Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Marine shot dead in front of his kids!

Featured Replies

Ok. Here is a true example. Suspect creeps up behind an officer while he is helping somebody else. Places said officer in a choke hold. Officer is losing consciousness and draws weapon and shoots suspect. Good shoot but suspect has no weapon. Not saying it applies in this case but the general statement of no weapon no shoot doesn't hold. I can give more examples if you want to mouth off with generalizing stupidity again

  • Replies 67
  • Views 4.5k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • In all of your situations the cops are engaged in physical altercations. This is a discussion about a cop shooting someone from a distance. No one is going to argue with your situations as they are

  • greatgunstatenj
    greatgunstatenj

    I think both sides need to relax. We don't really know what happened in this situation, we weren't there. A person in a car could be a threat. Was he? We don't know. Just because the guy was a Vet doe

  • BlueLineFish
    BlueLineFish

    Ok. Here is a true example. Suspect creeps up behind an officer while he is helping somebody else. Places said officer in a choke hold. Officer is losing consciousness and draws weapon and shoots susp

Ok. Here is a true example. Suspect creeps up behind an officer while he is helping somebody else. Places said officer in a choke hold. Officer is losing consciousness and draws weapon and shoots suspect. Good shoot but suspect has no weapon. Not saying it applies in this case but the general statement of no weapon no shoot doesn't hold. I can give more examples if you want to mouth off with generalizing stupidity again

 

More examples please.

Female cop is being assaulted by a much larger suspect. No weapon. One more shot may render her unconscious. She shoots suspect. This even went to court and shoot was justified. You have to remember anytime an officer is involved so is a weapon. I am not saying these apply to this case because I do not know the details. But I hate sweeping generalizations from people who really don't know what they are talking about.

More examples please.

 

a couple officers respond to a large disturbance... on arriving the disturbance is a large rowdy group that grows agitated... the group as a whole turns on the two knocking one to the ground.. and are now kicking and stomping him...

 

no weapon.. but justified in shooting IMO..

In all of your situations the cops are engaged in physical altercations. This is a discussion about a cop shooting someone from a distance. No one is going to argue with your situations as they are clearly good shoots, but they have nothing to do with this conversation. Yes, the statement "no weapon=no shoot" can be taken out of context, but in the context of this thread it is correct. Unless you can share a scenario where a good shoot can be justified without physical danger happening to someone and no weapon you are just spewing out of context sentences.

 

 

a couple officers respond to a large disturbance... on arriving the disturbance is a large rowdy group that grows agitated... the group as a whole turns on the two numbers knocking one to the ground.. and are now kicking and stomping him...

 

no weapon.. but justified in shooting IMO..

 

This was my next example

I was merely responding to the no weapon- no shoot garbage. I also stated clearly that it doesn't seem to apply to this case

In all of your situations the cops are engaged in physical altercations. This is a discussion about a cop shooting someone from a distance. No one is going to argue with your situations as they are clearly good shoots, but they have nothing to do with this conversation. Yes, the statement "no weapon=no shoot" can be taken out of context, but in the context of this thread it is correct. Unless you can share a scenario where a good shoot can be justified without physical danger happening to someone and no weapon you are just spewing out of context sentences.

 

oh no question.. shooting a single unarmed individual dead is certainly questionable.. and unlikely to be a clean shoot..

Just wondering since when are fists and feet not weapons by the way?

 

Just because somebody punches me or kicks me doesn't mean I can shoot them. Punching or kicking is in most instances to be met with hands,OC or baton. I don't have a taser

Just because somebody punches me or kicks me doesn't mean I can shoot them. Punching or kicking is in most instances to be met with hands,OC or baton. I don't have a taser

 

If someone is kicking someones face in and you are a far distance away you could shoot someone for kicking someones face in. I agree with you that a a blanket statement no weapon = no shoot does not work, but for the purposes of this thread it does fit in as we are discussing shooting a person not in a physical altercation that has no weapon.

 

 

If someone is kicking someones face in and you are a far distance away you could shoot someone for kicking someones face in. I agree with you that a a blanket statement no weapon = no shoot does not work, but for the purposes of this thread it does fit in as we are discussing shooting a person not in a physical altercation that has no weapon.

I would generally agree with this statement.

