Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Would you take the 10 rnd mag limit if it came with national reciprocity?

67 members have voted

  1. 1. Would you take the 10 round magazine limit if it came with national reciprocity?

    • Yes
      32%
      22
    • No
      65%
      44
    • I don't care
      1%
      1
  2. 2. Would you take the 10 round magazine limit if it came with national open carry without a permt?

    • Yes
      31%
      21
    • No
      65%
      44
    • I don't care
      2%
      2

Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Featured Replies

Just currious. If Lautenberg's 10 round mag limit bill came with an amendment granting national reciprocity for any resident or non-resident CCW permit, would you take the deal? That would mean that anyone with a FL or other CCW permit would be able to carry concealed in all 50 states, D.C. and U.S. territories, ie Guam, P.R., U.S.V.I., American Samoa, etc. as long as it was not over 10 rounds.

 

...and,

 

Would you take the 10 round limit if it did not come with national reciprocity for CCW, but instead came with national open carry without a permit?

The first scenario would be a good deal for New Jersey but lousy for free America.

Just currious. If Lautenberg's 10 round mag limit bill came with an amendment granting national reciprocity for any resident or non-resident CCW permit, would you take the deal? That would mean that anyone with a FL or other CCW permit would be able to carry concealed in all 50 states, D.C. and U.S. territories, ie Guam, P.R., U.S.V.I., American Samoa, etc. as long as it was not over 10 rounds.

 

...and,

 

Would you take the 10 round limit if it did not come with national reciprocity for CCW, but instead came with national open carry without a permit?

 

Where is the "HELL NO!!!" option for both? :p We have the carry case going on right now in New Jersey. Also I am waiting for the Thune Amendment to be reintroduced in March.

Where is the "HELL NO!!!" option for both? :p

 

I was looking for an option a little less polite and a lot more personal. Still two words, though ;)

I would, then I would fight the mag limit.

it would be good for NJ, but sucks for the FREE states! =im bias.

In a "rationalizing my rights away" kind of mentality, if I were presented with the 2 options and could only pick one, I would choose to carry. A high cap at home is no good. At least with a low cap pistol I can now protect myself where I couldnt before.

I would be ok with it. I'll just carry 2 extra mags. If 30 rounds is not enough for you in a self defense situation outside the home, you are waaay in over your head, and no amount of ammo will help.

Seriously, where would you be outside your home where you need a few 30 round mags (range not included)? A drug kingpin's house where a drug deal goes bad? Inside a bank where a gang of men with assault rifles hold up the bank? Are you going to play John Mcclane in that situation?

The compromising of principles is how we got this screwed up to begin with. I do not subscribe to the theory of get a littl then ask for more either. That only works when the Govt wants to take our money and rights away.

 

If it is worth fighting for, it is worth getting it all. No compromise.

lets push a national reciprocity anyway WITHOUT any attachments! F U NY & NJ!

I vote Don't care because I don't care for either option. Do it all or none :)

lets push a national reciprocity anyway WITHOUT any attachments! F U NY & NJ!

 

This would be called the Thune Amendment :)

In a "rationalizing my rights away" kind of mentality, if I were presented with the 2 options and could only pick one, I would choose to carry. A high cap at home is no good. At least with a low cap pistol I can now protect myself where I couldnt before.

I agree with this. I know that not many of you are supportive of "bargaining", and honestly I don't really like the feeling either. I normally wouldn't. But having 10 rounds EVERYWHERE is much better than having 15 rounds just in my home. I think that in the end, it is a much better situation. On top of that, national reciprocity would be AWESOME. Being able to carry anywhere without having to worry about each individual state is a huge benefit.

I vote HELLLLLL NO!!!!!!! not everyone in this state is worried about CCW, just the thought of giving up the fight for high cap mags in trade for CCW makes me cringe.... Not everyone out there practices shooting for home defense or the boogey man in the night.

I vote HELLLLLL NO!!!!!!! not everyone in this state is worried about CCW, just the thought of giving up the fight for high cap mags in trade for CCW makes me cringe....

I agree, it will also include rifle mags. The reprecussions will affect more than just pistols.

You give an inch, the antis will take a football field. NO!

 

They already have the whole mile here, and we're looking to take a few 100 yards...

 

10rd for pistol is fine with me, if I could carry anywhere in the country.

I agree with the sentiment for give an inch lose a yard. However, knowing Bob, he is postulating something so I answered within the confines of his question.

