Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Vlad G

Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Vlad G

  1. Don't shoot the ones were yep the bullet has been pushed in. The ones in spec length should be fine. Call federal as well, you never know if the decide to replace it for safety.
  2. I don't really know that I care about justice, that leads back to eye for an eye. To my mind it is eliminating the problem. Think about it, the problem is not that he is lonely or in a closet (and btw for a lot of those crazy people being ignored and forgotten is a serious punishment) the problem is that they were killing people. Once you stop them from doing that, you solved the problem.
  3. I think that the "if not death then what" question is valid but secondary. Once we go beyond the equalizing of body temperature with the ambient environment, I'm far less concerned as long as the punishment is reversible if we discovered we were wrong. Don't start chopping bits off or injecting people with permanently damaging chemicals, don't starve them to death, etc. Basically stay away from the cruel and unusual and I'm mostly ok with it assuming a high confidence level regarding guilt and assuming that the punishment matches the crime. I don't think we should send pot smokers to the lead mines (or to jail at all really) but I'd accept and recommend fairly unpleasant imprisonments for high grade criminals.
  4. I've probably hurt every bit of my hands at some point or another with gun bits. Right now I have a nasty blood blister I've cut open on my thumb where I got it caught in the bolt of my shotgun, multiple cuts on my fingers from shotgun reloading practice, and a bruise on my knuckles. Crap happens, he is probably giving himself a bruise for no good reason.
  5. It isn't really a matter of what I feel about it. The question I'm leading to here is do the benefits outweigh the negatives. If you can list some tangible benefits of the death penalty then we can weigh them against the negatives, like handing power to the government, risking abuse, risking killing the wrong person, etc. If the only reason is "because it is right" with no quantifiable benefits to society I have no choice but to say the negatives outweigh the non-existent positives. I don't think the "fair" argument holds water because it boils down to the eye for an eye argument and as I said before, that is a concept selected from a code of laws we would view as barbaric if we examine it. I don't think there are many other Hamurabic or Old Testament legal ideas we really still follow. If you really want to discuss fair, we can go back to the notion that it is better that 9 guilty man walk free then one innocent man be incarcerated, which would think it would be doubly so for death penalty. In full disclosure, when I was younger I was definitely in the pro-death penalty camp. As I've grown older I've started asking myself what does it actually accomplish and how sure am I that the people we put to death actually deserve it. How sure am I that system doesn't fail people? How many example of the system failing does one need? As for specific killings .. I'm sure we would have rather arrested Bin Landen, but the moment he picked up a gun he was fair game. That goes under self defense and immediate danger which I've already said I have no issues with. The other ones, I ask again, what have we gained from it? For example Manson being still alive is harming us how? Or Ted Kaczynski? Berkowitz? Are they any different then the other 3? Why the different treatment? Does the different treatment lead to different results? Did Kuklinski dying of old age in prison is somehow different in end result then if we hung him?
  6. Well, I'm kinda curious what benefit the death penalty provides. I mean besides making some people feel better, what actual benefit does society draw from the death penalty, compared with lets say life time incarceration.
  7. They are in custody. If you can't figure out how to keep them from reproducing, I can't trust you to make a judgement that they need killing
  8. Well ok then. Its just that as far as I can tell we are back to the whole eye for an eye thing and other 4000 year old ideas. I'm trying to understand why you think killing someone who is not a threat (after all you have them in custody) is a good idea. I'm not even passing moral judgement on the notion, I'm trying to understand the logic of it. To be clear, I have no problem with eliminating an active threat, just trying to understand the logic of taking a even 0.001% chance you are wrong if an active threat is not eminent.
  9. So do be clear, you would be willing to kill some who is not an active threat to anyone? That is nothing but revenge.
  10. What? Corruption is harder? What world is that in? Corruption is easier and cheaper then ever. And yet you still are stuck on your "but what about this case". You simply are not listening to my big red letters. I don't care what case you come up with, just because you think today that is all it is going to be used for, tomorrow the state will use it for something else. The only answer is not to hand it to the state. Also lets think of it this way. What if you had to do it, not delegate it to the state, but if you personally had to be the dude weighing the evidence, pass the sentence, and press the trigger. How sure would you be that you were right? If you aren't willing to do it yourself, you sure as hell shouldn't have the state do it.
  11. To answer your question, yes, I think 99% of the time the correct punishment is hard time for life. And I mean hard time. And I mean for life. How sure are you that you never wrong? How sure are you that the state is never wrong? If those answers are not 100% but you want to impose a 100% penalty then I have a issues with that. The state is wrong a lot, on every damn topic. The juries are made of idiots. The judges take paybacks to put people in jail (actually to put children in private for profit prisons, look it up). The State is using every bureaucracy and power to intimidate and harass its opponents. So no, I don't think the death penalty should practically exist. If I put on my utopia hat, I have no issues with some people being put to death for their actions, but in the world we live in, I have a problem with the death penalty.
