Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

SAF and ANJRPC files suit against the state of NJ!

Featured Replies

how long do these suits take before a decision is made, or when it even goes to trial?

 

6 months? a year?

 

It was filed this week. In a few months, there will be a motion to dismiss filed by the State. If the motion is granted, the process ends there. If it doesn't, then a hearing gets scheduled (maybe a year later?). After it's argued and decided, then it'll likely be appealed.

 

Somebody said earlier that it'll likely be 2 years before it's ultimately settled. I think that sounds about right.

  • Replies 160
  • Views 17k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • In my eyes, the anjrpc is basically just the cherry ridge gun club. If it's supposed to be the NJ NRA org, why did it take them this long to do anything? it almost seems like they're riding the coatta

  • Well I guess I can scrap my letter to Gov. Christie about wedging a lawsuit up NJ's butt as SAF beat me too it. IMO the ANJRPC is just along for the ride as local representation. As promised (as far a

  • I live in NJ. Which happens to be in the USA.   That's all the "justifiable need" ANY citizen should require.

  • Author

It was filed this week. In a few months, there will be a motion to dismiss filed by the State. If the motion is granted, the process ends there. If it doesn't, then a hearing gets scheduled (maybe a year later?). After it's argued and decided, then it'll likely be appealed.

 

Somebody said earlier that it'll likely be 2 years before it's ultimately settled. I think that sounds about right.

 

Two years is a good estimate given the fact that no matter who wins in the district court the case is going to be appealed to the SCOTUS... You also have four other district court cases that mirror this case in the pipes that will follow similar paths.

It was filed this week. In a few months, there will be a motion to dismiss filed by the State. If the motion is granted, the process ends there. If it doesn't, then a hearing gets scheduled (maybe a year later?). After it's argued and decided, then it'll likely be appealed.

 

Somebody said earlier that it'll likely be 2 years before it's ultimately settled. I think that sounds about right.

 

Understand it was filed in federal court, its a 'facial' challenge, meaning, all of the laws regarding CCW in NJ are illegal. Its a big move in that it nulls NJ law void. Being that the federal court is bound by interpretation of the law, and the judge that may hear the case is a federal judge, not a state judge.

NJ will file a motion to dismiss for sure, but clearly a federal judge will not dismiss a case that looks as interesting as this one. If the permitting system is so arbitrary, and NJ has transferred a judge to an admin role while in that admin role they have a say of yes or no on a guaranteed right of citizens based on the 14th and 2nd amendments, then we are in front of the supreme court when NJ files an appeal. Then while it is in appeal, we may be able to carry as the appeals court would have a hard time granting an injunction on a federal right.

See, the issue in NJ is that the gun laws are illegal. The way they are written, is they make guns illegal as a category of prohibited 'things', then carve out 2 exemptions, in your home, or on the way to a range or back home with no stops pretty much...where in the USA is that legal? NOWHERE but NJ...

The SCOTUS has stated in notes that the state cannot totally ban carrying of guns in non sensitive places, nor can the process be arbitrary...NJ has done both via the latter....

24 months out....

Havent posted in awhile, been really busy with work but the email from ANJPRC got me interested again after I thought the 2A people forgot us. This is not going to take forever. Rep was on NRA news 2 days ago saying they will use whatever procedural methods they can to speed this along. A favorite trick on the govt is to ask for more time to answer and then file a motion to dismiss. Therefore, the request should be denied. I always grant them out of professional courtesy but they dont play fair, neither should we. That moves up their motion to dismiss. Technically they can start their scheduling about 6 months out, give 2 months for briefs. I can see an answer in 9 months. Then an appeal.

 

I also think the legislature will frantically try and change the laws to make the case moot. Thankfully we have a republican governor,so there is some chance he vetoes anything crazy.

All they have to do is change the law to shall issue, but define no-carry zones as the "sensitive" areas anywhere within 5000 feet of a school, courthouse, public transit station, or any municipal building.