Just because somebody punches me or kicks me doesn't mean I can shoot them. Punching or kicking is in most instances to be met with hands,OC or baton. I don't have a taser

 

This is just out of curiosity, I'm not looking to debate with you. But wouldn't your chokehold scenario be in the same catergory? Don't you learn some kind of ground fighting combatives in the academy? On how to counter a chokehold? Again, not looking to join the debate just my own idol curiosity.

If someone is kicking someones face in and you are a far distance away you could shoot someone for kicking someones face in. I agree with you that a a blanket statement no weapon = no shoot does not work, but for the purposes of this thread it does fit in as we are discussing shooting a person not in a physical altercation that has no weapon.

 

Thing is, each situation a reaction needed to be based on everything happening, way too many variables to ever have a clear Black and White rule, they is just way too much Grey area to cover. Also many times it is going to happen in seconds if not split seconds.

This is just out of curiosity, I'm not looking to debate with you. But wouldn't your chokehold scenario be in the same catergory? Don't you learn some kind of ground fighting combatives in the academy? On how to counter a chokehold? Again, not looking to join the debate just my own idol curiosity.

 

Take it a step further, your in a free state, you're CCW'ing, and you're in this situation, what would you do??

 

Remember the gun you have can easily be turned into their weapon.

 

6 or 12, you choose!!

 

 

This is just out of curiosity, I'm not looking to debate with you. But wouldn't your chokehold scenario be in the same catergory? Don't you learn some kind of ground fighting combatives in the academy? On how to counter a chokehold? Again, not looking to join the debate just my own idol curiosity.

 

A good rear naked choke can take a few seconds to immobilize or kill you. If your initial response of escape fails or you freeze then you are really left with one option. Again too many variables. I may be able to escape but someone else might not

I was merely responding to the no weapon- no shoot garbage. I also stated clearly that it doesn't seem to apply to this case

 

If it clearly doesn't apply to this case, then why did you mention it in this thread? And why would your initial response to him be all of two words.

 

not true

 

So you clearly didn't state that initially, yet you knew what he was referring to (as you admit here), and still posted such a [un]detailed response anyways....clearly you had an agenda.

Just wondering since when are fists and feet not weapons by the way?

 

99.999999999% of the time.

 

Edit: Disregard I was reading from the bottom of the thread and didn't follow the conversation.

 

I agree you can just as well be kicked or punched to death, as being shot.

Edited by PeteF

 

 

If it clearly doesn't apply to this case, then why did you mention it in this thread? And why would your initial response to him be all of two words.

 

 

 

So you clearly didn't state that initially, yet you knew what he was referring to (as you admit here), and still posted such a [un]detailed response anyways....clearly you had an agenda.

 

I responded to one quote that's it. If you think I have an agenda so be it. I should have know it was too good to be true that you hadn't chimed in yet. This thread is over for me because when you get involved it gets annoying.

  • Author

Just because somebody punches me or kicks me doesn't mean I can shoot them. Punching or kicking is in most instances to be met with hands,OC or baton. I don't have a taser

 

I knew you were a cop!

I knew you were a cop!

 

He is, but just a regular guy and not one I would feel is on a power trip at all.

This forum seems to be getting more of Us Vs. Them all the time.

 

Aren't we all fellow gun-owners that enjoy the sport and hobby?

 

Would we all say the same things face to face as we say here? I know I would, if I say it here, I'll say it to your face.

 

People gotta lighten-up........................

I will never change my opinion. What I say here is exactly what I would say in person. Like it or not. I wish it didint tun into these debates because everybody is entitled to their opinion. It just seems that certain people never like mine and choose to start pissing contests for no reason. Whatever.

Take it a step further, your in a free state, you're CCW'ing, and you're in this situation, what would you do??

 

Remember the gun you have can easily be turned into their weapon.

 

6 or 12, you choose!!

 

In this free state scenario am I guarenteed a "good shot/kill" and not risking a murder/manslaughter charge? If not, going to sleep for a few minutes sounds a lot better then a lengthy prison sentence. I would never want to risk my freedom to a judge or jury saying that said situation could've been handled without deadly force.

 

I don't really understand when you say, can be turned into their weapon. If I'm ccwing how is my attacker going to know I am carrying?

