Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Issuing a notice of Subpoena?

Featured Replies

Good luck with that, keep us updated.

 

This is nuts... there is no discovery in NYC?

 

Question, if you are in NJ... will this even come over?  Or isn't this the most that can come over is 2 points... and the first 2 points in NJ don't count with most insurance company for rates.

  • Author

Traffic court in NYC is Administrative. The presiding judges have no authority to issue a subpoena.

 

No video evidence can be presented and there are no tv's or computer monitors to present evidence. The only evidence allowed is the ticket and the officer's notebook.

 

I don't want to have two points on my license at all, because there is always an opportunity to get in this mess again, random as it was.

 

What bugs me the most are the following:

 

This judgement is accepted by insurance companies as being truth and rates are adjusted accordingly.

 

I have to present my case first and then the officer, who will be present, can respond by saying "that's not what I saw" and I have nothing to show otherwise.

 

The fact that my lawyer (i called him because I wanted to file the motion for discovery) told me that because NYC traffic court is run this way the best defense is to postpone over and over again so that the officer forgets things and trip him up. And that hearing my side of it will make him remember things, so he advises I don't speak in court or even be present.

 

The owner of the law firm is a former presiding judge at this same NYC traffic court, so how fu ked is that?

 

And most importantly is that for all 8 video cameras that taped me that day and the fact that this is a ticket for something that did NOT happen, I am forced to pay a lawyer to do the tap dance for me, and that tap dance looks no different from some scumbag just trying to get out of something he actually did.

 

If I got to pay a lawyer for this then I am putting the story out there with my video given to me by the port authority.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Yep, the NYC kangaroo traffic courts (if you want to call them courts) are run this way because it is a for profit business for the city. There is no presumption of innocence. They don't have to prove beyond a reasonable doubt anything. You are not entitled to supporting evidence. No evidence is even needed to prove guilt. Due process be damned. The judge works for the same people as the prosecutor. In fact they don't even hold any valid jurisdiction. Welcome to legal land. You don't even get one Mickey Mouse hat.

Great.  I got all the footage I need from the Freedom of Information act.  Video proof.  Just no court to show it in.

 

:banghead:

Can you convert the video to a dozen still images and submit that as evidence?

  • Author

It is due process within the limits of the court's jurisdiction.

 

Awesome, ain't it?

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Thinking outside the box with a radical suggestion - directly contact the officer who issued the ticket if you believe he has any sense of ethics/justice and show him the video evidence.  Perhaps he might decide not to testify on NYC's behalf, or even testify against NYC's case.

 

If the situation is as you describe it doesn't sound like you have anything to lose by attempting it.

Maybe Arnold Diaz, Shame Shame Shame guy can help you ;)

  • Author

I had thought about that earlier. You're right, the video might make a difference. It could make it worse too. The officer was not one of those asshole cops. He was just wrong. In fact he was being very nice about it. He only gave me the ticket because he thought I was straight out lying to him in the face of something he believes he saw. And he had a partner in the car with him.

 

 

Wrong to the point that he truly believes he saw me do something that did not happen. Convincing HIM might be the hardest part. Other people not so much.

 

Maybe I should consider sending it to the prosecutor. Now I have an atty though so who knows. All of this still pisses me of because if I had a window broken I could have used the evidence in civil court, but a ticket? No chance.

 

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Getting a guilty verdict in NYC traffic court is very difficult. There is this whole long list of facts that must be presented to get a guilty plea. If you go listen to the testimony of a highway cop and you will see what I mean. It basically a script. It sucks

Getting a guilty verdict in NYC traffic court is very difficult. There is this whole long list of facts that must be presented to get a guilty plea. If you go listen to the testimony of a highway cop and you will see what I mean. It basically a script. It sucks

 

In Staten Island, the conviction rate is very high. In the other boroughs, he has a better chance. The script explains it all and explains nothing at the same time.

