Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Supreme Court takes up straw purchase conviction case

Featured Replies

Related to straw purchase and buying a gun for somebody. Interesting read and basically brings up a post somebody made. In the end, we are responsible for our actions not the gun shops.

 

http://www.breitbart.com/Big-Government/2013/10/20/Supreme-Court-Takes-Gun-Rights-Case-on-Convicted-Policeman

  • Replies 79
  • Views 5.9k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

They took up this case the same day that they denied cert for the carry case in Maryland...

He really did break the law though. There isn't a gray area.

 

Too bad, if it were medicinal marijuana good ol Barack would probably pardon him.

What a joke. I can't argue that he broke the law but when you realize that he is facing federal time for what actually occurred it is a complete joke.

He really did break the law though. There isn't a gray area.

 

Too bad, if it were medicinal marijuana good ol Barack would probably pardon him.

 

Well yeah, of course he "broke the law" which is why this case exists.

 

But his uncle was not a prohibited person, so the spirit and intent of the law wasn't broken.

 

All he wanted to do was get a Glock for his uncle at the blue label price, not buy a gun for a felon to commit a crime or anything. 

 

I buy stuff for people all the time. Not guns because of the straw purchase thing, but I buy for people who can't get it where they live (out of the country) or because they don't have a credit card, or I have to use a club membership like Costco to buy the particular item. 

  • Author

I apologize if this was previously posted. Miss please close if this is a duplicate.

 

He broke the law but it seems like they are going to make an example out of him.

I am interested in this case because if Abramski wins it would mean that you can now truly buy firearms as gifts. That would be nice. Nothing like a glock or an AR under the christmas tree. 

Trying to find the link where I read this a couple of days ago, cant find it at the moment.  The article I read discussed that the main issue in this case is that the ATF/DOJ broadened the scope of the "straw purchase" law beyond what was passed by legislators.

 

As passed, the law prohibited buying a firearm and then giving it to a *PROHIBITED PERSON*.  It did not prohibit buying a firearm with the intent to give to a family member or other person who was otherwise eligible to possess it.

 

It was the ATF/DOJ who, on their own initiative, expanded the law to prohibit any transfer, whether the recipient was a prohibited person or not.

 

That's why the SC is taking this up - to review whether federal agencies can reinterpret and expand legislation as they see fit.

I am interested in this case because if Abramski wins it would mean that you can now truly buy firearms as gifts. That would be nice. Nothing like a glock or an AR under the christmas tree. 

Not that it's the end all, be all, but the instructions on 4473 says that you are allowed to buy it as a gift, so long as you don't have knowledge of the receiver of the gift as being a prohibited person. The example the instructions give implies that there is an issue when the person getting the gift pays the person who is buying it.

yet Eric Holder runs free..............................  :banghead:

Touche!

This sounds to me like an ATF agent who can't find a real criminal and US Attorney's office with too much time on their hands. Moreso as the guy bought it from a FFL in VA and transferred the gun to his uncle via a FFL in PA.

This sums it up nicely:

If Abramski purchased the gun on his own, then decided to give it to his uncle as a free gift, that would be legal. Or if Abramski bought it for himself, then the following week decided to sell it to his uncle, that would be legal. But because his uncle wrote him a check for the gun before Abramski went to the store to buy the gun, and thus was acting as his uncle’s agent to buy a gun, Abramski became a federal felon.

 

So the date the check was written is what makes this act illegal.  How did the ATF know this?  Did they just notice that the same serial number was on two different 4473 Forms very close together?

 

I have to wonder:  What was the Police discount?  After two FFL transfers and fees it couldn't have been much of a difference.

It was a Glock 19 for which his uncle wrote him a $400 check.

Figuring a $25 transfer fee at the PA FFL, he saved his uncle $75-$100.

 

EDIT: On gen 3 guns, you also got an extra magazine with the blue label Glock. Not sure about gen 4 (they already come with 3 mags, maybe you get a 4th?)

 

EDIT II: Though I don't think it's legally binding, it should be mentioned that at the time of purchase the buyer agrees, in exchange for the discount, that the gun is for personal use, not resale.

So, on balance, while I don't think he should have gotten a felony conviction (question 11a should be limited to buying for a prohibited person) he was, at the very least, dishonest. He lied on the ATF form and he lied to get the discount and got jammed up just to save a few dollars.

 

I hope SCOTUS rules in his favor, but still, it was a dumb/greedy move.

