Everything posted by Princetonian58
-
A Sad Day For California
No one should expect anything less from the Ninth Circuit, unquestionably the most liberal, and most reversed Circuit court in the country. Don't expect SCOTUS to grant cert. At 4-4, a tie means affirmance of the judgment below. The conservatives can be expected to bide their time. Here is the bright spot: the Ninth Circuit majority only held concealed carry is not protected by the Second Amendment. They expressly acknowledged that open carry may indeed be protected and, in an uncharacteristic display of deference, recognized that SCOTUS reserved that question in Heller and did not decide that issue. So if open carry is held constitutional, concealed carry may soon follow.
-
Operation Strikeforce
PB, The legal system doesn't work in the manner you describe. If you want to have an off-line discussion on this let me know. Otherwise, let's just agree to disagree as they say. We both seek the same goal but see different paths on how we ought to get there. P.
-
Operation Strikeforce
Instant gratification. How long has Operation Strikeforce, and its promise of litigation been announced, Pizza Bob? I'm curious to know why you would think 500 lawsuits would need to be filed. A small number (i.e., 2 or 3) against dug in towns sends a message, sets precedent and pushes the ball down the field. These are not complex issues. Are extra requirements being imposed or not? If the prospect of litigation is so daunting and overwhelming as you seem to believe why then did the Operation Permit Strikeforce announce it as a tool that would be used if needed? There is no legal requirement to notify a town that its practices violate the law before suing though I wholeheartedly agree that this was the preferable course of action as voluntary compliance is clearly desirable. But let's face it, there are towns that have called the ANJRPC's bluff on going to the mat, so it will act on its published, promised action or it will not. BTW, I'm not asking the ANJRPC to handle any specific individual problem. Let's not make this personal. I trust that you can see that there are those who feel that the ANJRPC's approach is too passive when it has the hammer of the law in its toolbox.
-
Operation Strikeforce
With all due respect, that's exactly what you said. But if money to litigate is not the issue, then please enlighten me on the reason for the inaction. Just how long must it take to gather the facts necessary to show a town is using unauthorized forms, imposing unauthorized requirements and is not coming close to meeting the 30 day requirement? And I would suggest, with respect, that any applicant who has been jerked around by his town contrary to the statute and contrary to the holding of the Appellate Division in the Jersey City case has the "right" to bitch about it. And they have the right to feel frustrated with a group they support that promises legal action, has the legal tools and the cash and/or manpower at its disposal, yet allows permitting abuses to continue, for years, in municipalities that will never comply voluntarily.
-
Operation Strikeforce
- Operation Strikeforce
I read that opinion, thanks. That was a private case brought by a guy via Nappen who was denied his permit because of extra requirements, I believe. As I understand Operation Strikeforce, however, suits were to be filed on a broad basis akin to a class action or for a declaration of rights for all similarly situated applicants.- Operation Strikeforce
Yes it does, that's one of the reasons ANJRPC collects dues for.- Operation Strikeforce
I listened to the GFH Radio show this week addressing the recent AG's directives on permitting, etc. I was struck by the extended discussion about recalcitrant municipalities like Hanover Park whose chief sits on applications for months on end, even for officers who live there but work elsewhere. Operation Strikeforce was announced about two years ago. Everyone knows that certain towns have never and will never obey the law voluntarily. Why has there not been at least one lawsuit, just one, taking on one of these dug in towns? I can see the merit of trying to work things out short of litigation with a town that may be ignorant of the ban on added requirements and the 30 day requirement but the show demonstrates there are others that will not comply until faced with with a court order and perhaps relief stripping them of their right to handle applications in favor of the State Police, etc. How about some action ANJRPC?- 1911 Recommendations
My budget is going to be $1000. I'm not too close to HGE, though. Thanks for the offer.- 1911 Recommendations
Primarily a range gun. Perhaps try competition down the road.- 1911 Recommendations
Thinking about acquiring my first 1911. May I have your recommendations? I've been looking at the Ruger SR1911 and Springfield Mil-Spec. 45. Auto, of course.- Visited Cheyenne Mt. and Sportsman Center today...
