February 24, 201214 yr Uh guys, she said she would be going home to meet the school bus, the school propety law has nothing to do with this thread. Just pointing that out before a full on thread jacking occurs. Sorry, I read it incorrectly. Agreed with your suggestion.
February 24, 201214 yr Author I won't go to the Brick High School Cafeteria or anything Yes , my son's school bus drops him off at our door. I would not be picking up or dropping kids at school. My route will be my driveway , to my dad's to drop the baby , the range 2 miles or so away , back to pick up the baby , then right home. I could wait in the car and have my dad get the baby out , and then put the baby back in without ever getting out of the car myself. That would be the height of mercenary grandparent use. I'll just play Cats In The Cradle while I'm idling in the car. Good grief , to have to think these things out.
February 24, 201214 yr Sorry, I read it incorrectly. Agreed with your suggestion. Same I thought Nascar was asking for the 2C:39-5 law.
February 24, 201214 yr Oh oh oh! I have a crazy solution for the crazy problem. Drop off baby and head to range as already has been said is kosher by a bunch of random dudes on the internet as this is legally binding and will hold up in court of course and then you can work out a deal with the range to leave the evil handgun there while you go visit your father for a couple hours, then go pick up you handgun at the range that you were storing there with the baby already picked up from your fathers and drive directy home. Wohoo for insanity! It's kinda like one of those there are 5 peope on the edge of a river and one boat that only carries 3 people how do you get all 5 people accross the river problems.
February 24, 201214 yr Nobody said it is legally binding. Ultimately one, to be completely safe, would not go to the range at all unless somebody was home to watch the baby. It could even be argued that the babysitter is an unnecessary deviation.
February 24, 201214 yr That is what is called a joke. I'm pretty sure everyone knows that legal advice on the internet is worth what you paid for it.
February 24, 201214 yr Yes but as an LEO I don't want o give people the wrong idea. In this state everything is subjective
February 24, 201214 yr Y'know, we're always harping over changing the CCW and AWB here in NJ, but after reading this and a few other threads about the reasonable deviation law, maybe we should focus on attacking that one as well.
February 24, 201214 yr Y'know, we're always harping over changing the CCW and AWB here in NJ, but after reading this and a few other threads about the reasonable deviation law, maybe we should focus on attacking that one as well. I agree, I think they should be treated like long guns.
February 24, 201214 yr Author What is the penalty anyway ? Curious. Let's just say I broke no other law. Hypothetical situation: I drop the baby off at 9:45 am , then go to SS and shoot from 10 to 11. I am back at my dad's at 11:15 , go inside , gather the baby's stuff , have a cup of coffee and a bagel. Leave my dad's at say 12:30. Go to the intersection of Rt 70 and Chambers Bridge rd and get rear ended ( that already happened to me a few years ago) . For whatever reason the officers who respond notice my firearms. Unlikely since I keep the handguns in their factory cases inside a zippered backpack bag , but let's just say they do. I show them my paperwork and tell them I was at SS , picked up my baby , and am on my way home. They ask " you stopped to drop off and picked up your baby , so you did not go directly to the range and back , that is not reasonable deviation" I am then charged with what? And the penalty for said charge is what? As an afterthought , even if my backpack went skittering across the road it would not scream " I have guns in here" Only the long guns would be obvious in their cases . Jeez , ironically maybe I should leave the long guns home because they would easily cause questions more so than a plain backpack.
February 24, 201214 yr OMG OMG OMG You want to have a GUN!!!! in the CAR!! with a BABY!!!! Someone call Michael Moore!
February 24, 201214 yr Author Just crossed my mind..if you are a member at SS , can you locker a gun there?
February 26, 201214 yr What is the penalty anyway ? Curious. Let's just say I broke no other law. Hypothetical situation: I drop the baby off at 9:45 am , then go to SS and shoot from 10 to 11. I am back at my dad's at 11:15 , go inside , gather the baby's stuff , have a cup of coffee and a bagel. Leave my dad's at say 12:30. Go to the intersection of Rt 70 and Chambers Bridge rd and get rear ended ( that already happened to me a few years ago) . For whatever reason the officers who respond notice my firearms. Unlikely since I keep the handguns in their factory cases inside a zippered backpack bag , but let's just say they do. I show them my paperwork and tell them I was at SS , picked up my baby , and am on my way home. They ask " you stopped to drop off and picked up your baby , so you did not go directly to the range and back , that is not reasonable deviation" I am then charged with what? And the penalty for said charge is what? As an afterthought , even if my backpack went skittering across the road it would not scream " I have guns in here" Only the long guns would be obvious in their cases . Jeez , ironically maybe I should leave the long guns home because they would easily cause questions more so than a plain backpack. It would be a violation of 2C:39-5b, 3rd degree for BB/air guns, 2nd degree for real handguns. So essentially you carrying your handgun into your fathers home, with his permission and no criminal intent, is equivalent to aggravated assault, manslaughter, robbery, larceny (of more than $75,000), or second degree murder. 5-10 years in prison, fines up to $150,000.
