Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Bryan Miller of CeasfireNJ on Brian Aitken

Featured Replies

The prosecutor and defense attorney pick the jury. The defense attorney should have had some gun owners on the jury. And how do you know there weren't any gun owners on the jury?

 

You are correct but the judge will exclude anyone he thinks will have a bias. Potential jurors fill out questionnaires to weed out people who may have a bias, it would be interesting to see what was on the one for this case.

 

I don't know if there were any gun owners on the jury, but the way this judge ran this case I would not be surprised if the were excluded.

  • Replies 73
  • Views 6k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • Cemeterys Gun Blob
    Cemeterys Gun Blob

    It's about him getting railroaded. He did not get a fair trial, and the Judge did not let the jury here about exemptions. As you know, firearms, and firearm related stuff is illegal in NJ, unless yo

  • And I agree with you 100%. I think that NJ's gun laws are absolutely stupid and foolish. The second I heard about the SAF and ANJRPC lawsuit, I was on their site joining both organizations. Once I

  • Ain't that a ****... I'd go in a heart beat if called but I never get called...   Funny story; in 1990 I lived in Howel and I worked for ADT in East Rutherford. I was laid off in March of 1991 a

You are correct but the judge will exclude anyone he thinks will have a bias. Potential jurors fill out questionnaires to weed out people who may have a bias, it would be interesting to see what was on the one for this case.

 

I don't know if there were any gun owners on the jury, but the way this judge ran this case I would not be surprised if the were excluded.

 

So are they changing it from a "jury of your peers" to a "jury of your oblivious, moronic, public education system indoctrinated drones"?

So are they changing it from a "jury of your peers" to a "jury of your oblivious, moronic, public education system indoctrinated drones"?

Unfortunately in this case that's what it seems like.

It's been like that for a long time. They dont want to have a biased jury. The issue comes when they dismiss ANYONE who even knows ANYTHING about the topic. If one side doesnt dismiss someone for their knowledge, the other side will. The only issue is that there is a difference between a biased opinion, and simply being knowledgeable.

It's been like that for a long time. They dont want to have a biased jury. The issue comes when they dismiss ANYONE who even knows ANYTHING about the topic. If one side doesnt dismiss someone for their knowledge, the other side will. The only issue is that there is a difference between a biased opinion, and simply being knowledgeable.

 

I've SEEN Defense attorneys exclude anyone with a regular job, i've seen prosecutors use a lot of their challenges for the same thing. The System isnt broken, it's utterly Useless, because 90% of people when called for Jury Duty have the initial thought "WTF can i do to get out of this". There's also no consistancy. Before I moved to Monmouth, i got called a couple of times, i was also barred from any criminal cases because of what i do, and the plaintiff's attorneys cut me ASAP as soon as they found out I was a LEO for Civil cases. I've been here, registered as a voter since 2003, and I have YET to be called for jury duty. until everyone actually steps up and accepts Jury duty as a DUTY, and not something to get out of, the system wont ever be "Right".

I've SEEN Defense attorneys exclude anyone with a regular job, i've seen prosecutors use a lot of their challenges for the same thing. The System isnt broken, it's utterly Useless, because 90% of people when called for Jury Duty have the initial thought "WTF can i do to get out of this". There's also no consistancy. Before I moved to Monmouth, i got called a couple of times, i was also barred from any criminal cases because of what i do, and the plaintiff's attorneys cut me ASAP as soon as they found out I was a LEO for Civil cases. I've been here, registered as a voter since 2003, and I have YET to be called for jury duty. until everyone actually steps up and accepts Jury duty as a DUTY, and not something to get out of, the system wont ever be "Right".

I dont see what the issue is with people not wanting to do it. I mean personally, it is something I would rather not have to do. But that does not mean I will actually make an effort to get out of it for some reason. No sooner did I send in my voter registration did I get a card for jury duty. December 20-24. If my group gets selected to go in, Im going in. If I go in, I will be completely honest in any questions asked of me. If I was on a jury, I would do the job with a completely unbiased point of view. However, given my major, I doubt they would even select me anyway. Its crazy though. If the point of a trial is to in fact find out the TRUTH, which is what the Justice System should be based around, then having somebody who is knowledgeable of the laws and how things work should not be taken out of the pool. Its just downright scary how many rights and opportunities defendants have.

he was judged by 12 people too stupid to get out of jury duty :facepalm:

 

Ain't that a ****... I'd go in a heart beat if called but I never get called...

