Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

I can't believe I even have to mull this over , but..

Featured Replies

I live in So. Bergen County. My dad lives in Brick. He is about 2 miles from Brick Armory and Shore Shot.

 

I'm am home with an 8 month old all day..other two kids are in school , the earliest anyone gets home is 3pm.

 

My dad tells me he will gladly sit with his 8 month old grandson for an hour or two while I get some range time in at either of those places.

 

Now the question..reasonable deviation.

 

Would everyone here be comfortable with driving to a sitter , dropping the baby , driving two miles or so to the range , then back to visit with dad for a while and have some lunch and stuff before heading in home in time to meet the school bus .

 

I have an SUV so anything in the back is all over the road if I God forbid get rear ended or anything.

 

So , mom with a baby in the car , minor rear ending , a Colt .45 , A mini 14 , and a Model 60 are scattered across Rt 70. I am definitely off course from BA or SS at my dad's ( it is about a 2 or 3 mile deviation), in regards to my way home.All stuff is NJ legal , and I would probably carry FID card and copies of the 2 pistol permits even though not required. Can't hurt.

 

Are the police making anything of it , should I not worry about and assume that dropping the baby off at a sitter on my way to an approved activity with my handguns qualifies as " as is necessary to perform activity blah blah blah"

 

Can't believe I even have to wonder about this :/

I think you will be fine. Take your dad up on the offer and have fun.

I would say the sitter is ok since that could be deemed necessary. The lunch with dad would be the unacceptable part. To much time away from vehicle and firearms.

  • Author

My personal opinion is I'm fine..having to drop your 8 month old off at a sitter that is 2 miles from the range seems reasonable to me. Can't take him to the range , they don't make eyes and ears in his size. I can't picture getting charged with anything.

 

But I just want to make sure I am not underestimating the ridiculousness of these conditions.

  • Author

I thought of that too...time away from the vehicle. I may have to skip any visiting afterwards?

 

I hate to "use" my dad for 2 hours then say " see ya!!" He would want to feed me and enjoy my company for at least a measly hour after I was done.

Order in and eat lunch at the house then bring em in with you so no worries.

  • Author

and I am not allowed to bring my bag with my safely kept firearms into my dad's home while I sit with him for an hour I suppose.

 

Well , he'll understand. I don't like that I have to do it that way though.

  • Author

Order in and eat lunch at the house then bring em in with you so no worries.

 

Oh , I can bring the guns in the house with me for safe keeping?

Both stops are reasonable to a sane person. Unfortunately most the people in this state are not sane. I would do both and not worry about it. If you feel the stop is reasonable then you are not breaking any law.

  • Author

I would definitely only be visiting his home .. having a bite to eat there and solving what ever vexing computer issue my dad last got himself got himself into. :)

I agree both are logically reasonable but that doesn't matter in this state when weapons are involved. Technically having thm with you in someone else house is against the rules. The rifles are ok just not the handgun

I'm not saying she can't be arrested, I am just saying she is doing nothing wrong. In this thread alone we have two LEO's with different opinions on the matter. Both agree that the drop off on the way there is fine, but the staying for lunch had different answers. Shows how gray the laws are for sure. In any state not just NJ you can be arrested while not breaking the law if the LEO doing the arresting wants to, then you get o go to court and sort it out. It's the world we live in now unforunately.

Remember that a FID is essentially a travel permit for long arms (shotguns and rifles). If you have a FID, the reasonable deviation restriction goes away for long guns. For handguns you are taking a chance, IMO a very small one. If you can live with just shooting the mini 14 and Marlin, then all is good.

Missed in the OP the Colt .45. Rifles are good, the handgun, technically a no-no.

I'm just wondering if anyone would think it would be a better idea to drop the kid off then go home and get what was needed to go to the range. I know it's nuts we even have to think about this but with the close proximity to the home, range and sitters anleo may think its not a reasonable deviation.

 

Just putting another option out there even though its nuts to even have to do something like this.

  • Author

Ah , I would primarily be interested in practicing with my NEW revolver ( I pick it up Tuesday :) ) and my .45 . The Mini 14 is for fun . I also have a Mossberg I've been wanting to let dislocate my shoulder. But my primary interest in practicing for improvement is for handguns.

 

I have always found the Brick police to be a good bunch ( as long as you're not a summer Benny lol) ...

 

How far would they go to determine how long ago I left the range? Would an officer really say you should not have stayed for that sandwich when you picked up the baby?

 

I know , nobody knows the answer to that . I depends on the officer who responds to whatever situation .

  • Author

I'm just wondering if anyone would think it would be a better idea to drop the kid off then go home and get what was needed to go to the range. I know it's nuts we even have to think about this but with the close proximity to the home, range and sitters anleo may think its not a reasonable deviation.

 

Just putting another option out there even though its nuts to even have to do something like this.

 

I live 1 hour 10 minutes from my dad..then another 2 miles or so to the range , then back to my dads to pick up the baby , then home. It all comes down to being polite and having a cup of Joe and a sandwich before going back home turns it into a punishable offense.