  12. Are you even reading what I'm typing? You scenario is irrelevant. Let me use simple words I DO NOT TRUST THE GOVERNMENT WITH THE POWER TO KILL PEOPLE I don't care if we don't have it now, I don't care if other states have it. I don't have a problem with the ideas of death penalty in a idealized non-existant world, I just know that world doesn't exist, won't exist, can't exist, so given reality I don't want to hand the state the power to kill people it doesn't like Yes I am aware they can already do that. If there is any angle by which I can reduce the amount of power they have on the subject, then I'll take it.
  13. I don't care about your scenario. I'm not being a dick, I just don't trust the government with this power. I can come up with all sorts of scenarios where you might want someone dead, but you either have the right do it right fracking now, by yourself, or it doesn't need to happen. You don't delegate non-emergency killing power to a government because it will abuse them. It is that simple. I also don't think talking about "correct conditions" because those are things that don't happen. Whenever you have a power structure, some twit who thinks she knows better claws here way to the top and start offing people. The history of the world if nothing but a long strings of examples of this. The only thing you can do is delay that as long as possible and you do that by jealously keeping power in the hands of the individual and not handing it to the state. For that reason alone, you don't hand the state the power to legally kill its citizens, specially in a non-emergency.
  14. Dear lord, you keep missing my point. You don't get to decide what murder means. The state does. Stop thinking there is a working justice system and stop giving the state any power
  15. Err ... I think you are very confused. First, 55gr bullets are fine in 1:9 barrels. Secondly there is not recipe, there is load data. Just lookup the load date for the bullet and powder you want to load.
  16. Sorry, that is meaningless. I can make a self defense case fit that category. Watch me: So Mr B. Hunted, you are saying that the choir boy broke into your house, was trying to have sex with daughter against her will and you shot him? Why sir! That is MURDER MOST FOUL! Mr Choir did not deserve to die. I can even prove that you have done with malice and forethought and that you have premeditated this crime most vicious. Why else would have purchased a gun, practiced with it fastidiously, stored loaded in your house hold with bullets specifically designed for killing? Those are signs of premeditation, sir! Further, we can prove that you acted out of malice. I present to you this forum postings from 2 years where you advocated ritual mutilation as valid punishment. You have expressed hate and malice towards people who may or may not be guilty of a crime. You sir have taken it upon yourself to be judge, jury and executioner! You sir are a murderer! In closing we also note that you supported the death penalty for all murderers, with no lengthy waits or appeals! Bailiff, take Mr Hunted out and hang him, if it may please the court. Words have no meaning when they are controlled by a corrupt system.
  17. So .. define murder. Also let me know how you plan on keeping the state from changing that definition at will.
  18. Err .. so ritual mutilation then? Thats what eye for an eye really means at its core. Think of it this way, what other components of the Hammurabi Law do we still hold dear? Wives as property? Adultery punished by drowning (unless with a son's fiancée, where it was just a fine, figure that out)? Cutting out the tongues of people who bad mouth their parents? Killing the son of a builder if the house he built killed someone else's son? I could go on, but we really shouldn't conduct modern life on legal notions of desert dwellers from nearly 4000 years ago. I think we have maybe learned a thing or two since then. And then please define murder. Oh wait, you can't or it doesn't matter how you define it because the definition of murder is in the hands of the STATE. Sorry Mr B. Hunted, we understand that you think you defended yourself, but really we define that as murder this week so off with your head!
  19. If you believe that, try not paying your taxes.
  20. Why? I mean I know having a job is kinda passe now, but working for a living and paying taxes is not exactly cruel and unusual. Working for your keep, and contributing whats left over to others isn't exactly an alien notion.
  21. Well I guess the Duke lacrosse team sure as hell is glad they don't live in South Africa. Or you know .. all those other people accused of rape, dragged through the news, then oh .. oops .. see ..she lied. Mind you, I have no tolerance for rapists, but you can't uncut someone's head so you better be REALLY sure.
  22. You can do that by exiling people to the moon, the salt mines, or Australia. Oh wait, we did that one already. Most of those have an exit clause if you got it wrong or if you overthrew the engorgement that sent political prisoners into the gulag. You really should consider how much power you want to hand a government who can never have enough or abuse it enough.
  23. That isn't justice, that is revenge. It serves no benefit to the victims of the crime. I'd rather see criminals put to work and their labor pay for their incarceration and any excess be returned to victims. I'm not actually against the death penalty, but consider this, how often does the government get it wrong? Sure, they often also get it right, but I don't trust the government to run a bath, never mind run a "justice" system that doesn't railroad people. I think in a ideal world, where people are treated fairly, money doesn't buy lawyers, judges and juries, and juries are actually competent instead of people who couldn't think of an excuse to get out of jury duty then the death penalty is option that should be used sparingly. I think in a system where the government views the people as subjects and uses all its many bureaucracies to oppress political enemies we should think long and hard about where we used the death penalty. We should probably think of a burden of proof like we think of treason, something that has witnesses, a confession, and significant overabundance of evidence before we consider the death penalty.
  24. They are not wrong, they are into marketing. There is no point of talking about religion of natural rights in a NJ paper.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.