Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Newbie impressions of four 9MM pistols

Featured Replies

I am new in the pistol arena.

 

I shot a lot as a teen, but nothing worth mentionig re: pistols.

 

I recently took NRA Basic pistol.

 

I am in the market for a 9MM, and after speaking with friends, researching here and other sites, I narrowed my choices down to 4 guns:

 

Beretta 92FS

Beretta PX4

Sig 226

Glock 17

 

I like the DA/SA option. Glock is in there because, well, it kinda has to be, with the popularity and reputation of the brand.

 

I have large, but not huge hands (XL to XXL gloves). I am 5'10" and 250, so I have a little mass behind me. I have good upper body strength.

 

Yesterday, I went to Heritage Guild in Easton and shot 25 rounds through each pistol. Spent time working the controls and trying the DA action of the 3 DA/SA pistols. Shot the DA pistols in both DA and SA modes.

 

Again, this is my very limited experience and very limited try out speaking, by no means am I offering an opinion beyond that scope. One of the Range Officers, Doug, at Heritage was a great help and gave me pointers as I went along in the tryout.

 

I bought a paper target with 5 seperate round targets on it, 1 for each weapon, with 1 left over.

Target was 5 yards down range. I was not shooting for bulls, I was shooting to get the feel of each gun.

 

First up was the PX4.

I was not very accurate with it, and the group was fairly spread out. The gun felt good in hand and controls worked for me. After my first clip of 10, Doug pulled the target back and use a magic marker to color in the bull, which helped. Gave me some pointers on trigger squeeze. Put another 15 through the PX4, with better results, but still a fair spread.

 

I then went to the 92FS.

Immediately liked the feel of the gun in hand. Controls were good. Trigger squeeze was good.

I put 10 rounds through the gun and could not see where I was hitting on the target. Pulled the target back and all 10 went into a 1.5" group or so, dead center. So neadless to say, this gun worked best for me. I put another 10 through it and all 10 went into the same hole. I was leaning towards this gun beforehand, and this limited test pushed me even further.

 

Glock 17 was next.

I did not like the magazine release. All other controls were fine.

I actually shot this gun well, with a 2" grouping. Accurate, easy to aquire the target. Did not particularly like the hold on the gun, though.

Only put 20 rounds through it.

 

Sig 226

I know Sig is a great weapon. I did not find it fit me very well. I found myself trying to avoid all the controls on the left side, when gripping the pistol.

Shot reasonable accurate with it, but probably a 3" group.

It had the least recoil.

Shot about 20 rounds through it.

 

I then went back to the PX4, since I had calmed down and was shooting more accurately. My grouping improved with the final 20 rounds I put through the gun. Somewhere near the Glock grouping size, slightly larger.

 

Doug then let me shoot his Sig 225. I actually liked that very much and was very accurate with it as well. I would put it in second place behind the 92FS

 

So with this info in hand, I can say that the 92FS will be my first pistol purchase. I like the feel of the weapon, and in this limited exposure, it was the most accurate for me. I may go with a 92A1.

 

YMMV

The PX4 is a great pistol. The 92 is also a fantastic firearm. If I had to choose 1, I would go with the more modern poly framed PX4 platform. I have both, I prefer the PX4's weight, balance, and rotating barrel system.

 

I should also mention I have the PX4 in .40 s&w not 9mm. The design make shooting .40 feel like shooting 9mm, so the 9mm must be a real cream puff.

 

Another option is the PX4 Compact. Same rotating barrel, 15rd standard 9mm mags, and I hear it has less recoil than the full size PX4. I would like to get one of these in the near future.

You should really look at a CZ75. They are all steel and shoot very good. They have 15 rounds mags and you have a choice of Blued, nickel and stainless. This was my second gun and still love this pistol. Also you can find a lot of aftermarket parts and many people can work on them with CZ- Custom being on the top of the list for quality work. I think you should at least look at it.

Welcome to the sport.

 

The PX4 Compact is a fantastic pistol, but you can't go wrong with the 92FS. As an added bonus, you can throw a .22LR slide on there and shoot .22 LR ammo for just $0.03 per round.

Good report, thanks for the information.

