Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Flash Suppressor on semi-auto rifle: Legal or not? (I'm getting mixed answers)

Featured Replies

I'm looking at the Ruger Mini-30 Tactical, which has the detachable magazine and what Ruger calls a flash suppressor. I have been told by an FFL "you can't have a flash suppressor in NJ unless its welded on", another FFL tell me you can on THAT rifle because it has none of the other "banned features", and another FFL tell me his "state trooper buddy told him that 'you can't have a flash suppressor, period' ".

 

I know the laws are grey, but if I'm reading the them correctly, a flash suppressor IS legal as long as it's the ONLY banned item in addition to the detachable magazine. Can anybody verify this FOR SURE?

A semi-automatic rifle that has an ability to accept a detachable magazine and has at least two of the following:

This means that if it is a semi-automatic rifle and has a detachable magazine it can have ONE of the following features and still be legal, but if it has two or more, then it would not be legal.

 

1) A folding or telescoping stock;

2) A pistol grip that protrudes conspicuously beneath the action of the weapon;

3) A bayonet mount;

4) A flash suppressor or threaded barrel designed to accommodate a flash suppressor;

5) A grenade launcher

 

 

youre good

  • Author

That's my reading of the law as well, but I'm getting different answers from FFLs and LEOs, so I want to be SURE. My local FFL said if I bought it (online, he can't get one) he'd call Trenton and talk to the "head guy that knows everything" to get the answer... and that the answer might be removing the "flash supressor" and replacing with a "muzzle break"... which is legal. I don't even care, I just don't want to spend the extra $100 to replace like with like.

By not permanently attaching the flash hider to your Mini 14, you have BOTH a flash suppressor AND a threaded barrel.

Depending on which side of the bed-of-nails the prosecutor woke up that morning, you could be defending yourself on an assault weapon charge.

 

IMHO, play it safe and make the threads inaccessible by permanently attaching (tack weld, silver solder, pin and weld) the flash hider.

Your savings account (and your bung hole) will certainly appreciate it!

Mini 30 tatical has a pistol grip correct? In that case NO it would not be legal with a flash supressor or threads. If it has a standard rifle stock then yes it would be legal IMHO

Mini's have a rifle stock. FWIW - You can get a M1A with a Flash Hider as long as you keep don't have a bayo lug or pistol grip.

 

Gotta love this state...of consfusion.

Mini 30 tatical has a pistol grip correct? In that case NO it would not be legal with a flash supressor or threads. If it has a standard rifle stock then yes it would be legal IMHO

You raise a good point, as I'm not familiar with the Ruger rifles.

But http://www.budsgunshop.com/catalog/product_info.php/products_id/56842 this one at Bud's does NOT have a pistol grip.

 

Even so, consider the sage advice and cover your butt.

Make the threads a non-factor

Life is better on THIS side of the bars.

Mini-14/30s do not have a pistol grip, collapsible stock or bayonet lug, and I know for a fact that the tactical version with the flash supressor, unpinned, is sold in this state. As for the risk, yes there is always some this being NJ, but IMHO if a prosecutor were to bring a case against an otherwise law abiding citizen arguing that the gun is an assault weapon it would create a sh*tstorm along the lines of the Aitken case. (Yes, I understand that no one wants to be that poster boy).

 

It seems unambiguous that the statute provides that that a flash supressor on a threaded barrel (with no pinning requirement) or the threaded barrel itself is ONE item. Think about it. If you had a plain threaded barrel, that would under any possible reading be ok under item # 4. The threaded barrel is meaningless unless you can thread something on it. The only thing that you can thread on it in this state would be a flash supressor. It simply makes no sense to read the statute any other way.

You're trying to apply logic and sense to the prosecution of 2C:39 and 2C:58

That's a mistake!

 

As a risk-averse person, I'd make the threads inaccessible.

Your neighborhood muffler shop can help you out with that.

 

eta: And even with Brian Aitken's commutation of the balance of his sentence by Gov. Christie, he's still a convicted felon with no firearm or voting rights.

I just checked the website and there is a version of the tatical with a PG and collapsable stock. However it seems as this model is only available in .223

  • Author

Mini 30 tatical has a pistol grip correct? In that case NO it would not be legal with a flash supressor or threads. If it has a standard rifle stock then yes it would be legal IMHO

 

No. No pistol grip.

post-5413-0-11173500-1348769709_thumb.jpg

It can have a threaded barrel or a flash suppressor. When it's screwed on it's a flash hider. When it's off it's a threaded barrel. It can't be both unless the flash hider is threaded to accept a suppressor.

  • Author

By not permanently attaching the flash hider to your Mini 14, you have BOTH a flash suppressor AND a threaded barrel.

Depending on which side of the bed-of-nails the prosecutor woke up that morning, you could be defending yourself on an assault weapon charge.

 

IMHO, play it safe and make the threads inaccessible by permanently attaching (tack weld, silver solder, pin and weld) the flash hider.

Your savings account (and your bung hole) will certainly appreciate it!

 

Can anyone verify 100% that by welding the flash hider onto the barrel it's 100% legal? Hell, I can silver solder the thing myself.

If I were you I'd print out the list of laws(2:C,bs) that East Brunswick Sportsman quoted, bring that to your FFL, and show him per NJ's made up rules you are perfectly legal. Detachable magazine and flash hider G2G, if he still wants to call the guy in Trenton, take your business elsewhere. There's already one FFL in this thread who would have no problem selling it to you.

