Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Woman dies from gunshot wound caused by a hug.

Featured Replies

Someone has got to explain this to me.

"A woman in Detroit has died from a gunshot wound to the chest after hugging a friend, who was a off duty officer,from behind."

"The officer had a gun in a holster made from a soft fabric on his waist which would allow the trigger to be activated".

I don't see how unless she was very short and his holster has an extreme forward tilt.

seems very fishy, dont understand how a holstered weapon with the proper holster (trigger fully covered, muzzle pointed downward) can go off and hit someone in the chest.

Here's what I figure is at least plausible. Horizontal shoulder holster with a retention snap through the trigger guard. When you pull the gun, you pull it through the retention snap. Conversely, if the gun is pushed deeper into the holster, as it might be if she came up from behind him and hugged him (as reported), the trigger would push against the snap and the gun may discharge into the hugger's thorax.

 

Sounds like the "perfect storm" of ND's, but I can't figure any other way given the sketchy facts reported.

 

Adios,

 

Pizza Bob

  • Author

The only other relevant line in the article is "There was some manipulation along the officers waistline that he did not control". Which I take to mean that she somehow fumbled with the gun and shot her self?

Thats really sad, especially if it was just a freak accident due to his rig, a friend comes up to hug you and dies by you're own weapon. I would have a real hard time living with that and also would lose confidence in carrying going forward.

 

Then again I would never use any sort of holster that put any straps or buckles through the trigger guard potentially setting off gun.

I read that it was a waist holster. Only thing I can think of is a small of the back with the gun sideways?

Nylon crap holsters. Pay $600 bucks for a gun but $60 for a holster is "too much". :facepalm: By the way, before all the glock hate, it was an M&P...

 

Reminds me of those guys riding bmw motorcycles with the cheapest helmet they could find. To paraphrase the UNCF "A mind is a terrible thing to waste"...

She must have been horsing around with him or something. Has to be more to it.

Or maybe they were not standing up..know what I'm saying...

 

Where is the original article?

I was thinking along the lines of Pizza Bob. Shoulder rig, horizontal muzzle (hate those things). Then reading it was a belt mounted holster I'm thinking WTF? Grabbing from behind a ND should go down. Was he bending over at the waist? Was she tossing his salad...I got no clue.

 

What irked me was the statement by her parents. Which I fully sympathize with them, but thier statement was goofy. "He is off duty why is he carrying it at a party?" Hello, you're in Detroit.

Others have covered this already, what with a shoulder holster and all (Thanks Bob--I read this and thought the same exact thing). But a ND in a waistband holster is odd as described. Only thing I can think of is the hug from behind was interpreted by the Cop as an attempt at getting his gun, so HE went for it and it discharged as he was trying to pull it / secure it to/from it's holster???

 

Not enough info about this yet to really KNOW what happened!

 

Dave

By the way, before all the glock hate, it was an

 

You're right. If it was a Glock, it would have Ka-Boomed, blowing them both up. :p

 

Not enough info about this yet to really KNOW what happened!

 

 

This x10000000000

 

Original articles below -

 

The Detroit Free Press’s article (the second article) states an inside the waistband holster was involved.

 

Sounds like the officer was in his own home, dancing with his wife at a party he was throwing. By the article, the victim and the cop did not know each other. She arrived to the party as a "friend of a friend" type deal. My guess is she was "dirty dancing" with him, possibly on her knees and grabbed his belt. I don't see in either article where it states make of pistol only caliber .40 Smith & Wesson.

 

 

http://abcnews.go.com/US/wireS...-kills-woman-1673747

Police: Hug Triggers Officer's Gun, Kills Woman

 

DETROIT July 9, 2012 (AP)

 

A woman celebrating the weekend before her 25th birthday was fatally shot Sunday when she hugged an off-duty police officer while dancing at a party, causing the officer's service weapon to fire, according to police and her mother.

 

Adaisha Miller would have turned 25 on Monday, according to her mother, Yolanda McNair.

 

The shooting happened at an outdoor social gathering about 12:30 a.m., said police Sgt. Eren Stephens. It happened on the city's west side.

