information of the case.. as it is HUGE for gun owners.. to have an actual case where someone had an AW per AG guidelines and WON is huge.. and VERY important to hear about... and I appreciate you relaying that info.. in slightly more detail..
-
How to Pin Magpul CTR Stock without Drilling
what he is likely saying is the opposite.. what he is probably saying is he tries to cut people a break.. he tries to not be a dbag.. but if he is involved in a situation where an individual is less than cooperative and causes issue.. then yes he presses the issue.. he is using his discretion as officers do every single day...
-
When is a magazine not a magazine?
your google skills are epic.. lol if they reject temp block.. which is an assembled mag that can only hold 15.. then I am pretty confident a disassembled 30 rounder would be a big bunch of fail as well..
-
When is a magazine not a magazine?
I agree completely.. and generally the lack of a test case in a very pro-prosecution state like NJ would be enough for me to say go for it.. but I am just really unsure about this one instance.. but I completely agree with you... when the law is unclear as it is IMO in this case.. then looking for a case to reference is the way to go.. I have always wondered why they would instruct dealers that it HAS to be permanent but ignore the end user.. my assumption is just that it is unintentional.. and that they felt that just saying capable was enough.. maybe not maybe so.. unfortunately as you pointed out.. until there is a case or a letter of clarification, we are just guessing..
- Sons of Guns Season 3
-
Shotgun extension greater than 6 OK?
yeah.. you know.. somewhere out on the internet is a list of pretty much all of NJ gun laws.. http://njgunforums.c...j-gun-law-faqs/ "fixed magazine" is used in one instance.. but in the actual "law" it simply says vaguely "magazine capacity exceeding six rounds.. does not say fixed or removable.. one would be reasonable to take the wording at face value.. "a magazine capacity exceeding 6 rounds"
-
When is a magazine not a magazine?
right but there is a difference between fabricating something and putting manufactured parts together... there is no "building" involved in taking a magazine apart.. magazines come apart and go back together without constructing.. or tools.. or fabricating.. at the end of the day it is always the same.. if you are comfortable.. go for it.. I just see it differently.. a manufactured magazine does not stop being a magazine just because you take it apart.. they are manufactured to be taken apart.. again far different than stretching it to encompass raw materials.. or something that has nothing to do with a gun at all.. and lets remember.. I did not choose the word capable.. nor did I alter its meaning..
-
When is a magazine not a magazine?
the problem again is the word capable.. if you read the definition of the word it does NOT indicate immediate state.. capable implies that it could be made ready... capable of murder (for instance) does not mean a murder is occurring.. it does not even mean the person IS a murderer.. it simply means the conditions to be a murderer are there.. having the ability for.. if a magazine is "permanently modified" so that it can NEVER accept more than 15 rounds.. then it is no longer capable of accepting 15 rounds.. if a block of wood is inserted into the bottom.. does that make it so it is incapable of accepting more than 15 rounds? that is where I run into issue.. "capable" does NOT describe a present state.. it instead refers to potential.. does taking apart a magazine remove its potential to function? does it make it so the magazine is no longer in a state of "having the ability or capacity for" function? I think construction possession does not need to be referenced since they are literally saying if a magazine has the capability to accept +15 rounds.. it is high cap.. the parts of laws that always scare me is choice of wording.. because intentionally or unintentionally it can make all the difference in the world.. the word AND instead of OR can change the entire scope..
-
When is a magazine not a magazine?
the issue I see is capable.. a disassembled magazine still possesses the capability to be reassembled into a working magazine which can continuously feed ammunition... the word capable is what bothers me.. the argument that a disassembled magazine is no longer capable is one I would not rest my freedom on.. you (and pretty much anyone who reads my posts) KNOWS that I generally view the laws in our favor.. and hate to be limited by "guessing".. rarely do I "err on the side of caution"... but the term capable is incredibly vague.. A "firearm" is defined partially by the working function of the item (which may be fired or ejected any solid projectable ball, slug, pellet, missile or bullet, or).. if you take the firing pin out is a firearm no longer a firearm? can you sell rifles at a yard sale to anyone simply by removing one component that is critical to function? since at the time of sale the item no longer possesses the ability to "fire or eject a solid projectile".. I do not feel that disassembly satisfies voiding function or capability.. I am certainly not a lawyer.. and I certainly have no legal grounds to believe this.. other than the simple common definition of "capable".. capable does not necessarily indicate a state of immediate preparedness.. it instead means capable.. "capacity" in itself can be used to indicate potential ability.. which clearly indicates immediate ability is not necessarily the intent.. in thinking about it further this also makes me rethink temporary modification of magazines to limit them to 15.. if the mag is temporarily modified to 15 then the magazine technically is still capable in that the magazine has the potential capacity to accept more than 15 rounds.. this intention is echoed where the state spells out in the admin code how magazines much be modified.. granted that is dealer code.. but it does allow one to assume how the state views large capacity magazines..
