Everything posted by Newtonian
-
Update on Right to Carry appeals case, Almeida Vs. Sussex Co.
You are not living in the real world. Look around you, see how other states have done it. See how everything in the Constitution is regulated to one degree or the other. Isn't 225 years of history and legal practice enough evidence? The Supreme Court has heard exactly seven 2nd Amendment cases in all that time. Don't lecture on what to support or not support. I donate generously to pro-gun causes, and pay my dues to three organizations, including NJ2AS, basically -- so far -- in return for membership cards. From your post it would appear that you don a robe and powdered wig and actually litigate these cases. Through dues and donations I support litigation as much as you do. Probably more. My position is simply that the courts are a dead end. They have not worked in NJ, and rarely elsewhere. The degree to which NJ Gun Forum members believe in this approach is inconsistent with reality. The only way to get reasonable gun laws in this state is to remove legislators that oppose them.
-
Update on Right to Carry appeals case, Almeida Vs. Sussex Co.
Let me try this again: We have the numbers to vote a significant number of vulnerable senate and assembly dinosaurs out of office. I have presented the numbers in excruciating detail, more than once. My posts on this subject are based on fact, on hard numbers, with some very liberal assumptions to accommodate the uncertainty. I even assumed the number of gun owners in this state, estimated at 1 million, was high by 20%. Every time I present those numbers the argument becomes stronger and more statistically rigorous. The reaction from this forum? Next to nothing. One guy wanted to use absentee ballots as the basis for "get out the vote." If you are infirm that's ok, but if you simply can't be bothered to get off your ass and go to the polls then you deserve what you get. As Churchill said, people get the government they deserve. And, as I've written before, if the legislature is faced with some miraculous judicial fiat, they can drag the process out for as long as they like. They can mandate a two-week boot camp-like training course, a $4,000 licensing fee due every six months, etc. They will be just as spiteful as they are now. Every one of those restrictions will be fought in the courts. It will take years if not decades.
-
Update on Right to Carry appeals case, Almeida Vs. Sussex Co.
Despite the 2nd Amendment's clear wording there is no letter-by-letter law of the land. The Feds have traditionally allowed the states to regulate this right as vigorously or leniently as they like. I don't know what is so difficult to understand about that. It is up to the legislatures. It is up to the legislatures. It is up to the legislatures. It is up to the legislatures. It is up to the legislatures. It is up to the legislatures. It is up to the legislatures. It is up to the legislatures. It is up to the legislatures. It is up to the legislatures. It is up to the legislatures. It is up to the legislatures. It is up to the legislatures. It is up to the legislatures. It is up to the legislatures. It is up to the legislatures. It is up to the legislatures. It is up to the legislatures. It is up to the legislatures. It is up to the legislatures. It is up to the legislatures. It is up to the legislatures. It is up to the legislatures. It is up to the legislatures. It is up to the legislatures. It is up to the legislatures. It is up to the legislatures. It is up to the legislatures. It is up to the legislatures. It is up to the legislatures. It is up to the legislatures. It is up to the legislatures. It is up to the legislatures. It is up to the legislatures. It is up to the legislatures. It is up to the legislatures. It is up to the legislatures. It is up to the legislatures. It is up to the legislatures.
-
Update on Right to Carry appeals case, Almeida Vs. Sussex Co.
Not sure how your comment and mine differ. And technically, constitutionally, this is how it's supposed to work. For the last 100 years public concealed carry was not considered to derive directly from the 2nd amendment. Like it or not, that's how courts ruled. Three or four states have constitutional carry, another 40 are shall-issue; four or so additional states are restrictive, selective, but still issue (NY, CA, MA; despite its recent craziness CT is de facto shall-issue), and three states don't allow carry outside your property. Plain reading of the 2nd amendment aside, that's about the distribution you'd expect for a right that has traditionally been highly regulated. For a long time the 2nd Amendment was believed, through some sort of legal fiction, not to apply to the states. Clearly -- at the risk of beating a dead horse -- many, many states have loosened their criteria for allowing citizens to bear arms in everyday life, and the overwhelming majority have achieved this through their legislatures. Again, like it or not, this is how 2nd Amendment rights are dispensed in the U.S.A. The Supreme Court hearing Drake and ruling favorably would have been highly unusual but a joyous thing nonetheless. But as they've done hundreds of times in the past, they passed on establishing a clear 2nd Amendment precedent. Maybe the "northeast Italian" factor I've mentioned before came into play, or maybe Kennedy found his federalist mojo. Or Maybe Roberts sensed that hearing the case would turn out bad for gun owners and voted with the minority liberals so the court would NOT hear the case. We'll never know. NJ will never get CC as long as the majority of activists believe in a deus ex machina in the form of a favorable court ruling. Keep dreaming. The only way we get it is by voting out those who obstruct its legislative passage. I do not understand why this clear, unassailable fact -- supported by history and experience in dozens of other states -- is lost on so many intelligent people in these forums.
