Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

U.S. Supreme Court weighs taking up major gun rights case

Featured Replies

Have hope, but don't hold your breath.   They had a perfect storm of gun cases to choose from last year and took none of them. That was seven years after they refused to hear the Drake case. Something that deeply disappointed me and my faith in the court.  I do realize  the composition of the court has changed since last year. However, I regard Scotus as having been pummeled into submission (eg Kavanaugh) and impotent when it come to taking decisive action on 2A. 

Also, the earliest they will decide whether to hear the case will be Monday. It is also common for them to hold it over until the following week after week after week, .........before making a decision.

For something that is so clear “Shall not be infringed”, the nuances of the legal process to get something decisively  ruled in our favor is a sham, a rigged game, it is all theater. 
(Eg eg things like the use of lesser levels of legal scrutiny, reversing decisions to hear cases (NJ Supreme Court) by stating it was “improvidently granted”, etc.)

 

1 hour ago, oldguysrule649 said:

Have hope, but don't hold your breath.   They had a perfect storm of gun cases to choose from last year and took none of them.

I'll be really surprised if the decide to touch this one.

My bet, they punt, just like all those other cases.

Guns are too hot of an issue today. They won't touch the third rail.

  • Author
16 minutes ago, Sniper said:

Guns are too hot of an issue today.

They are always going to be a hot issue, just getting hotter. Not wearing a hat here but whenever cases start to get to Supreme Court things seem to pick up. Another shooting last night, that's 3 in 2 weeks.

SCOTUS is not supposed to look at the current events nor take social or political pressures into account. Their decisions should be based on the Constitutionality of the facts before them...Period!

23 minutes ago, JohnnyB said:

SCOTUS is not supposed to look at the current events nor take social or political pressures into account. Their decisions should be based on the Constitutionality of the facts before them...Period!

In a pure world, sure..

But, is that what we've seen the last few years concerning guns, elections and other politically involved cases?

Here's a link to many of the cases they refused to hear, see if you notice a pattern:

https://duckduckgo.com/?q=u.s.+supreme+court+refuses+to+hear&t=h_&ia=web

I haven't been able to find anything on if they have announced if they will hear any of the 2A cases. Anyone else see anything?

4 minutes ago, kc17 said:

I haven't been able to find anything on if they have announced if they will hear any of the 2A cases. Anyone else see anything?

I checked, not seeing any updates today but this:

....."The Court has several current opportunities to further address the scope of its Heller decision that generally pose one legal question: How far may states go in restricting the individual right to carry guns outside a home?

These various legal challenges have worked their way up to the Supreme Court and now require at least four members of the court to vote to grant the application to hear the cases. These challenges include the New York law as well as multiple other cases nationally presenting distinct legal issues.

The Supreme Court has not directly addressed the issue of gun rights since its landmark rulings in 2008 and 2010. 

https://www.shreveporttimes.com/story/opinion/columnists/2021/03/29/royal-alexander-gun-rights-cases-returnto-supreme-court/7044474002/

Will we see this, instead?

giphy.webp

I thought one was up for consideration last Friday and results published today.  I checked the results on SCOTUSblog but couldn’t remember the case and nothing caught my eye. 

There's a theory that all the earlier rhetoric from the left about packing the court was to intimidate the conservative justices.  The message is "if you follow the constitution and we don't like it, we'll just add enough justices that your vote won't ever count again".

The Supreme Court didn’t make any public announcements about taking or rejecting a challenge to New York State’s licensing regime for concealed carry as it released its orders from last Friday’s conference on Monday morning. Instead, it looks like the Court will hold the case over for reconsideration at this week’s conference.

Source for above along with some theories on why: https://bearingarms.com/camedwards/2021/03/29/waiting-game-scotus-carry-case-n42692

 

 

I think they're going to want to review the 9th Circuit case before making a decision. 

  • 2 weeks later...
On 3/29/2021 at 6:31 PM, maintenanceguy said:

There's a theory that all the earlier rhetoric from the left about packing the court was to intimidate the conservative justices.  The message is "if you follow the constitution and we don't like it, we'll just add enough justices that your vote won't ever count again".

Its much more than a theory.   And it Is intimidating the court.  Search... 2020 Presidential Election supreme court.  There was a particular reluctance to take any case or even hear the facts.