February 26, 201214 yr Just to be clear, by "reasonable risk" and "technically" and "a no-no" we are talking about 5 years in jail. I don't think you'll be caught. I hope a cop doesn't arrest you if you are caught. If you do end up in court, I think the risk is very real and the odds not in your favor.
February 26, 201214 yr Author Well , as remote the possibility , I can't risk 5 years in jail. So I won't be lunching or visiting . Or , I'll just bring the long guns. Ridiculous. Thanks for all the advice guys
February 26, 201214 yr I didnt read through all the responses, but personally.... You need to make sure you kid is properly being supervised, and people got to eat! Stopping for food is reasonable, even if its at your dad's house. IMO, all of this is far too left open to interpretation. A reasonable deviation at the very least would cover this so long as you are able to keep on track with the reasonable side. As in, making sure you kid is properly being watched, and you are able to eat. Having a meal is very important, and as long as you don't deviate too far from point a and b you should be fine. God forbid you pass out driving on the way home from low blood sugar!
February 26, 201214 yr I didnt read through all the responses, but personally.... You need to make sure you kid is properly being supervised, and people got to eat! Hope springs eternal in the concentration camp. So does bargaining with reality when there is no hope. She doesn't have to go to the range in the first place, so she doesn't need to make sure her child is properly supervised. There is no right to bear arms in NJ. All possession of firearms is illegal by default. Based on the BS I've seen coming from black-robed criminals in NJ over the course of decades, I would expect most rulings on "necessary" to mean you were under way and something happened that you had no choice but to deal with. Not "this makes it easier for me to make a decision to go to the range." They don't give a crap if you can get to the range or not. Firearms possession is illegal. It is nice to see the LEO on here doing the best they can to use the grey area to the benefit of an otherwise law abiding subject. Don't expect all cops to do that, and don't expect any judges to do that.
February 26, 201214 yr Author How exactly does the law read? I can't find it here , internet search just yeilds the words on transporting into , through nj .
February 27, 201214 yr The law makers need to fix the transportation laws regarding handguns before CCW can ever exist in this state. How would one CCW, only directly to and from an exempted location like a range? Frickin' rediculous laws.
February 27, 201214 yr How exactly does the law read? I can't find it here , internet search just yeilds the words on transporting into , through nj . 2C:39-6
February 27, 201214 yr Thanks Dan I mean , the way I read it ( and I know it only matters in the end how a Judge reads it) you are allowed "reasonable" deviations . Dropping a kid at a sitter for an hour is reasonable IMO. Going to the Pilot House for clam shooters isn't . Of course I do not "have" to go to the range. But neither does anyone. I would hope the fact that I need a sitter to go for an hour would not land me in jail and leave 3 kids without their mother. I'm hoping that some other law breaking on my part would have to happen ( like DUI , reckless driving , having the baby on my while rolling down the road..none of which will happen) , and then that "unreasonable" deviation would be a tack on charge. Yeah , it's a big assumption , but I would be shocked to find myself in a heap of trouble just because I dropped and picked up from a baby sitter on my way to a range. It isn't like when someone who does not know the NJ law( usually from out of state) gets caught with a concealed at a circus or something. The Brick officers are a good bunch in my experience. My course of "deviation" would only be through Brick since I will get on and off the parkway in Brick . Once I am on the Parkway I am not "off course" from the Range. I just don't see a Brick officer doing me in for something like this. The only way it would be questioned would be God forbid I have a wreck on the Parkway and a State Officer asks " what did you do with the baby when you were at the range ? " Then I would answer " he does my reloads for me while I shoot" lol Sigh.......
February 27, 201214 yr A perfectly legal way around the whole "necessary deviation" would be to have your dad meet you at the range and take his grandchild home with him. Since he is close that shouldn't be too big of a deal. Going home have him bring child back to the range and then both head home. At a later time set up quality time with your family. Like a nice family dinner with your parents. It's stupid that a nice simple lunch with your dad can be so difficult, but like you said your kids might miss you if you're away for 5-10 yrs
February 27, 201214 yr Thanks Dan I mean , the way I read it ( and I know it only matters in the end how a Judge reads it) you are allowed "reasonable" deviations . You hit the nail on the head. It is up to the judge if he/she will let your defense use the "reasonably necessary deviations" wording in the statutes, and if they do, which side can convince the jury that your deviation was "reasonably necessary". Imagine a jury made up of apathetic non-gun owners trying to understand our gun laws... scary. Unfortunately we all take the chance when transporting HG's to and from the range. LE is well within their power according to the statutes to arrest and charge. You could tell the cop till you are blue in the face that you are going to the range with your HG, with your range equipment, etc etc, but they don't have to believe you. Will that happen? Nobody could say, and the good news is we don't see a slew of these types of experiences on the forums, hopefully because LE 99% of the time has a cool head and can tell when someone is really going to or from a range, and not out to cause trouble. Whenever you travel with your HG in NJ, either under NJ statutes or FOPA, the steps you take during that travel are essentially preparing for your defense against an unlawful possession charge. This is how the statutes are set up in black and white. That is the nature our gun laws concerning HG's where they are "illegal" except under certain circumstances (exemptions). Either the LEO feels/determines that you are within the exemptions, or they just make the arrest under 2C:39-5 and let the system sort you out. They have that much power under these circumstances (pulled over and they have knowledge that you have a HG in the car).