-
Update on Right to Carry appeals case, Almeida Vs. Sussex Co.
A fire extinguisher costs $15. Air bags I have no choice about, but I would pay for them anyway. I own numerous firearms But none are deployed defensively for reasons i choose not to explain in a public forum. You're right. You're talking about insurance, basically. Having armed guards at every school in the U.S. would be fine if we weren't paying for 1 million other ridiculous things. "Security" is about more than the worst case scenario, about shooting people. It is, as you and others have mentioned, about preparedness, awareness, leadership (I said that) and much, much more. Maybe a former LEO would be better at defusing social problems at schools than the idiot administrators who suspend kids for biting quasi gun-shaped forms out of pop tarts. Maybe not. I'm not completely sure why we're arguing. I totally agree with the proposition of shooting assholes who come on campus with guns. But as you know that's a 1:100,000 proposition. My point was there is a lot more we could gain by having ex-law-enforcement guys at schools.
- Update on Right to Carry appeals case, Almeida Vs. Sussex Co.
-
Update on Right to Carry appeals case, Almeida Vs. Sussex Co.
I'm talking only about concealed carry. I don't know the details on the less onerous provisions of our law. OGPM is more of an inconvenience than anything. We can get air guns, no? This is a complete guess: I'd bet that at least half the states had some kind of silly stuff. Edit: I meant to write that for ME OGPM has been more of an inconvenience than anything. It involves making multiple trips to my FFL. But it has probably prevented at least one rash purchase.
-
Update on Right to Carry appeals case, Almeida Vs. Sussex Co.
They've actually heard very few 2A cases -- seven in total in 225 years. See here. Heller and McDonald vs. Chicago are the most notable in that they represented total bans on handgun ownership. That's a lot different than NJ, where we're "allowed" to own as many guns as we can purchase (OGPM) and walk around our property carrying them. And this will surely be news to you: For most of our history many if not most states WERE more like NJ today and less like today's nearly universal shall-issue environment, which began in earnest in 1987. Except for a few blips, the "Feds" have pretty much allowed the states to stew in their own broth. The Supreme Court is not just a higher form of small claims or traffic court. It does not exist to right every itty bitty wrong that state legislatures inflict on their citizens. Traditionally, on second amendment issues at least, they have deferred to the miserable decisions of people like Weinberg, Sweeney, and Gil, and lower court decisions. I'm going to say this until I'm blue in the face: 2A rights have been earned, for the most part, legislatively. If you think otherwise you are deluding yourself. If one day the Pennsylvania legislature decides to follow a NJ model for granting concealed carry permits, the Supremes will decline to hear that case as well.
- Update on Right to Carry appeals case, Almeida Vs. Sussex Co.
- Update on Right to Carry appeals case, Almeida Vs. Sussex Co.
- Update on Right to Carry appeals case, Almeida Vs. Sussex Co.
-
Update on Right to Carry appeals case, Almeida Vs. Sussex Co.
Let me take this one step further. Shooting is a ***minuscule*** part of police work. Most cops never fire their guns, even though their jobs require them to "look for trouble." Serving as a cop for 20 years is exactly the type of training you would want for a school security guard. EXACTLY. Unless you've done this, in real life, for years, you are UNQUALIFIED. I don't care if you shoot IDPA, NFL, HBO, and NJARPC seven days a week and can shoot a toothpick out of Jerry Miculek's clenched teeth while wearing a blindfold. Shooting at targets is not the same as interpersonal and community relations, investigation, leadership, keeping the peace, which are 99.9% of police work.
-
Update on Right to Carry appeals case, Almeida Vs. Sussex Co.
Last time I looked the judicial and legislative branches are separate. If what you say is true, the Supremes would have heard Drake and upheld NJ's insane laws. That would have established near-total regulation of a constitutional right, and provided every subsequent gun-grabbing jurisdiction with something to point to for the next 240 years. By not hearing the case they essentially say it's up to us, the people. Which it is.
-
Update on Right to Carry appeals case, Almeida Vs. Sussex Co.
A well-trained civilian would have had to be in some branch of law enforcement, either municipal/state/federal, or in the armed forces. Why would you hire someone who only dreams of running outside and shooting someone, vs. a person with 20 years experience in the kind of work that police do, which goes much deeper than shooting?
-
Update on Right to Carry appeals case, Almeida Vs. Sussex Co.
