Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Illinios Wins Right to Carry Lawsuit

Featured Replies

  • Author

You're right but, of course, the fury over the DB who shot up the mall tonight will likely overshadow the importance of this ruling and how it's going to be portrayed by the media, right or wrong.

 

It should be used as reinforcement of why we should have the right to carry a firearm.

It should be used as reinforcement of why we should have the right to carry a firearm.

 

You're right. It should. Let's see if the media buries it.

Ya. Like Heller was a great decision! It's not called negativism. It's called realism!

 

Seriously dude, your attitude is messed up. Would have you preferred that Heller went the other way with the SC deciding that there was no right to won a firearm. Did Heller say that we should all have machinguns mounted on out cars? No, so I suppose is you expected them to say RPGs for everyone then yes Heller sucked, but in the actual real world where nothing is friking perfect Heller was actually quite great. After decade of the US government repression of firearm rights Heller drew a line in the sand, and then McDonald moved all the states over that line in the sand.

 

If you want realism, realize that it didn't have to go that way, it could have gone exactly the opposite way and stop living in a dream world.

 

Hey I have an idea. Why don't one of you guys just conceal carry and get cought by the cops. Then you can be the test case for the supreme court and say even though NJ has a "may issue" law they don't issue at all.

 

Who the hell suggested that we should celebrate this decision as a victory of NJ? It is a victory for gun rights. It is not the end of the war, but to get to where we want to be we had to go through this point. If we failed at this point we would have been set back, but we didn't so we move forward. We celebrate that not because it will fix NJ today or even tomorrow, but because without it NJ will never be fixed.

Problem is, IL had NO system of carry whatsoever. NJ "has" a CCW system, so there's no standing to say "you can't carry in NJ" because under certain conditions, you can. The best you could ever hope for in NJ is to argue those conditions are too strict, in front of judges who think they are just fine. And possibly, as a best case scenario, the system will stubbornly change to another set of massive financial/time consuming hurdles rather than the current one. So while I hate to be negative, the reality is, I doubt you will ever be able to obtain a CCW in NJ as you would in PA with a simple process, or even as you would in FL with a lengthy but realistic process.

I'm sure lots of people on the Illinois gun forums were saying "It is never going to happen here, ever" too.

I doubt you will ever be able to obtain a CCW in NJ as you would in PA with a simple process, or even as you would in FL with a lengthy but realistic process.

All the more reason why it's important that Muller v. Maenza reaches SCOTUS. It is custom tailored and laser focused on the one thing that keeps the population unarmed. I don't believe NJ could wiggle out of a high court ruling banning discretionary approval (may issue via justifiable need). MD and NY's cases are a good substitute in that they concern the same theme, namely a state official gets to decide who can exercise a civil right and who can not. The lawsuits can even be joined with one another depending on the timing. I truly believe that the only thing that can thwart 2nd Amendment restoration in NJ is an Obama appointment. So long as we have the 5 who gave us McDonald & Heller, we should be good to go.

Yes I did read it. And the state will do everything they can even being dragged back to court. Have you forgot that "may issue" has already been upheld by many courts as a reasonable restriction and that is just what they will do there. What is it you don't understand?

 

You forgot to mention that in every single ruling where "may issue" has been upheld, it has always been based on the misinterpretation of the Heller ruling; there is no right to carry a gun outside your home. This ruling says there is. If one of the "may issue" carry cases is granted cert by SCOTUS, then the issue should be resolved in one fell swoop. If this IL case is heard, then we will likely have to redo the "may issue" cases again, using that case as precedence.

 

Ya. Like Heller was a great decision! It's not called negativism. It's called realism!

 

Heller was a great a decision. It was the first time the courts officially recognized an individual right to own a firearm.

 

Hey I have an idea. Why don't one of you guys just conceal carry and get cought by the cops. Then you can be the test case for the supreme court and say even though NJ has a "may issue" law they don't issue at all.

 

Way to knock down that strawman.

  • Author

Im still not sure why this is good for nj.

 

NJ Federal Court ruled that the 2nd amendment does not apply outside the home (Being appealed to the 3rd Circuit). Also, NJ AG insists the 2nd Amendment is a privilege and and does not apply outside the home.

