Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Best HG Round For When You Have To Put a Deer Down Humanely

Featured Replies

Explain how where you live in nj dictates whether you can legally brandish a handgun on a public road? My understanding is that without a ccw you cannot. Furthermore, my understanding is that a handgun is not a legal weapon with which to kill deer. True this is in the course of hunting, but I'd love some clarification. And what does "regular people" mean?

  • Author

....I always.have.problems wwith threads like.this with.low.post count OP....smells.trollish....

 

But that's just me......

 

Who cares what you have a problem with. If you don't don't like the topic, post somewhere else.

Ha, I see a pattern here. Like my post said....I've seen deer hit and mangled and, while I'm not crying, I do feel bad for something that's in bad shape and scared sh^tless. On only a couple of occasions I've seen the LEO on scene and each time they've fired a round or two from their HG (which tend to be .40 HP), the deer was not dispatched very quickly. Just out of curiosity I was wondering if a .40 HP was pretty ineffective for dispatching a hurt deer. Also wasn't sure about skull penetration on a deer with a HP round since on both occasions, I saw the LEO place rounds near the heart rather than the head.

 

I believe the answers to your original question have been answered by others in their responses. It is all about placement, not so much caliber. If you deer hunt, you know what I am talking about. There is no magic round. A round from a high-powered rifle, a slug gun, or a more powerful pistol cartridge like a .44 Magnum fired into the chest cavity in proximity of the heart of a deer oftentimes does not result in instant death, or bang-flop, as they say. A hit to the spine, or high shoulder shot will instantly drop a deer, but not necessarily kill it.

 

How does an low-velocity arrow kill a deer? An arrow into the chest cavity of a deer, the only logical location for shot placement, strikes a deer with less than 50 ft. lbs. of energy. Pretty paltry compared to energy from a firearm, right? The broadhead imparts massive wounding by cutting vital organs, resulting in rapid blood loss. (That's all a bullet does, only at times more traumatic.) Death by an arrow is not instantaneous. The deer can run a few yards and fall over and expire, or run a lot farther, which then becomes the bow-hunter's nightmare. The same can be said for a pistol round fired into the same location. There is no target or organ in the chest that short-circuits a deer quickly like a shot to the brain.

Who cares what you have a problem with. If you don't don't like the topic, post somewhere else.

 

Way to make friends and influence people dude.

 

 

LOL.....let's not pile on him....I have been pushing him/her I guess....so I am partly at fault....I appear to be in a contentious mood....dunno why...

 

:)

 

You need to get out and shoot when was the last time you smelled burning powder :)

It is rather obvious that a round ...regardless of caliber......to the high function area of the body of the animal......no matter what type....is the surest way to terminate its life....not any other region of the body.

 

This would "seem" to be accurate, and yet, OP was concerned (at least the way I read it) about the ability of a std HG round to penetrate the skull. Again though, shot placement is the key. Utilize one of the "already existing holes" in the skull (ie ears) to get the round to the brain to take care of the deal.

 

I would have some serious doubts about the ability of certain rounds (ie 25acp) to have the ability to penetrate the skull bones of many living critters.

 

 

This would "seem" to be accurate, and yet, OP was concerned (at least the way I read it) about the ability of a std HG round to penetrate the skull. Again though, shot placement is the key. Utilize one of the "already existing holes" in the skull (ie ears) to get the round to the brain to take care of the deal.

 

I would have some serious doubts about the ability of certain rounds (ie 25acp) to have the ability to penetrate the skull bones of many living critters.

 

Didn't mob hit men use a 22 to the back of the skull alot of the time. I think it is just more about police not wanting to see the animals face and lose confidence. It is hard I would think to look something in the eyes as you are killing it

Explain how where you live in nj dictates whether you can legally brandish a handgun on a public road? My understanding is that without a ccw you cannot. Furthermore, my understanding is that a handgun is not a legal weapon with which to kill deer. True this is in the course of hunting, but I'd love some clarification. And what does "regular people" mean?

 

Regular people = people that don't loose their minds when they see people with rifles & guns.

 

I regularly see people on my road with hunting gear (firearms & bows). They walk down the road to access public and private land. I do this as well. If I happened to come across a deer in the road that had been struck by a car, I wouldn't hesitate to to put one in its ear..and continue walking down the road with my weapon.

 

Life is different in the NW corner of the state.

 

Regular people = people that don't loose their minds when they see people with rifles & guns.

 

I regularly see people on my road with hunting gear (firearms & bows). They walk down the road to access public and private land. I do this as well. If I happened to come across a deer in the road that had been struck by a car, I wouldn't hesitate to to put one in its ear..and continue walking down the road with my weapon.

 

Life is different in the NW corner of the state.

 

I see. True enough. Would you concede, however, that a handgun is NOT a hunting weapon in NJ? And that regardless of region, there is functionally no circumstance in this state where one could legally deploy a handgun to dispatch a trapped or injured animal? As far as I know, there is only one answer to this question.

