Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Police confiscate guns, NO ARREST/NO CHARGES FILED... wtf?!?

Featured Replies

Every time I look at a firearms/police related story, the cops are always in the wrong, or perilously close to it. I'm not bashing cops (which I know is a no-no here), but in 9 out of 10 stories in the last 6 months... if the shoe fits...

 

 

http://www.dailyherald.com/article/20130609/news/706099896/

 

 

Arthur Lovi is suing the Arlington Heights police for what he says was an illegal search of his home and seizing of three antique guns, including a double barrel musket that's more than 100 years old.

 

This isnt about cops- its about a new healthcare system with electronic records, new regulations to report on you, and a director of homeland security who sees American vets as the face of terrorism. Lots of people will not be seeking help because they fear this reporting, and the ones who open their mouths will be inviting that late night knock on the door.

I am sure the doctor reported his threats and also stated that he was angry and depressed. This might lead to him hurting himself or others. That's why they confiscated them. It may not be right but unfortunately we live in the CYA era.

To add to what BLF is saying about CYA. I don't think it's always the cops personal desire as much as what's coming down from the top or what they are afraid will roll down hill (in their direction) if they aren't doing this stuff. A good percentage of the cops I personally know think the anti hysteria is ridiculous but they also need a pay check to feed their families. At the same time though, most of them don't know jack about firearms laws at a granular level.

  • Author

I don't think these stories are showing the wrong actions of INDIVIDUAL cops, per se...  they are showing the wrong actions of the POLICE.  As in moving closer to a police state.

 

And I understand they are just "doing their job", but when your "job" requires actions that are constitutionally wrong, that excuse will only go so far... you won't be winning any popularity contests thats for sure.

 

I think LEOs are going to find themselves increasingly in the waters other union members are in- such as teachers for example- where their "organization" (be it their union, their bosses, or whatever) are actually their own worst enemy. 

People have to understand this. Police are made up of members of the public. Most cops are not gun guys. When it not one of your interests it's not a big deal to you. We see that all the time. If it doesn't personally affect people they could care less. If you don't care about it then your allegiance is to the law. If the law says something is illegal then as a cop you act. It's pretty simple and it's not personal

Honest question BLF....what about all the situations where the authorities act on something that is NOT illegal?

Specifically in Delaware, there are a lot of open carry individuals who continually get harassed, and the LEO's clearly don't know the law. What is one supposed to believe in a situation like that?

 

One man was handcuffed, disarmed, ID taken and detained by the local PD until the SP arrived and informed them the man had done nothing wrong and to let him go.  

It's situations like that that give LEO's a bad rep. I understand the majority of cops are good people, but when you have a sizable portion who don't seem to know the law, and even worse don't seem to care....it creates a lot of animosity.

I dont know the laws in Deleware so i cant comment. I would have to see how the statutes are written plus how case law is decided to make a judgement.

I read the article, so here's my "take":

 

This is a classic example of over-reaction and trampling of Constitutional Rights.  It's a case of preventing something that probably wasn't going to happen, just so "we can say that we did something".  This old Vet had old antiques up on his wall, NOT a safe loaded with AR's and high-cap mags.  The Wife's Doctor (who mis-diagnosed) was contacted and said he felt fine, and not in any danger.  So it should have been left right there.  NO history of miss-use, NO history of aggressiveness towards others, just a lonely old vet letting-off some steam about a missed diagnosis that wouldn't have had a different outcome due to the timing (which is in the article), so the old Vet KNOWS the Wife's Doctor isn't really to blame, he just doesn't like the situation as a whole.  Second Doctor (Shrink) goes into full-report mode, so Cops do their due-diligence (as they HAVE TO) and pay a visit to the old Vet.  

 

Here's where this went-off the rails:

 

Old Vet's rights were violated because no due-process was initiated by the Cops.  NO crime had been committed, and upon inspection during the "voluntary seizure" none of the antiques were loaded and he didn't posses the means to load them (which will come-out in Court).  What SHOULD have immediately PRECEDED the illegal confiscation of personal property is a hearing before a Judge, or at the very least, a WARRANT signed by a Judge to go search for the means to carry-out a threat.  If no means existed, then the Cops preformed their function and kept society "safe", and they guy gets to have his antiques stay hanging on his walls.  Everybody's a$$es are covered, everybody "feels good", the public is protected from an antique collector who gets lonely and grumpy when he misses his Wife, and the world keeps on spinnin' the RIGHT way.......

 

What this world really needs is for some more Cops to become 3%'ers (Cops who will fight for the 2nd Amendment), and simply refuse to escalate obvious over-reaching/seizure activities.  Righteous independent thought (common sense) has to be allowed to enter into the equation, or this type BS will continue to plaque otherwise fine examples of good Cops doing great Police work.

That therapist broke the confidentiality. You are only supposed to report when you feel they are a danger to themselves or others. She stated she did not think so thus what she did was wrong. Terrible therapist.