 

Funny story; in 1990 I lived in Howel and I worked for ADT in East Rutherford. I was laid off in March of 1991 and at the time had no vehicle other than my work truck which they obviously wouldn't let me keep... One week into unemployment I received a jury duty notice from Monmouth County Court for I think it was the first or second week in June. The following week I received a second jury duty notice to serve on US Grand Jury in Trenton for the same week in June as the Monmouth Court jury notice, mind you no car from Howell... I sent a copy of the Monmouth County notice to Trenton and a copy of the US Grand Jury notice to Monmouth and they both excused me... That was the first and last time I ever got called for jury duty... :icon_lol:

I was called in 95 or 96 when I lived in Monmouth County. At the time, I was friends with an older gentleman, a former detective who was, at the time of my jury service, the person in charge of the evidence room at that very same County Courthouse. Based on my occupation (not LEO) and my association with this man, I was excused from EVERY SINGLE CASE during voir dire.

 

I concluded that a) the Prosecutor wanted absolutely no evidence of bias on the jury and B) both the prosecution and defense did not want anyone with an analytical mind serving as a juror.

 

The system is fouled up. In law school they teach lawyers how to "mold" a jury in order that they can win a case. There are actually "jury consultants" who teach and guide lawyers as to how to appropriately select a jury. It's totally fouled up.

Ain't that a ****... I'd go in a heart beat if called but I never get called...

 

Funny story; in 1990 I lived in Howel and I worked for ADT in East Rutherford. I was laid off in March of 1991 and at the time had no vehicle other than my work truck which they obviously wouldn't let me keep... One week into unemployment I received a jury duty notice from Monmouth County Court for I think it was the first or second week in June. The following week I received a second jury duty notice to serve on US Grand Jury in Trenton for the same week in June as the Monmouth Court jury notice, mind you no car from Howell... I sent a copy of the Monmouth County notice to Trenton and a copy of the US Grand Jury notice to Monmouth and they both excused me... That was the first and last time I ever got called for jury duty... :icon_lol:

 

I'm a civic minded person, so I never dread jury duty. I think we all should serve at least once in our lives.

 

A few years ago, I was summoned for state and local jury duty for back to back weeks. The state was first, and my number was called. So I go up to the bench and answer the questions. Then I'm told to go sit in the jury box. My butt no sooner hit the seat, and the defense attorney had me dismissed. Now, I'm a fair person, so the defense attorney may have missed out on a "good" juror for his client, but they will dismiss people based on averages and, dare I say it, stereotypes. Here's why I was dismissed. The defendant was a black man. I'm a white guy, in my 30's, shaved head. The attorney took one look at me and thought there was no way his client would get a fair shake from me. I wasn't offended (some people would have been, but the lawyer has to play the odds). When I showed up for the local jury duty, they counted my service in the state jury and dismissed me immediately.

 

So, like you, I'd love to serve, but it just hasn't been in the cards.

The judge probably dismissed anyone who owned guns during jury selection. He obviously didn't like gun owners.

 

I recently had Jury Duty in Mercer County. There was an orientation with a video that told all of the potential jurors that the judge was the judge of the law and that the jury was the judge of the facts and that the jury must follow the instructions of the judge on how to apply the law.

 

Then, in the courtroom, during jury selection, all of the potential jurors, for that case, had to fill out a questionnaire. Question #19 was (I'm paraphrasing) "Are you able to follow all of the instructions of the judge regarding interpretation and application of the law, even if you don't agree with it?"

 

That is when I realized that there was a lot of effort being put into finding jurors who would not think for themselves.

 

I am sure something similar happened in Brian's case, and is certain to be happening in many cases in NJ.

