Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

What's the deal with open carry in NJ?

Featured Replies

I have to agree with Damagedworld on this guy. The fact that his wife was afraid to be in the house with him, he built an indoor shooting range tells me there is something wrong with this guy. I own more firearms then this person but I am not shooting them in the house or stock piling smoke grenades. I believe in my 2nd Amendment rights but there is a line between being a responsible gun owner and someone that thinks the 2nd Amendment give them the right to do what ever they want with a firearm.

I don't care what everyone says...I think the guy has a few loose screws in his noggin. The guns I understand and accept. The kevlar vest and mask and smoke grenades is what is troubling. " i use it for hunting" or "it's for self defense" is just not gonna cut it.

well maybe his neighborhood is different... but HERE I don't think that you can turn a third story of your house into a shooting range.. and i further dont think you can legally have ANY type of grenade... I am no lawyer but it DOES appear the state has a case in this instance.. while i LOVE guns... while I further believe there IS a possibility for our society to slip into civil unrest.. while I even own a bullet proof vest... i DO NOT discharge my firearms in residential areas.. certainly not in my home.. can you HONESTLY say that you believe no laws have been violated here?

 

No, smoke grenades are not illegal to own in his area. Neither are flash suppressors. Or batons. Or pieces of steel. All his guns were lawfully purchased.

 

Furthermore, they keep calling it a firing range, but have shown no evidence that firearms were fired there. Judging by how they labeled crusty old Enfield's "Assault Rifles" I wouldn't think it very unrealistic at all that his "firing range" was a little steel pellet trap from Dick's for shooting air guns. If they come up with evidence that he is firing guns up there, then yes he is guilty of a crime. But judging by how badly they exaggerated everything else, I have a feeling this "firing range" was a BB trap.

 

Also to tommy, please explain to me how armor would not be useful for self defense?

 

Regardless, my posting of that article was not to stick up for Mr. Girard. I have no dog in that fight. It was to display how if you seriously think you can throw an unloaded gun in your backseat and then play roadside lawyer with a state trooper, I hope you like the food in jail.

well maybe his neighborhood is different... but HERE I don't think that you can turn a third story of your house into a shooting range.. and i further dont think you can legally have ANY type of grenade... I am no lawyer but it DOES appear the state has a case in this instance.. while i LOVE guns... while I further believe there IS a possibility for our society to slip into civil unrest.. while I even own a bullet proof vest... i DO NOT discharge my firearms in residential areas.. certainly not in my home.. can you HONESTLY say that you believe no laws have been violated here?

 

No, smoke grenades are not illegal to own in his area. Neither are flash suppressors. Or batons. Or pieces of steel. All his guns were lawfully purchased.

 

Furthermore, they keep calling it a firing range, but have shown no evidence that firearms were fired there. Judging by how they labeled crusty old Enfield's "Assault Rifles" I wouldn't think it very unrealistic at all that his "firing range" was a little steel pellet trap from Dick's for shooting air guns. If they come up with evidence that he is firing guns up there, then yes he is guilty of a crime. But judging by how badly they exaggerated everything else, I have a feeling this "firing range" was a BB trap.

 

Also to tommy, please explain to me how armor would not be useful for self defense?

 

Regardless, my posting of that article was not to stick up for Mr. Girard. I have no dog in that fight. It was to display how if you seriously think you can throw an unloaded gun in your backseat and then play roadside lawyer with a state trooper, I hope you like the food in jail.

 

he had tear gas grenades, NOT just smoke grenades.... are they legal there? neighbors stated he told them not to be alarmed if they heard gun fire.. they say he shot at the plate and have images of the bullets impact on it.. at any rate... comparing this nutcase to me driving down the road with an UNLOADED shotgun in my trunk to me is an unfair comparison.. while i do NOT trust my government.. i do not live in fear of prosecution while FOLLOWING the letter of the law.. to be honest.. i am not out to prove a thing.. but if i was confronted and arrested at a time for LAWFULLY transporting a firearm TO THE LETTER of the LAW... i would NOT play roadside lawyer.. i would allow the officer to do his job and fight my battle in court if need be.. the irony is as i stated before i was stopped in NJ by a STATE TROOPER who observed a PR24 in my vehicle.. the ONLY issue we had that night was me being informed i could NOT travel with that item within the passenger compartment of the vehicle.. and was instructed to put it in the trunk..