Have the PX4 Storm sub ans the 92fs. Both nice guns the Storm SC is for close in work but shots well.

I have the 92FS and am overall happy with the gun. I also have the practice kit.

 

One thing I find with this gun is that, while I have large hands, I have to almost over rotate when I go to exchange magazines. I need to manipulate my grip a little more than I think I should have to in order to reach the magazine button. Thinner grips might help...I don't know.

 

My next 9mm will no doubt be a PX4 storm, full size. As much as I like the 92...the PX4 fits my hand like butter...you know. I will say that if the PX4 came with a practice kit option, or a similar 22 platorrm, I would have gone that route in the first place.

 

They are both great guns and to the OP....go with what fits your hand best. :th:

  • Author

Thanks for the feedback/welcomes.

 

Like I said, this is my impression after a whopping 25 rounds per.

 

The 92 is going to be pistol #1, but that 225 and a compact PX4 are on the list as well.

 

I am waiting on 2 P2P, should be 2 more weeks.

Hello and welcome to the Forums!

:hi:

 

 

post-2785-0-03996400-1337835331_thumb.jpg

 

The 92fs is a nice pistol. Last summer in a defensive pistol class I had a tough time with the mag release on the 92fs. We were being timed on clearing jams on 8 pistols, 6 Glocks, 1 Beretta, 1 1911. I could not release the magazine quick enough with the thumb on my strong hand.

Well that's the way to do it. Try whatever catches your eye and find the one (or more :)) that YOU like the best.

The 92FS is a great choice. That was the one I started out with many moons ago. I dry fired the snot out of that one! Taught me great trigger control with the long trigger pull that is inherent to that model Beretta. Turned me into a better shooter because of that.

My next 9mm will no doubt be a PX4 storm, full size.

 

See if you can get your hands comfortably around the PX4 Compact. It's a little smaller, but somehow a lot more concealable if you ever wanted or needed to go that route. It also comes with 15 round magazines. So does the PX4 Full Size, but I think you'll have to buy them aftermarket.

  • Author

Just put down money on my FS and CX4 at Heritage Guild, Branchburg. The CX4 in 92 Magazine is almost impossible to find right now. HG pricing was good on both guns. JCPD said 2-3 weeks after fingerprinting, so hopefully I will have these in hand before New Year!

  • Author

Thanks guys. Should be picking them up Tuesday

 

Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2

I have the PX4 in 40 and love it. Add a hogue Hand-ALL grip to it and it fits my hand perfectly. I was not very accurate with it at first but as I got used to it I got a lot better.

 

The 92FS is fantastic, especially with larger hands. Either gun would be a fine choice.

If they made a single-stack 92FS I would buy it in a heartbeat. I like the CZ 75B, because, for a larger, metal handgun, it fits my hand much better. I would recommend the 92A1 or M9A1.

  • Author

I am very happy with the 92 vs as my choice. Don't need nor want tactical rail and the other is just a military look alike, which is not important to me.

 

Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2

Of the 4 you have chosen, the 92FS hands down. A pistol you can count on when the chips are down and something you could pass on to your children, or ex wife.

Have to agree with Ray. M9 was my first pistol (essentially a 92fs) and the thing is a beast. Accurate, reliable, and good ergo. You win.

  • Author

Just put in my NICs. Should get to shoot tomorrow

 

Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2

CZ PCR, simply the best, fits everyones hands, do the research and youll choose this gun, for 9mm this is it.

Certainly a 92 is a great choice, I have 3 of them in my collection currently. Since I'm a Sig guy, I thought it relevant to point out to you that Sigs can be had with a variety of trigger mechanisms (DA/SA, DAK, SAO, SRT); standard and slim triggers; beavertail or non-beavertail frame; and, E2 or standard grip, and with standard grips the sky is the limit for panels out there. What this equates to is that you have many options for getting a fit, feel, and performance you like. So, as you build your collection off that 92, don't rule out other makes based on one experience handling one model with one configuration.

  • Author

Went to stop with a buddy today. First time shooting MY 92 and cx4.

 

Put 200 rounds down range with the 92. reaffirmed my initial impressions. Was grouping very well and loved every minute of it.

