Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Police Captain said I can't Get an FID because of my Misdemeanor (Not Domestic Violence)

Featured Replies

  • Author

I'm still waiting on the letter from Miami. Been almost 2 weeks and I'm getting impatient.

 

Good luck. I would also follow up by phone just in case.

 

Thanks.

 

So you openly and voluntarily told your local PD of an out of state arrest you had without a conviction? LOL sorry dude

 

Yea, it was an accident like I said. I didn't realize that it said conviction.

 

As was already pointed out, being charged is NOT the same as being convicted. If the charges where dropped you don't have anything to worry about. An arrest record isn't the same as a conviction.

 

Yea, I realized that later. I'm not too worried because I'm very confident that even if I was denied, then during my appeal the judge would grant me the permit.

 

May I ask what town you are in?

 

I sent you a PM

  • 5 months later...
  • Replies 86
  • Views 15k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • Author

So after taking months to receive the proper documentation, I handed it in a few months ago. The clerk seemed to have misplaced, not a big deal, but lost a few months. I went back today and gave her a new copy. The Sergeant said everything appears to be in order, but the Captain insists I get it expunged.

 

He said to go apply at the state level. I was wondering:

 

Should I apply in Trenton, or should I have him deny me the FID and then appeal? I'd like to avoid having on record that I was denied if in any way possible.

The appeal should over turn the denial, unless you didn't appeal and applied again. AND an appeal isnt any promise it will be over turned. I think it's ridiculous that the captian wants an expungment, it just changes whats on paper, it doesn't change what happened in the past, it doesnt change who you are.... it is simply stupid at this point if he plans on granting it after the expungment knowing full well the history of the situation. You should get it expunged either way, and then apply, it will be an all around better situation if you hit any more snags.

  • Author

The appeal should over turn the denial, unless you didn't appeal and applied again. AND an appeal isnt any promise it will be over turned. I think it's ridiculous that the captian wants an expungment, it just changes whats on paper, it doesn't change what happened in the past, it doesnt change who you are.... it is simply stupid at this point if he plans on granting it after the expungment knowing full well the history of the situation. You should get it expunged either way, and then apply, it will be an all around better situation if you hit any more snags.

 

Do you have any idea where the appeal would take place? if it were to happen within my city, then I'm pretty certain the captain would easily persuade the judge to not rule in my favor since it's such a small town.

 

Also, I know expungement is better, but I don't feel like spending the money on getting it expunged. I don't see how the arrest would interfere with much more in my life than this situation, and I read somewhere that it's removed from records or something after 5 years. I would have to research that a little bit more, but it's already been 3 years so I might as well wait.

 

And if it went to the appeal court, what reason could the judge have to not give it to me? I understand the city has leeway in making a decision, but I thought that state would basically give it to me as long as I didn't break any of those rules.

but the Captain insists I get it expunged.

 

"I declareth thou shalt expunge thy arrest record, peon!"

 

I wonder if it were his son or buddy's son applying if he would insist on expungement... :mad:

Do you have any idea where the appeal would take place? if it were to happen within my city, then I'm pretty certain the captain would easily persuade the judge to not rule in my favor since it's such a small town.

 

Also, I know expungement is better, but I don't feel like spending the money on getting it expunged. I don't see how the arrest would interfere with much more in my life than this situation, and I read somewhere that it's removed from records or something after 5 years. I would have to research that a little bit more, but it's already been 3 years so I might as well wait.

 

And if it went to the appeal court, what reason could the judge have to not give it to me? I understand the city has leeway in making a decision, but I thought that state would basically give it to me as long as I didn't break any of those rules.

 

A judge can deny based on moral character, your basically leaving yourself to his discretion, so its a toss up. you would probably win in appeals court but you would need(want) a lawyer$$. I believe the appeals go to county court, can someone verify?

Appeals go to Superior Court.

 

And you do not need a lawyer. You can go Pro Se. However, the adage that a man who represents himself has a fool for a client may apply here...

A little late to this game but you were arrested for public intox? When I was in college I got two tickets one for public intox one for open container at a party. I never had anything expunged and I received my p2p and fid no problem. I don't really think you can be denied for that. People make mistakes and I don't think one thing proves you're an alcoholic or anything. If you had a history and multiple run ins with the law for drinking I can see it but not one.