I have a hard time believing you've ever been in Sportsman's Center recently but can believe you're some pal of someone associated with Cheyenne Mountain Outfitters. I find the staff at SC relaxed, friendly and approachable whether you're a long time firearms owner or a newbie. CMO staff seems abrupt and treats everyone like you're wasting their time. Never have seen the "Large" dudes in SC or guys in camo working the counter. I've bought four handguns from SC and they have always got me exactly what I've wanted at a price that is fair, competitive and always below CMO. I for one like being able to walk in to a dealer who will shake my hand, find out what I want and take care of me. If I want to walk in to a shop and take a number to be waited on, I'll just go to Shop Rite.- Scott Bach's Letter to NH Union Leader
I believe Bach is playing the long game and perhaps foresees Christie becoming AG in a Republican administration and is hoping on support for national reciprocity and other advances on the federal level that may eventually force the PRNJ to become a semi-free state. Certainly there are more pro-gun Republicans Bach could have supported in New Hampshire so there must be a reason to throw a bone Christie's way. Having said that, on another note, I can't help but feel frustrated with the ANJRPC's bravado on "Operation Strikeforce." This has been touted for over a year, and despite a published appellate case that expressly prohibits extra requirements and delays, I have not heard of one single lawsuit filed by the ANJRPC on behalf of an applicant to seek a remedy for the denial of their civil rights under the Second Amendment. Are people getting their permits in 30 days in Paterson and Jersey City or did I miss something?- Carpal Tunnel from Shooting?
Has anyone ever heard of developing carpal tunnel syndrome in your shooting hand from recoil?- What's Up with Peruta?
Here is the link to the audio/video feed of the hearing, to begin this evening at 6:30 EDT. http://www.ca9.uscourts.gov/media/view_video.php?pk_vid=0000007833- gun cleaning
I clean my guns after every use. I find it oddly relaxing to field strip them and getting all the gunk out. Like the poster said, I also find that more carbon come out of the barrel once I run a lightly oiled patch down even though earlier patches on the dry bore came out clean. I thought it was just me. I don't go back and reclean the bore either. Figure it's close enough for government work.- Police departments can not add their own requirements, court rules
Cases are published in a series of books (now mostly on line) that all lawyers must and judges should review on a given issue.- Police departments can not add their own requirements, court rules
The JC case was also from the Appellate Division. Generally speaking a case is published when it is considered to make new law or settle a question under existing law. All NJ Supreme Court opinions are published. Maybe about 3-5% of Appellate Division cases.- Police departments can not add their own requirements, court rules
Because this case was published, it becomes binding on all trial courts in the State and, by extension, upon all police departments/chiefs. The Jersey City case was not publiished and as a result, a trial court hearing a denial of a FPID card or P2P could, if he/she desired, opt not to follow it. The panel of appellate judges hearing and deciding a case decides whether to direct whether to have their opinion published. So, then, this particular panel of judges wanted to make their decision stick and extend beyond the particular facts of this case. I also liked the last part of the decision where the court ordered the chief to issue the FPID card in 30 days of the opinion just as the statute requires, assuming no disqualifier turns up in the investigation.- Beretta 92FS
Thank you Krdshrk and 67gtonut.- Beretta 92FS
I have a quesiton on the operation of the Beretta 92FS hopefully someone can answer. As I understand its operation, if the safety is engaged, once a magazine is inserted and the slide is racked, the hammer will be down and the firearm in double action mode for the first shot; single action with hammer cocked on remaining shots. If the magazine is first inserted with the safety not engaged, however, the hammer will be cocked and the gun in single action operation from the start. It is my understanding that the activation of the safety will lower the hammer and allow the user to return the firearm to double action. Tried this on dry fire and the activation of the safety led to the hammer lowering quickly (unlike my Sig P229), so quickly that it made me wonder if the gun would have fired had a round been chambered. Question: do you need to carefully control the descent of the hammer with your thumb to avoid the possibility of an accidental discharge like you would with a DA revolver? I understand the safe and correct procedure is to insert the magazine with the safety engaged and ensure the hammer is down and that's what I intend to do. I just want to know all aspects of the gun's operation and thus be able to warn or caution anyone else who may demo the firearm at the range, etc. Thanks.- Second Amendment Preservation and Protection Act (SAPPA)
- HP Ammo for Home Defense
Yes, that is also my understanding. I examined the statute and the exception. It does not expressly speak of use of HP at home but does not declare it illegal either. I've found no case holding that the use of HP ammo in an otherwise lawful self defense situation in the home is illegal.- HP Ammo for Home Defense
Took a NRA pistol course and there was debate whether hollow point ammo is legal to use in an otherwise lawful exercise of self defense in ones home. Some maintain that while its legal to possess HP ammo in one's home, it's unlawful to use it. What's the consensus here?- What's Up with Peruta?
There is little doubt that the three month delay on any action on this case was spent by the liberal majority of the Ninth Circuit Court of,Communists whipping together votes until they were certain they could overturn the panel. In the event of a reversal en banc there is no way SCOTUS grants certiorari given the conservatives failure to make it happen in Zrake. - Operation Strikeforce