 

Everyone should read this article called, "Jury Nullification, The Top Secret Constitutional Right." After my experience, I started looking into what it meant to be the judge of the law vs. the judg of the facts. At that point, I had never heard of "jury nullification." I was astounded with what I found. This article pretty much sums it up. The jury may judge the law as well as the facts. Although the judge can remove you from the jury if he wants to and replace you with an alternate, you cannot be punished in any way for refusing to convict based on your conscience, no matter what the law says or what the judge says.

 

I read stories about the judge receiving a note from the jury asking "what is jury nullification?" The judge's response was something along the lines that the jury may not nullify and must follow the judge's instructions. Of course, that is not the case. The lesson being, if you are a juror, vote your conscience and stand your ground without ever mentioning that you disagree with the law or mentioning the term jury nullification.

 

As a juror, your job is to protect the accused up to the point where you believe he is guilty, then your job is to protect society from the accused. If that's a new concept for you, you're not alone.

 

http://www.constitut...chol/131jur.pdf

 

Jury Nullification.pdf

A few years ago, I was called for jury duty. I had no problem going. I think sitting on a jury is a civic duty, much like voting, that is part of what you do in a civilized society.

 

They called my number, and we piled into another room. The case was of some local county politician who was accused of jury tampering and soliciting bribes.

 

I was asked if I can objectively form an opinion based on whatever facts were presented. I politely replied that I have a basic distrust in the honesty and integrity of politicians, and that that slant may cloud my judgement. They thanked me for my answer and excused me. I haven't been called since.

Ain't that a ****... I'd go in a heart beat if called but I never get called...

 

+1

 

I'm the same. Havent been called yet. Although, I am only 21. Meh. I think it would be a cool experience.

I'm with Glenn. Never made it to the courthouse but if I did I feel the experience would be quite interesting.

+1

 

I'm the same. Havent been called yet. Although, I am only 21. Meh. I think it would be a cool experience.

 

 

I'm with Glenn. Never made it to the courthouse but if I did I feel the experience would be quite interesting.

 

I'm glad you guys feel that way. The role of the Jury is extremely important. It is a check on the legislature and the judiciary from enforcing bad law. Juries can refuse to convict.

 

When smart people avoid jury duty, they leave this up to those who may not have the level of competence required to maintain that check.

 

I only recently understood this. I now am very serious about jury duty and whenever I know someone who gets called I make sure they know what I have learned. In addition to the article I posted above, there is also a very good website (The Fully Informed Jury Association). It has a Juror's hand book and a series of videos on the subject that are very informative (they're also a bit dry at points, but it's worth going through the whole series).

 

http://fija.org/

In New Jersey the pool for jury duty is made up of registered voters and all licensed drivers.

Check out the front page o fox news. Nice to see it getting some national attention

Check out the front page o fox news. Nice to see it getting some national attention

Check out the front page o fox news. Nice to see it getting some national attention

 

Fox News needs to get it's facts straight... sigh.

In New Jersey, a person must have a purchaser's permit and a carry permit to have a handgun in his or her car

Fox News needs to get it's facts straight... sigh.

Quote (from Krshrk's post):

In New Jersey, a person must have a purchaser's permit and a carry permit to have a handgun in his or her car

 

 

 

The above is true if you don't fall under one of the exemptions, which I guess is what the prosecutor was arguing and the reason Evan was trying to get the jury to hear what the exemptions are and how they applied in this case.

I recently had Jury Duty in Mercer County. There was an orientation with a video that told all of the potential jurors that the judge was the judge of the law and that the jury was the judge of the facts and that the jury must follow the instructions of the judge on how to apply the law.

 

Then, in the courtroom, during jury selection, all of the potential jurors, for that case, had to fill out a questionnaire. Question #19 was (I'm paraphrasing) "Are you able to follow all of the instructions of the judge regarding interpretation and application of the law, even if you don't agree with it?"

 

That is when I realized that there was a lot of effort being put into finding jurors who would not think for themselves.

 

I am sure something similar happened in Brian's case, and is certain to be happening in many cases in NJ.