The form doesn't ask if you were arrested, it asks if you have been convicted! So the answer to every question is no. The arrest is totally irrelevant. If you join ANJRPC which is like 30 bucks you can get free advice from Evan Nappen on the phone not crappy advice here. There are no questions on the form asking about an arrest, the form only asks about conviction. There is a presumption of innocence in the USA. If the Florida charges were dropped then you are totally cleared of that.

 

Sent from my DROID2 GLOBAL using Tapatalk 2

When I talk to young people I try to make them understand that what they do can often affect their adult life. Your case is a good example of the negative consequences of doing things that do not seem like a big deal when we are young and just want to have fun. We all do things when young but most of us are lucky enough not to get caught.

  • 1 month later...

Hello guys, I may be the newest person with a denied FID application in Freehold "By statute 2C:58_3d." I was arrested as a minor for standing up to a drunk guy that was picking on kids. he swung and i swung back and police was called etc etc. Because he knew and police knew he was drunk, he never showed up to court so the Judge dropped the case. Apparently not everyone got the memo. the second thing was an actual lapse in judgement in my part that was changed to a misdemeanor if i agreed to restitution and fines. I am a servicemember (Infantry) with 16 years thus far with zero history of violence. Today i got a letter from the chief of police with the denial and things get better. my employer closed down my job for 2-3 months which puts me jobless until they re-open (hopefully in 2 weeks) so i got 30 days to appeal... I have considered writing a letter to the Chief of Police to ask him to reconsider and that one charge was as a minor AND supposedly dropped. Thoughts?

 

 

 

BTW, I think i met NJDREW1 at the range in Jackson once.

  • 3 months later...

well, I got Denied for my ID, i appealed and they changed my court date twice.  then i get a call from prosecutor telling me to call a detective handling gun permits and that my FID should be in the mail shortly.  now its a waiting game to see how shortly, shortly is.  

BTW, I think i met NJDREW1 at the range in Jackson once.

 

I'm there often enough!  I'm sure you did.  Glad to hear the issue is finally about to be cleared up.  Now...no more beating up drunks. Are you back to work?

I returned to work in march and the drunk was over 6" and was still a minor, i was also a minor.  that was like 15 years ago.  I am doing well and just about back on track. few questions popped up meanwhile.  I have a coworker whose father in law left them a few guns when he passed. one of which i am interested on (Argentine Mauser Modelo 1909 with a 30.06 barrel) but neither he nor his wife are into guns.  How would i be able to legally buy that from him?  Also looking into an XD-M .40 in the near future, but encountered an issue with having one of its magazines hold 16 rounds which makes it illegal.  (kinda like making Ferraris Illegal because they can go faster than 65mph.  idiotic if you ask me.)  Is it even possible to order one with the smaller capacity or even have Springfield pin the mag down to 15?  Just curious.

I had to go through the appeal process. I had a lawyer file it but I represented myself in court. The township didn't have age to stand on but still fought me tooth and nail. I won't though. The judge even yelled at the chief of police and their lawyer for giving me a hard time

Once you have your FID and a matching DL you can obtain the firearms from your co worker by filling out 2 copies of the NJ C.O.E http://www.njsp.org/info/pdf/firearms/sp-634.pdf 1 copy you keep and 1 copy they keep.

Thank you.   do we turn those in and to who? or do we keep for our records?

you both keep one copy. no turning in anything to anyone, as registration is not required.

If you don't have a conviction, there is no criminal record to be expunged. An expungement seals a previous criminal conviction. The conviction would not be generally available, but it may still be viewable to those that matter in this case, such as police. You really have nothing to expunge in this case.

 

Regardless, this record should not disqualify you for the FPID and you have every right to apply for it.

This is correct. No conviction... No record for you to report to the local PD! Who told you that you had to inform them of this arrest?

Technically you can expunge an arrest record too. You can even expunge an investigation file on you that did not even lead to an arrest. The expunged records go to a special warehouse where they are only looked at for certain reasons like applying for a law license or sentencing after a subsequent conviction, but otherwise are not obtainable and deemed to legally not exist. This is something you can do without a lawyer if you can get to the courthouse during the day and do all the paperwork.

 

 

 

Sent from my DROID2 GLOBAL using Tapatalk 2

 

 

I had to go through the appeal process. I had a lawyer file it but I represented myself in court. The township didn't have age to stand on but still fought me tooth and nail. I won't though. The judge even yelled at the chief of police and their lawyer for giving me a hard time

 

Are you using some voice to text software or something??

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.