Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

30 gang bangers outside your home? Defend yourself = arrest

Featured Replies

the official chrage is felony reckless endangerment..no weapons charges were filed...he could beat this in front of a jury....2 other shootings were reported within a block of his house that night.....

  • Replies 70
  • Views 2.9k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Hiding in your house is fine when you are talking about 1, 2, 3, maybe even up to 5 attackers. But 20?? No, Im sorry. I KNOW that what he did was not legal, but the was absolutely no other way for him to protect his family. Windows can be broken, and when you have guys pouring in through a doorway and two windows.....from every direction......you cant protect your family. Confronting them OUTSIDE the house, while they were in a group, before they split up.....to me was the right thing to do. As for the warning shots....at least he shot them them into the ground, and not into the air. I also agree that if he pleads that he feared for his life, and the life of his family....any sane jury should let him go.

hes on channel 5, good day NY right now. greg kelly immediately said 'its an assault rifle', and the guys lawyer right away say its not an AK47, and its not an assault rifle, nothing illegal about it. i used to like greg kelly, but now hes being a douche, somewhat attacking the guy, making it seem like he used too much force, and his family wasnt in danger since they were inside.

one thing that strikes me, and yes, the guy had a right to protect his family, but why didn't he just call the cops first. granted, they would've taken an hour to show up, but it would've been on the record that he called the police before taking up his rifle.

he told his wife to call the cops. according to the story, she couldnt find her cel phone and didnt get a chance to.

there's just one phone in the house? no house phone, just cell? I dunno, it sounds like there's much more to this story than is being said...

there's just one phone in the house? no house phone, just cell? I dunno, it sounds like there's much more to this story than is being said...

 

I don't have a house phone.

meh..... this 21st century crap... you're right, many people don't. still, it's fishy....

I do not have a house phone as well, my father and I just have cell phones. And I can guarantee you that if there were 20+ guys gathering in front of my house, I would confront them outside.

I would too. but I almost always have my phone in my pocket and the local PD phone # on speed dial (long story why - job related)

Anyone know how to view the interview on Fox News fro this morning. Would like to see it but can't find it on the web site.

 

Never mind - I found it.

Ok, will one of you "I'd go outside" people explain the logic of confronting 20+ people outside of your house instead of calling the cops and waiting? Assuming they aren't trying to enter your house, how are they a direct threat to you? And how are you protecting your family by going outside and leaving your family alone inside the house?

 

20 to 1, even armed with an AK, aren't very good odds... It's one thing if they're all outside of your home and actively trying to do you or your loved ones harm... but why put yourself and your family at risk when the threat isn't directed at you?? Let the bangers beat the snot out of each.. who cares.

Ok, will one of you "I'd go outside" people explain the logic of confronting 20+ people outside of your house instead of calling the cops and waiting? Assuming they aren't trying to enter your house, how are they a direct threat to you? And how are you protecting your family by going outside and leaving your family alone inside the house?

 

20 to 1, even armed with an AK, aren't very good odds... It's one thing if they're all outside of your home and actively trying to do you or your loved ones harm... but why put yourself and your family at risk when the threat isn't directed at you?? Let the bangers beat the snot out of each.. who cares.

I get the feeling you didnt read the posts in this thread, or the article itself. They were not rival gang members, they all belonged to the same gang. They were not arguing outside amongst themselves, they were threatening this man and his family saying they would kill his wife and his babies.

 

As for confronting them outside, I have said it several times. If he confronts them outside the way he did, they are in a GROUP, not individual. It is much easier to defend against a solid group of 20 that is in ONE direction, then to defend against 20 guys coming in every single window of your house. Any given room in my house has at least two windows, plus the doors....and my house has ~12 windows. Imagine being in a single story house, with 2 people coming in EVERY WINDOW at the exact same time. You pick which scenario is better.

I get the feeling you didnt read the posts in this thread, or the article itself. They were not rival gang members, they all belonged to the same gang. They were not arguing outside amongst themselves, they were threatening this man and his family saying they would kill his wife and his babies.

You're right - I didn't read every post. But I did read this one

And I can guarantee you that if there were 20+ guys gathering in front of my house, I would confront them outside.

Why would you go outside?

 

ETA: And just for clarification, and I guess I should have made this clearer in my original statement, I wasn't so much referring to the guy with the AK... it was a general question regarding the blanket comments about going outside.

Imagine being in a single story house, with 2 people coming in EVERY WINDOW at the exact same time. You pick which scenario is better.

 

That sounds more like a zombie attack though. My personal assumption is that all 20 of those guys have guns. If I'm outside, in the open, there's a lot more of a chance of me getting shot and killed. If you're defending your home, it would be best to pull back and create choke points. Yes, they could potentially come in via windows, but do you think that all of the gang members that were involved were thinking about that?