  • Author

Its legal without doing so..so why bother?

 

Well, that's what I'm trying to find out, FOR SURE! I don't want to make a mistake on this.

 

FWIW, the Springfield M1A Scout Squad has a removable flash supressor (the manual calls it a flash supressor, the website calls it a muzzle brake), and it's legal...

  • Author

If I were you I'd print out the list of laws(2:C,bs) that East Brunswick Sportsman quoted, bring that to your FFL, and show him per NJ's made up rules you are perfectly legal. Detachable magazine and flash hider G2G, if he still wants to call the guy in Trenton, take your business elsewhere. There's already one FFL in this thread who would have no problem selling it to you.

 

I did that. My local FFL is well-liked, no one has a problem with him, I think the fact that it's called a "flash suppressor" instead of a "muzzle brake" has him questioning. After I sent him a copy of that "clarification letter" he agreed with me, but then was told by his trooper friend (who worked in the firearms section of the dept) that no flash suppressor is legal, ever (which I don't believe, the way the law is written.)

 

If this turns into an "issue" with him, I will use one of the other FFLs here for the transfer (it won't be new, they are impossible to find... the tactical version is, anyway.)

Its very clear up above in black and white as far as I'm concerned. That gun with a mag capicity of lower then 16 is legal.

I did that. My local FFL is well-liked, no one has a problem with him, I think the fact that it's called a "flash suppressor" instead of a "muzzle brake" has him questioning. After I sent him a copy of that "clarification letter" he agreed with me, but then was told by his trooper friend (who worked in the firearms section of the dept) that no flash suppressor is legal, ever (which I don't believe, the way the law is written.)

 

If this turns into an "issue" with him, I will use one of the other FFLs here for the transfer (it won't be new, they are impossible to find... the tactical version is, anyway.)

 

I'm sure he is a good guy, but for this particular gun he is throwing up unnecessary roadblocks. IDK where you are located but call up East Brunswick Sportsman tell him about this thread and have it shipped there. Within a week you'll have a nice new gun that you want and know is perfectly legal, and you won't have to jump through any hoops while this guy gets 5 referrals from government employees who have no idea what they are talking about. Don't make this process any harder on yourself.

  • Author

I'm sure he is a good guy, but for this particular gun he is throwing up unnecessary roadblocks. IDK where you are located but call up East Brunswick Sportsman tell him about this thread and have it shipped there. Within a week you'll have a nice new gun that you want and know is perfectly legal, and you won't have to jump through any hoops while this guy gets 5 referrals from government employees who have no idea what they are talking about. Don't make this process any harder on yourself.

 

May do that. I was hoping more FFLs would chime in... since mine seems to be questioning. I also had another FFL here tell me he'd do the transfer as well (I did a price check request, he got back to me)

As a risk-averse person, I'd make the threads inaccessible.

Your neighborhood muffler shop can help you out with that.

 

Well, the one you're talking about might be able to help you out. Some others might ask you to hold on while they have somebody call officer friendly to arrest you for bringing a gun to their shop... :fie:

By not permanently attaching the flash hider to your Mini 14, you have BOTH a flash suppressor AND a threaded barrel.

Depending on which side of the bed-of-nails the prosecutor woke up that morning, you could be defending yourself on an assault weapon charge.

 

IMHO, play it safe and make the threads inaccessible by permanently attaching (tack weld, silver solder, pin and weld) the flash hider.

Your savings account (and your bung hole) will certainly appreciate it!

 

 

 

A semi-automatic rifle that has an ability to accept a detachable magazine and has at least two of the following:

 

each item is numbered individually..

it is saying a flash hider (that is a permanent part of the barrel) OR threads to accept one

that is why threaded barrel is not individual and flash hider is another category..

 

 

1) A folding or telescoping stock;

2) A pistol grip that protrudes conspicuously beneath the action of the weapon;

3) A bayonet mount;

4) A flash suppressor or threaded barrel designed to accommodate a flash suppressor;

5) A grenade launcher

  • Author

Thanks PK90. Was hoping other FFLs would chime in. (thanks also to East Brunswick Sportsman)

You're trying to apply logic and sense to the prosecution of 2C:39 and 2C:58

That's a mistake!

 

As a risk-averse person, I'd make the threads inaccessible.

Your neighborhood muffler shop can help you out with that.

 

 

You're worrying too much, the gun is legal.

I was under the impression that a flash hider-by name-was not legal in NJ but a muzzle brake was ok.Guess I'm mistaken? I wonder why i've been thinking that all along.

  • Author

I was under the impression that a flash hider-by name-was not legal in NJ but a muzzle brake was ok.Guess I'm mistaken? I wonder why i've been thinking that all along.

 

idk, but alot of people think that, including my local FFL.

I was under the impression that a flash hider-by name-was not legal in NJ but a muzzle brake was ok.Guess I'm mistaken? I wonder why i've been thinking that all along.

 

probably because you make the choice not to be educated on the law... you have have almost a thousand posts on a NJ based gun sight... and have a thread literally a handful of threads above this pinned for all to see explaining the law in detail... A thread that is the combined effort of several members, and hours of work.... hey if you get bored and are looking for some reading material check out this thread..

 

http://njgunforums.c...j-gun-law-faqs/

 

it is not a single feature but a combination of features...

  • Author

then you should get a new FFL because he is WRONG...

 

Why the condescension? From someone in... PENNSYLVANIA????? It's no secret the NJ laws are purposefully confusing...

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.