Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

4 Walmart employees fired after disarming gunman caught shoplifting

Featured Replies

I understand the concept of wanting employees to just be compliant neutral drones during the event of a hold up or similar situation..

 

It's an issue of competing interests. The corporation does not have your best interest in mind, it has its own. You on the other hand, in a life or death struggle should not be required to relinquish your right to life so that a corporation doesn't lose any money. I recognize that it's easy to make a situation worse, but don't tell me I have to sacrifice my life to some hump just because the corporation doesn't want to lose a buck.

  • Replies 60
  • Views 2.5k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • I'd rather stand in the unemployment line than be carried by 6.

  • I would not risk my life for Walmart or any other establishment I worked for. There is nothing in a retail store worth a human life. Unfortunatly these guys thought they were doing a good thing only

  • Love this... Screw walmart in this thread, yet everyone was swearing by Walmart for free Ammo.   +1 Kpd. It sucks, but it is like that in every store... then again, it is their store. Easier to

I'm sorry guys but altho I agree that policy is a policy and lawsuit , bad publicity is undesirable, I was always taught that if somebody attacks you (weapon or no weapon) believe , yes beileve with all yout body and soul that their intention is to kill you. This way you will fight for your life untill the danger has passed and not just give up and comply. ( chk my signature)

There is no freaking way Im gonna let some lowlife decide my faith.

 

 

Now lets replay the worst case....

 

In your house, guy is confronted by commando NJGF guy :icon_rolleyes: , you start roughing him up, the guy shoots and kills the three guys, during the misses, bullets go stray and hit your neighbors. All of those people are now suing you. No one is going to sue the bad guy.... because he has nothing anyway. Everyone wants money.

 

In the NJ law books, under no circumstances do you try to restrain the bad guy. That is why you have really good police officers. You do not lay a hand on the thief. The thief is there to steal your stuff, not to put a round in your head.

 

Is risking your life worth your measly belongings?

Doesn't sound so reasonable now, does it? It's a matter of principle. Ever since we were children, we were taught that stealing is bad, respect people and their property, and all that other good stuff. Just because it's a corporation and not a person it doesn't make it right. Frivolous lawsuits is what will kill this country. Whatever happened to common sense and moral values?

Tommy, agree with you 100 percent, but what has to change first.... the litigation society or the policies?

 

Let's say Walmart says ok... employees can carry, how many customers would be held at pinpoint because a crazy employee thinks you stole a pack o of skittles.

If someone broke into my house, took my tv and ran, I would not Chase him down with a gun. A 300 dollar tv is not qorth the risk that the guy may have friends in the car.

 

The point is, the employees put themselves in that position. They went out of their way to restrain the thief. The moment the thief said let me go, as someone posted earlier, open the door and "have a nice day and thank you for shopping at Walmart."

There is insurance for theft oross, there is nothing that will bring your life back.

 

I will agree once the gun is out to defend self, but... the guys were stupid to put themselves in that position.

If someone broke into my house, took my tv and ran, I would not Chase him down with a gun. A 300 dollar tv is not qorth the risk that the guy may have friends in the car.

 

The point is, the employees put themselves in that position. They went out of their way to restrain the thief. The moment the thief said let me go, as someone posted earlier, open the door and "have a nice day and thank you for shopping at Walmart."

There is insurance for theft oross, there is nothing that will bring your life back.

 

I will agree once the gun is out to defend self, but... the guys were stupid to put themselves in that position.

 

 

right and wrong can be decided at the drop of a hat.. and it is quite easy for all of us to say today at this moment that there was no need to intervene in this situation or that situation.. but in the moment.. when you have been raised for decades to understand right and wrong.. when you see something bad unfolding and assume the worst possible thing is about to happen.. how hard is it not to get involved..

 

Trust me.. I understand how important maintaining order is.. but I think that big box retailers get carried away at times..

 

right or wrong.. in my experience.. I have always got involved.. and always tried to stop people I have seen doing obvious wrong.. if someone stole my TV I would stop them.. or at least attempt to.. degree of crime will in many cases escalate over time.. maybe a TV today.. maybe a jewelry store robbery 8 months from now.. getting a criminal off the street today may save someone's life tomorrow..

