Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Police Captain said I can't Get an FID because of my Misdemeanor (Not Domestic Violence)

Featured Replies

Hi, I'm new to these forums and I just went to put in my FID application today at the local PD (very small town). The clerk asked me to speak with the Captain and he said that due to my Public Intoxication arrest in Florida, I would be denied an FID/P2P. From my understanding, a misdemeanor should not prevent me from getting an FID unless it were for a Domestic Violence Case. I was arrested and stayed in the jail for about 12 hours. I had an attorney handle the case and it was dropped, but I believe it's still on my record.

 

He told me I could still put in the application, and I did, but he told me it would be denied. I asked him if the decision is made at my local PD or at the state level, and he responded at the local. I wouldn't be worried if it were at the state level, but if it's local and he had already told me that I would be denied, I feel I have reason to be worried now.

 

I plan on getting my record expunged, but I don't live in FL so I can't go to court to handle it. I also don't have the $1000+ to have an attorney take care of it for me.

 

Should I just forget about trying to get an FID, or should I get the $60 fingerprints and hope for the best? Am I wrong in believing that my misdemeanor should not prevent me from acquiring my FID? Also, if anyone can direct me towards the exact statute that would apply to my case, I would appreciate it.

 

Thanks.

  • Replies 86
  • Views 14.9k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

You should proceed with the process, and allow him to deny the application, since otherwise you will have no basis to challenge a suggested denial in court without having standing in the matter. You will then have the opportunity to challenge the denial in your county court. You have 30 days to appeal the denial, and the county has 30 days to reply and set up a court date. Sounds like it's something the court will overturn, but you never know in this gestapo state. Include a copy of this part of the statute with a letter from your physician with the application.

 

13:54-1.12 Appeal

 

(a) Any person denied a firearms purchaser identification card or a permit to purchase a handgun may request a hearing

 

in the Superior Court of the county in which he or she resides or in the Superior Court of the county in which his or her

 

application for a firearms purchaser identification card was denied if he or she is a nonresident.

 

(b) Any person denied a firearm purchaser identification card or a permit to purchase a handgun shall be notified in

 

writing by the issuing authority of the reasons for the denial.

 

© The request for a hearing shall be made in writing within 30 days of the denial, and such request shall also be served

 

upon the chief of police or the Superintendent.

13:54-1.6 Exception for physical disability, mental disorder or alcoholism

A permit or identification card may be issued to a person who had previously suffered from a physical defect or disease,

 

or mental disorder, or was an alcoholic if the applicant provides a certificate of a medical doctor or psychiatrist licensed

 

in New Jersey, or other satisfactory proof that he or she is no longer suffering from that particular disability in such a

 

manner that it would interfere with or handicap him or her in the handling of firearms.

I am not a lawyer, but if you were never charged with anything, I don't see how it could still be on your record. Something is not right, and those somethings can come back and haunt people.

 

IMHO, If you can't afford $1,000 for an Attorney, you can't afford a $600 gun and all of the stuff that goes with it either. Find the money. Get the record expunged. Who knows when stuff like this could turn up again. Then resubmit.

  • Author

You should proceed with the process, and allow him to deny the application, since otherwise you will have no basis to challenge a suggested denial in court without having standing in the matter. You will then have the opportunity to challenge the denial in your county court. You have 30 days to appeal the denial, and the county has 30 days to reply and set up a court date. Sounds like it's something the court will overturn, but you never know in this gestapo state. Include a copy of this part of the statute with a letter from your physician with the application.

.

 

Thanks for the info. But I wouldn't have money to hire an attorney for the appeal, and if I did, I'd rather have my record expunged so I wouldn't have any of these problems.

 

Since it seems like I would be denied anyway, I think I'm just gonna hold off on the whole process for a few years till I have this sucker expunged.

  • Author

I am not a lawyer, but if you were never charged with anything, I don't see how it could still be on your record. Something is not right, and those somethings can come back and haunt people.

 

IMHO, If you can't afford $1,000 for an Attorney, you can't afford a $600 gun and all of the stuff that goes with it either. Find the money. Get the record expunged. Who knows when stuff like this could turn up again. Then resubmit.

 

I hear what you're saying, and I agree, the expungement is far more important than a gun, but I wouldn't be purchasing an expensive firearm. Probably $300 ish plus a case and ammo.

 

Either way, I don't think there's anything fishy going on in terms of the it being on my record. I was arrested, and though the case was dropped (nolle Prosequi), it still stays on my record until I have it expunged. I wish it happened in NJ so I could take care of it, but I have to hire an attorney to handle it. On top of that it takes about 6 months.