Not everyone out there practices shooting for home defense or the boogey man in the night.

why does one shoot or practice? for home defense, boogeyman in the night, competition, relaxation/hobby, self defense outside the home, anything else?

 

In the cases mentioned, how much does it really matter if you have 10 round mags instead of 15 (or 20+ for that matter)? don't get me wrong, I wish we all had the ability to own more than 15 round mags. But with our situation, we are only allowed to have 15 with no carry licenses at all. We even have issues and discussions on transportation of firearms within the state and out of state. If we all had national carry licenses, that would all go away. you can carry with you 30 mags of 10 rounds each and no one can say $hit.

Yes but cost wise it is more expensive having the 15 rd mag capacity. If i lived in a free state, I can order ak mags for $7 each and have them shipped to my house. In PRNJ I have to buy either factory 15rd mags or have original mags pinned. It gets expensive. The 15 rd mag thing has to be taken on, I will not give an inch to THEM.

I would be ok with it. I'll just carry 2 extra mags. If 30 rounds is not enough for you in a self defense situation outside the home, you are waaay in over your head, and no amount of ammo will help.

Seriously, where would you be outside your home where you need a few 30 round mags (range not included)? A drug kingpin's house where a drug deal goes bad? Inside a bank where a gang of men with assault rifles hold up the bank? Are you going to play John Mcclane in that situation?

 

Never heard of missing in a high stress situation? If 4 guys do a home invasion at your house do you really think 4 rounds are going to stop them? When the choice is unload all you got to protect your family, that's exactly what I'll do.

Never heard of missing in a high stress situation? If 4 guys do a home invasion at your house do you really think 4 rounds are going to stop them? When the choice is unload all you got to protect your family, that's exactly what I'll do.

we're talking outside the home. you get mugged by a guy, you have two 10 round mags. you mean to tell me that's not enough? even if you miss the first couple shots, it will give you enough time to retreat.

inside the home, i'm unloading everything i've got. i can always hide that 75 round drum for the AR after i've taken care of the threat. "officer, i only used these 10 round mags, i just reloaded." LOL :icon_e_biggrin:

 

 

 

that 75 round drum is a joke, but you get the picture. you have homefield advantage

Thune Ammendment, if it went up now for a vote it would pass.

No, for both.

 

Living in NJ is pretty terrible. Most aspects of our daily lives are pretty bad, and, of course, our gun laws are total jokes.

Seeing a theoretical question posted above will of course create answers that we see as logical, but ultimately are injected with our own prejudices. In simpler terms, we would answer the above question with the mentality of being an NJ resident who has been shafted, continuously.

However, beyond our state borders, there are great and wide bodies of land (insert states) that do have and celebrate the actual freedoms of our nation. A question posed as above would be terrible for the nation and 2A rights as whole-- regardless of how much of a small [maybe large] win it would be for NJ residents.

 

I'm sorry, maybe its because I believe that we need states like NJ in this nation to make people realize how messy and ineffective too much government/regulation can be on the citizen. It isn't fun being the proverbial whipping boy, but I believe that there is no perfect world where there would only be one train of thought (actually, I wouldn't want that at all!). Instead balance is required, and, again, we, as NJ residents, are on that short end of the stick.

 

So, no to both, for the sake of the greater whole.

I carry a 1911 (8+1) with two spare mags and a 5 shot bug (30 total) .....speaking for myself, I'm fine with it but the principal of them limiting our ability is appalling to me and apparantly many others....more people can carry two firearms with 10 rounds each plus a few spare mags....I would like to get the recriprocity passed and, if it was with these restrictions, fight them later....more the reason to practice mag changes....

Let me get this straight. Some of you guys in NJ are willing to take a hit and "fight it later?"

 

How's that worked out for you the past 30 years? How has the fight gone for NJ? Should I count on your record?

 

Basically, you're telling the rest of the country to F-off because you want something in Jerseystan. At the expense of America. And you know you will do nothing and expect everybody else in the country to clean up your mess.

 

If you want change, change your state. If you can't do that, how are you going to fix the country as an afterthought?

 

Listen, I know this is just an academic exercise. And I know how screwed and desperate you guys are. So this is just an academic response, with no ill-will intended. But this is the type of mentality that has caused totalitarianism and communism to dominate America over the last 80 years. "I don't have what I want, I'm not willing to do anything about it, not even move to another state, so screw everybody else so I can get what I want and we'll sort it out later."

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.