Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Someone trying to pass new law concerning guns

Featured Replies

  • Author

This has always been a tricky issue for me. I think it would be a great idea to take training if you are going to carry. Would I make it mandatory? I don't know. I'd prefer not to, as imposing any regulation is subjected to government bureaucracy. For example, someone who has a severe case of the shakes(due to some medical condition) when they get nervous to the point where they couldnt hit the broad side of a barn, would that person do more harm than good in a CCW defense scenario? It's a tough call. Again I want to refrain from telling any particular law abiding citizen what they can or can not do. I tend to side with individual liberties.

Showed this to my guy, he tells me this is dead and will never see the light of day. This is Stack and Cunningham.

As far as training, there is a tricky line there. Training should be STRONGLY ENCOURAGED but cannot be forced.

Showed this to my guy, he tells me this is dead and will never see the light of day. This is Stack and Cunningham.

As far as training, there is a tricky line there. Training should be STRONGLY ENCOURAGED but cannot be forced.

 

 

hope your right because I barely know anyone who had a firearms ID card the first time they fired a weapon.

Altho I think it is BS, certainly the part about renting guns, I am not totally against having to have taken a basic firearms course prior to being able to purchase a handgun.

I did purchase mine before I took the class, but took the class very shortly thereafter.

 

The 2nd amendment didn't mention training requirements.

 

 

I'm with both of you. I firmly believe in safety training, but how do you make it a requirement to exorcise a right?

 

If we could find an incentive for people to take a class, well, then, maybe......

The incentive is you can't get a carry permit without taking a CCW course.

 

Simple and the requirements end right there.

 

I do not agree letting any as$hole walk around with a gun is a good idea.

You need to take a driving test and pass to drive a car right?

Driving is a privilege... 2A is a right. Trouble starts when you turn rights into privileges. Then, only the "privileged" have them.

 

 

Unfortunately, it is not since we can not carry.

 

I am all for reasonable background checks (NOT an FPID) but basic NICs for gun purchases and for required training if you intend to carry. PERIOD!

 

I'm not sure, but I think you do need training as a requirement for a CCW in NJ, along with a sack of cash.

The incentive is you can't get a carry permit without taking a CCW course.

 

Simple and the requirements end right there.

 

I do not agree letting any as$hole walk around with a gun is a good idea.

 

I agree with you on the CCW training. But I think we were discussing training as a requirement to get the basic NJ FID card first. I don't know how you would reconcile that. But then again, it is a requirement in DC.

Altho I think it is BS, certainly the part about renting guns, I am not totally against having to have taken a basic firearms course prior to being able to purchase a handgun.

I did purchase mine before I took the class, but took the class very shortly thereafter.

 

The 2nd amendment didn't mention training requirements.

 

 

I'm with both of you. I firmly believe in safety training, but how do you make it a requirement to exorcise a right?

 

If we could find an incentive for people to take a class, well, then, maybe......

 

There is no training requirement in PA and LTCF owner incidents are almost unheard of. With 1/14 people carrying in the Commonwealth. That being said, I agree training is a good thing.

Training should be STRONGLY ENCOURAGED, and the police should offer courses if the Legislature is going to throw another unfunded mandate. I have been muzzle swept one too many times, and have had to stop shooting to go tell someone how to handle their gun, or tell some kids dad that 'you need to teach them this'

I really dont give a shit if its rude, or whatever.

Training should be STRONGLY ENCOURAGED, and the police should offer courses if the Legislature is going to throw another unfunded mandate. I have been muzzle swept one too many times, and have had to stop shooting to go tell someone how to handle their gun, or tell some kids dad that 'you need to teach them this'

I really dont give a **** if its rude, or whatever.

 

How does the government strongly encourage something? Either it's law or it aint.

 

The reason there are so few issues of incidents that you describe among CCW carriers is because handguns are safe when they are in holsters. They can shoot themselves in their home, or sweep you at a range. These are serious issues. But CCW has nothing to do with this. Anybody that owns a gun can make these mistakes.