Personally, I would go with what Drew suggested... and TJ is probably right ;-)

you HAVE to use a lawyer to appeal a denied FID? I dont think that is the case...

Hi, I'm new to these forums and I just went to put in my FID application today at the local PD (very small town). The clerk asked me to speak with the Captain and he said that due to my Public Intoxication arrest in Florida, I would be denied an FID/P2P. From my understanding, a misdemeanor should not prevent me from getting an FID unless it were for a Domestic Violence Case. I was arrested and stayed in the jail for about 12 hours. I had an attorney handle the case and it was dropped, but I believe it's still on my record.

 

He told me I could still put in the application, and I did, but he told me it would be denied. I asked him if the decision is made at my local PD or at the state level, and he responded at the local. I wouldn't be worried if it were at the state level, but if it's local and he had already told me that I would be denied, I feel I have reason to be worried now.

 

I plan on getting my record expunged, but I don't live in FL so I can't go to court to handle it. I also don't have the $1000+ to have an attorney take care of it for me.

 

Should I just forget about trying to get an FID, or should I get the $60 fingerprints and hope for the best? Am I wrong in believing that my misdemeanor should not prevent me from acquiring my FID? Also, if anyone can direct me towards the exact statute that would apply to my case, I would appreciate it.

 

Thanks.

 

Did you live in Florida?

Welcome to the forums, sorry to hear of your situation

You can certainly represent yourself during an appeal, if you were comfortable doing so.

I would make an appointment to speak with the CLEO and have another discussion first though.

A Non-Violent misdemeanor conviction should not be grounds for a denial, but this is NJ, so your CLEO can do pretty much whatever he wants.

I figure the questions on the application that it seems he'll try and deny you on are these:

(19) Have you ever been convicted of a disorderly persons offense in New Jersey or any criminal offense in another jurisdiction where you could have been

sentenced up to six months in jail that has not been expunged or sealed? If yes, list date(s), place(s) and offense(s)

AND

(20) Have you ever been convicted of a crime in New Jersey or a criminal offense in another jurisdiction where you could have been sentenced to more than

six months in jail that has not been expunged or sealed? If yes, list date(s), place(s) and crime(s)

 

Do some verification, and point this out, this shouldn't be grounds for denial

.Violation of FSA 856.011 is a misdemeanor of the second degree punishable for a term not exceeding 60 days (FSA 775.082(4)(b)) and a fine of up to $500 (FSA 775.083(1)(e)) plus a court fee of $20.

 

AND This:

(23) Are you an alcoholic?

 

if you can get documentation from a healthcare professional that you are not an alcoholic, and therefore not a prohibited person, this also, is not grounds for denial.

 

Keep in mind that alot of the bullying and foot dragging by Nj LEO is bolstered by people just rolling over and taking it!

If the Chief sees you're willing to appeal his decision, and you know your facts, he may decide not to screw with you.

Good luck, I know its intimidating to walk into the police department and stand up for yourself, but its worth it!

I, too, have a misdemeanor conviction on my record for a stupid thing I did when I was young. I listed it on my application, spoke to the detective, and was granted my FID and 6 psp's.

 

Your arrest should not be a problem. Lots of people get arrested and nothing comes of it.

 

Were you convicted?

Oh, and in NJ, a misdemeanor offense is referred to as a disorderly persons offense. A felony is referred to as a crime.

Email or call Evan Nappen. He can advise you on how to handle this. You may not want to wait until you are denied because if things don't go smoothly you could end up having to put the denial on every fuTure application. Evan may be able to send a letter to the captain for a few hundred bucks reminding the captain of the law. This might be faster and less expensive then appealing. Just food for thought.

Thanks for the info. But I wouldn't have money to hire an attorney for the appeal, and if I did, I'd rather have my record expunged so I wouldn't have any of these problems.

 

Since it seems like I would be denied anyway, I think I'm just gonna hold off on the whole process for a few years till I have this sucker expunged.

 

Others have suggested you contact Evan Nappen. You really don't need an attorney to appeal. If you include the statute, and a letter from your physician certifiying your not being an alcoholic, it will immediately "raise the flag" to the chief that you are aware that you can appeal if he denies your FID. Based on that, he may well issue it rather than to have to deal with having his bad decision overturned by the court.

Look into the expungement yourself. I can't speak for Florida, but you don't need a lawyer to expunge your record in NJ. It is tedious and a bit irritating, but if you can read and follow instructions exacty as they are written you can do this yourself. Expect it to take a while, but you will get there eventually. It is a worthwhile endeavor whether you are getting a gun or not.