I don't really understand when you say, can be turned into their weapon. If I'm ccwing how is my attacker going to know I am carrying?

 

Your in a struggle and it pops out or shirt gets pulled up and it shows, or you paint leg get pulled up and it shows. The person goes to grab for you and feels it. Probably a few other ways but that's all I could think of in 10 seconds..

 

Now your while you stopped from doing something, they see it, your firearm is no theirs, now what's ya going to do??

Your in a struggle and it pops out or shirt gets pulled up and it shows, or you paint leg get pulled up and it shows. The person goes to grab for you and feels it. Probably a few other ways but that's all I could think of in 10 seconds..

 

Now your while you stopped from doing something, they see it, your firearm is no theirs, now what's ya going to do??

 

Well that's really hard to prepare for in the situation that there's a loaded gun pointed at you, your natural fight or flight response is going to kick in. In that split second you're going to either decide I can wrestle my gun back, it's time to surrender, or this guy wants to murder me do anything you have to do.

A good rear naked choke can take a few seconds to immobilize or kill you. If your initial response of escape fails or you freeze then you are really left with one option. Again too many variables. I may be able to escape but someone else might not

 

it wont always work but..

 

it is very hard to choke someone with one arm from behind.. so if you are being choked put your two hands on one of their arms to obtain control..

pull the arm forward so that the individuals arm is extended straight with their elbow resting on your shoulder..

hold onto the wrist with all your might and pull straight down towards the ground..

 

a couple things will happen.. but all of them boil down to the individuals arm bending in a way it is not meant to be bent... and all of them boil down to you getting them off your back..

you have to do it fast in a smooth fluid motion free of hesitation... you have to do it with complete commitment.. and you have to use all the strength..

The SUV was a weapon...The girls were potential hostages...juvenile female hostages...cause as a parent and former Marine, I take my kids out for a nice ride to the local track at o'dark thirty, too...Then walk around talking to myself, ignoring uniformed law enforcement officers attempts to speak with me, and acting erratically...obviously it's a Police cover up...

What you don't know that you don't know, is painfully obvious to those who actually do...particularly when you allow your bias to drip out in nearly every post...

It never ceases to amaze me...the near instant furor that develops here, and repeatedly is permitted to run full bore or nearly so, under the guise of "discussion" to bash Cops at the slightest opportunity.

Flip the script and let a "deranged man" drive away with two young girls in the truck never to be seen or heard from again, or wrapped around a bridge embankment, or off the Oceanside dock into the ocean a short distance away, and it would have been,"WHY DIDN'T THOSE COPS DO SOMETHING WHILE THEY HAD THE CHANCE!"

Far be it from me to point out the obvious, but parents have in the past and will in the future, kill their children. It's unfathomable to me as a parent of three, but it happens, and seemingly more frequently each day. As a former Marine, I know what a good conduct medal represents...It means I never got a serious disciplinary during the review period. It means I never "got caught". I have one, and was brought back to base by the Duty NCO on more then a few occasions for getting drunk and getting into bar fights. It's a young Marine's favorite past time. I was banned from at least two Enlisted Clubs on base for it. There were plenty of real shitbirds that had them in my time, and I doubt it's changed significantly since my time...sometimes it just means I had a boy working in the admin office or I slid them some cash to make it go away...not that anything like that ever happened...

Reports discussing the failing of some gun user posted in the media are dissected for the slightest possible reasons, real or imagined, to show support and exonerate the shooter, and just as importantly to show the media bias and libel. After all, it's common knowledge at that time how twisted and bent the media version of anything is...

Let them say something about a Cop though, and for the moral imperative here, it becomes gospel, and a likelihood for some never was armchair quarterback to talk about how those jack booted thugs did it wrong again, and how he could do it ten times better from the comfort and safety of his living room...yeah...sure...hindsight is always twenty twenty...and Chuck Norris ain't got nothing on their skills...

Why do I even bother to read these threads any longer...

Now come the open challenges, internet muscle flexing and baiting threads because I'm young and naive enough to feed...honest...

PS

Oh, and Los Angeles is a little over an hour North of here, but your doing great otherwise...carry on...they're all JBTs anyway...right?

Its a shame how a few potential bad apples ruin the batch. I wonder if they tested the officer involved for drug use.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.