 

Then it's guaranteed to go to the SC for a weigh in on what qualifies as "sensitive".

All they have to do is change the law to shall issue, but define no-carry zones as the "sensitive" areas anywhere within 5000 feet of a school, courthouse, public transit station, or any municipal building.

 

Then it's guaranteed to go to the SC for a weigh in on what qualifies as "sensitive".

 

5000 feet is almost a mile. Some small towns are only a mile or two in square mileage. That would pretty much bar you from carrying in your entire town.

5000 feet is almost a mile. Some small towns are only a mile or two in square mileage. That would pretty much bar you from carrying in your entire town.

 

 

like mine. they use the 5000ft. mark as their own loophole, as nearly everything in the state is within a mile of said buildings. my house is 300ft from 2 schools. youd be hard pressed to find a single spot in bergen county that is outside of a mile from the bullshyt 'sensitive' areas. youre talking a mile radius of every school, courthouse, civic center, police station, train station........its absolutely ridiculous.

5000 feet is almost a mile. Some small towns are only a mile or two in square mileage. That would pretty much bar you from carrying in your entire town.

 

That was kinda my point.

I don't know about you guys, but im really pissed off that they would use my tax dollars to fight something that's obviously unconstitutional in the first place.

im pissed after all of our tax dollars are collected, we're still 3 trillion in debt. im pissed my taxes have funded a war that started in the wrong country and continued for the next 8 years.

I don't know about you guys, but im really pissed off that they would use my tax dollars to fight something that's obviously unconstitutional in the first place.

+1. That member who stated they should see "The writing on the wall...." I really wish that were the case. Not only would just admitting defeat speed up this process, it would cost a hell of a lot less tax money too! That money could easily go elsewhere, such as......I don't know maybe funding these police departments that supposedly cant afford to hold staff. Nope, not NJ....in fact, not POLITICIANS. And on top of all that, guess who is funding the organizations that are fighting this? Most of it is coming from US. We are funding both sides of a fight that should not exist, in order to exercise a Constitutional right that has been denied :icon_rolleyes:

+1. That member who stated they should see "The writing on the wall...." I really wish that were the case. Not only would just admitting defeat speed up this process, it would cost a hell of a lot less tax money too! That money could easily go elsewhere, such as......I don't know maybe funding these police departments that supposedly cant afford to hold staff. Nope, not NJ....in fact, not POLITICIANS. And on top of all that, guess who is funding the organizations that are fighting this? Most of it is coming from US. We are funding both sides of a fight that should not exist, in order to exercise a Constitutional right that has been denied :icon_rolleyes:

 

maybe we should all call our local politicians and let them know how we feel about this, maybe they wont waste OUR tax dollars on it, after all the state is flat broke, this would show they are at least using their noggin.

maybe we should all call our local politicians and let them know how we feel about this, maybe they wont waste OUR tax dollars on it, after all the state is flat broke, this would show they are at least using their noggin.

I would be all for this. If we could totally avoid the situation, that would be fantastic.

Lets keep this discussion going. I have been thinking about it...and its just downright scary to think of the mess that will happen if this pulls through. Could you imagine how many issues are going to pop up because of ignorance? I actually think I would actually consider waiting 2-3 months for all those issues to subside.

You know i dont even really want to carry all the damn time, but if i'm going to be driving in a bad area it would be nice to be able to bring some protection. Or even hiking.

 

I love how the anti immediately assume everyones going to running around with their guns drawn and shoot outs happening on main street.

You know i dont even really want to carry all the damn time, but if i'm going to be driving in a bad area it would be nice to be able to bring some protection. Or even hiking.

 

I love how the anti immediately assume everyones going to running around with their guns drawn and shoot outs happening on main street.

 

 

cowoboy boots have been ordered in anticipation of this passing

Don't forget to order your CCW badge. Plus you definitely need a long barreled wheel gun. :D

You know i dont even really want to carry all the damn time, but if i'm going to be driving in a bad area it would be nice to be able to bring some protection. Or even hiking.

