Everything posted by Princetonian58
-
Judicial Directive on Processing Gun Permits
I didn't see this discussed before. If I overlooked it, please forgive me. On May 20, 2019, the Administrative Director of the Courts in NJ issued a directive outlining uniform procedures to be followed by Superior Court judges when considering carry permit applications, whether approved or denied by the local chief of police; and denials of FPID cards and handgun purchase permits. Mandates a hearing before decision if the court has any concerns about whether a permit should be issued and mandates adherence to a 30 day review period. Also, the NJ Supreme Court heard argument in the Carlstrom case yesterday which is to decide whether a carry permit applicant is entitled to a hearing before the Superior Court rules on whether a permit should be granted/denied. The Court will likely defer to this directive on a going-forward basis. Not sure if Lou Nappen's client is going to get his hearing, however. Several of the judges questioned what type of meaningful evidence Carlstrom could have presented that would have made a difference. May 20, 2019 Directive on Gun Permits (07384020xA1E35).pdf
-
Thomas R. Rogers and ANJRPC v. Gurbir S. Grewal, et al
Agree that there are likely 4 votes. However, I do not think the 4 will vote to grant cert. unless they are highly confident that the Chief will join them in an opinion on the merits. Otherwise, they run the risk of a 5-4 decision against public carry if Roberts votes with the liberals.
-
Thomas R. Rogers and ANJRPC v. Gurbir S. Grewal, et al
Nice job on the petitioner's reply by Dan Schmutter and colleagues. I too would handicap SCOTUS like PDM. The wild card is Roberts and I'm sure he is wrestling with the impact on the country, given its current state of political division, if the Court forces all the blue states to allow some form of carry outside the home. Libturd heads would explode everywhere.
-
SCOTUS agrees to hear 2A case from NYC
I am happy to report that the Supreme Court today denied NYC's motion to put the briefing of this case on hold while it considers amending its unconstitutional ban on travel with a gun outside the five boroughs: "Motion of respondents to hold briefing schedule in abeyance DENIED."
-
Thomas R. Rogers and ANJRPC v. Gurbir S. Grewal, et al
The State filed its brief today. Here is the link: https://www.supremecourt.gov/DocketPDF/18/18-824/96857/20190419122517548_18-824 BIO.pdf It's disappointing to acknowledge that the State did a good job in offering reasons to SCOTUS not to grant cert. in this case (as opposed to addressing the merits). NJ argues first that there is an insufficient split in the Courts of Appeals, dissecting the details of the Young case in the 9th Cir.; Moore in the 7th Cir; and to a weaker extent even Wrenn out of the D.C. Cir. Next, it points out that Rogers lacks a factual record that in fact shows what small percentage of applicants receive NJ concealed carry permits. We all know it's a ridiculously small percentage but NJ points to the wholesale absence of any evidence in the record. It further argues that the Court should pass on Rogers in favor of a Massachusetts case, Gould v. Morgan, which also is waiting for a decision on cert. but has not yet been briefed fully. NJ also asks the Court to deny cert. here or hold off pending its decision in the NY Assoc. case. NJ pulled out all the stops to offer reasons to delay and dodge a decision here.
-
SCOTUS agrees to hear 2A case from NYC
New York City filed a motion with SCOTUS on Friday, April 12, seeking to kneecap this case from being heard. NYC has introduced an amendment to its rule that would allow NYC residents to transport handguns to other locations outside the City where is is legal to possess them, such as a second upstate home; a range; or a competition out of state. NYC's lawyer is arguing that SCOTUS should hold further briefing in abeyance as in their view, the case will become moot once the new rule is adopted and SCOTUS could not therefore grant the plaintiffs any relief. SCOTUS does not have to accept this position but if it does, the case will be dismissed as moot. This might enhance the odds for certification to be granted in NJ's Rogers v. Grewal case since there is no chance that NJ will flip flop and suddenly allow concealed or open carry outside the home.