I will conceed that a hand gun is not a hunting weapon if you will conceed that many hunters carry a hand gun for the purpose of a humane put-down shot.

A HG can be a hunting weapon....however NOT in NJ and based on the state where we live...NO to both your above concessions......not in NJ anyway...

 

Yes, I guess almost anything can be a hunting weapon. I was raised in PA where we did use a piston for the humane shot. When I was 10 my dad carried the pistol. When I started hunting on my own at 15 I carried. Since I moved to NJ 25 years ago I've have mostly hunted on my own land and the adjacent farms. I will continue to carry when I hunt because it is perfectly legal for me to carry on my own property.

 

Man there are just too many non-sense rules in this state. When the kids are out of school I'm movin' out.

Yes, I guess almost anything can be a hunting weapon. I was raised in PA where we did use a piston for the humane shot. When I was 10 my dad carried the pistol. When I started hunting on my own at 15 I carried. Since I moved to NJ 25 years ago I've have mostly hunted on my own land and the adjacent farms. I will continue to carry when I hunt because it is perfectly legal for me to carry on my own property.

 

Man there are just too many non-sense rules in this state. When the kids are out of school I'm movin' out.

 

The rules in this state ARE nonsense. I would be cautious with the handgun carry during hunting season. It may be your property or a friend's, but if you have a hunting license in your possession for hunting you can only use a firearm that's legal for hunting. Explaining that to a CO might be dicey.

 

f. Nothing in subsections b., c. and d. of N.J.S.2C:39-5 shall be construed to prevent:

 

(2) A person carrying a firearm or knife in the woods or fields or upon the waters of this State for the purpose of hunting, target practice or fishing, provided that the firearm or knife is legal and appropriate for hunting or fishing purposes in this State and he has in his possession a valid hunting license, or, with respect to fresh water fishing, a valid fishing license;

  • Author

.....probably no one.......LOL

 

It just seems silly to even ask the question....

 

It is rather obvious that a round ...regardless of caliber......to the high function area of the body of the animal......no matter what type....is the surest way to terminate its life....not any other region of the body.

 

Then I think if this is that obvious there must be a larger motive for the question .... hence my statements .....sorry if your offended.

 

 

You missed the point. Question came from seeing LEO’s putting .40 HP rounds into the chest cavity of an already suffering deer and it did not die very quickly, which was in the original post. Of course, a head shot or anything to obliterate the CNS would be lights out. But seeing LEO’s go for the chest instead of the head made me wonder if a .40 HP wouldn’t reliably penetrate the skull of a deer…maybe it’s a lot denser than a human’s….I don’t know….hence the question of round and placement. Thought maybe a .40 HP will not reliably penetrate the skull, which is why the 2 instances I saw were “boiler room” shots with that round, bc a .40 HP is what they had to work with.

 

Nah, I’m not offended. But when you say that my post smells trollish while your own previous responses were pretty inflammatory….."ummm....OK.." and “seems like a dumb ass question”, I’m going to raise an eyebrow to that.

 

It’s all good though.

 

 

 

I believe the answers to your original question have been answered by others in their responses. It is all about placement, not so much caliber. If you deer hunt, you know what I am talking about. There is no magic round. A round from a high-powered rifle, a slug gun, or a more powerful pistol cartridge like a .44 Magnum fired into the chest cavity in proximity of the heart of a deer oftentimes does not result in instant death, or bang-flop, as they say. A hit to the spine, or high shoulder shot will instantly drop a deer, but not necessarily kill it.

 

How does an low-velocity arrow kill a deer? An arrow into the chest cavity of a deer, the only logical location for shot placement, strikes a deer with less than 50 ft. lbs. of energy. Pretty paltry compared to energy from a firearm, right? The broadhead imparts massive wounding by cutting vital organs, resulting in rapid blood loss. (That's all a bullet does, only at times more traumatic.) Death by an arrow is not instantaneous. The deer can run a few yards and fall over and expire, or run a lot farther, which then becomes the bow-hunter's nightmare. The same can be said for a pistol round fired into the same location. There is no target or organ in the chest that short-circuits a deer quickly like a shot to the brain.

 

Yes they have, but thanks for the thorough response.

357 Magnum.

  • Author

I did.....LOL....sorry I'm.in a funk and was being douchey.......in retrospect not the best choice of words...I'm kinda protective and some threads make me think....I am sure some antis are out here trying to bait us etc....

 

Img your up our way coffee or.or cold.one are.on.me... :)

 

 

Ehh…my post probably could have been a little more concise anyway. We've all been in the “funk” so I hear you on that. My gf loves to inform me when I'm in one of my own- trust me.

I’ll take you up on that coffee or beer next time I’m up in near your neck of the woods. Thanks.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.