Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Dick's won't sell field boxes without answering questions about citizenship

Featured Replies

Why is this even a thread? Why the big deal? Click the dam button and leave. If your really worried about admitting you ARE a citizen we have bigger problems.

 

what exactly are you giving up by anonymously answering a question about citizenship... look I get it.. the question is stupid.. especially for a plastic box.. or a sling.. what happened is obvious.... someone in an office somewhere made the decision that the question had to be asked for any "firearms goods" so now it just pops up for everything... if you are really that furious about it.. call corporate .. if you are still completely disgusted that they insist on asking if you are a citizen of the US.. if that makes you over the top angry.. then shop somewhere else.. the people at the store level.. even the manager.. are just trying to earn a living... and they did not invent the ridiculous policies you are annoyed with..... I just never understood taking it out on people at the lowest level... these people have nothing to do with making OR changing the policies.... we are inconvenienced all the time.... I bet if you look real hard there are a ton of things you could get really mad about on a daily basis..

 

Yep...

 

I find it sad you all can piss and moan about a stupid question at a box store....but if I complain about ammo hoarders, I'M the asshole. :rolleyes:

  • Replies 87
  • Views 3.2k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

I agree with you on that. These issues will not be resolved at the lower levels. They need to be taken up with corporate level reps. Just like laws need to be taken up with lawmakers.

 

That being said - some guys here are right... Where does it stop?

Why is this even a thread? Why the big deal? Click the dam button and leave. If your really worried about admitting you ARE a citizen we have bigger problems.

 

Why should I have to tell a private company something that they could use to unlawfully discriminate against me?

 

It's a fookin plastic (or metal) box. It's not a nuclear warhead or anything. They have ZERO business asking.

some guys here are right... Where does it stop?

 

retail store =/= government

 

we live in a free society... if the store wants to have dumb policies about asking silly questions.. they should be free to... if you don't like it you can take your money elsewhere... where does it stop? for me it stops when they start wanting to scan my drivers license to purchase an ammo box..or want any other personal information.... but again this is a retail structure.... all exists for a reason.... the reason they ask you that is some corporate lawyer somewhere decided it was in the companies best interest.. it wasn't to piss you off or violate your rights.... the same thing goes for asking you your zip... or email address... different line or info.. in that case they are just trying to market themselves better... they are not doing it to make you have the worst day in the world... I don't really like to give my info out... but in the same breath I think we get overly agitated by stuff like that.. but again.. this is simply a retail store... not the government taking a DNA sample to buy serialized ammo... so who really cares..

 

it's a shame we don't get this "mad" about gun laws... people are furious about being asked if they are a US citizen to buy a plastic box... but are totally willing to show ID with finger prints on it to purchase HP ammo... then have their name and info recorded.. that then must be driven straight home from place of purchase..

 

maybe we should be mad about that... because honestly... that seems way more absurd..

I am pissed about our gun laws, and I have been pounding my law makers from the local level on up to federal level with my thoughts and what I think should be done.

Why should I have to tell a private company something that they could use to unlawfully discriminate against me?

 

It's a fookin plastic (or metal) box. It's not a nuclear warhead or anything. They have ZERO business asking.

 

because they are a private company and can ask you whatever they want... you have the freedom to not shop there...

 

Go buy a cell phone... you will need to give them your name.. address.. social security number.. age.. ID number.... and credit history... along with a photo ID... for a phone..

I am pissed about our gun laws, and I have been pounding my law makers from the local level on up to federal level with my thoughts and what I think should be done.

 

I am not saying you don't.. I am just saying in the greater scheme of things.. being asked if you are a citizen is a pretty small inconvenience.. there are FAR more ridiculous hurdles people are required to jump through on a regular basis..

because they are a private company and can ask you whatever they want...

 

No they can't.

 

If they refuse to sell me a stupid plastic box because I am not a US citizen that is illegal.

 

A private company is not like a private home. If you operate a retail store that is a place of public accommodation. You can decide which individuals you do business with but you CANNOT discriminate against protected classes.

 

Go buy a cell phone... you will need to give them your name.. address.. social security number.. age.. ID number.... and credit history... for a phone..

 

Completely and totally different, and they still can't refuse me service because of my nationality or national origin except for very specific exemptions.