February 27, 201214 yr Author A perfectly legal way around the whole "necessary deviation" would be to have your dad meet you at the range and take his grandchild home with him. Since he is close that shouldn't be too big of a deal. Going home have him bring child back to the range and then both head home. At a later time set up quality time with your family. Like a nice family dinner with your parents. It's stupid that a nice simple lunch with your dad can be so difficult, but like you said your kids might miss you if you're away for 5-10 yrs It is sad , isn't it? So , he could drive his car , meet me at the range , we swap cars with the baby in his seat , then he comes back with the baby. That would keep it legal . That is a good idea . It would be a lot on my dad though. But sometimes I wonder if catering to the circumstances that way only fuels the ridiculous law. I ALMOST would rather fight in court for my right to drop off my kid at his Grandpa's so I can go to the range. KWIM? You hit the nail on the head. It is up to the judge if he/she will let your defense use the "reasonably necessary deviations" wording in the statutes, and if they do, which side can convince the jury that your deviation was "reasonably necessary". Imagine a jury made up of apathetic non-gun owners trying to understand our gun laws... scary. Unfortunately we all take the chance when transporting HG's to and from the range. LE is well within their power according to the statutes to arrest and charge. You could tell the cop till you are blue in the face that you are going to the range with your HG, with your range equipment, etc etc, but they don't have to believe you. Will that happen? Nobody could say, and the good news is we don't see a slew of these types of experiences on the forums, hopefully because LE 99% of the time has a cool head and can tell when someone is really going to or from a range, and not out to cause trouble. Whenever you travel with your HG in NJ, either under NJ statutes or FOPA, the steps you take during that travel are essentially preparing for your defense against an unlawful possession charge. This is how the statutes are set up in black and white. That is the nature our gun laws concerning HG's where they are "illegal" except under certain circumstances (exemptions). Either the LEO feels/determines that you are within the exemptions, or they just make the arrest under 2C:39-5 and let the system sort you out. They have that much power under these circumstances (pulled over and they have knowledge that you have a HG in the car). well put. In the real world they will not know I have guns in the car unless there is a fender bender bad enough to cause the storage compartment to be exposed. The long guns and knapsack each have a totally out of plain view storage area in the back of my SUV where they can be stored. So I would either have to break the law and be subject to search. Or have an accident. No way I'm mentioning it or the range otherwise. Where are you going?? To my dad's in Brick. Home from my dad's in Brick. And that would not be a fabrication. So it would only come up if A) we have an accident B) There is a Silver or Amber Alert on a vehicle just like mine and I can't convince them that I do not have cognitive impairment or that the baby is mine.
February 27, 201214 yr The ideal solution would be if one of the ranges would let you store your guns there for a little while. I know that RTSP provides this service, so it's possible that those other ranges might as well. Otherwise, if it were me, I would probably take the chance on it. Does anyone know if anyone has ever been prosecuted for stopping off for lunch on the way back from the range? Gosh, Irish Pete is a lucky guy to have a wife asking questions like this!
February 27, 201214 yr Author Hey , Old Glock guy , it was nice meeting you the other day! I was wondering the same thing. Has anyone ever been caught and prosecuted JUST for stopping for a burger on a long ride , or for picking up a friend on the way or something? That is what I meant when I said I envisioned it being more of a tack on charge. As in " no you can't bring your bag with your gun in it into an IHOP , and by the way you are suppose to go RIGHT home from the range."
February 27, 201214 yr The long guns and knapsack each have a totally out of plain view storage area in the back of my SUV where they can be stored. So I would either have to break the law and be subject to search. Not necessarily. The cop could search you and make up some BS reason. It would probably float in court. It probably also doesn't happen often unless the cop suspects you of something or he doesn't like you. Or have an accident. No way I'm mentioning it or the range otherwise. Where are you going?? To my dad's in Brick. Home from my dad's in Brick. And that would not be a fabrication. Not a fabrication, certainly a lie in my opinion, but that doesn't bother me in this case. I think that's a pretty good strategy if we look at the odds of having a problem based on which response you choose. Your response would be a reasonable choice. But it is not without peril. You have just waved your defense to possession of a handgun by saying you are headed to your dad's house. That is illegal. In the unlikely even your handgun is discovered, you're going to jail. Why might that happen? Well, the cop may decide he wants to search your car. Or, your accident may occur after you see the cop rather than before. I think both are extremely unlikely, but they are not out of the realm of possibility. If one of them does occur, your possession defense is gone. I am defintely not a lawyer.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.