 

An over reaction either way by the police as well.

I am sure the doctor reported his threats and also stated that he was angry and depressed. This might lead to him hurting himself or others. That's why they confiscated them. It may not be right but unfortunately we live in the CYA era.

 

"Don't look at me I'm just doing my job" like a good subject. 

So...when the mass shootings happen, we Second Amendment supporters rallied around the concept that it's not a gun problem, it's a mental health problem. When the powers that be respond to a potential mental health issue, by proactively interceding in confiscating the weapons of someone who might pose a danger to himself or others, we jump back up on our soap boxes and decry the same powers that be for taking action on the mental health front...so basically we know it's not a gun problem, it's a mental health problem, but we want them to figure out how to treat someone with a possible mental illness, while still maintaining that person's rights under the second amendment? FFS...

So...when the mass shootings happen, we Second Amendment supports rallied around the concept that it's not a gun problem, it's a mental health problem. When the powers that be respond to a potential mental health issue, by proactively interceding in confiscating the weapons of someone who might pose a danger to himself or others, we jump back up on our soap boxes and decry the same powers that be for taking action on the mental health front...so basically we know it's not a gun problem, it's a mental health problem, but we want them to figure out how to treat someone with a possible mental illness, while still maintaining that person's right to their second amendment? FFS...

 

We still want due process. 

They had no warrant, came in without his consent and took his guns. Didn't charge him with anything. Doesn't that seem blatantly unconstitutional to you? 

 

He went and got evaluated, came back clean. Went to ask for his guns back they kept stonewalling him. 

 

And FFS, it was a few antique muskets. Hardly weapons of terror. 

Tell that to the British...

I dont know the laws in Deleware so i cant comment. I would have to see how the statutes are written plus how case law is decided to make a judgement.

I'm not asking you to comment on the specific case....I'm asking how you feel about LEO's who act wrongly against the law, either knowingly or unwittingly, and how I hope you understand that a lot of animosity is fairly deserved.

 

Even though OC is legal here, I'm terrified of the day I encounter a LEO who either doesn't know what I'm doing is perfectly lawful, or simply doesn't agree with the law. I shouldn't have to feel that way.

That therapist broke the confidentiality. You are only supposed to report when you feel they are a danger to themselves or others. She stated she did not think so thus what she did was wrong. Terrible therapist.

 

An over reaction either way by the police as well.

 

 

agree....lawsuit happens against her too I'll bet

agree....lawsuit happens against her too I'll bet

And that lawsuit won't go anywhere. The Tarasoff precedent will likely cover the shrink

So...when the mass shootings happen, we Second Amendment supporters rallied around the concept that it's not a gun problem, it's a mental health problem. When the powers that be respond to a potential mental health issue, by proactively interceding in confiscating the weapons of someone who might pose a danger to himself or others, we jump back up on our soap boxes and decry the same powers that be for taking action on the mental health front...so basically we know it's not a gun problem, it's a mental health problem, but we want them to figure out how to treat someone with a possible mental illness, while still maintaining that person's rights under the second amendment? FFS...

 

From the article:

 

After the session, Lovi's therapist was concerned. She called the Arlington Heights police to report he had made a threat against the first doctor who saw his wife.

She told them she didn't think he would carry it out or that he was dangerous to himself or others, but she just wanted to do her job and report it

 

According to an Arlington Heights police report, officers contacted the doctor who diagnosed the cold. The doctor told police he "did not feel like his safety was in immediate jeopardy."

 

Lovi, who is retired and whose son lives with him, told them yes, he had three antique firearms, including a musket that was more than 100 years old, but no ammunition.

 He says he's never fired any of the guns and wouldn't know how to even load the musket.

 

So the shrink didn't think he was a threat (though she called it in anyway?), the diagnosing doctor didn't think he was a threat.. and the vet had antiques with no ammo.

 

I don't think the shrink should have called it in.. it's blatant CYA'ism given that she also admits that she didn't think he was a threat.  Once that call is made, however, the PD has a duty to investigate.   If the article is to be believed that investigation also seems heavy handed.. again, if the article is true:

 

Lovi and his lawsuit, filed by lawyers at Chicago-based Meyer & Kiss LLC, say the officers entered his home without his consent and seized his three guns and FOID card. When Lovi asked if they had a warrant, he was told "they could go get a warrant and if he insisted they do that, they would come back and tear the (expletive) out of his house," according to the suit.

 

Two days later, Lovi called the police about his guns, and an officer came to his house. He says the officer turned the conversation to his late wife, and Lovi got upset. The officer determined he needed a psychiatric examination, but again, the two reports of the situation differ.

Lovi's suit alleges police threatened that if he didn't go into the ambulance willingly, they would handcuff him and physically put him in the ambulance.

