Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

SAF and ANJRPC files suit against the state of NJ!

Featured Replies

  • Replies 160
  • Views 17k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • In my eyes, the anjrpc is basically just the cherry ridge gun club. If it's supposed to be the NJ NRA org, why did it take them this long to do anything? it almost seems like they're riding the coatta

  • Well I guess I can scrap my letter to Gov. Christie about wedging a lawsuit up NJ's butt as SAF beat me too it. IMO the ANJRPC is just along for the ride as local representation. As promised (as far a

  • I live in NJ. Which happens to be in the USA.   That's all the "justifiable need" ANY citizen should require.

  • Author

BRN169, I see where you are coming from but I think that NJ may have been passed over NRA style if it were not for the efforts of in state organizations.

 

NJ's laws are too over the top to ignore. To pass up the state that issues carry permits yet makes the process so political, so corrupt and so arbitrary and capricious that people who have legitimate cause are routinely denied would have been to do so at the detriment of the overall effort being undertaken. Think of NJ as low hanging fruit... :icon_e_biggrin:

  • Author

Keep in mind... a few of us, cannot speak of stuff we know, yet very tough to hold back. :thsmiley_deadhorse:

 

So if that be the case how far off am I? :icon_mrgreen:

Keep in mind... a few of us, cannot speak of stuff we know, yet very tough to hold back. :thsmiley_deadhorse:

 

You would not play poker with all of your cards face up. It's only wise to play this game (cause let's face it, all politics is a game and this is basic, basic politics) to win. All of you that know more than the unwashed masses, PLEASE keep your mouths shut for all of our sakes.

Another question. With the change in power in the congress would national CCW reprococity pass? And, if so, wouldn't NJ be forced to allow CCW from some 40 states. Again doesn't that make paying money to defend against this lawsuit totally pointless.

  • Author

Another question. With the change in power in the congress would national CCW reprococity pass? And, if so, wouldn't NJ be forced to allow CCW from some 40 states. Again doesn't that make paying money to defend against this lawsuit totally pointless.

 

It would never pass the Senate as Schumer, Feinstein, Lautenberg, Kerry, etc. would filibuster any attempt and the POTUS would veto it even if it did manage to make it to his desk... Check back after 2012... Trick now is to get these cases before the SCOTUS before the court has a chance to tip against us.

I don't know about that. It missed breaking the filibuster by only one vote last june. I have heard there are three different bills that include the national reprococity provision and without a line item veto and with the political climate against him POTUS may well sign. It would force NJ's change.

The original Thune amendment excluded reciprocity in the home state of the non-resident permit holder. So, a NJ resident with a FL permit could carry in any shall- or may-issue state except NJ.

True, but what is the point of preventing CCW by your residents when the rest of the country can carry here?

Keep in mind... a few of us, cannot speak of stuff we know, yet very tough to hold back. :thsmiley_deadhorse:

 

No teasing Please :unsure:

True, but what is the point of preventing CCW by your residents when the rest of the country can carry here?

Because, in its infinite wisdom, the federal government took that opportunity to determine that states still had some rights to determine what happens inside their borders. Just that once, otherwise, states can go twist for their rights.

Personally I think that all firearms laws should be federal. The states shouldnt be able to do what they want.

Personally I think that all firearms laws should be federal. The states shouldnt be able to do what they want.

I think the rest of America, where they actually enjoy the rights that we covet, would take issue with that.

  • Author

Personally I think that all firearms laws should be federal. The states shouldnt be able to do what they want.

 

Funny, I thought "...shall not be infringed" was the original federal gun law... :icon_lol:

 

Slippery slope there but I feel no state should be able to hold any law abiding citizen back from exercising their rights under the federal laws. I think the states should be able to do what ever they like to those that have a history that precludes them from owning firearms or those that abuse firearms to commit a crime...

Personally I think that all firearms laws should be federal. The states shouldnt be able to do what they want.

 

Right - because they've done such a wonderful job with DC, the Senate, the House, the Presidency, the Supreme Court, etc.

 

No thanks Baba.

If they win and just provided the permits to carry to those individuals, wouldn’t that just open another door as then the ruling would then be considered arbitrary and capricious?

Right - because they've done such a wonderful job with DC, the Senate, the House, the Presidency, the Supreme Court, etc.

 

No thanks Baba.

 

 

I was gonna say the same thing, it seems the states get some right, and feds get some right, for the most part they both get a lot wrong. Take Medical MJ for example.... despite all the research, and im talking about hands down proof it's a viable solution to help patients, FEDs still keep it under class 1 controlled substance, right next to heroin.. meaning a cancer patient can go to jail for trying to alleviate some pain.

 

Put that into gun control aspect, you get one viable movement to ban guns, and its over for everyone.

If they win and just provided the permits to carry to those individuals, wouldn’t that just open another door as then the ruling would then be considered arbitrary and capricious?

 

This case is not about the individuals filing suit, they are not suing the state to get ccw permits, they are fighting the legality of the law. If it was the way you claim it to be it would not be a civil suit, it would be an appeal.

The original Thune amendment excluded reciprocity in the home state of the non-resident permit holder. So, a NJ resident with a FL permit could carry in any shall- or may-issue state except NJ.