Asset protection coordinator Poulsen met him at the door and ushered him back to the loss prevention room to confront him. Not long after, Ray and Richins -- both asset protection associates -- filtered in, followed by Stewart, an assistant manager, to witness.

[/Quote]

 

I think people are missing something. The employess who detained the man were the store's SECURITY GUARDS not a cashier. That is what security guards do, detain suspect then call police. Security guards theoretically have the training to deal with this type of issue.

 

the workers say Longton also pulled out a handgun and charged toward the closed office door. Ray, Richins and Stewart were in the way. He grabbed Stewart as his way to get out.

[/Quote]

 

Once the crook pulled a gun and stuck it in the managers back, store policy goes out the window, and you do what you have to do to protect yourself.

I think people are missing something. The employess who detained the man were the store's SECURITY GUARDS not a cashier. That is what security guards do, detain suspect then call police. Security guards theoretically have the training to deal with this type of issue.

 

 

 

Once the crook pulled a gun and stuck it in the managers back, store policy goes out the window, and you do what you have to do to protect yourself.

+1

I think people are missing something. The employess who detained the man were the store's SECURITY GUARDS not a cashier. That is what security guards do, detain suspect then call police. Security guards theoretically have the training to deal with this type of issue.

 

 

 

Once the crook pulled a gun and stuck it in the managers back, store policy goes out the window, and you do what you have to do to protect yourself.

 

I think the legality hinges on the detention room. The Walmart policy to have a detention room and instruct the guards to bring suspected shoplifters to this room is contradictory to the no restraint/fighting back policy. You can't have it both ways. Walmart's policy said to bring the suspect to the room. There has to be an assumption that things might get hairy when you detain someone. The guards followed the policy and then a gun was produced by the suspect and the guards were assaulted. You can't simply say, the guards must give up and hope for the best. Walmart put them in harm's way with their detention policy. You can't punish the guards for taking action to save their lives.

I think people are missing something. The employess who detained the man were the store's SECURITY GUARDS not a cashier. That is what security guards do, detain suspect then call police. Security guards theoretically have the training to deal with this type of issue.

 

Once the crook pulled a gun and stuck it in the managers back, store policy goes out the window, and you do what you have to do to protect yourself.

 

I think the legality hinges on the detention room. The Walmart policy to have a detention room and instruct the guards to bring suspected shoplifters to this room is contradictory to the no restraint/fighting back policy. You can't have it both ways. Walmart's policy said to bring the suspect to the room. There has to be an assumption that things might get hairy when you detain someone. The guards followed the policy and then a gun was produced by the suspect and the guards were assaulted. You can't simply say, the guards must give up and hope for the best. Walmart put them in harm's way with their detention policy. You can't punish the guards for taking action to save their lives.

 

I agree with both of these sentiments. +1 for both of you. Who's to say that once he pulled that gun out that he wouldn't start shooting people on the way out if some good samaritan tried to stop him.

Listen, I totally get why its smart business to strictly maintain & enforce policies that prevent employees from putting others in danger or risking lawsuits with poorly executed attempts at heroics. But, this really sounds like a case where these people had no reason to assume their attacker would spare them as long as they were compliant, as the policy would require. I'm not saying Walmart needs to change the policy, but there is no reason they can't show some discretion in it's application. They could publicly state what the policy is, but note that they are making an exception for this incident because the employees did not have the choice to flee and could reasonably conclude that their own lives were already in danger.

No, they cant, because it opens them up to lawsuits in the future. It's much like the Pizza Hut manager who shot the gunman who was herding him employees and customers into the back..MOST LIKELY to execute them. he shot and killed the Gunman. GOOD SHOOT..but it cost him his job. SHOULD he have gotten an award? Certainly, but the company CANT do that. Simple facts here these policies are made by the SAME People who would be Suing the a** of the company if they represented the "Victim" it's a cuircular argument, the same as bitching about how legilsatures (Comprised of mainly attorneys) Make laws with loopholes that favor Defense Attorneys.