The incentive is you can't get a carry permit without taking a CCW course.

 

Simple and the requirements end right there.

 

I do not agree letting any as$hole walk around with a gun is a good idea.

 

I agree with you on the CCW training. But I think we were discussing training as a requirement to get the basic NJ FID card first. I don't know how you would reconcile that. But then again, it is a requirement in DC.

 

 

I am talking about for CCW.

 

Wouldn't be bad to need it to pruchase 1st handgun, but I am not for a law requiring that. CCW, yes.

We have a range master every day just to make sure we have someone to help out there with safety and just general instructions, you HAVE to now a days, its a must and a business expense we just have to deal with to keep everyone safe.

what congressmen? district 30? if so, we need to keep on top of this, and as soon as the bill makes it's way into the public eye, we need to hit em hard with phone calls, emails, and mailings..

I had to have a certification of firearms training and use when I applied for the Florida CCW permit, and I think (I forget) I had to show a copy of the certificate for other permits as well.

I don't think it's unreasonable to require some training to CCW, as long as the requirements don't place an undue burden (either financial or logistical) on an applicant. The days when basic firearms training was passed from generation to generation as part of growing up are, sadly, long behind us, and knowing how to properly use and manage a firearm protects the owner as well as any unfortunate bystanders who may be in the line of fire.

I'm not sure, but I think you do need a truck load of cash as a requirement for a CCW in NJ, along with a sack full of diamonds.

 

I fixed it for truth. :lol:

not to point out the obvious as it applies to training.. training for ANYTHING is good.. BUT...

 

there was a time in this country where a gun was really just another item of personal ownership.. and there were no "special" requirements in place to stop law abiding citizens from owning and carrying these items.. safety classes were not forced onto people and life went on just fine, its not like there were crazy mass killings and chaos..

 

again i PERSONALLY think that classes are great AND important.. i have taken several firearms classes and learned a ton.. but making them required seems to not really be appropriate.. so what can you do.. when you start taking something that is a right and adding on little restrictions.. you open the door for over regulation..

not to point out the obvious as it applies to training.. training for ANYTHING is good.. BUT...

 

there was a time in this country where a gun was really just another item of personal ownership.. and there were no "special" requirements in place to stop law abiding citizens from owning and carrying these items.. safety classes were not forced onto people and life went on just fine, its not like there were crazy mass killings and chaos..

 

again i PERSONALLY think that classes are great AND important.. i have taken several firearms classes and learned a ton.. but making them required seems to not really be appropriate.. so what can you do.. when you start taking something that is a right and adding on little restrictions.. you open the door for over regulation..

 

Mind you that you can still buy a car/truck in NJ without a driver's license. In addition, you can operate that vehicle on your property without any type of licensing required despite driving being a "privilege" in NJ.

not to point out the obvious as it applies to training.. training for ANYTHING is good.. BUT...

 

there was a time in this country where a gun was really just another item of personal ownership.. and there were no "special" requirements in place to stop law abiding citizens from owning and carrying these items.. safety classes were not forced onto people and life went on just fine, its not like there were crazy mass killings and chaos..

 

again i PERSONALLY think that classes are great AND important.. i have taken several firearms classes and learned a ton.. but making them required seems to not really be appropriate.. so what can you do.. when you start taking something that is a right and adding on little restrictions.. you open the door for over regulation..

 

Mind you that you can still buy a car/truck in NJ without a driver's license. In addition, you can operate that vehicle on your property without any type of licensing required despite driving being a "privilege" in NJ.

 

Your truck doesn't dispense hot lead moving at 1200 fps though. I see some people shoot and I :pray: (for their neighbors) nobody ever breaks into their homes. Especially since people seem to like +P and +P+ loads for home defense. :naughty:

...Your truck doesn't dispense hot lead moving at 1200 fps though. ...

 

Your gun can't move 2 tons of steel at 100 mph either.

 

Both are dangerous when their energy is focused the "wrong" way.

...Your truck doesn't dispense hot lead moving at 1200 fps though. ...