-
Permit case going to NJ Supreme Court
I of course hope Nappen wins this for his client but the Supreme Court describes the issue on appeal as one of due process and the right to a hearing, not whether "justifiable need" is valid anymore: "Among other issues, was petitioner entitled to a hearing on his application for a permit to carry a handgun?" Also, others may correct me if I'm wrong, but I seem to recall that a few years ago, when SCOTUS was considering whether to grant cert. in Drake, the NJ Supreme Court granted cert. in a carry case only to revoke it once SCOTUS denied cert. in Drake. I wonder if the NJ Supreme Court is trying to send a message to SCOTUS to deny cert. in Rogers so as to allow the NJ Supreme Court to weigh in on "justifiable need" first? I may be cynical, but perhaps this strategy is at play again and the State's delay in briefing Rogers is/was designed to allow the NJ Supreme Court time to grant cert, in Nappen's case before SCOTUS could in Rogers.
-
Thomas R. Rogers and ANJRPC v. Gurbir S. Grewal, et al
What follows is a quote from remarks given by Dean Erwin Chemerinsky, an well known follower and commentator on the US Supreme Court and very much a liberal, This bodes well for constitutional carry: Think of the ages of the conservative justices. Clarence Thomas is 70. Samuel Alito is 68. John Roberts is 65. Brett Kavanaugh is 53. Neil Gorsuch is 51. It’s certainly easy to imagine these five justices sitting together for another decade or two. So, I think the bottom line is when you think about the U.S. Supreme Court, now and for the foreseeable future, is that if you are politically conservative, this is a time to be jubilant. Conservatives have long wanted a solid, staunch conservative majority. They now have it on the High Court. If you’re politically liberal, maybe the most encouraging thing I can say is perhaps the Supreme Court will continue to decide fewer and fewer cases.
- Thomas R. Rogers and ANJRPC v. Gurbir S. Grewal, et al
-
Thomas R. Rogers and ANJRPC v. Gurbir S. Grewal, et al
Yesterday, the State applied to SCOTUS for an additional 30 days in which to submit its brief in opposition to certiorari. The petitioners consented to this, presumably as a courtesy, and this extension should be granted as a matter of course. However, this extension kicks the can down the road yet again. It seems that the State is looking to run out the clock on this term of the SCOTUS. Petitioner's brief is thus not likely to be filed before the end of April The last conference date this term, at which a vote could be taken on hearing the case, June 20, 2019.
-
Thomas R. Rogers and ANJRPC v. Gurbir S. Grewal, et al
The New York case will not be heard until the next October term of SCOTUS. The Association and New York filed a joint application to extend the time to brief the appeal on its merits until August. The prior briefing was addressed to whether certiorari should be granted, even though the merits were thoroughly discussed and argued. The Court wants further briefs dealing solely with the merits issues. This could work to improve the chances for a grant of certiorari for Rogers v. Grewal. SCOTUS could grant certiorari in Rogers before the term ends on June 30 and consolidate it with the New York case for argument and decision next fall.
- Thomas R. Rogers and ANJRPC v. Gurbir S. Grewal, et al
-
Ninth Circuit to Give Hawaii Carry Case the Peruta Treatment
After Peruta, another panel of the Ninth Circuit held that the Second Amendment protects the right to carry outside the home in Young v. State of Hawaii. The decision was written by the same judge who authored the Peruta panel decision. Last Friday, 2/8/19, the Ninth Circuit granted Hawaii's petition to have the case reheard en banc so it seems all but certain that the panel decision will be overturned just as was the panel decision in Peruta itself. If SCOTUS does not grant cert in Rogers v. Grewal, this case will be in line for another attempt.
-
SCOTUS agrees to hear 2A case from NYC
The real value in a SCOTUS decision in this case may be in terms of how the Court breaks down, whether it's 5-4 or maybe 6-3; who writes for the Court and, most important, the Court's comments upon its prior decisions in Heller and McDonald in terms of what those decisions mean; the comments may foreshadow where the majority is regarding other restrictions from the mag ban to carry outside the home.
-
NJ SUPREME COURT TO ISSUE OPINION THIS MONDAY ON JILLARD CASE!
Cheeseman's done too. https://www.njcourts.gov/attorneys/assets/opinions/appellate/unpublished/a2412-17.pdf?cacheID=BXbjsSW
-
NJ SUPREME COURT TO ISSUE OPINION THIS MONDAY ON JILLARD CASE!
Unfortunately, more short shrift from NJ judges. The only way NJ will ever get carry is for SCOTUS to mandate it. Jillard (06531746xA1E35).pdf
-
NJ SUPREME COURT TO ISSUE OPINION THIS MONDAY ON JILLARD CASE!