 

According to Stephens, the woman "embraced the officer from behind, causing the holstered weapon to accidently discharge." The bullet punctured Miller's lung and hit her heart, and she died at a hospital.

 

Stephens said the Detroit officer will remain on administrative duties while authorities investigate the shooting and report their findings to the Wayne County prosecutor. The officer's name was not released.

 

"For this to happen to her, whether they want to call it freak accident or mistake in judgment, it should have never happened to my child, and there's nothing I can do to get her back," McNair told WDIV-TV.

 

McNair said her daughter was out to mark her upcoming birthday.

 

"All she wanted to do was enjoy the weekend for her birthday," the mother said. "She had every right to enjoy turning 25 and look beyond that."

 

__________________________________________________________________________

 

 

July 9, 2012

 

http://www.clickondetroit.com/.../hav3lz/-/index.html

 

Woman hugs off-duty Detroit police officer — and dies after his gun goes off

Detroit

 

Detroit Free Press

 

Yolanda McNair wants to know why she is planning a funeral for her daughter Adaisha Miller rather than a birthday celebration today.

 

“The story keeps changing,” McNair said. “There’s no logical reason.”

 

Miller, who would have turned 25 today, was fatally shot early Sunday morning while attending a party on Archdale in Detroit. Police reports say she was killed when an off-duty Detroit police officer’s pistol fired as she embraced him.

 

“Instead of giving her a party this week, I’m planning her obituary and funeral,” said McNair as she sat on her west-side Detroit front porch Sunday evening with solemn relatives, neighbors and friends.

 

The police news release called the 12:30 a.m. shooting “a tragic incident,” but McNair said she cannot understand how it occurred.

 

Police said that Miller hugged the officer -- whose name has not been released -- from behind as he was dancing, and the gun discharged.

 

However, McNair said she also was told her daughter “was being a little flirty” with the officer and the gun fired as they were in a face-to-face hug.

 

If you’re at a party, she asked, “why do you need a weapon with a round in the chamber?”

 

Police spokeswoman Sgt. Eren Stephens said officers have the option of carrying a gun off-duty but there is no requirement for them to be armed.

 

A departmental investigation is being conducted by internal affairs, and the officer will be assigned to administrative duties during the probe, Stephens said.

 

The Wayne County Prosecutor’s Office will conduct a separate, independent review of the shooting, said office spokeswoman Maria Miller. Such reviews are standard for shootings involving police officers.

 

McNair endorsed a second investigation: “Yes, take it to the full extent.”

 

Miller’s younger brother Shane Miller, 23, said he also wants answers from the officer: “My sister is dead and you’re alive walking around -- like you didn’t even know what happened?”

 

John Goldpaugh, a lawyer for the Detroit Police Officers Association, said, “This was just a freak accident.

 

“They were having a party and the next thing, a woman is dead. He’s devastated by what happened.”

 

Goldpaugh, who spent several hours with the officer after the shooting, said the veteran beat patrolman was hosting a party at his home and was dancing with his wife when Miller came up behind him and tugged at his waist.

 

“And the gun went off,” Goldpaugh said. “It’s a fluke accidental shooting.”

 

The weapon, a department-issued, 40-caliber Smith & Wesson semiautomatic pistol, was in a holster worn inside the officer’s waistband and was covered by his shirt, Goldpaugh said.Goldpaugh said the physical evidence from the incident corroborated the officer’s account of the shooting. The officer did not know the woman, who attended the party with other guests, Goldpaugh said.

 

Miller was a certified massage therapist, her mother said, and a young woman with “a gentle heart who was giving to anybody.”

 

McNair said she waved good-bye to her daughter Saturday evening as she left for the party.

 

“Then I saw her at the morgue,” McNair said.

 

Miller must have been thinking of her grandmother who died in 2010, McNair said.

 

“And there a smile on her face."

