December 4, 201015 yr Yes, but airstrikes can be lazed and then the soldier can get the hell out of harms way. In this situation, the target must be lazed, explosion time set, aimed properly (because this is not a computer guided projectile) yet simply a launched grenade. The soldier launching this is definitely putting himself in harms way much more than an airstrike.
December 4, 201015 yr Hey vjf915 you should join the military then that way you could get first hand experience with the new weapon platform. You will no longer need to speculate about the efficiency, and all your questions will be answered. How could you play armchair quarterback with such authority having never used this?
December 4, 201015 yr I understand your concern for the troops welfare, vjf. From my understanding, lazing a target in this situation is different when comparing airstrikes and the XM25 (which is my mistake). My understanding of the XM25 is that the lazing process is to find the most accurate range. Anybody who has used a laser range finder knows that, especially with practice, the process is relatively quick. This is different for the airstrike process in most cases as the operator normally has to stay on target until the payload is delivered and the hit confirmed (the phrase "painting" made famous by Hollywood). The troops themselves are in no more danger than they normally would be. Barring equipment issues and freakish incidents where the opposition can actually shoot straight over a long distance, the XM25 will improve the lethality and save lives in the process-- sounding like a combat multiplier to me. And when comparing 1-to-1, this option is far cheaper than flying drones, jets, or Apaches... plus, it'll give tactical discretion to boots on the ground, which, to a person who wasn't even a grunt, is probably the most important.
December 4, 201015 yr Hey vjf915 you should join the military then that way you could get first hand experience with the new weapon platform. You will no longer need to speculate about the efficiency, and all your questions will be answered. How could you play armchair quarterback with such authority having never used this? I don't know what you see in my posts as offensive to either you or our soldiers, but I said nothing wrong. I was simply questioning the method in which it is fired to ensure that it doesnt needlessly put our troops at risk. As bbk stated, it is just a concern for their safety. I understand your concern for the troops welfare, vjf. From my understanding, lazing a target in this situation is different when comparing airstrikes and the XM25 (which is my mistake). My understanding of the XM25 is that the lazing process is to find the most accurate range. Anybody who has used a laser range finder knows that, especially with practice, the process is relatively quick. This is different for the airstrike process in most cases as the operator normally has to stay on target until the payload is delivered and the hit confirmed (the phrase "painting" made famous by Hollywood). The troops themselves are in no more danger than they normally would be. Barring equipment issues and freakish incidents where the opposition can actually shoot straight over a long distance, the XM25 will improve the lethality and save lives in the process-- sounding like a combat multiplier to me. And when comparing 1-to-1, this option is far cheaper than flying drones, jets, or Apaches... plus, it'll give tactical discretion to boots on the ground, which, to a person who wasn't even a grunt, is probably the most important. If this is the case, I feel more confident and comfortable about it. I was not questioning as in stating that it would not be effective.....I was asking because I am unfamiliar with how the technology works.
December 4, 201015 yr Here is a link that might answer some questions about the workings on the XM-25 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s5jOs5x54ds
December 4, 201015 yr Okay it seems I was misunderstood about the concept, thanks for those videos. However, watch the first video at 1:10 in. "Soldiers can fire it accurately as far as two and a half football fields" yet it shows 500m on the screen. Since when was a football field 200 meters long
February 15, 201115 yr Saw this article today: http://www.armytimes.com/news/2011/02/army-xm25-punisher-battlefield-test-021411w/ ‘Punisher’ gets its first battlefield tests XM25 ‘performs flawlessly’ in Afghanistan By Lance M. Bacon - Staff writer Posted : Monday Feb 14, 2011 5:33:15 EST The XM25 has changed the battlefield with only 55 rounds, and earned a new name among soldiers. They call it “the Punisher.” Since its first contact Dec. 3, the XM25 has been in nine engagements with two units at different locations, officials said. Specifically, it has disrupted two insurgent attacks on observation posts, taken out two PKM machine gun positions and destroyed four ambush sites. In one engagement, an enemy machine gunner was “so badly wounded or so freaking scared that he dropped [his] weapon” and ran, said Lt. Col. Christopher Lehner, Program Manager Individual Weapons. ‘A GAME CHANGER’ The XM-25 Counter Defilade Target Engagement System enables small units and individual soldiers to engage targets with a 25mm air-bursting capability for all operational environments. There were no casualties among units carrying the XM25 in those nine engagements, Lehner