Hey, you have fun with that. I'll just wait to live somewhere that you can have a real CCW.

 

I am NOT stating that carrying an unloaded shotgun in the trunk is equal to carry conceal :roll: I am simply saying that AS the law is WORDED it appears to be completely appropriate to transfer an UNLOADED LONG GUN in any manor consistent to what is stated within the law, even when NOT going to the range.. or NOT going to hunt.. etc... drawing a comparison between carry conceal and what is being discussed here is kind of a stretch IMO..

Hey, you have fun with that. I'll just wait to live somewhere that you can have a real CCW.

 

I am NOT stating that carrying an unloaded shotgun in the trunk is equal to carry conceal :roll: I am simply saying that AS the law is WORDED it appears to be completely appropriate to transfer an UNLOADED LONG GUN in any manor consistent to what is stated within the law, even when NOT going to the range.. or NOT going to hunt.. etc... drawing a comparison between carry conceal and what is being discussed here is kind of a stretch IMO..

 

I fail to see the stretch. The only reason I'd ever want a gun on/near me is either to have fun at the range, hunt, work on/maintain, or defend myself. An unloaded shotgun in the back of my truck serves none of those purposes so why would I want that liability?

 

I'm aware of what the law states and your interpretation makes sense, and aside from it being useless, I certainly wouldn't want to be explaining to a state trooper on the side of the highway, or worse yet, a local cop. What can I say, you've got more balls than me lol. :D

I fail to see the stretch. The only reason I'd ever want a gun on/near me is either to have fun at the range, hunt, work on/maintain, or defend myself. An unloaded shotgun in the back of my truck serves none of those purposes so why would I want that liability?

 

I'm aware of what the law states and your interpretation makes sense, and aside from it being useless, I certainly wouldn't want to be explaining to a state trooper on the side of the highway, or worse yet, a local cop. What can I say, you've got more balls than me lol. :D

 

no worries ;) not saying it is overly useful... just stating it is likely legal.. :D

re Girard: Gas Grenades are DEFINITLY "Infernal Devices" under Ma Law. Also, because they pose a significant risk of starting fires the jury is out up there on Smoke grenades as well (Both of which are actually legal here in NJ BTW). Rockwell can spin this either way, but the simple fact is that the Wife reported a domestic, and IIRC got a Restraining Order in the process..which means those guns would have been forfeit ANYWAY.

That's why I specified a SUB2K. At 16" x 7" folded (per their website) it would be possible to carry around; requiring unfolding and inserting a magazine to bring into play. Any non-short-barrel shotgun is going to be much less portable.

 

Other amusing monkeywrenches of the law would include an air gun with a projectile of larger than 3/8" (the law specified that an airgun has to have a projectile smaller than 3/8" to be considered a firearm), a pump-action weapon with a folding stock, or a pump-action weapon with a magazine larger than 15 rounds (6 for shotgun). All of these are technically not covered by the various laws. But I would expect to be arressted, maybe tried, and possibly convicted if I actually tried to carry any of those about my person in public; at least until the 2A is incorproated Nd the "bear" part of the 2A is ruled as allowing carry.

 

In NJ the law does not distiguish between open and concealed carry; both are illegal unless permitted by law. While there *is* a clause permitting someone to carry an unloaded longarm after obtaining a FID, I don't seriously believe it would be a good idea to do so arbitrarily, just that you will get a little more tolerance at the margins of transport under the legal exemptions for possession.

Here is a novel idea. . .

 

Those who think its legal, do it.

 

Those who think its not, don't.

 

Perhaps the fine folks of NJGF will hold a fund raiser for bail money for one of those groups. Can you guess which one?

Here is a novel idea. . .

 

Those who think its legal, do it.

 

Those who think its not, don't.

 

Perhaps the fine folks of NJGF will hold a fund raiser for bail money for one of those groups. Can you guess which one?