57 minutes ago, gleninjersey said:

Thomas is chomping at the bit to take a 2A case.  He wrote a SMOKING dissent last year.  

I hope he gets one.

He had the opportunity at a bunch in the last few years. They punted on every one.

  • 3 weeks later...
16 minutes ago, siderman said:

... plenty of time to do a moot & boot.

I'd place my money on the side of NY State is going to fight this one in SCOTUS.  To "moot" they'd have to become a "shall issue" state.

That's a bridge too far for them.  NYC's previous "moot and boot" was to allow NYC residents to take their handguns outside of the city - that was a much smaller "give" than to essentially make the entire state "shall issue".

I'm not counting out Roberts to side with the majority solely to write the majority opinion and make it as narrow in scope as possible. We need Strict Scrutiny so they can no longer trample our rights. 

So will this apply outside of NY and 2nd circuit.

If it does what proactive actions have our 2A organizations taken to be ready if this goes our way.     We should be ready within micro seconds of the courts decision to file lawsuits immediately against murphy, grewel and all others that infringe on the right.

The 2A groups should immediately band together and start a common fund to fight this,  This is it,    this will be the biggest decision the SC has made in its existence.     If it does not go the way of the constitution we know where we will stand forever in this state unless the next civil war starts before the decision.

If the ruling rules in our favor, does that mean shall issue ccw in NJ?

13 minutes ago, always_an_eagle said:

If the ruling rules in our favor, does that mean shall issue ccw in NJ?

Applies to all States.

14 minutes ago, revenger said:

If it does what proactive actions have our 2A organizations taken to be ready if this goes our way.     We should be ready within micro seconds of the courts decision to file lawsuits immediately against murphy, grewel and all others that infringe on the right.

Isn’t there a NJ case against Justifiable Need making its way through the courts?  If so that one is well positioned to be ruled in line with the outcome of the scotus decision 

11 minutes ago, voyager9 said:

Isn’t there a NJ case against Justifiable Need making its way through the courts?  If so that one is well positioned to be ruled in line with the outcome of the scotus decision 

  Yes, I believe there is.   My concern is the left wing communists and the way they do not follow any laws which they don't want to follow such as illegalizing pot and going against the federal law.    Commies such as murphy and deblasio would still continue to hold onto the unconstitutional laws  and fight this that is why we need to be as proactive as possible.     If we do win than murphy will only open up cc permits processing on the 34th of each month,  we should all know how they fight by now.

Roberts will prove beyond any doubt, the utter COWARD AND TRAITOR that he is. And another visitor to Epstein's Island.

I am hopeful that this will go our way, but I also worry what other nefarious means the likes of Grewal and his ilk can come up with. An obvious one is a expansion of the "sensitive areas" that were carved out in Heller. If they expand that to 5000ft from a school, how much of NYC would be a prohibited area?

Just now, Mr.Stu said:

I am hopeful that this will go our way, but I also worry what other nefarious means the likes of Grewal and his ilk can come up with. An obvious one is a expansion of the "sensitive areas" that were carved out in Heller. If they expand that to 5000ft from a school, how much of NYC would be a prohibited area?

This is exactly what I mean about being ready to fight them,  they will stop at nothing to oppress the citizens rights that interfere with their master plans.    we must be ready to organize and fight now ,  not after a positive decision.   

Yup. One round mags. $2000 heavily restricted """permits""" with 3 month renewals. Full medical exams. 50 unique valid references not to be re-used upon next renewal application. Caliber restrictions to 9mm ONLY. 2 mile distance restrictions from any "govt" bldgs schools and libraries and parks. And all businesses. All smokers are automatically denied permits unless proof of smoking cessation for at least 7 years can be provided and consent to monitor going 'forward'. I am NOT JOKING.

31 minutes ago, quikz said:

Yup. One round mags. $2000 heavily restricted """permits""" with 3 month renewals. Full medical exams. 50 unique valid references not to be re-used upon next renewal application. Caliber restrictions to 9mm ONLY. 2 mile distance restrictions from any "govt" bldgs schools and libraries and parks. And all businesses. All smokers are automatically denied permits unless proof of smoking cessation for at least 7 years can be provided and consent to monitor going 'forward'. I am NOT JOKING.

Onerous requirements like annual training, qualifications and insurance.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.