said. “No longer can the enemy shoot at American forces, then hide behind something,” said Brig. Gen. Peter Fuller of Program Executive Office Soldier. “This is a revolutionary weapon. This is a game-changer.” The XM25 has a target acquisition system that calculates range with the push of a button. The data is transferred to an electronic fuse, enabling the 25mm round to explode over the target and rain shell fragments on the enemy. All five prototypes were sent to Afghanistan in November. Officials are putting the final touches on data and analysis, but said Col. Douglas Tamilio, project manager for soldier weapons, said the weapons “performed flawlessly” and no maintenance issues showed. Soldiers have been so pleased with the XM25 that they are carrying it as a primary weapon, and not bothering to bring an M4 as a secondary weapon, said Maj. Christopher Conley, who monitored the employment of XM25 on behalf of PEO Soldier. Lehner said the tests revealed only one problem: The units didn’t want to give the Punisher back. That’s not to say there isn’t room to improve. “We’ve got to do something about the battery,” Tamilio said. “It needs a longer life.” In addition, he is convinced that the effective area range can expand from 700 to 1,000 meters. The effective range for a point target is 500 meters. There were no complaints about the 13-pound weight. “If you can give them this kind of capability, they will handle the weight,” Tamilio said. The weapons were tested by two units at separate locations. Tamilio recalled comments from one platoon leader, who said engagements that typically take 15 to 20 minutes were over in “a matter of minutes.” Officials plan to put the weapons with a third unit for the spring offensive, but officials must first determine how to cover the cost of rounds. Because they are hand built, the rounds run about $1,000 each. That cost will drop to $35 once a production line is started. The XM25, which runs about $35,000 per copy, is about to enter engineering and manufacturing development. Tamilio said efforts are underway to purchase an additional 36 weapons in 2012. The XM25 is scheduled to begin low-rate initial production in late 2013. The plan is to buy 12,500 weapons — one for each infantry squad or special forces team.
February 16, 201115 yr Any new technology that helps our brave men and woman is great, however, the United States needs to stay out of wars we don't seem to have the desire to win. You can't fight a politicaly correct war against a bunch of scumbag ragheads that don't like us. Don't send mine or your kid over there to be a target. The right mindset is a far superior weapon than any a new gun. And stop looking in my grandmas brazier and my kids diaper at the airports. If we profiled the right scumbags in the first place we wouldn't have to go to war with them in their donkey crap infested homeland.Political correctness is the enemy and is destroying our country.
February 16, 201115 yr Another waste of taxpayers money. The US Govt has all the tools available to them and the problems over there should have been resolved by now!!!!
February 16, 201115 yr And stop looking in my grandmas brazier and my kids diaper at the airports. If we profiled the right scumbags in the first place we wouldn't have to go to war with them in their donkey crap infested homeland.Political correctness is the enemy and is destroying our country. They keep stealing my shave cream everytime I fly. Seems a container with 7oz of shave cream instead of the 3oz limit is more dangerous than riding between 40,000 lbs of jet fuel!
February 17, 201115 yr It's an expensive solution looking for a problem. Anyone who thinks counter-defilade is a new problem in warfare is smoking crack. A Barrett is more precise and already in our arsenal. Also, I'd hate to be the trigger puller who wastes an entire innocent family unfortunate enough to have their house used as a hasty ambush site. Ever wonder why the suicide rate in returning troops is so high? A lot of them have killed noncombatants and can't live with themselves. You enter a house and see the dead bad guys right next to the bodies of parents trying to shield their children from the gunfire. And please don't sell me the "It keeps the troops safe" line of BS cause I ain't buying it. Safety is not part of the job description in the military and judicious use of overbearing force means you put your a** on the line to clearly ID your targets. Unfortunately, that means instead of lobbing high explosives through windows, you stack next to the door and start going room to room. Lastly,I bet the a-hole general officer who approves this ends up serving on a cushy multi-million dollar a year board job with the company that manufactures this crap. Because that's typically the retirement plan for procurement Pentagon officers.
February 17, 201115 yr I see the downfall of our military is that we are becoming too dependent on technology. Issue 14's in Afghan and completely re-write the rules of engagement and we will take care of that problem quickly.
February 17, 201115 yr I think at times we have taken "precision warfare" to levels that are unrealistic, and unfortunately it's at the U.S. taxpayers' expense. And those two words; "precision" and "warfare" simply don't go together. One has to only study history and realize that's never fully possible.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.