 

And FYI. you CAN purchase as a gift. Just have to jump through all the legal hoops to transfer (COE/P2P etc).

Not that it's the end all, be all, but the instructions on 4473 says that you are allowed to buy it as a gift, so long as you don't have knowledge of the receiver of the gift as being a prohibited person. The example the instructions give implies that there is an issue when the person getting the gift pays the person who is buying it.

Oh nice. Wonder how that would work in NJ though.

Oh nice. Wonder how that would work in NJ though.

You answer yes to question 11a (are you the actual buyer).

If both NJ residents, you transfer the same as a private sale (minus the $): FID, COE, P2P if it's a handgun.

Out of state, it goes through a FFL I'm the recipient's home state and follows whatever rules that state has.

If course in NJ (for a handgun) that just seems like a waste of a permit. I'd just give him/her a gift card.

If this was  NJ, as a government employee he would also be guilty of violating the states ethics laws on using his official position to gain a benefit. That benefit being the discount price of the gun.  just google NJ ethics laws and you will see, I feel this is no different than a shooting range or any other business offering a "law enforcement" discount.   Any government employee who accepts the same is guilty.    Of course you will only be targeted if  (a.)  the person targeting you can gain a promotion, or (b.) your on the S@ list with your department.

Under a strict reading of the ethics rules, that would be correct. The State had a zero tolerance policy when it comes to gifts, services or anything of value given to a state employee (including discounts) when such gifts are in anyway related to their official duties.

That would apply to Glock's blue label program.

Under a realistic reading, I don't think it's ever happened.

Seems like a very expensive way to save $100..........

 

Nonetheless, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit in Richmond (with jurisdiction over the Mid-Atlantic states) agreed with two other federal appeals courts in holding that when Abramski checked the box affirming he was the purchaser, he committed a serious federal crime.

 

If Abramski purchased the gun on his own, then decided to give it to his uncle as a free gift, that would be legal. Or if Abramski bought it for himself, then the following week decided to sell it to his uncle, that would be legal. But because his uncle wrote him a check for the gun before Abramski went to the store to buy the gun, and thus was acting as his uncle’s agent to buy a gun, Abramski became a federal felon.

 

Ooooooo, a "serious" crime.  Well, I feel safer. 

 

What kind of jury convicted this man?  Everyones a zombie.

 

Jury nullification FFS.

 

Howd "they" even know?  There must be a ton of transfers between MD and PA. 

If course in NJ (for a handgun) that just seems like a waste of a permit. I'd just give him/her a gift card.

 

Problem is you won't get the blue label discount. 

After browsing thru the above link its noted in the comment section by the guys dad that the evidence about the transfer(gun reciept/info) was found in a bank bag a search of his house resulting from hearsay accusations about him robbing a bank. Didnt matter that his wife got the bag(s) when working there and didnt match the wanted bag......This poor bastard is being victomized by a lot of mouth diarhea. He may be guilty of something but so far all it is is hearsay. This whole story is messed up.

Why don't people use cash to do something like this?  The "pre dated" and already cashed check, before the original purchase date, is what will get him in trouble. 

 

Cash money guys, cash money.  Don't write checks for private firearms sales....

I thought his uncle was paying him for mowing the yard and chagning the oil in his car................

Why don't people use cash to do something like this?  The "pre dated" and already cashed check, before the original purchase date, is what will get him in trouble. 

 

Cash money guys, cash money.  Don't write checks for private firearms sales....

 

Even so, there are no private handgun sales in PA. Every handgun sale must go through a FFL. 

I thought his uncle was paying him for mowing the yard and chagning the oil in his car................

Fully agree, my first thought as well after I read that article.

Unless this guy used that particular check from his uncle as a third party check to actually pay for a gun, I don't see how the exact purpose of writing this check could be proven...

And why not say "I bought Glock 19, tried it once. Quickly realized that it's too small for my hand. Decided to sell it asap to my uncle. Went to him the next day and did the sale". End of story? or not?

If this was  NJ, as a government employee he would also be guilty of violating the states ethics laws on using his official position to gain a benefit. That benefit being the discount price of the gun.  just google NJ ethics laws and you will see, I feel this is no different than a shooting range or any other business offering a "law enforcement" discount.   Any government employee who accepts the same is guilty.    Of course you will only be targeted if  (a.)  the person targeting you can gain a promotion, or (b.) your on the S@ list with your department.

 

With firearms and ammo, this IS different than an LEO discount as most of the time, the reduced LEO price excludes the excise tax n the firearm.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.