 

I understand exactly what you are saying. Sometimes you are doing something where you are either going to be in a "bad" area, or just out and about alone (think a long run, hiking, etc). I'd love to be able to do a long run in a nice secluded area while knowing I have a tool that can be used to ensure my safety.

I'll get mine just to avoid be Aitken'd on my way to/from the range

 

Also an excellent point. With concealed carry, it may lessen of a lot of the travel limitations.

 

There's so much work to do AFTER this though... The broken permit system, AWB, hollow point regulations... Ugh....

Also an excellent point. With concealed carry, it may lessen of a lot of the travel limitations.

 

There's so much work to do AFTER this though... The broken permit system, AWB, hollow point regulations... Ugh....

 

Well, the law as proposed doesn't add any travel restrictions. As the firearms law stands now, if you have a permit, you can possess anywhere save the grounds of an educational institution; and this law doesn't change that.

 

Nice list of things to go after next

You know i dont even really want to carry all the damn time, but if i'm going to be driving in a bad area it would be nice to be able to bring some protection. Or even hiking.

 

I love how the anti immediately assume everyones going to running around with their guns drawn and shoot outs happening on main street.

 

Yes... the Antis are right, all these Cowboy open carry states in the Midwest like Vermont, Pennsylvania, Virginia, Maine....are robbing banks and shooting everyone up wait, I thought those states were in the North East? Maybe I need to recheck my map....I could have sworn....

Well, the law as proposed doesn't add any travel restrictions. As the firearms law stands now, if you have a permit, you can possess anywhere save the grounds of an educational institution; and this law doesn't change that.

 

Nice list of things to go after next

 

I guess what I meant was that if we could actually get a permit then we'd be covered. Where as without one, you can't travel with a loaded gun locked in the back of your truck with three layers of steel plating welded around it without going to jail as a felon.

I guess what I meant was that if we could actually get a permit then we'd be covered. Where as without one, you can't travel with a loaded gun locked in the back of your truck with three layers of steel plating welded around it without going to jail as a felon.

 

A permit doesn't lessen them, it eliminates them. That's kind of cool. Even if the process to get one isn't.

Just joined SAF... at least someone is fighting for us here in NJ.

 

I know this is premature, but is this something that has a good chance of going through or should i not get my hopes up? We all know what NJ is doing is Unconstitutional,but are the antis too strong and corrupt here in NJ for this to become a reality?

Just joined SAF... at least someone is fighting for us here in NJ.

 

I know this is premature, but is this something that has a good chance of going through or should i not get my hopes up? We all know what NJ is doing is Unconstitutional,but are the antis too strong and corrupt here in NJ for this to become a reality?

 

It really has nothing to do with the strength or corruption of the antis in Jersey, since this is in Federal court. It just depends if SAF can make a compelling case against which they can't defend.

I'll get mine just to avoid be Aitken'd on my way to/from the range

 

+999 - exactly.

 

Now you can stop anywhere you'd like on the way to/from the range. Kinda alleviates the annoyance of the trip if you drive 1/2 hour or more to a range. At least you can get other stuff done at the same time.

+999 - exactly.

 

Now you can stop anywhere you'd like on the way to/from the range. Kinda alleviates the annoyance of the trip if you drive 1/2 hour or more to a range. At least you can get other stuff done at the same time.

Granted that will only work if you just take ONE pistol. But what is to stop it from happening with your "arsenal of military style weapons, and cop killing ammo"?

Have to see if we can get permits with multiple guns on them. Not a big deal for me; I only own 1 handgun.

Granted that will only work if you just take ONE pistol. But what is to stop it from happening with your "arsenal of military style weapons, and cop killing ammo"?

 

Correct me if I am wrong, but I didn't think NJ's current carry permit system limits you to carrying one handgun, just the type(s) of guns you are allowed to carry. And what about long guns - there should be no limit on that :icon_twisted: .

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.