I'd still figure out a way to call the cops. and stay in the house. as it's been said before, this guy and his family are now targets of this gang. wherever they go, supermarket, work, daycare/school they aren't safe. they can't live there anymore.

I'd still figure out a way to call the cops. and stay in the house. as it's been said before, this guy and his family are now targets of this gang. wherever they go, supermarket, work, daycare/school they aren't safe. they can't live there anymore.

 

And if they called the cops this would be different?? :roll:

I'd still figure out a way to call the cops. and stay in the house. as it's been said before, this guy and his family are now targets of this gang. wherever they go, supermarket, work, daycare/school they aren't safe. they can't live there anymore.

 

And if they called the cops this would be different?? :roll:

 

they are targets no matter what, he should have let them in and then see what his rifle could do..

I should have clarified "going outside". I do not mean face to face outside, I meant in the doorway so that you could EASILY fall back inside. I would just make sure that I confronted them before they got the idea to split up and come in from every direction but up.

Imagine being in a single story house, with 2 people coming in EVERY WINDOW at the exact same time. You pick which scenario is better.

 

That sounds more like a zombie attack though. My personal assumption is that all 20 of those guys have guns. If I'm outside, in the open, there's a lot more of a chance of me getting shot and killed. If you're defending your home, it would be best to pull back and create choke points. Yes, they could potentially come in via windows, but do you think that all of the gang members that were involved were thinking about that?

 

Create a "Fatal Funnel", that's the only way to deal with 20 people coming at you, especially if they're armed. For me, it's my staircase to the second floor of my house. If I go prone in a certain spot, I always see you before you see me.

Here's the piece on FOX for those that haven't seen it:

http://www.myfoxny.com/dpp/good_day_ny/ ... e-20100909

 

 

Thanks for the link. Sounds like he was just at his front door based on what he was saying and from what I can see from the picture of the house.

 

Tough call on falling back inside since he was in fear for the life of his cousin who was outside and surrounded.

I should have clarified "going outside". I do not mean face to face outside, I meant in the doorway so that you could EASILY fall back inside. I would just make sure that I confronted them before they got the idea to split up and come in from every direction but up.

 

 

it sounds like this is what he did. he didnt just saunter out into the yard in the middle of the brawl. im fairly sure he stood in his doorway, or at least directly in front of it, then fired the shots.

 

to be more 'legal', he could have stayed completely in his house, not a foot outside, possibly using the 'castle doctrine' kind of defense, even though im sure NYC doesnt have one. with any luck, the case will be thrown out and he'll get his gun back.

I should have clarified "going outside". I do not mean face to face outside, I meant in the doorway so that you could EASILY fall back inside. I would just make sure that I confronted them before they got the idea to split up and come in from every direction but up.

 

 

it sounds like this is what he did. he didnt just saunter out into the yard in the middle of the brawl. im fairly sure he stood in his doorway, or at least directly in front of it, then fired the shots.

 

to be more 'legal', he could have stayed completely in his house, not a foot outside, possibly using the 'castle doctrine' kind of defense, even though im sure NYC doesnt have one. with any luck, the case will be thrown out and he'll get his gun back.

 

 

There is a part of NY law that says you are authorized to use deadly physical force to prevent the death or serious injury of another. I can see how that could very well come up. YOU would have to retreat, but to defend another, in this case, would not prevent anything.

 

From what he tells, he was plenty authorized to use it. If he had gone inside and taken them out there would be real dead people. Sounds like everyone got off a little better than they could have.

Grier said he knew Nassau County Police employ the hi-tech
Create a "Fatal Funnel", that's the only way to deal with 20 people coming at you, especially if they're armed. For me, it's my staircase to the second floor of my house. If I go prone in a certain spot, I always see you before you see me.

That works great for you. Luckily you have a second story that you can do that with. I dont, so what am I left with in this situation? Im left with trying to scare them away when they are in a group, or trying to defend my home while they are coming in from every direction. I just honestly dont think there was any way this guy could have SAFELY defended his family, AND not break the law in some way. Thats why I feel that his method was the best way TO DEFEND HIS FAMILY. It may not have been the most legally sound decision, but I think it was honestly the best way to defend his family. Hopefully this will be taken into consideration.

Here's the piece on FOX for those that haven't seen it:

http://www.myfoxny.com/dpp/good_day_ny/ ... e-20100909

 

 

Thanks for the link. Sounds like he was just at his front door based on what he was saying and from what I can see from the picture of the house.

 

Tough call on falling back inside since he was in fear for the life of his cousin who was outside and surrounded.

 

Staying in the house would not be an option with someone from the family outside. Who know what would have happened to his cousin. Easier to live with the possibility of jail, then failing to defend loved ones. Isn't that why we all have / practice home defense?

Oh wow, I didnt even know that his cousin was outside. Hell yea, protecting a family member that is on your front lawn surrounded by 20-25 gang members DEFINITELY warrants using a gun.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.