I think the legality hinges on the detention room. The Walmart policy to have a detention room and instruct the guards to bring suspected shoplifters to this room is contradictory to the no restraint/fighting back policy. You can't have it both ways. Walmart's policy said to bring the suspect to the room. There has to be an assumption that things might get hairy when you detain someone. The guards followed the policy and then a gun was produced by the suspect and the guards were assaulted. You can't simply say, the guards must give up and hope for the best. Walmart put them in harm's way with their detention policy. You can't punish the guards for taking action to save their lives.

 

 

Problem here is that Walmart security is PROHIBITED From using ANY force whatsoever. They can ASk that the shoplifter accompany them to the Detention room..if the shoplifter decised to say "Screw you' and walk away the ONLY recourse they have is to call the local PD. I Believe they MAY be allowed to try and slow a shoplifter down by standing in front of them, or blocking the door but if the shoplifter becomes physically confrontational, they are required to retreat. of course if that Shoplifter actually TOUCHES a LP employee, or any other employee or person, they go from "Shoplifter" to Robbery Suspect" and into Felony land.

No, they cant, because it opens them up to lawsuits in the future. It's much like the Pizza Hut manager who shot the gunman who was herding him employees and customers into the back..MOST LIKELY to execute them. he shot and killed the Gunman. GOOD SHOOT..but it cost him his job. SHOULD he have gotten an award? Certainly, but the company CANT do that. Simple facts here these policies are made by the SAME People who would be Suing the a** of the company if they represented the "Victim" it's a cuircular argument, the same as bitching about how legilsatures (Comprised of mainly attorneys) Make laws with loopholes that favor Defense Attorneys.

just to be clear as to what I said before..

 

I understand what you are saying.. and dare I say I SUPPORT walmart and any other business having whatever policy they want to have.. a privately run business SHOULD be allowed to have no firearms.. no physical conflict policies.. it is sad that we live in a climate where everyone is sue sue sue.. but that is what it is.. but even with that said I feel these guys did exactly what they should have done.. there is no job out there.. walmart.. pizza hut.. etc.. that is worth risking my life for.. so if they want to terminate me for responding to a physical threat.. that is by all means their right to do so.. but with that said.. I think that it should be treated conditionally.. meaning that to say someone was fired for violating company policy when they actively broke company policy stealing time.. being late.. violating uniform code.. etc... that is one thing.. but in a split second situation where one has to decide between what is potentially life or death.. I think that it is in poor form to terminate with the same negative notation.. fired is fired.. but I just don't think that defending your life.. and stealing time are similar situations.. so they should IMO be treated differently.. I didn't even realize these were security personal at first either.. if that is in fact the case then the situation is even more complex.. because expecting security to engage individuals but then expecting them to break off the engagement when a weapon is produced.. seems like a flawed system.. this guy is stealing.. this guy has a weapon.. the point he is at in life is likely VERY low and VERY dangerous.. people who have nothing are very dangerous people.. as they have nothing to lose.. policy or not.. if I was working and someone presented a weapon towards me.. I would for all practical purposes assume they are trying to kill me.. I am not some ninja..lol or specially trained combatant... but I have taken tons of martial arts/self defense/knife type classes.. I would hope that I would react without thinking.. and I think that is the part we are all getting hung up on..

 

should an employee of 20 years.. who was threatened with a weapon.. get fired for subduing the attacker... "we" are just irritated that Walmart says yes.. you should..

 

I respect their right to hire and fire who they want.. but I see it as a bad move.. as do others.. it is not so much (for me at least) saying that they are not allowed.. it is just more saying it is a lame thing to do..

 

if that all makes sense..

sorry to babble.. lots of coffee this morning.. lol

It's kind of like the guy who got fired in Pa for violating his comapny's "No weapons" policy THREE Times. The rights of the property owner trump everything IMO. If your boss wont allow you to CCW (Again i KNOW its not an issue in nj...but im using a popular example from ARF) and it's THAT crucial a Deal..quit and go elsewhere. If a local store has a "No Firearms" allowed Sign on their door. Take your business elsewhere, and let the local firearms community know it. It's the same as being HERE... your "Free Speech Rights' END when you sign in, because by Signing in YOU HAVE AGREED to abide by Mak's rules, because this is Mak's HOUSE. My wife worked for Quik-Check for a time..the VERY first thing she was told was the policy on weapons, and what to do if anyone tried to rob the place (Cooperate and get him/her out ASAP. you wont find Many, if ANY large companies that dont have the exact same policies..be it Wally world, target, Kmart, Home Depot, Lowes, Kohls...should I go on? it is what it is and for a change not PRIMARILY because of any anti-gun policy, but because of a litiginous society that is looking for a quick payoff for everything.