 

I like that idea! :lol:

Also to tommy, please explain to me how armor would not be useful for self defense

...

when it's used with the intent to commit a crime. But that was more for the "for hunting" excuse. I just grouped all the stuff found that was considered questionable.

there are enough ACTUAL laws on the book to dance around.. why sit here and make up more that are NOT defined.. while i would NOT carrying an unloaded firearm in public i WOULD carry one in my vehicle even if i was not headed to the range.. the ONLY reason i would NOT carry one around openly in public is due to the likelihood of creating some false public panic.. carrying an UNLOADED long gun in some type of case OR in the trunk of a car consistent with NJ law does not appear to be a problem.. why we would sit here and accept and or agree is beyond me.. maybe some of us are on the other side of the fence..

read the law.. if what you want to do is NOT prohibited.. OR it requires criteria to be met (unloaded firearm for example), then you are FINE...

 

saying "i would not drive around with an unloaded shotgun in your trunk because you might get hassled is being OVERLY cautious, and is a statement made with NO SOUND LEGAL GROUND"

It's not that I'm interpreting any law the wrong way.

 

It's that, why the hell would I want an unloaded long gun locked in my trunk for? Serves me no good, and only a liability if the car is stolen, etc. There is no way I could possibly use it to defend myself if needed.

 

I could carry a bagpipe, a kitchen sink, a Boba Fett action figure in my trunk too, but what the heck is the point?

 

I assure you, I know which side of the fence I'm on. I believe in the right of the people to keep an bear arms. And I am also aware that I currently do not posses that right, and have no need to pretend that I kinda do.

 

Anyway this crap just keeps going in circle so I really don't wanna debate anymore. Congrats on finding the grey area, have fun carrying the unloaded long gun. Me, you won't catch me with so much as a single spent casing in my truck if I'm not on the way to the range. To each his own.

  • Author

Semi - 0T -- until very recently I was highranking in the booze biz... LSS

last summer I made sure one of my guys gave a discount to a clean cut retired mil looking gentleman wearing an all black bdu-style uniform and wearing a niceness belt with a hammer-type black semi pistol. He thanks me, I tell him as the son of a high ranking career cop capt it's my pleasure , what do you do? LMFAO , but he's like , I'm a guard for a 7 - 11 , they gave me a job, sent me to a short training class, and applied me for a weapon. So I guard the 7 11 hot dog area, making sure no one takes too many mustard or ketchup packs , abuses the " PUSH FOR FREE CHILL

/ PUSH FOR FREE CHEESE " buttons , or wastes the frsh condiments like chopped onions, pickles, relish, etc.

 

He was 1000% serious.

Semi - 0T -- until very recently I was highranking in the booze biz... LSS

last summer I made sure one of my guys gave a discount to a clean cut retired mil looking gentleman wearing an all black bdu-style uniform and wearing a niceness belt with a hammer-type black semi pistol. He thanks me, I tell him as the son of a high ranking career cop capt it's my pleasure , what do you do? LMFAO , but he's like , I'm a guard for a 7 - 11 , they gave me a job, sent me to a short training class, and applied me for a weapon. So I guard the 7 11 hot dog area, making sure no one takes too many mustard or ketchup packs , abuses the " PUSH FOR FREE CHILL

/ PUSH FOR FREE CHEESE " buttons , or wastes the frsh condiments like chopped onions, pickles, relish, etc.

 

He was 1000% serious.

 

Yep. Wouldn't doubt that for a second. We had clowns at my old job carrying that didn't even know how to wear a gun belt properly, much less draw the gun :lol:

If you have an NJ CCW you could open carry a handgun and it is 100% legal provided you are not in a prohibited place.

 

However, if you are not in a security guard uniform, and walking around in public places like restaurants, gas stations, down the street, you will draw lots of unwanted attention and possibly even panic. You cannot be charged with a crime for open carrying if you are licensed to do so, but you can and will be charged with other things like "disturbing the peace" "terroristic threats" etc.

 

Check out some open carry websites like opencarry.org or youtube videos, people videotape their open carrying in states like NH, OH, etc. and in certain towns even though perfectly legal they are often thrown to the ground, searched, hassled, and even brought down to the station on various other charges by PDs who "don't want that sort of thing in their town"

 

I noticed you didn't mention PA. I OC 100% of the time. Including inside my bank branches. I just leave my gun in the car when I go in the Post Office, that's it. And I conceal in State Parks because it's a reg.