Well , I know we can't "know" what happened from an article ..but I for one will follow the story because I really WANT to know what the hell happened. A holstered IWB gun can't just go off from a hug or pressure from outside the holster ..can it? Because if it can I, as a person who would consider an IWB CCW as protection around the home on nice days when the windows are wide open , would like to know what friken' holster he had so I don't get the same type. I have small kids hanging on my leg all the time , and I am under the impression that a holstered weapon in a good IWB holster should not go off unless you pull the damn trigger.

 

I'll tell you what , I know you should not assume anything from an article..but if it was a party and people were drinking I bet she came up behind him , did some kind of grind dance and stuck her hand down his pants and got her fingers in the gun. I've been at enough parties in my life to know how ...emmm.."intimate" drunk dancing people can get.

 

In other words I'm hoping being drunk or whatever and some girl sticking her hands down some hot cop's pants is what happened here ..because otherwise it raises a lot of questions in my mind about the safety of CCW around people who might give you a reach around.

I just don't get it. I mean I get that there was a nd. But how does a weapon, in a iwb holster discharge, which u have to assume was facing down or horizontal with the barrel facing behind the officer shoot someone in the chest giving them a hug. It's like the magic Kennedy bullet I guess.

Only logical explanation I came up with is he drew his weapon in a weapons retention stance when he was "startled" and had his.finger on the trigger

The article also doesn't say anything about the officer sustaining any injury. My first thought was that a gun iwb discharging at his side would cause some nasty burns that could require hospitalization. No mention of that.

I'm not a fan of manual safeties but this is a good argument for them on concealed pistols.

  • Author

....thus my question, I have no experience with holsters besides what I've read but even with the limited adjustments afforded a very few IWB models, it would seen quite a feat to accomplish an accidental fatal chest shot, even more so with the victim behind you...

From the uk ..which often has more info than we do. Go figure. Lots of eye rolling while reading this..you've been warned.

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2170759/Adaisha-Miller-killed-police-officers-gun-fires-hugs-him.html?ITO=1490

 

I'll tell you what . I'll bet she gave him a flirty IWB Hey How Ya Doin , found his gun , got her fingers in the holster maybe , especially if it was a roomy soft holster. If she was dancing and was down low...

 

The autopsy should be pretty conclusive in the who pulled the trigger department and the angle of entry. Until then who knows what happened? The one thing I feel confident not believing is that she merely hugged him and caused his IWB gun to "just go off" .

I'm not a fan of manual safeties but this is a good argument for them on concealed pistols.

 

If you are not a fan of manual safeties, why would you want one on a CCW?

 

What about revolvers?

 

Careful how you state things as a representative of the shooting sports and an advocate for firearms in a world full of antis and those that don't know any better. Your words may come back to bite you.

 

 

....thus my question, I have no experience with holsters besides what I've read but even with the limited adjustments afforded a very few IWB models, it would seen quite a feat to accomplish an accidental fatal chest shot, even more so with the victim behind you...

 

What if she was kneeling? What if it wasnt a hug, but instead she fell and pulled on the cops belt to help pull herself up? Between different weapon/holster combos and body interactions, I can think of a million different scenarios where this could happen.

 

Also, please rememebr this report is a news article, not an official investigation report. It was written to show guns and cops in a bad light because that's what the public likes right now. If it bleeds it leads, truth doesn't come into play. When was the last time a reporter got anything correct in a story about firearms?

This story would be believable if the officer's wife drew her his gun and shot the unknown woman that decided to dirty dance with her husband.

 

Just saying...

I think the wife got wind of the dirty dancing and took matters into her own hands..

  • Author

If you are not a fan of manual safeties, why would you want one on a CCW?

 

What about revolvers?

 

Careful how you state things as a representative of the shooting sports and an advocate for firearms in a world full of antis and those that don't know any better. Your words may come back to bite you.

 

 

 

 

What if she was kneeling? What if it wasnt a hug, but instead she fell and pulled on the cops belt to help pull herself up? Between different weapon/holster combos and body interactions, I can think of a million different scenarios where this could happen.