It's kind of like the guy who got fired in Pa for violating his comapny's "No weapons" policy THREE Times. The rights of the property owner trump everything IMO. If your boss wont allow you to CCW (Again i KNOW its not an issue in nj...but im using a popular example from ARF) and it's THAT crucial a Deal..quit and go elsewhere. If a local store has a "No Firearms" allowed Sign on their door. Take your business elsewhere, and let the local firearms community know it. It's the same as being HERE... your "Free Speech Rights' END when you sign in, because by Signing in YOU HAVE AGREED to abide by Mak's rules, because this is Mak's HOUSE. My wife worked for Quik-Check for a time..the VERY first thing she was told was the policy on weapons, and what to do if anyone tried to rob the place (Cooperate and get him/her out ASAP. you wont find Many, if ANY large companies that dont have the exact same policies..be it Wally world, target, Kmart, Home Depot, Lowes, Kohls...should I go on? it is what it is and for a change not PRIMARILY because of any anti-gun policy, but because of a litiginous society that is looking for a quick payoff for everything.

 

 

I agree completely..

You know what I'm wondering ... Why do they have security guards if they don't want them to do anything ..,, anybody can call cops ..

Problem here is that Walmart security is PROHIBITED From using ANY force whatsoever. They can ASk that the shoplifter accompany them to the Detention room..if the shoplifter decised to say "Screw you' and walk away the ONLY recourse they have is to call the local PD. I Believe they MAY be allowed to try and slow a shoplifter down by standing in front of them, or blocking the door but if the shoplifter becomes physically confrontational, they are required to retreat. of course if that Shoplifter actually TOUCHES a LP employee, or any other employee or person, they go from "Shoplifter" to Robbery Suspect" and into Felony land.

 

I agree with you if the shoplifter decided to say "screw you" and walk away. In this case the shoplifter said "screw you" and stuck a gun in someone's ribs. Now what? Yes, the robber went into felony land. He could have went into mass murderer land.

I agree with you if the shoplifter decided to say "screw you" and walk away. In this case the shoplifter said "screw you" and stuck a gun in someone's ribs. Now what? Yes, the robber went into felony land. He could have went into mass murderer land.

 

 

In FL you could shoot him for that.. Walmart might still fire you.. lol but just to put it into perspective.. there are states that recognize your ability to LEGALLY use deadly force to stop a forcible felony.. I think that we as NJ guys tend to forget just how normal what went on here actually was.. yeah it's Walmart's right to do whatever they want.. they own the store.. they call the shots.. but in a place like FL.. if you shot that guy stone dead you would be in the right legally.. and no one would even so much as bat an eye.. so I think it is just frustrating that these individuals got involved and paid for it with their employment, when they were doing the morally right thing..

I agree with you if the shoplifter decided to say "screw you" and walk away. In this case the shoplifter said "screw you" and stuck a gun in someone's ribs. Now what? Yes, the robber went into felony land. He could have went into mass murderer land.

This is what many people are missing. Yes companies have policies regarding if a weapon is present.....but what if your life is literally in danger? The employees couldn't walk away as the gunman was between them and the only door out. So if four of you outnumbered one gunman, what would you do?

You know what I'm wondering ... Why do they have security guards if they don't want them to do anything ..,, anybody can call cops ..

It's like having a home alarm system warning sticker on the windows without actually having an alarm system. It's a deterrent and to give customers a false sense of security.

I agree with you if the shoplifter decided to say "screw you" and walk away. In this case the shoplifter said "screw you" and stuck a gun in someone's ribs. Now what? Yes, the robber went into felony land. He could have went into mass murderer land.

You do what you need to do..but understand that whether or not its the "Right" think it's not going to save your job. In that situation I WOULD HAVE DONE THE SAME THING..but I also wouldnt get all butt-hurt about getting fired. Their job isnt worth MY life.

You know what I'm wondering ... Why do they have security guards if they don't want them to do anything ..,, anybody can call cops ..