 

Everyone should read this article called, "Jury Nullification, The Top Secret Constitutional Right." After my experience, I started looking into what it meant to be the judge of the law vs. the judg of the facts. At that point, I had never heard of "jury nullification." I was astounded with what I found. This article pretty much sums it up. The jury may judge the law as well as the facts. Although the judge can remove you from the jury if he wants to and replace you with an alternate, you cannot be punished in any way for refusing to convict based on your conscience, no matter what the law says or what the judge says.

 

I read stories about the judge receiving a note from the jury asking "what is jury nullification?" The judge's response was something along the lines that the jury may not nullify and must follow the judge's instructions. Of course, that is not the case. The lesson being, if you are a juror, vote your conscience and stand your ground without ever mentioning that you disagree with the law or mentioning the term jury nullification.

 

As a juror, your job is to protect the accused up to the point where you believe he is guilty, then your job is to protect society from the accused. If that's a new concept for you, you're not alone.

 

http://www.constitut...chol/131jur.pdf

 

Jury Nullification.pdf

 

If you mention Jury Nullification in Hudson County at least, you will be charged with Contempt..and NO im NOT shitting you. I saw the assignment Judge go completely Batpoop Crazy when someone brought it up. As far as Picking Juries, My dad got called back in the early 90's, and got picked for the pool for a fairly Infamous Homicide case. He went in for the interview portion, and the prosecutor asked if he belived that Poverty could be an affirmative defense for committing a crime of violence. My dad answerd "Absolutely Not" The Defense attorney pounced at that point "Well mr K, why dont you explain to us what YOU would know about poverty" in a nice, snide, and sneering fashion (I'd dealt with that Attorney before and since, and he is a Smarmy Elitist Ron-Kuby-Wannabe little turd-burglar). i would have given a weeks pay to be a fly on the wall and seen the look on his face when my Dad told him that he'd grown up during the depression, and there had been whole months where the only meat his family had was what he'd been able to hunt out in the marshes (NJ was a lot different in the 1920's, even up north). Needless to say the Defense Attorney bounced him, but the prosecutor fought hard to keep him. Worked out in the end the Skell got Life/NoP anyway.

If you mention Jury Nullification in Hudson County at least, you will be charged with Contempt..and NO im NOT shitting you. I saw the assignment Judge go completely Batpoop Crazy when someone brought it up.

 

 

Can judges even do that? That seems completely absurd to me.

 

I'm half tempted to put Jury Nullification info fliers on cars at court house. That should make them **** a brick.

Can judges even do that? That seems completely absurd to me.

 

I'm half tempted to put Jury Nullification info fliers on cars at court house. That should make them **** a brick.

 

 

Good luck with that..better have an Attorney on retainer first though.

I'm confused, do juries in NJ courts have to explain their verdict? Because even if the Jury never heard of nullification they knew there was some exceptions to the law, the judge refused to explain it to them, but they asked about it so they knew it existed. Wouldn't that still leave them with reasonable doubt?

If you mention Jury Nullification in Hudson County at least, you will be charged with Contempt..and NO im NOT shitting you. I saw the assignment Judge go completely Batpoop Crazy when someone brought it up.

 

I believe you and it doesn't surprise me. Until we get an amendment to the NJ Constitution stating that in criminal trials, the jury shall be the judge of both law and fact, jurors will have to be discrete in their assertion of their right to nullify.

I believe you and it doesn't surprise me. Until we get an amendment to the NJ Constitution stating that in criminal trials, the jury shall be the judge of both law and fact, jurors will have to be discrete in their assertion of their right to nullify.

Superior Court Judges at least, are pretty much tyrants in their courtrooms Jury Nullification takes the power away from them. One thing I'd like to point out is that wile the US Constitution allows Jury Nullification, has anyone researched of the NJ STATE Constitution does as well??? Rememebr the US Constitution puts limits on the powers of the FEDERAL Govt, not the individual states unless and until, the issu at hand is "Incorporated" under the 14th ammendment. Heller meant NOTHING in NJ until McDonald took it from the federal level to that of the states.

  • Author

he was wrong and did break the law...

he should pay..

7 years is just too much..

 

I think that is the point some people on the outside are not getting...

 

based on what we know, he was well within the exemptions of the law. The judge did not allow these exemptions into the trial. Thus he did not receive a fair trail.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.