-
When is a magazine not a magazine?
the problem is the definition of "large capacity magazine" does not stop at function.. it stops as capacity to function.. is a box of links capable of feeding more than 15 rounds? sure... the nature of the links makes them able to be attached to lengths far exceeding 15 rounds.. do two 15 round belts have the capability to continuously feed more than 15 rounds? sure.. link them together.. does a magazine parts kit possess the capability of feeding more than 15 rounds.. sure.. the problem is that the law appears to simply deem an object that is capable of feeding more than 15 rounds illegal.. capable is a very vague word..
-
When is a magazine not a magazine?
it is a high capacity magazine in parts.. is it not... 16 links that can be attached to fire 16 continuous shots without reloading.. 16 round glock magazine that can fire 16 rounds without reloading... I see absolutely no difference..
-
Any Opinions on the S&W M&P Sport?
good for you.. keep us updated on your progress..
-
When is a magazine not a magazine?
yes.. I have said that a million times over.. and I see no other way to view it..
-
When is a magazine not a magazine?
you say that as if it is unusual.. lol the ONLY issue with that is be sure that NONE of your other mags are the same as said high cap body.. example... a body in which spring, follower out of another mag will fit and function... with NJs goofy anti gun mindset I would not want to roll the dice simply to have a magazine body..
-
When is a magazine not a magazine?
just to add... nj does define high cap magazine.. http://njgunforums.com/forum/index.php?/topic/29389-nj-law-summary-read-first-nj-gun-law-faqs/
-
When is a magazine not a magazine?
a magazine is the sum of its parts assembled or disassembled (in NJ)
-
Franklin Armory’s New AR-15 Is Neither A Pistol Nor A Rifle
telescoping stock is illegal.. the stock moves forward and backwards on a tube collapsing on a tube.. as defined by telescoping.. don't worry I am sure you will get the answer you do not want.. attorney general, I am a concerned NJ citizen, and I am inquiring about this rifle stock that is available. The concept of the stock is to allow full auto fire from a semi automatic gun. It does this in a clever way by bouncing the gun all over the place causing your finger to hit the trigger every time. This basically skirts the law because there is one trigger pull per fire.. can I legally own this in NJ? sincerely, john doe if you watch the video the gun is really not controlled well since the operation involves more than a trigger pull of a stable rifle.. it uses the momentum of the gun to bounce it all over the place.. sometimes resulting in what looks like no fire when you expect it to fire.. and other times an extra round or two when you are not expecting one... further what range is going to let you shoot this? I have heard of many ranges going on red alert lock down from someone shooting normal semi too fast.. I can only imagine what this would trigger.. but hey it IS a free country.. and if NJ gives you the green light.. by all means go for it if you like.. I just totally do not understand this..
-
Beretta CX4 Storm impressions?
primary arms makes a great inexpensive quality red dot.. the shroud just makes the gun stupid heavy.. save your cash IMO..
-
BB/pellet gun
I remembered reading something to that effect (on this site I think)
- Sons of Guns Season 3
-
Who would win in a fight?
honey badger.. no question..
-
BB/pellet gun
no one can technically answer that with %100 accuracy due to the insanity that is the NJ legal system.. BUT I will say this.. in PA the gun is NOT a firearm... so the gun is legal for you to purchase in PA... that is set in stone %100 accurate.. in NJ it IS a firearm.. there is no mandatory gun registration that I am aware of so you are good to go there.. you simply have to treat it as a real gun.. which creates the ONLY catch.. if it is a "real firearm" in NJ.. then does that technically mean ALL rules.. (15round mag capacity.. no folding stocks,, etc...) that is the only catch IMO..
-
BB/pellet gun
NO.. the NJSP.. ATF... and FBI will raid your house with a chainsaw and shoot you dead.. now for the non ridiculous answer. NJ classifies bb/pellet guns as firearms in NJ.. meaning that while in NJ you must abide by the laws.. PA has no such view on BB/pellet guns.. NJ law stretches to its border.. while IN PA you may purchase a BB/pellet gun.. because it is not a firearm in PA.. once you cross NJ border it magically transforms into a firearm (seriously) meaning the moment you cross the border you treat it the same as any other gun.. at this time there is no mandatory gun registration in NJ so you would not need to do anything with it once purchased.. just follow the same laws as regular firearms..
-
Thoughts on Glock sights and holsters
do you use a holster with a retention system? if you are using a holster with a thumb controlled retention system I personally find the serpa to be better and faster.. only for the following reason... to draw a gun with a thumb driven retention system you are taking your hand out of shooting position to break the retention.. on a serpa.. your hand stays in complete control of the weapon.. you grasp the grip as you shoot.. ride the release and end up with your trigger finger on the slide.. ready to go.. can't imagine anything faster.. except a non retention holster.. but that is apples to oranges..
-
Any shotgun shell types against the law for HD ?
what about hollow points? there are no NJ laws regarding specific ammunition that is to be used in a HD situation.. you can not discharge tracer/incendiary rounds in NJ afaik...