 

they are not security guards. they are LP, Loss Prevention. they just watch the monitors if they suspect theft, and then call the cops. thats it.

 

They are not trained/certified security guards.

I agree with you if the shoplifter decided to say "screw you" and walk away. In this case the shoplifter said "screw you" and stuck a gun in someone's ribs. Now what? Yes, the robber went into felony land. He could have went into mass murderer land.

 

Once again, what the article doesn't say is how the LP tried to detain the BG. If they lay a hand on him, or made him go to the LP office, they brought it on.

 

They were absolutely right to defend their lives... but absolutely deserved to lose their jobs.

Once again, what the article doesn't say is how the LP tried to detain the BG. If they lay a hand on him, or made him go to the LP office, they brought it on.

 

They were absolutely right to defend their lives... but absolutely deserved to lose their jobs.

 

I think they did the right thing. They followed policy and detained the suspect, once the gun was produced and threatened their lives they reacted, and reacted in the right manner in my opinion. I agree with the statement, "rather be judged by 12 then carried by 6" BUT....in this day in age to be judged by 12 means you have to be judged by all the fruit loops out there that want their "friendly" "go-green" "eco-friendly" agendias passed but dont want to deal with the situations that may arise.

 

Good job done by these employees...should they have lost their jobs over it? No...should they sue over it? NO...by suing over this makes them just like the rest of the sue happy assholes in todays society. They saved their lives and POSSIBLY the lives of others. People cant always look at the what if, consider the now. They saved lives...period. Walmart fired them....oh well....screw walmart and go find another job. I sure as **** would put on my application at my next job that I did what was required of me UNTIL a weapon was presented and I did what I had to do to protect myself and my fellow employees and was fired for it. If you dont like that I will gladly apply elswhere.

 

 

-Scott

The problem is... did walmart or does walmart tell there security to prevent the shoplifter from leaving the store, but not assert force? If the shoplifter goes quietly with security, just to brandish a weapon in the "interrogation room" and threaten there lives by pointing a gun directly at person point blank (hostage situation), is it not walmart who put them directly in the position to violate company policy? (in this instance). My problem with this is.. i can understand company policy to let a shoplifter walk out the door to catch him later. I cannot understand how a company tells it's employees to engage with a shoplifter, and then told they cannot do anything.

The fact that the security guards had some sort of protocol to follow which led them to this back room is what put them in the position to begin with, how can walmart fire them for violating a protocol in which walmart forced them to violate. It's walmart who put them in this position, they should fire themselves.

 

If walmart wants employees to avoid confrontation with dangerous situations they should not put them into dangerous situations to begin with. If i could sue them for putting my life in danger i would, and then maybe they would let shoplifters walk out. Who's to say this guy wouldnt just blow them away when they approached him. Thank god he didnt. But let's face it, this wasnt a hold up robbery where an employee is forced into the situation by the criminal.

 

There policy basically says corner the criminal until he pulls out a gun and comes out shooting.

 

Personally, i hope walmart burns in hell for many other reason then this.

I can't think of one company who wouldnt award these Employees for doing the right thing, even when policy told them not to. Shows good morals and values, something many companies look for in there employees.

No company tells their LP to hold the person at the store.

 

The vast majority of petty thiefs will just follow because they are scared and they just got caught. If people knew they can just walk out, they would. But no one wants that to go out.

 

Ie, the best buy guy who chased a guy out the store and jumped him when he stole a PS3. Guy was caught for theft, then sued the crap out of Best Buy.

 

Alright, unless anything new is being added, I think it is time to let this thread die.

The employees will be on Fox News with Megyn Kelly at about 1340 today, Monday.

The employees will be on Fox News with Megyn Kelly at about 1340 today, Monday.

 

I side with the employees on this. Like I said previously - if they let that guy go he could have shot people on the way out.

 

Also - WTF is that video footage of? That wasn't from the incident - there weren't any shots fired (circles on the curb/pavement).

I side with the employees on this. Like I said previously - if they let that guy go he could have shot people on the way out.

 

Also - WTF is that video footage of? That wasn't from the incident - there weren't any shots fired (circles on the curb/pavement).

 

LOL. I saw that too Nick and wondered WTF are they showing with the red circles.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.