  • Author

Getting a guilty verdict in NYC traffic court is very difficult. There is this whole long list of facts that must be presented to get a guilty plea. If you go listen to the testimony of a highway cop and you will see what I mean. It basically a script. It sucks

I don't understand what you mean by a guilty "plea". Do you mean verdict?

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

  • Author

Some quick answers.  but first I want to point out that I am so angry about this at times I might be missing some information.  so here is the best I ahve based on shopping around to three different attorneys

 

A solid 90% of those that defend themselves in NYC traffic court fail and are found guilty because they think it works like that on television.

 

It might be tough for some cops to go throught the "script" but those are the ones being questioned by lawyers.

 

Wriiten evidence is all that is allowed and so are witnesses.  So technically more than just the ticket and the notebook are allowed, but how many people can provide written evidence that they did not run a red light?

 

The written evidence I have right now is that I asked for the video through the freedom of information act and I received a written response from the Port Authority along with a DVD.  This, as far as my lawyer is concerned, is unprecidented.  He has never seen PA video from the tunnel.

 

The video is not great but my 22 year old POS car is VERY distinctive in the video and has me in a place that makes it impossible to be where the offiecer said I was, but this all would have to be explained with a map.  The freakin' camera right over the intersection doesn't record anything.  (http://nyctmc.org/multiview2.php select 9th ave and 30th st. then "view")

 

Anyway, as I write this the anger boils up, so I am ending this one abruptly.

  • Author

That may well be what happens.  however the attorneys have a quiver of things that they throw at them all at the ready and the tried and true by the guys that know might make all of that mute.   I am just pissed off that it cost me money, one way or the other.

 

They already took a court date in January because by that time even if there is no delay and found guilty the points will be on record for the shortest amount of time save for further continuances.  Continuances are expected from my side simply to lessen the impact/duration of points on the license. 

 

As for as your earlier question about carrying over ( I asked him this afternoon), my atty says that he could never answer with 100% certainty ; "imagine how many thousands of policies can be written for tens of thousands of people."  Then he asked me not to ask my insurance company directly because they can decide that is enough to raise my rate.. 

 

Fun.......not...

Do they allow for pictures (screenshots from the video)? That is probably real evidence that would actually be both applicable and prove it one way or the other...so I'm guessing not. 

 

Just learning about how this tribunal works makes me bad, and I'm not even the one involved! Legalized extortion...

Could you show the video to a bunch of people and have them all show up as witnesses. "I saw "bulpup" on the day of question minutes or seconds before he got pulled over on this road which makes it imposible for him to have done what that officer said he did." It's not lying because if they watched the video they did see you on that road shortly before you got pulled over.

  • Author

Could you show the video to a bunch of people and have them all show up as witnesses. "I saw "bulpup" on the day of question minutes or seconds before he got pulled over on this road which makes it imposible for him to have done what that officer said he did." It's not lying because if they watched the video they did see you on that road shortly before you got pulled over.

I can't imagine that actually working. Frankly that would fall on the wrong side of a line in my moral compass.

 

The thing is, with what I am limited to presenting, the lawyer's delay tactics actually sounds like the safest bet. Which, I say again, also pisses me the F' off!

 

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

can I ask what the lawyers delay tactics will do or how they will help?

Can't you get a professional witness to describe the evidence of the videotape?

  • Author

The points are only good on the license for a certain number of months after the date of the ticket, not the court date.  So if it goes bad for me they don't stay on as long.  It also servers to lessen the officer's memory, we hope.  For all that I have to say, if the guy says "well that's an interesting story, but I absolutely saw him turn off ninth avenue,"  then I am hosed.  He also had a partner in his car and who knows if he will be there.  Lots of variables so hedging the bets is prudent.

 

As far as a professional witness, I might be allowed but I would rather not incur that expense on top of the lawyer.  I am still learning all this so I might be wrong on all of it, but since the video can't be shown and creativity might not have the odds in its favor, I am choosing to listen to my lawyer and get better odds or lessen the damage.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.