 

Never had a single problem. I live in Lehigh Valley where we are crawling with NY'ers and NJ'ers. Probably one out of ten license plates. Dozens of cops have seen my sidearm. I have certainly heard of people being hassled, but it is rare. And even more rare after 2009 when all cops were re-trained it is legal and they are not permitted to require ID or charge disorderly conduct simply for OC. That is Official Oppression in PA, and we have rule of law here.

If you have an NJ CCW you could open carry a handgun and it is 100% legal provided you are not in a prohibited place.

 

However, if you are not in a security guard uniform, and walking around in public places like restaurants, gas stations, down the street, you will draw lots of unwanted attention and possibly even panic. You cannot be charged with a crime for open carrying if you are licensed to do so, but you can and will be charged with other things like "disturbing the peace" "terroristic threats" etc.

 

Check out some open carry websites like opencarry.org or youtube videos, people videotape their open carrying in states like NH, OH, etc. and in certain towns even though perfectly legal they are often thrown to the ground, searched, hassled, and even brought down to the station on various other charges by PDs who "don't want that sort of thing in their town"

 

I noticed you didn't mention PA. I OC 100% of the time. Including inside my bank branches. I just leave my gun in the car when I go in the Post Office, that's it. And I conceal in State Parks because it's a reg.

 

Never had a single problem. I live in Lehigh Valley where we are crawling with NY'ers and NJ'ers. Probably one out of ten license plates. Dozens of cops have seen my sidearm. I have certainly heard of people being hassled, but it is rare. And even more rare after 2009 when all cops were re-trained it is legal and they are not permitted to require ID or charge disorderly conduct simply for OC. That is Official Oppression in PA, and we have rule of law here.

 

That is awesome, I am very glad to know that, especially Lehigh Valley because I plan on moving to that area late next year. That's where I go shooting currently too. How regular is open carry around there?

If you have an NJ CCW you could open carry a handgun and it is 100% legal provided you are not in a prohibited place.

 

However, if you are not in a security guard uniform, and walking around in public places like restaurants, gas stations, down the street, you will draw lots of unwanted attention and possibly even panic. You cannot be charged with a crime for open carrying if you are licensed to do so, but you can and will be charged with other things like "disturbing the peace" "terroristic threats" etc.

 

Check out some open carry websites like opencarry.org or youtube videos, people videotape their open carrying in states like NH, OH, etc. and in certain towns even though perfectly legal they are often thrown to the ground, searched, hassled, and even brought down to the station on various other charges by PDs who "don't want that sort of thing in their town"

 

I noticed you didn't mention PA. I OC 100% of the time. Including inside my bank branches. I just leave my gun in the car when I go in the Post Office, that's it. And I conceal in State Parks because it's a reg.

 

Never had a single problem. I live in Lehigh Valley where we are crawling with NY'ers and NJ'ers. Probably one out of ten license plates. Dozens of cops have seen my sidearm. I have certainly heard of people being hassled, but it is rare. And even more rare after 2009 when all cops were re-trained it is legal and they are not permitted to require ID or charge disorderly conduct simply for OC. That is Official Oppression in PA, and we have rule of law here.

 

That is awesome, I am very glad to know that, especially Lehigh Valley because I plan on moving to that area late next year. That's where I go shooting currently too. How regular is open carry around there?

 

It depends on how you define "regular." It's pretty rare for me to see strangers doing it outside of gunshops, etc. But I know many people in my nearest town that do, and others all over LV.

 

Make your move. It will change the way you think about life. Let me know when you get here.

I definitely will. Once I finish up trade school next year, I'm gone! It's great there, my club is in Lehigh Valley too so I'm out that way maybe every other week or so.

mipafox, where are you located in relation to Lehigh Valley Airport? I've been working contract for a company based there for the last 11 months and hope to go full time with them. If I do, I hope to move with in a year or 2. Free state sounds good. :D

I'm close. But it doesn't matter. I OC all over that area. It's a great place to fly out of, you don't have to show up two hours before your flight. And they are not douchebags, and the place is quiet.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.