 

My buddy brought his 226, among other guns and I shot it again. Must say I really like it. Shot as well with it as with the 92. Was much more comfortable with it. Might have to add one to the stable.

 

The cx4 was a ton of fun. Only shot about 50 rounds through it. I was not going to put optics on her, but after today, I can see how they would be beneficial. Next on the shopping list.

 

Headed towards home and somehow ended up at Bullet Hole. Put another hour and 200 rounds through the 92. Ran the last 20 shots through her at 23 yards. 7 of 10 in the 10 point body target. The other 3 in the 9. Next 10 were at the head and 8 hit the noggin. Love this gun.

 

Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2

 

 

  • 2 months later...

I have owned and shot all but the Beretta PX4. While I have owned a lot of DA/SA guns I no longer am a big fan of them for self defense/home defense purposes. I bet that you shot all or most of your shots in single action which is OK for fun range shooting. However with a DA/SA gun the first trigger pull is very heavy and most will not shoot their first shot accurately. I used to throw my first shot away when training which is simply just shot it quickly into the ground so that my gun went into SA mode fast. Most people I know with DA/SA guns shoot them only in SA mode at the range and will be in for a surprise if they ever have to shoot it for HD. Even those who shot the first shot in DA do not practice enough with it in that mode since only the first shot is fired in DA. I used to go through a few mags shooting it DA in every range session to get used to the DA pull and still it was never as good as the subsequent SA trigger pulls. For my defensive guns I want to a 6-7 lb trigger pull that stays the same all the time. It does take lots of practice to transition from DA to SA mode. You can try that yourself at the range by shooting defensively and not slow fire for groups. Most people shoot groups which is ok for target guns but unfortunately they do it with their defensive guns not realizing how that promotes habits that will slow them down in a gun fight. Anyway enough of my feelings on DA/SA.

 

I like the Glock 17 and recommend it to people although with your 15 round NJ limit I would go with the Glock 19. It is a perfect size and the most popular of the Glocks. I have bought 6 Glocks and own none now as I just never could get comfortable with them. I do like their reliability and have found that HK and the less expensive FNH guns are also very reliable. Take a look at the FNX-9. You can set it in a DA/SA mode with and without a manual safety or in SA mode with a safety. It gives you choices, comes with 3 mags and is more reliable than most of the Glocks I owned. Yeah, Glocks jam too. For about $30 more than a Glock the FNX-9 is more to my liking and worth a look. You will find that almost all posts about the gun and brand are very positive. On the high end a new model HK like the P30 is worth a look. Not only can you change out the back straps but also the grips so you get an almost custom fit.

 

I liked the FS-92 but the grip was too big for my hand. In DA mode I could not put my trigger finger on the face of the trigger and that promotes bad first shots when combined with a heavy DA pull. Great gun and never jammed on me. Probably would fit you hands better than mine. With our Military using them for so long all the kinks have been worked out of the design so if there are any problems it is going to be a rare mfg defect and not anything to do with a new design.

 

The Sig P226 is also a classic and choice of some special forces but hold out for a new version with the SRT (Short reset trigger). After you shoot you just let up on the trigger a small fraction of an inch and it resets and is ready to fire. Can never go wrong with a Sig. Take a look at the shorter P229 which is my favorite. I tend to like shorter barrels as they balance better in my hand and are fast to get on target but that is only applicable if you are going to use it for defense and take training classes with it. For shooting at static targets any gun will do that shoots straight and fits your hand.

 

That is about all I can add. If you want a lighter reliable gun that you can use as a DA/SA or SA cocked and locked, look up the FNX-9. Their new model is the striker fired FNS9 but I am not a fan of striker fired guns. Like hammers for several reasons that have to do with safety.

 

If you are committed to the four you mentioned I would go with your top choice of the FS-92 in any of its formats as you cannot go wrong with it. If you want what the elite military units use rather than the common grunt Beretta then consider the P226. Sigs have easier to rack slides, are very accurate and soft shooting. Reliable as heck too. If you get a chance, shoot an HK. They are my favorites, even more than my beloved Sigs and two of my carry guns are Sigs. :)

  • Author

Slightly old thread. I have 3 Berettas and am competing in steel and uspsa. Waiting on permits for a cz.

 

Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2

 

 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.