One would hope that the vast majority of incidents in which these guards would be involved would NOT include shooting somebody. Being a security guard isn't the same as target practice. Police are trained not only to shoot but to apprehend people, to defuse violent situations, to confront unruly individuals. On the job they do it weekly if not daily. Experience, no?
-
Update on Right to Carry appeals case, Almeida Vs. Sussex Co.
With all due respect and admiration for those who try through the courts, the right to bear arms outside the home has been largely achieved legislatively, and to a lesser degree through the executive branch. Illinois and that recent California decision are the exceptions, by no means the rule. The PA attorney general's recent decree on Utah permits is an example of the "executive" route for changing a state's gun laws. Northeast courts and even the Supreme Court have pretty much treated concealed carry as a federalist issue. In other words the 2nd Amendment is subject to state regulation; the degree and severity of that regulation has traditionally been left to the states. In some ways this is a good thing. The federal government already controls enough of our lives. If they feel obligated to tell NJ they must scrap our "need" requirement they can also force Vermont to do away with constitutional carry. Or tell Kentucky that their laws regarding purchasing firearms are too lenient. Instead they stay out, even if it means erring on the side of more-restrictive government. This is why I keep writing that the only way to CC in this state is to vote out those obstructing it. I have demonstrated several times how this can be done, and in fact quite easily. My real-world proposals have barely inspired a half-dozen responses. Instead you guys prefer to chase windmills, even in the face of defeat after defeat after defeat. Yeah, maybe some judge is disconnected enough from the sewer that merges law, politics, and money that he or she will see the light. And also, maybe those painted pigs at the Susses Fairgrounds will come to life, and we'll have hog hunting.
-
Update on Right to Carry appeals case, Almeida Vs. Sussex Co.
You have to admit that a retired state cop is infinitely more qualified than somebody you pull out of a GFH training class. The main problem is not that they hire a cop, but that the cop collects a full pension while working a second job. We wind up paying two, three, in some cases FOUR individuals for the same job. The abysmal state of right to carry in NJ is a totally separate issue.
-
I never do this, but I need this forum's help.
Urging somebody, at this stage of the game, to carry a handgun in NJ is so far beyond bad advice. Maybe when the aliens land and microchip us.
-
Browning Buckmark FTEs
Thanks, Jon. I'm going to try the mag first because it's easy and, worst comes to worst, I'll have a second mag.
-
Cherry Ridge (ANJRPC) Range - Big Thumbs Down
It's hard to follow who said what and who's quoting whom in this thread. From the way OakRidge mentioned "NJ shooters" this mystery range is probably in PA. Unless he flies a helicopter "twelve minutes from my house in Warren County" means one of four areas: Stroudsburg, Easton, or whatever they call the area across the river from Belividere. The ranges near Stroud are probably more than 12 minutes from, say, Columbia. Shongum, in NJ, is the fourth possibility based on distance but I know it charges much more than $20/yr, there's a waiting list, and probably has as many "rules" as CR. My best guess is this "range" is a tree stump in a field next to an abandoned ketchup factory, just across the bridge from Belvidere, where there's some kind of "Land Management Area." The $20 is for a basic PA hunting license. Actually it's $20.70.
-
22lr 5c shipped
If you can believe it, Thunderbolt screws up my S&W 617 revolver. The amount of leading in the barrel was unreal. The gun started shooting weird after two cylinders (20 rounds). By the 3rd or 4th cylinder I couldn't hit the broad side of a barn. When I took it home I removed the equivalent of one third of a bullet worth of lead. I'm lucky the damned thing didn't blow up on me.
-
Browning Buckmark FTEs
Doesn't matter what ammo I use. I have some high-priced CCI, and the shells still stick. Hey: 4-5 per 50 rounds is about what's happening to me.
-
Cherry Ridge (ANJRPC) Range - Big Thumbs Down
I understand. RTSP is a schlepp for me, like CR is for you. I have a feeling I can get my newbie wife to Flatbrook under the pretense of hiking. I'll try it tonight after a glass or two of wine and let you know how it goes. BTW, last time I was there, around 1997, my hunting partner told me that "chukas" were in season and/or flying through. It was the coldest day in decades, at least -10 F. All we saw that day that remotely looked alive was bear poo-poo.
-
trading ammo
Depending on how you do the accounting, I paid 4-9 cents/round. I wanted to trade only because I'm tired of comments from UPS/Fedex guys. I'd rather shoot it. Won't last through August
-
Cherry Ridge (ANJRPC) Range - Big Thumbs Down
I used to shoot clays and .22s up there in the mid-1990s, and hunt pheasant as well. Nice change of pace. Maybe I'll see if wifey wants to go one day.