 

Please provide a link to the text that excluded reciprocity in the home state. The bill said any valid permit issued by a state is good in any other state that has CCW provisions in its laws. The "home state" text provided a way for the people of VT to carry in the other 48 states by just showing proof of residency (i.e. a driver's license) since VT has no permit system.

 

If you can prove this interpretation wrong, I'll stand corrected. But the text of the bill didn't say anything about having to be a resident of the state from which you hold a permit.

(2) A person who is not prohibited by Federal law from possessing, transporting, shipping, or receiving a firearm, and is otherwise than as described in paragraph (1) entitled to carry a concealed firearm in and pursuant to the law of the State in which the person resides, may carry a concealed firearm in accordance with the laws of the State in which the person resides in any State that allows its residents to carry concealed firearms, subject to the laws of the State in which the firearmis carried concerning specific types of locations in which firearms may not be carried.''.

 

so, if you have a FL carry permit, with a NJ address, and you don't have a NJ CCW, you may not carry in NJ.

 

This discussion went on in the forum last year. The original text of the Bill didn't have the resident exception. It was added as a revision in response to the states complaining that the fed gov't was infringing on their right to regulate their own citizens.

I think the rest of America, where they actually enjoy the rights that we covet, would take issue with that.

I heard something about Montana wanting to allow the manufacture of new MG's for civilian purchase by instate residents only. They were claiming home rule allows this and since they would not be sold across state lines Congress should have no authority to regulate it.

I heard something about Montana wanting to allow the manufacture of new MG's for civilian purchase by instate residents only. They were claiming home rule allows this and since they would not be sold across state lines Congress should have no authority to regulate it.

 

Yeah, but the ATF said "It doesn't matter what you say, we regulate machine guns and we'll enforce the laws". It would set the stage for some tense moments when state police would be required by the governor to arrest federal ATF JBTs...who would then call in other resources for protection. It'd be curious to see who the Montana national guard would follow. Certainly they report to the governor in times of peace but in 2007, the Insurrection act was tweaked giving the president authority to use guard troops as police in times of emergency, natural disaster and probably when the ATF calls and whines that they have a boot on their neck. They're used to it being the other way round.

 

The Federal government has so twisted the commerce clause in the constitution, they believe it gives them the right to regulate and mandate anything they wish. So far they've gotten away with it.

Yeah, but the ATF said "It doesn't matter what you say, we regulate machine guns and we'll enforce the laws". It would set the stage for some tense moments when state police would be required by the governor to arrest federal ATF JBTs...who would then call in other resources for protection. It'd be curious to see who the Montana national guard would follow. Certainly they report to the governor in times of peace but in 2007, the Insurrection act was tweaked giving the president authority to use guard troops as police in times of emergency, natural disaster and probably when the ATF calls and whines that they have a boot on their neck. They're used to it being the other way round.

 

The Federal government has so twisted the commerce clause in the constitution, they believe it gives them the right to regulate and mandate anything they wish. So far they've gotten away with it.

Yea, I didn't think it was going to fly, just like Cal. almost legalizing pot, the feds vowed to enforce federal law.

so, if you have a FL carry permit, with a NJ address, and you don't have a NJ CCW, you may not carry in NJ.

 

This discussion went on in the forum last year. The original text of the Bill didn't have the resident exception. It was added as a revision in response to the states complaining that the fed gov't was infringing on their right to regulate their own citizens.

 

(1) A person who is not prohibited by Federal law from possessing, transporting, shipping, or receiving a firearm, and is carrying a valid license or permit which is issued pursuant to the law of any State and which permits the person to carry a concealed firearm, may carry in any State a concealed firearm in accordance with the terms of the license or permit, subject to the laws of the State in which the firearm is carried concerning specific types of locations in which firearms may not be carried.

 

(2) A person who is not prohibited by Federal law from possessing, transporting, shipping, or receiving a firearm, and is otherwise than as described in paragraph (1) entitled to carry a concealed firearm in and pursuant to the law of the State in which the person resides, may carry in any State a concealed firearm in accordance with the laws of the State in which the person resides, subject to the laws of the State in which the firearm is carried concerning specific types of locations in which firearms may not be carried.

 

You didn't highlight the part in section (2) that says "and is otherwise than as described in paragraph (1)". Read the whole statement, not just the part you highlighted. The second section says, if you don't have a permit issued from any State (that's all in section (1)), but you can carry in your State of residence, then you can carry under this amendment.

 

I'm sorry, but you misread/misinterpreted this bill.

Sadly, we can't search back to last year's discussion on this very subject, so, okay.

 

3rd Paragraph

Sadly, we can't search back to last year's discussion on this very subject, so, okay.

 

3rd Paragraph

 

Uhm. In the box above "view new content", type THUNE in the box, click search. Make sure Search Forums is ticked. This yielded the threads quickly.

Thank you, Mark.

 

BigHayden - you were even in on this one. NJCSD discussion

how long do these suits take before a decision is made, or when it even goes to trial?

 

6 months? a year?

Thank you, Mark.

 

BigHayden - you were even in on this one. NJCSD discussion

 

I'm still not 100% convinced, but since it failed last year there's no use :thsmiley_deadhorse:

 

I'll concede that I agreed with you in that discussion, but I may have been hasty in my post there too. Either way, it's water under the bridge at this point, so back to the OP's topic.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.