  • Author

Good money making idea for any range owners . DAYCARE! Just like the gyms. Get the stay at home moms in the range during the weekdays lol

 

 

I live 1 hour 10 minutes from my dad..then another 2 miles or so to the range , then back to my dads to pick up the baby , then home. It all comes down to being polite and having a cup of Joe and a sandwich before going back home turns it into a punishable offense.

 

Oh, sorry I thought they were all close to each other. Back to what others said I see it as a reasonable stop. Sorry hard to read on this iPhone. :-)

  • Author

Oh, sorry I thought they were all close to each other. Back to what others said I see it as a reasonable stop. Sorry hard to read on this iPhone. :-)

No worries :) I can never read anything but email on phones.

 

I'll maybe tell him I can only come in for 10 of 15 minutes because I have to get my locked up unloaded denizen of hell 's machine back home asap before it breaks its bonds in the back of my Honda Pilot and goes on a killing spree in the retirement trailer park.

I would say that stopping for food is perfectly acceptable. The 4 necessities for life are FOOD, water, air, and shelter. You need food to survive. If you stopped off at the mall and did some shoe shopping, that would be a different story.

 

Reasonable deviation from the range in my opinion. Plus the fact that your firearms are all stowed properly in your vehicle shows you follow the law.

 

I would stop for lunch and not worry. It disturbs me that we even have to have threads like this. we can drive a few miles to PA and go to lunch with our dads while carrying our pistols on our person loaded with dangerous cop killing hollow points for christs sake. this state is a freaking joke.

Hmmm I dunno about that 10-15 minutes doesn't sound as reasonable as 7 minutes and 37 seconds....

Check me on this, but I thought I read something here not to long ago about firearms in a school zone. Maybe it doesn't apply in the case, but I figured I'd throw it out there.

Don't take this the wrong way, but I'll lay it out in worst case here... Ultimately it is up to you to interprete the laws and make your own decisions of course.

 

Even if the chances are slim... I'm putting myself in an anti-gun prosecutor's shoes out for blood, I could argue that the "deviation" of dropping off your child was not a "necessary deviation" as you could have chose not to bring your HG, or choose to shoot your HG's another time. You put yourself in the situation of needing to make that deviation. I would argue that "reasonably necessary deviations" would be things like roadblocks, navigating around traffic, or even stopping for gas if your car is running out while on your way from point A (home) and B (range).

 

Stopping for lunch is definately a no-no with a HG in the car, as eating food is not "necessary" as you can wait until you are home even if you are hungry (unless you had a very good medical reason that you would harm your health if you didnt eat right then and there). Bringing your HG over to your father's while you are there is also out of bounds, thats a definate illegal posession charge as your father's house is not an exempted posession location or destination for travel.

Check me on this, but I thought I read something here not to long ago about firearms in a school zone. Maybe it doesn't apply in the case, but I figured I'd throw it out there.

 

School property

(1) Any person who knowingly has in his possession any firearm in or upon any part of the buildings or grounds of any school, college, university or other educational institution, without the written authorization of the governing officer of the institution, is guilty of a crime of the third degree, irrespective of whether he possesses a valid permit to carry the firearm or a valid firearms purchaser identification card.

(2) Any person who knowingly possesses any weapon enumerated in paragraphs (3) and (4) of subsection r. of N.J.S.2C:39-1 or any components which can readily be assembled into a firearm or other weapon enumerated in subsection r. of N.J.S.2C:39-1 or any other weapon under circumstances not manifestly appropriate for such lawful use as it may have, while in or upon any part of the buildings or grounds of any school, college, university or other educational institution without the written authorization of the governing officer of the institution is guilty of a crime of the fourth degree.

(3) Any person who knowingly has in his possession any imitation firearm in or upon any part of the buildings or grounds of any school, college, university or other educational institution, without the written authorization of the governing officer of the institution, or while on any school bus is a disorderly person, irrespective of whether he possesses a valid permit to carry a firearm or a valid firearms purchaser identification card.

OK, thanks guys. Now I remember the huge thread we had on that one to, debating what "knowingly" actually meant. "Sorry officer. I had forgotten my gun and ammo was with me. I would never knowingly traveled with it unless I was going to the range, let alone be on school property". If I recall a fellow member or one of his family members was caught on schools grounds with a firearm or something along those lines.

Uh guys, she said she would be going home to meet the school bus, the school propety law has nothing to do with this thread. Just pointing that out before a full on thread jacking occurs.

sometimes in life you have to live on the edge...

 

dropping the kids off is fine.. remember even if the state pushed the charge for some insane reason a court still has to find you guilty.. dropping your kids safely off to go to the range is a necessary divination as there is nothing else you can do with them.. firmly believe that and I fail to see an issue..

 

leaving your guns in a car on a public street while you eat lunch... probably not so smart as anything could happen..

 

ordering lunch and eating at his house? sure.. if the NJSP comes and breaks down his door to serve a warrant and finds these guns you might find your self in trouble...

that is IMO a reasonable risk in life to take..

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.