 

Also, please rememebr this report is a news article, not an official investigation report. It was written to show guns and cops in a bad light because that's what the public likes right now. If it bleeds it leads, truth doesn't come into play. When was the last time a reporter got anything correct in a story about firearms?

" I can think of a million different scenarios where this could happen". A million? really? You Sir have a way more vivid imagination than most on this forum, myself included.

I am sure we are all aware of the shortcomings of the media and their credibility in relation with firearms, as well as watching our P's and Q's but thanks anyway for your sage advice.

I can only think of one reason . Someone touched the trigger. The question is who touched and who was where when said trigger was touched.

 

The autopsy is done , and the fact that it only says she was shot through the lung and heart and mentions nothing about trajectory , distance , powder burns , residue on the hands of the trigger....toucher. makes it obvious there is more to it and like so many other incidents facts will just trickle out and people will make up their stories as it goes because that is human nature and that is what we do.:)

" I can think of a million different scenarios where this could happen". A million? really? You Sir have a way more vivid imagination than most on this forum, myself included.

I am sure we are all aware of the shortcomings of the media and their credibility in relation with firearms, as well as watching our P's and Q's but thanks anyway for your sage advice.

 

I think everyone knows that a statement like "a million" is an exaggeration in common usage, that simply means "quite a few" but thanks for bringing me back to Earth here. Really, much appreciated and very helpful to all involved. I am sure everyone else that read that statement thought I LITERALLY meant 1,000,000 distinct and seperate scenarios that end with a holstered firearm discharging and killing a young woman. Thanks for clearing that up ;)

 

And as someone with self proclaimed:

 

"no experience with holsters besides what I've read"

 

I can see why your vast experience should limit us all to the belief that it would be:

 

"quite a feat to accomplish an accidental fatal chest shot, even more so with the victim behind you..."

 

With a holstered firearm.

 

The fact that I carry a firearm daily and have experience with a multitude (sorry, I have 9 seperate and distinctly different holsters that I now use on a regular basis, and a boxful in the closet that didn't fit my needs or expectations, I wouldn't want the readership to believe I was trying to lead them astray again with my use of the term "multitude") of holsters and different methods of firearm carry should clearly prevent me from interjecting there at all.

 

Again, many thanks to you sir, and apologies to everyone reading this thread for leading you astray by playing fast and loose with the facts. It won't happen again.

  • Author

I think everyone knows that a statement like "a million" is an exaggeration in common usage, that simply means "quite a few" but thanks for bringing me back to Earth here. Really, much appreciated and very helpful to all involved. I am sure everyone else that read that statement thought I LITERALLY meant 1,000,000 distinct and seperate scenarios that end with a holstered firearm discharging and killing a young woman. Thanks for clearing that up ;)

 

And as someone with self proclaimed:

 

"no experience with holsters besides what I've read"

 

I can see why your vast experience should limit us all to the belief that it would be:

 

"quite a feat to accomplish an accidental fatal chest shot, even more so with the victim behind you..."

 

With a holstered firearm.

 

The fact that I carry a firearm daily and have experience with a multitude (sorry, I have 9 seperate and distinctly different holsters that I now use on a regular basis, and a boxful in the closet that didn't fit my needs or expectations, I wouldn't want the readership to believe I was trying to lead them astray again with my use of the term "multitude") of holsters and different methods of firearm carry should clearly prevent me from interjecting there at all.

 

Again, many thanks to you sir, and apologies to everyone reading this thread for leading you astray by playing fast and loose with the facts. It won't happen again.

I'm sure we all appreciate your clarification and value your expertise with holsters and seemingly difficult yet possible accidental shots. And a belated Welcome to the forum.

Realize, I am not commenting on the story or the shooting. Nor am I stating what I believed may, or may not, have happened - I am not and I will not guess what transpired here. I wasn't there, I don't know any of the parties involved, and I didn't see it happen.

 

I am just stating that sometimes shit happens and usually at the worst possibly time. No one should rely solely on their own personal experiences when trying to figure something like this out. It is a big world and just because you haven't experienced something, doesn't mean it can't happen.

 

And a belated Welcome to the forum.

 

Thanks!

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.