I think the Captain is bluffing. Certainly go through with it. If he denies it appeal

You don't need to expunge your record to help you get an FID what you have is not in any way a disqualifier. There are many people who have much worse charges than you on their record and have still been approved.

the Captain is probably a habitual drunk and he gets to carry a gun

 

I might get in trouble for saying this, but that was the case in Bayonne a few years back.

You do not need an lawyer for expungement or to appeal a FID denial.

 

The captain can deny the application at his discretion for the best interests of the community.

 

Expunging the record is a good thing but once the captain knows about your record expunging it doesn't matter that much. If you appeal the denial the record is expunged, it's not expunged to the judge and the judge can use it at his discretion to deny your appeal. In other words, expungment is not a magic bullet to make past sins go away. Your sins are not grounds for denial and the judge will most likely grant your appeal. Remember, NJ is a shall issue state for FID meaning that the burden of proof is on the state to prove why you should be denied. They will dig up all the dirt on you they can find.

  • Author

Thanks for all the info, help, and suggestions

 

You do not need an lawyer for expungement or to appeal a FID denial.

The reason I need one is because I would have to appear in court (I believe) and I would have to fly down. An attorney would be able to handle it for me

Welcome to the forums, sorry to hear of your situation

You can certainly represent yourself during an appeal, if you were comfortable doing so.

I would make an appointment to speak with the CLEO and have another discussion first though.

A Non-Violent misdemeanor conviction should not be grounds for a denial, but this is NJ, so your CLEO can do pretty much whatever he wants.

I figure the questions on the application that it seems he'll try and deny you on are these:

(19) Have you ever been convicted of a disorderly persons offense in New Jersey or any criminal offense in another jurisdiction where you could have been

sentenced up to six months in jail that has not been expunged or sealed? If yes, list date(s), place(s) and offense(s)

AND

(20) Have you ever been convicted of a crime in New Jersey or a criminal offense in another jurisdiction where you could have been sentenced to more than

six months in jail that has not been expunged or sealed? If yes, list date(s), place(s) and crime(s)

 

Do some verification, and point this out, this shouldn't be grounds for denial

.Violation of FSA 856.011 is a misdemeanor of the second degree punishable for a term not exceeding 60 days (FSA 775.082(4)(b)) and a fine of up to $500 (FSA 775.083(1)(e)) plus a court fee of $20.

 

AND This:

(23) Are you an alcoholic?

 

if you can get documentation from a healthcare professional that you are not an alcoholic, and therefore not a prohibited person, this also, is not grounds for denial.

 

Keep in mind that alot of the bullying and foot dragging by Nj LEO is bolstered by people just rolling over and taking it!

If the Chief sees you're willing to appeal his decision, and you know your facts, he may decide not to screw with you.

Good luck, I know its intimidating to walk into the police department and stand up for yourself, but its worth it!

 

Thanks for the info. But how would a Dr. prove i'm not an alchy?

 

I, too, have a misdemeanor conviction on my record for a stupid thing I did when I was young. I listed it on my application, spoke to the detective, and was granted my FID and 6 psp's.

 

Your arrest should not be a problem. Lots of people get arrested and nothing comes of it.

 

Were you convicted?

 

I wasn't convicted. The charges were dropped.

 

Look into the expungement yourself. I can't speak for Florida, but you don't need a lawyer to expunge your record in NJ. It is tedious and a bit irritating, but if you can read and follow instructions exacty as they are written you can do this yourself. Expect it to take a while, but you will get there eventually. It is a worthwhile endeavor whether you are getting a gun or not.

 

I definitely want to get it expunged, but I don't think it's possible to do it without actually appearing in court, which would require me to fly down.

 

You do not need an lawyer for expungement or to appeal a FID denial.

 

The captain can deny the application at his discretion for the best interests of the community.

 

Expunging the record is a good thing but once the captain knows about your record expunging it doesn't matter that much. If you appeal the denial the record is expunged, it's not expunged to the judge and the judge can use it at his discretion to deny your appeal. In other words, expungment is not a magic bullet to make past sins go away. Your sins are not grounds for denial and the judge will most likely grant your appeal. Remember, NJ is a shall issue state for FID meaning that the burden of proof is on the state to prove why you should be denied. They will dig up all the dirt on you they can find.

 

 

The captain can deny the application at his discretion for the best interests of the community.

 

Expunging the record is a good thing but once the captain knows about your record expunging it doesn't matter that much. If you appeal the denial the record is expunged, it's not expunged to the judge and the judge can use it at his discretion to deny your appeal. In other words, expungment is not a magic bullet to make past sins go away. Your sins are not grounds for denial and the judge will most likely grant your appeal. Remember, NJ is a shall issue state for FID meaning that the burden of proof is on the state to prove why you should be denied. They will dig up all the dirt on you they can find.