 

And yes, I am fully aware that this particular incident may be an oversight, retail store drones blindly following the computer etc. But this should absolutely be brought to their attention and it should be fixed.

 

 

 

Yep...

 

I find it sad you all can piss and moan about a stupid question at a box store....but if I complain about ammo hoarders, I'M the asshole. :rolleyes:

 

 

First, ammo hoarding is bad, hate 'em. Hurts the community. And makes it hard to spend an hour at the range for most of us.

 

I understand you opinion on the "stupid question," I hope you understand mine. This is not a question of expediency. It is not relevant nor reasonable. If I hire someone they have to fill out an I-9 form. If I'm crossing a border they can ask the legality of my crossing the into their country.

 

Imagine of they asked "gay or straight" when you bought condoms? Or if you're married during a job interview? Or what religion you are when you purchased an airplane ticket?

 

In any event, just like it isn't the employee's fault, it isn't mine. They could just as easily not ask me the question and make my day go smoother than I could by answering to make their day go smoother. Apparently the response has no bearing and they know that.

 

There is a legal argument of "atmosphere" where the further argument of "reasonableness" comes into play. The logic goes that if the population accepts such a question as common occurrence in simple commerce then it is reasonable to expect a similar question from somewhere else. Like the school nurse asking if daddy has any guns.

 

Both pieces of information are private on all but very specific circumstances.

 

There are lots and lots and lots of things going on that enrage me on a daily basis. So I write our elected officials, contribute to organizations that share my outrage, and seek out like minded individuals to vote for on Election Day. Those are my islands of calm in a sea of discontentment. I owe it to my children to do what I can to preserve what freedoms we have left to pass on.

 

Giving up privacy that was bought with blood, however trivial in some's opinion, is not something I think is negotiable. In my most humble of opinions.

What if you said, "Yes I'm a citizen".... "of the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics."

What if you said, "Yes I'm a citizen".... "of the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics."

 

They would say "welcome, comrade"

 

 

No they can't.

 

If they refuse to sell me a stupid plastic box because I am not a US citizen that is illegal.

 

A private company is not like a private home. If you operate a retail store that is a place of public accommodation. You can decide which individuals you do business with but you CANNOT discriminate against protected classes.

 

[/font][/color]

 

Completely and totally different, and they still can't refuse me service because of my nationality or national origin except for very specific exemptions.

 

And yes, I am fully aware that this particular incident may be an oversight, retail store drones blindly following the computer etc. But this should absolutely be brought to their attention and it should be fixed.

Have you read posts 11,16 and 22 on this tread? do you really believe some high school cheerleader behind a Dick's register is going to deny your purchase simply because you pressed NO?

You've most properly divulged more information about yourself,family,likes,dislikes right here on a public forum but get bent when some corporate hack decides to add and extra step to potentially cover his and his employer's ass.

Don't want to press a button? ......don't shop at Dick's.. simple.

they are not refusing you... as others stated they sell you the item anyway....

 

Then why are they asking?

Have you read posts 11,16 and 22 on this tread? do you really believe some high school cheerleader behind a Dick's register is going to deny your purchase simply because you pressed NO?

You've most properly divulged more information about yourself,family,likes,dislikes right here on a public forum but get bent when some corporate hack decides to add and extra step to potentially cover his and his employer's ass.

Don't want to press a button? ......don't shop at Dick's.. simple.

 

Simple question, why are they asking?

Simple question, why are they asking?

My guess is that in the attempt to predict some draconian passage of anti firearm/ammunition bill, some overzealous corporate lawyer thought is wise for Dick's to be proactive and have this feature included to show compliance and potentially cover their collective asses

Who knows... maybe they just included it to piss you off. The point is press the button or don't press the button but you can still purchase your item or shop elsewhere.

No, they are asking because federal law says that illegals and non-resident aliens cannot possess ammo, and they can't knowingly sell to them:

 

http://www.justice.g...nts/guncard.pdf

Okay then.. if that be the reason wouldn't a better question be "Are you a legal resident of the united states" but then that could be too obtrusive of a question and possibly illegal to ask.....I don't know but again it just proves my theory, it's essentially a CYA step. A useless one in my opinion because if answered no, you can still complete your purchase without anyone challenging you. Just do like me and say it's none of their business, make the purchase and carry on with your day.