Lovi says he went back to the Arlington Heights police station three more times to try to retrieve his guns and FOID card. On one trip, he was told he had to get a note from the original therapist, whom he was no longer seeing. Later he was told his FOID card had been sent to Springfield, which he later discovered was not true.

Two months later, Lovi hired a lawyer, which he found through his membership in the NRA. Shortly thereafter the Arlington Heights police returned his FOID card and the weapons, one of which he said was damaged.

 

At some point in this chain of events, the PD should have determined he was not a threat and returned his possessions.  Or determined that he was a threat and act/charge accordingly. 

Just the facts that the therapist didn't perceive a problem but was just doing her job when she made the call, and more importantly the fact that the police showed up at 11:00 PM in numbers says it all! 

 

This could have been handled completely different by the authorities.  What had occurred could actually have set this man off kilter if he had mental health issues.   This was an abuse of power by the state and part of the further conditioning and deterioration of our society.

Voyager 9's last comment

^^^^^THIS^^^^^!

 

I feel the same way!  There really isn't any other righteous way of interpreting these events as published.  Seems common sense was thrown-out the window in favor of more "feel-good"....

I tried to read the story, but I can't because the Daily Herald's marketing script goes to war with my internet security software.  Their script mad over 30+ attempts to embed marketing crap on my computer before I killed the page. 

Yep, the old CYA. Which of the Amendments that "limit" the gov'ts power to infringe upon our rights says they can just throw said rights out the window so they can "CYA"?

From the article:

 

So the shrink didn't think he was a threat (though she called it in anyway?), the diagnosing doctor didn't think he was a threat.. and the vet had antiques with no ammo.

 

I don't think the shrink should have called it in.. it's blatant CYA'ism given that she also admits that she didn't think he was a threat.  Once that call is made, however, the PD has a duty to investigate.   If the article is to be believed that investigation also seems heavy handed.. again, if the article is true:

 

 

At some point in this chain of events, the PD should have determined he was not a threat and returned his possessions.  Or determined that he was a threat and act/charge accordingly. 

Hey Brother,

I get your point, but liability is a damned if you do, and damned if you don't situation. If the Police had not insisted he be taken in for a review, but instead left him at home per his request, and he then committed suicide, who would have been at fault? Of course, they would have been held liable, specifically because they were advised by a trained professional in the mental health field of his duress, which he subsequently demonstrated on scene.

There seems to be a few who think that antique firearms are somehow not dangerous, or at least less so. Has anyone seen the pictures of the firearms carried by the most recent nit wit who went on a shooting spree at the PD in Calif.? The pistol carried was black powder. The "lack of ammunition" is a non starter as is the "wouldn't know how to load it" comment. In Jersey, as I'm sure you already know, "antique" firearms are still considered firearms.

Enter in also the lack of real information from the article, the conflicting reports about the mental stability of an individual who failed to control his emotions on at the very least the initial interview, much less the under reported future contacts, and it's easy to see why the PD chose to allow it to run it's course and force a Judge to return the firearms, thus placing the onus on the court and off the PD.

There's perfect world, morally right, and regrettably, reality. As much as we'd like them all to share the same space at the same time, the truth is, in many things they are exclusive. It's not about Cops trying to be heavy handed, or run a Police state, or whatever fallacy of logic floats to the top of the bowl this week. It's just about men and women who are regrettably all too familiar with what some would deem frivolous lawsuits and their associated complete break down of common sense, trying to get through a shift, day and career, with not only their mental and physical well being in tact, but also their financial well being. Yes, to a degree it was a case of CYA, but the Police Officers and Department didn't create it; they are simply forced to deal with it.

  • Author

"antique" has nothing to do with it. This whole episode is a classic example of giving up liberty for a little POSSIBLE security. I won't even get into the whole doctor-patient confidentiality thing.

 

Gun owners- ALL of them- need to understand, this isn't about antique weapons, assault rifles, or mental health- it's about confiscation. Period. In the end, they WILL come for yours.

 

 

 

First they came for the communists,
and I didn't speak out because I wasn't a communist.

Then they came for the socialists,
and I didn't speak out because I wasn't a socialist.

Then they came for the trade unionists,
and I didn't speak out because I wasn't a trade unionist.

Then they came for me,
and there was no one left to speak for me.

 
 
...first they came for the "machine guns"...
 
...then they cam for the high-capcity magazines and "assault rifles"...
 
...then they came for all semi-automatic weapons...
 
...then they cam for anything holding over 6 rounds...
 
...then they came for all the handguns...
 
...then they came for all the long guns that were left...

All good points and arguments, however the Government intrusion from the federal level to the local level is completely out of control.! From lying dirtbag presidents to the local mayor they all have GOD syndrome.

  Personally i think its time for "The People" to grow some nuts and stand up against the abuse of power from every level of government and law enforcement, Just like Mr Lovi..

Leave me alone to live my life, as long as im not hurting anyone stay the f out of my life

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.