The Jillard case is scheduled for decision Monday, November 5. Opinion will be released at 10:00 a.m. It's listed as unpublished so unfortunately this usually means an affirmance of the decision below.
-
Mag Ban Injunction Hearing 7/12/18
Hoping for some details from the ANJRPC and/or counsel but according to the U.S. District Court docket, the ANJRPC's and the State's closing briefs with proposed findings for the judge to make have been submitted. Final arguments were made last week. It would appear that the case has now been submitted to the judge for his decision which could come at any point.
-
Mag Ban Injunction Hearing 7/12/18
According to the docket, live testimony has been presented.
-
Mag Ban Injunction Hearing 7/12/18
It would be nice to have an update from the ANJPC on how the hearings having been going. From the District Court's docket, the plaintiffs have withdrawn an expert from the NSSF who submitted a declaration attesting to the commonality and sheer number of "LCM," i.e., those in excess of 10 rounds. No reason given other than plaintiffs state they did not intend to call this witness or rely upon his testimony any longer. That did not sound good. I also saw that the State has produced an expert who claims to have trained neophyte soldiers how to shoot pistol who laughably claims that it takes in excess of 10 seconds for inexperienced shooters to swap out a magazine in a semi-automatic handgun. Obviously the idea is by forcing a sooner need to reload by mandating 10 rd. mags more opportunities will be created for escape from an active shooter. The mere fact that Judge Sheridan was willing to make a record before deciding on the preliminary injunction is still a positive step for gun owners, though. The docket states that proposed findings of fact for the judge to consider are due in early September. It stands to reason that a decision would be forthcoming within 30 days or so after that.
-
Ordering Ammo over the web & delivering to NJ address
No problem. I order from Cabela's often. There is usually free shipping on orders over $50.00 and their prices are competitive. You do pay NJ sales tax since the merger with Bass Pro.
-
Gun Restriction executive order
From Governor Free Sh*t's webpage: Governor Phil Murphy ✔@GovMurphy Join me live in Asbury Park as I sign an executive order to make information on gun crimes accessible to the public: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Vv0tRQ2P56Y …
-
Supreme Court, The 2nd Amendment And The NRA
No. The federal court system is independent of the State of NJ and has the power to decide if state law is violative of the Constitution, including the Second Amendment. The Supremecy Clause provides that authority. But the federal District Court, as a trial level tribunal, is bound to follow the decisions of the Third Circuit which is its own intermediate appellate court. So ANJRPC must lose at the trial level as the District Judge is not going to refuse to follow a binding decision from a higher court. Theoretically, the Third Circuit could reconsider its holding in Drake in light of Wrenn but I think you or I have a better chance of getting a carry permit under the current justifiable need standard than that happening.
-
Supreme Court, The 2nd Amendment And The NRA
The State defendants moved to dismiss the ANJRPC suit on its face yesterday arguing it is foreclosed by the Third Circuit's decision in Drake. This was expected as the District Court must follow Drake; the Third Circuit will affirm that decision and once again we will be waiting to see if SCOTUS will agree to hear a right to carry case. Interestingly, the essential defense of "justifiable need" made by the State is that it has been around since 1924 and by that fact alone is a longstanding regulation exempt from reach of the Second Amendment. Its response to Wrenn is that the District of Columbia's "justifiable need" scheme was only adopted in 2014 and is therefore not "longstanding." That in my view is a very weak argument. If the right to carry outside the home is a core Second Amendment right, as Wrenn held, then the fact that NJ has been violating the constitutional rights of law abiding gun owners who wish to carry for 94 years does not earn it a pass going forward. No real attempt to reach the merits of the majority opinion in Wrenn.
-
Applying for FID in Cherry Hill, NJ
My town also has a short extra form. It is just the basics that are already on the STS-033 so it’s redundant but, as a final request, it does ask for disclosure of next of kin. The police department does not send out any additional form to my wife. However, they do have a clerk call my home number and leave a message on the answering machine when the permit is available for pick up, even though I put my cell number on all the forms. So they go out of their way to minimally let my wife know that a permit has been applied for. It is irritating but I’m not going to hold my breath for Operation Strikeforce to do anything.