I have not the time to go tilting imagery windmills when so many more important causes go unchallenged.

I actually don't mind if there's an actual law and they ask.

 

But here we have them tagging all "firearm related items" as needing info about citizenship. This to me is a very slippery slope. If they were just asking about guns and ammo, fine. I would happily say "yes" when they ask me about my citizenship.

 

But not for ammo boxes. I don't need to "show my papers" to buy a stupid plastic/metal box.

To these questions I just answer "No Thanks",

 

If asked after that, "Would you prefer none of your f'ing business"

 

That usually ends any conversations.

I actually don't mind if there's an actual law and they ask.

 

But here we have them tagging all "firearm related items" as needing info about citizenship. This to me is a very slippery slope. If they were just asking about guns and ammo, fine. I would happily say "yes" when they ask me about my citizenship.

 

But not for ammo boxes. I don't need to "show my papers" to buy a stupid plastic/metal box.

The sku# for the box is most probably categorized under Firearms and firearms accessories because it's easier to order and inventory by category than to separate it and create a sub category. It was not meant as a personal affront to your sensibilities but merely a by product of inventory control.

The sku# for the box is most probably categorized under Firearms and firearms accessories because it's easier to order and inventory by category than to separate it and create a sub category. It was not meant as a personal affront to your sensibilities but merely a by product of inventory control.

 

Then they need to fix that... I said it was likely an error but they still need to fix it.

To these questions I just answer "No Thanks",

 

If asked after that, "Would you prefer none of your f'ing business"

 

That usually ends any conversations.

 

it's on the computer and your only choices are "yes" or "no". You have to press the button.

Then they need to fix that... I said it was likely an error but they still need to fix it.

Some locations have... they simply have instructions to press Yes at the register without bothering the customer with stupid questions.....and that friends... is customer service.

This is sort of the same principle when you go to purchase a fishing license and they ask you if you owe child support. I do not have kids but that's a stupid question for a fishing license!

I've been to that location several times, and I have only had a problem ONCE. Not all of their employees (including a few that work the hunting/firearms section) have complete knowledge of gun laws in New Jersey. If they hit a wall, they ask the manager, who just so happens doesn't know anything himself. You have to remember that this is not a gun store specializing in all of your shooting needs. Their main sellers are sportswear and atheltic gear. Honestly, their employees are morons when it comes to that too. They don't hire specialists, especially an minimum wage.

 

Their policies are legal no matter which arguement you may throw out there. It is in no way illegal for a corporate business to have their own requirements or policies to protect their story, company, and reputation. Read state and federal laws or speak to a corporate attorney. Why can a restaraunt require it's employees to remove earings and cover tattoos? It may offend the employee, but it's policy.

Their policies are legal no matter which arguement you may throw out there. It is in no way illegal for a corporate business to have their own requirements or policies to protect their story, company, and reputation. Read state and federal laws or speak to a corporate attorney. Why can a restaraunt require it's employees to remove earings and cover tattoos? It may offend the employee, but it's policy.

 

It's legal if they are not actually denying sales based on citizenship, which supposedly they are not doing now.

There seems to be some confusion.

 

Being or not being a citizen has no bearing on anything other than eligibility to be president. What else? Sure as shit has nothing to do with buying a gun.

 

Here's my FID, passed NICS and money. Have a nice day.

 

Again, they may as well ask sexual orientation or religion.

 

I don't get the reasoning or anyone accepting a corporation asking random irrelevant questions. Or government for that matter.

 

To be clear, I won't shop there. I made my choice. The issue is that complying or not making a stink is tacit approval for convenience's sake.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Not to stir anything up, but I just went to Dicks on Rt. 22 and spoke with both an associate and a manager. Out of curiousity, I asked them if their store policy has changed, because I haven't purchased anything from that location since Sandy hit last Fall. Last fall, I purchased some home defense rounds with 110% no questions asked. I provided my license, FID, and was out of the door in 15 minutes.

 

Niether the manager or associate working in the hunting section had any idea what I was talking about. They said I would need a valid drivers license and FID to purchase guns or ammo. I could purchase accessories, gun safes, etc. without any form of ID. Knives would require me to show ID proving I'm of age.

 

Who exactly did you deal with? Because nobody in that store had any idea what I was talking about when I mentioned a proof of citizenship.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.