 

Your gun can't move 2 tons of steel at 100 mph either.

 

Both are dangerous when their energy is focused the "wrong" way.

 

Exactly. More people are killed each year in automobile wrecks than with guns.

 

2006, United States

Firearm Deaths and Rates per 100,000

All Races, Both Sexes, All Ages

ICD-10 Codes: W32-W34,X72-X74,X93-X95,Y22-Y24,

Y35.0,*U01.4

 

 

 

Number of

Deaths Population Crude

Rate Age-Adjusted

Rate**

30,896 298,362,973 10.36 10.22

 

2006, United States

Overall Motor Vehicle Deaths and Rates per 100,000

All Races, Both Sexes, All Ages

ICD-10 Codes: V02-V04,V09.0,V09.2,V12-V14,V19.0-V19.2,V19.4-V19.6,V20-V79,

V80.3-V80.5,V81.0-V81.1,V82.0-V82.1,V83-V86,V87.0-V87.8,

V88.0-V88.8,V89.0,V89.2, X82,Y03,Y32

 

 

 

Number of

Deaths Population Crude

Rate Age-Adjusted

Rate**

45,509 298,362,973 15.25 15.06

 

http://webappa.cdc.gov/sasweb/ncipc/mortrate10_sy.html

not to point out the obvious as it applies to training.. training for ANYTHING is good.. BUT...

 

there was a time in this country where a gun was really just another item of personal ownership.. and there were no "special" requirements in place to stop law abiding citizens from owning and carrying these items.. safety classes were not forced onto people and life went on just fine, its not like there were crazy mass killings and chaos..

 

again i PERSONALLY think that classes are great AND important.. i have taken several firearms classes and learned a ton.. but making them required seems to not really be appropriate.. so what can you do.. when you start taking something that is a right and adding on little restrictions.. you open the door for over regulation..

 

Mind you that you can still buy a car/truck in NJ without a driver's license. In addition, you can operate that vehicle on your property without any type of licensing required despite driving being a "privilege" in NJ.

 

Your truck doesn't dispense hot lead moving at 1200 fps though. I see some people shoot and I :pray: (for their neighbors) nobody ever breaks into their homes. Especially since people seem to like +P and +P+ loads for home defense. :naughty:

 

 

i dont know.. stand 100 yards away and get hit with a single bullet OR a car barreling down towards you at top speed.. i think in a situation where you get hit with both.. id take the bullet.. granted placement of shot is going to be an issue.. but i think youd have a better shot (no pun intended) living through it.. like i said before all for training.. but not really all for a nanny state mandatory training.. guns, chemicals, cars, cigarettes, etc.. there are TONS of dangerous things in the world.. you can only rely on the government to hand hold to some point..

Training is great. Some of it is good, some bad. Anyone can call themselves a master of the art and start selling it.

 

The bottom line comes down to getting the best from those that know what they are talking about. If one decides to accept the responsibility of possessing a firearm under the various circumstances, they better believe they need training. Only an idiot would do so without it.

 

I see more idiots up here that have no business possessing, much less carrying a firearm. Probably the reason that incidents are rising. We are at the point of rewriting membership rules for applications to screen potential members even closer. A club's use has been suspended when a wild shot traveled a mile and struck a car driving down the road. Expensive modifications will be required before being allowed open. Why? Because some are just too stupid to know where their muzzle is before firing a shot. I'd like to think it was really rare but after seeing on no longer a member rapid fire his AR15 from his hip unaimed, I no longer wonder.

 

Just yesterday an arrest was made when during a road rage someone pointed a handgun at the other motorist.

 

Too many carry thinking the piece of paper is all they need. Or a quick several hour course. But God help them if they are involved in an incident because there is no going back to change things. Anyone that has ever been involved in a case can multiply it several times. One incident years back cost a resident everything he owned when he screwed up and shot his daughter's boyfriend.

 

REALLY good training can help avoid such problems but nothing perfect. But why put yourself behind the eight ball to start with? On the other hand, stupidity isn't going to be cured by any training I know of.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.