 

7c ruled it does apply outside the home. The more conflicting rulings in federal court the better chance of Scotus hearing the case and ruling.

 

Once its law that the 2nd am does in fact apply outside the home, it will be easier to fight the justifieable need clause.

Im still not sure why this is good for nj.

 

I may be wrong, but my layman's take is this:

On it's own the IL decision doesn't impact NJ too much. What it does do is establish some blocks that could one day be used to help things in NJ.

First, it establishes an interpretation of the Heller ruling that an individual has a right to carry outside the home.

Second, it creates a situation where lower courts from different areas have conflicting rulings, which means the Supreme Court will most likely take up the case to clear up the discrepancy.

Third, as BigHayden mentioned, the NJ "may issue" law has been upheld due to a misinterpretation of the Heller Ruling.. basically that an individual does NOT have a right to carry outside the home so the states can enact any restrictions they want.

 

So, the IL ruling undermines the basis by which the "may issue" laws have been upheld. If the SC takes the case and rules in favor of IL then that interpretation is upheld and anyone challenging the NJ "May issue" laws could use it as precedence.

So we are "hoping" this tips the scales for us, but it may still be some time before we see any real action to change things here. Correct?

If I'm a practicing [insert a religion of your choice here], applying the current "logic" of NJ means that my 1st Ammendment rights would only be allowed inside my home (or on my property) unless approved by the government. Right? If that's the case, I'm definitely going to pay closer attention to this issue.

So we are "hoping" this tips the scales for us, but it may still be some time before we see any real action to change things here. Correct?

 

listen to scott bach talk on gun for hire radio. he explains it better than i can. there are 5 or so lawsuits across the country, all saying the same thing. that "may issue" (which is effectively no issue) is unconstitutional. the wording in this case couldnt be better for gun rights. heller and mcdonald guaranteed a right to own a handgun for self defense. inside the home. this wording says that it also applies, possibly more so, outside the home. so we now have different federal courts disagreeing with only one way to go. so its good for NJ if the supreme court agrees with the illinois ruling. its bad if they agree with the NY ruling. we have yet to hear the appeals of california and NJ to determine their final outcome pre-supreme court.

 

since its federal, it doesnt matter which case makes it to the supreme court, since they argue the same thing. so if this case goes to the supreme court, and they side in our favor. it then means that carry is a constitutional right all the states must follow.

A friend of mine sums this up the best.

 

 

"Maybe the moops in this state can use the arguments from Illinois. The worst case scenario is that the federal court hearing an NJ case would not agree, and thereby sending it off to the SC. In which case the SC can only say, hey, didn't we already tell you that you have to allow the right?

The best case would be that the court will agree and strike down the NJ law."

Question?

If everybody here applied for a ccw permit would that help?

 

Almost all would be denied but logic comes from numbers

Question?

If everybody here applied for a ccw permit would that help?

 

Almost all would be denied but logic comes from numbers

 

I've always wondered this myself. What if we got a few hundred people to apply for ccw? Just jam up the works make our case.

 

Sent from my Nexus 7 using Tapatalk 2

can I carry yet?

can I carry yet?

 

Yeah. People in Newark and Camden do it all the time.

 

Sent from my Nexus 7 using Tapatalk 2

Yeah. People in Newark and Camden do it all the time.

 

Sent from my Nexus 7 using Tapatalk 2

 

Exactly....no one said you can't carry if you don't get caught.

  • Author

So we are "hoping" this tips the scales for us, but it may still be some time before we see any real action to change things here. Correct?

 

Correct. Any ruling that the 2nd amendment does in fact extend outside ones home will help our cause.

 

If the 4th circuit for the MD lawsuit rules in favor of the 2nd amendment extending outside the home, it would make it very likely (and easy for) the 3rd circuit NJ lawsuit to be ruled the same.

 

As of right now the 4th circuit arguments have been heard and ruling is pending. The 7th circuit ruling is going to be very helpful to the judges in the 4th circuit to rule in our (Marylands) favor.

can I carry yet?

Not Legally my brother. Reminds me of Spaceballs:

 

President Scroob: When we then be now?

Colonel Sanders: Soon.

Yeah. People in Newark and Camden do it all the time.

Don't forget Trenton! I put one of them away last year...

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.