 

I may not NEED to have an attorney to appeal, but I would much rather have one.

 

What do you guys think about just mailing him the statue and explaining that technically my misdemeanor is not grounds for denial. HE told me to expunge it so I don't have a problem, so I would HOPE that he wouldn't hold it against me once I had it done. But it seemed to me like he didn't know that a misdemeanor does not automatically mean you are rejected. Now if it's brought to his attention, I feel he may take it nicely, or (more likely) take it as an insult that I'm telling him that I know the law better than him and deny me out of spite. I wouldn't mind meeting with him in person and showing him the law either.

 

If not I think I'm just gonna have to let it go for now. Once I get a decent job and have the money, I"ll have my record expunged and then reapply I guess.

 

Is it bad to get rejected a first time? Also, I already submitted the application, but did not get my fingerprints done yet. If i Don't submit my prints, then when I apply next time, do I have to say I already applied once before?

Change your drivers license and tags to pa buy a gun your good to go; I have a misdemeanor on my record from Alabama (attempting to elude the police) I got a gun. But then again I bought my gun in Virginia. But that shouldn't be the case.

Change your drivers license and tags to pa buy a gun your good to go; I have a misdemeanor on my record from Alabama (attempting to elude the police) I got a gun. But then again I bought my gun in Virginia. But that shouldn't be the case.

worst advise ever, follow the rules don't take advise from a troll

 

I, too, have a misdemeanor conviction on my record for a stupid thing I did when I was young. I listed it on my application, spoke to the detective, and was granted my FID and 6 psp's

 

 

No one gets issued 6 Permits. And if so, you wasted $6

 

The reason I need one is because I would have to appear in court (I believe) and I would have to fly down. An attorney would be able to handle it for me

...

I wasn't convicted. The charges were dropped.

...

I definitely want to get it expunged, but I don't think it's possible to do it without actually appearing in court, which would require me to fly down.

...

I may not NEED to have an attorney to appeal, but I would much rather have one.

 

What do you guys think about just mailing him the statue and explaining that technically my misdemeanor is not grounds for denial. HE told me to expunge it so I don't have a problem, so I would HOPE that he wouldn't hold it against me once I had it done. But it seemed to me like he didn't know that a misdemeanor does not automatically mean you are rejected. Now if it's brought to his attention, I feel he may take it nicely, or (more likely) take it as an insult that I'm telling him that I know the law better than him and deny me out of spite. I wouldn't mind meeting with him in person and showing him the law either.

 

If not I think I'm just gonna have to let it go for now. Once I get a decent job and have the money, I"ll have my record expunged and then reapply I guess.

...

 

If you don't have a conviction, there is no criminal record to be expunged. An expungement seals a previous criminal conviction. The conviction would not be generally available, but it may still be viewable to those that matter in this case, such as police. You really have nothing to expunge in this case.

 

Regardless, this record should not disqualify you for the FPID and you have every right to apply for it.

No one gets issued 6 Permits. And if so, you wasted $6

 

REALLY??? And why do you feel that what many of have done doesn't happen?? Please explain...

No one gets issued 6 Permits. And if so, you wasted $6

 

Wrong, happens all the time, every day. You can use 4 permits in the allotted 90-days without an extension, and almost all PD's will give an extension for another 90-days.

A. You don't need to appear in court in NJ. You probably don't need to appear in FL either, especially if you were never convicted and it was a minor charge.

 

B. It's not up to you to prove you're not an alcoholic. It's up to the state to prove you are. Drunk on Spring Break in Florida is a lot different than 3 DUI convictions.

 

C. Since you've applied, you've applied. You can call up and cancel it. The chief could deny you before fingerprinting. The other option is that it just sits in limbo waiting for your fingerprints. My recommendation is to either cancel the application before you get denied or go through with the fingerprints and reference letters.

 

D. When I appealed my denial, the judge told me that a lot of towns just don't want to be the decision maker if there is any mark against you. So, they deny and let a judge make the decision.

worst advise ever, follow the rules don't take advise from a troll

 

umadbro? truth hurt? I have a misdemeanor in al on my driving record I moved to va in the navy got guns multiple guns. Now I reside in this crap state uh oh still with guns. nothing wrong with changing states nuff said go be a cool troll somewhere else heaterboob lol

No one gets issued 6 Permits. And if so, you wasted $6

Nonsense....and before OGAm I'd gotten as many as 12 at once

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.