Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

FBI dumping .40 and going to a 9mm

Featured Replies

 

^This, all day.

 

http://www.adn.com/2009/08/13/897940/twig-snap-alerts-dog-walker-to.html

 

The slightest noise -- a twig snapping -- prompted Brush to glance over his shoulder. Less than 20 yards away, a brown bear was charging, "ears back, head low and motorin' full speed.

"Came with zero warning," Brush said. "No woof, no popping of the teeth, no standing up, nothing like what you think."

Brush said he wears a pistol on his walks because bears have chased his dogs in the past.

He drew a Ruger .454 Casull revolver. There was no time to aim, barely time to squeeze the trigger. He's not sure whether he got off two shots or three, but one proved fatal.

"Total luck shot," he said.

"It doesn't get any closer. He slid by me on his chin when I shot him," Brush said. "I was backpedaling as fast as I could. I wasn't even aiming. I tripped over my own feet as I pulled the trigger."

He estimated that the animal weighed 900-plus pounds, and was 15 to 20 years old.

 

that is an amazing story, that man should play the lottery!

  • Replies 213
  • Views 17.5k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

The purpose of that statute is probably to prevent people from baiting bear and shooting them.

I would tend to agree with this but as we know, intent of the law and its' application are 2 different things.

that is an amazing story, that man should play the lottery!

Yeah, then he can buy another pair of shorts...jeebus.

Yeah, then he can buy another pair of shorts...jeebus.

haha..no kidding....that man acted quickly and with resolve.  How many people would have fumbled the draw or panicked in that situation?  He's got a brass set for sure and I tip my hat to him.

 

You guys ought to read the states guidelines on what to do with a charging bear.  There is no way I'd do any of that as I'm sure I'd be shitting my pants too hard...lol  State says to talk in a monotone voice, don't run (most charges the bear stops or veers off), if attacked and knocked down, cover you neck and take the beating but if it lasts too long, then you fight back vigoruously....ha..no way, I'm going in with a shotgun with slugs that I trust to function 100%. 

One study indicates the average number of rounds fired in civilian defense situations is 2.2.  Same study indicates that ~50% of the encounters were at home. Shooting19 rounds of 9mm around the house or in public for that matter not a good idea (a person would probably cause much collateral damage). The idea is to end the fight and end it fast. 9mm magazine capacity is highly overated for real-life civilian encouters (it is good for shooting paper targets at USPSA though). I'll take the fatter bullets.

 

I never understood the "9mm sucks because it has too much capacity" argument. I don't need to shoot all 19 (or 15 for our purposes). If a person wants to gamble their lives on averages then that's their prerogative.

 

Sure, .45 ball has a track record of 100 years. So what? This is 2013 and I'm not limited by the Hague Convention. I'd rather be shooting a Hornady 135gr Critical Duty than a generic .45 ball which is the basis for that track record we hear so much about. It doesn't change ballistic data, and a 9mm hollow point is a sufficient and capable pistol cartridge. Of course a .45 will do more per bullet all other things being equal, but that's not the point. At the end of the day, we're talking pistols here and whether one pebble is slightly bigger than another misses the point that we're still talking about pebbles. I'd rather have 15 medium pebbles than 8 slightly-larger-but-still-medium-sized pebbles in my pocket (and I'd rather have a rifle over either).

  • Author

^^^ Yup well said!

 

Don't forget those "medium" pebbles are moving quite a bit faster than the "slightly-larger-but-still-medium-sized pebbles".

I never understood the "9mm sucks because it has too much capacity" argument. I don't need to shoot all 19 (or 15 for our purposes). If a person wants to gamble their lives on averages then that's their prerogative.

 

Sure, .45 ball has a track record of 100 years. So what? This is 2013 and I'm not limited by the Hague Convention. I'd rather be shooting a Hornady 135gr Critical Duty than a generic .45 ball which is the basis for that track record we hear so much about. It doesn't change ballistic data, and a 9mm hollow point is a sufficient and capable pistol cartridge. Of course a .45 will do more per bullet all other things being equal, but that's not the point. At the end of the day, we're talking pistols here and whether one pebble is slightly bigger than another misses the point that we're still talking about pebbles. I'd rather have 15 medium pebbles than 8 slightly-larger-but-still-medium-sized pebbles in my pocket (and I'd rather have a rifle over either).

If one feels the need to have extra rounds to hit your target, have at it and shoot your 135 grain HP. So far the Progressives haven't outlawed it - so in that sense it is a free country.

 

For some, who train well, and have the confidence that they can hit their target with 12 (yes, you may purchase several different 45s that hold 12 rounds) or even 8 they might shoot 230 grain HP.

 

Granted 135 can get the job done if you aim well, (hum, but then why does one need 19 rounds if they can aim well :nono: ); but anyone that wants to assert that a 9mm 135 grain HP will do the same damage as a 45 cal 230 grain HP is living at least temporarily with Dorothy in the land of OZ  :haha:  .

 

Toadett, Another thing you can try is the Grizzly-Bear test...I was amazed over the article posted  above of a person taking out a G-bear with 45 acp. Now, I knew it is a great PD round, but didn't think it could take out a G-bear - so I am very impressed...So take those 9mm 135 grain HP up to Alaska and see what they can do. If you come back (at all ;-)), I would be very impressed with the 9mm 135g HP :santablack: .

 

I make lite of this because as I stated in my original post, nobody wins a caliber discussion, too many variables, ingrained beliefs, biases, and individual tastes.

 

But in a rare civilian PD encounter I go with this one precept more than others: Use the biggest caliber you shoot well. -If it is 9mm for you Toadett, have at it.

So should I carry a Desert Eagle if I shoot .50AE well?

 

I also don't plan on shooting grizzly bears with my PPQ.

auto....so the 67yr old lady that killed a Grizzly with a .22 in 1953 kinda shoots (literally) what you said out the window........

auto....so the 67yr old lady that killed a Grizzly with a .22 in 1953 kinda shoots (literally) what you said out the window........

Rut, Merry Christmass...But I honestly havn't been able to follow a cohesive argument in your posts on this thread.

 

Like I said, shoot whatever you want. If you want to use a .22 for PD or Grizzlies ;-) for that matter, who am I to judge :-).

Rut, Merry Christmass...But I honestly havn't been able to follow a cohesive argument in your posts on this thread.

 

Like I said, shoot whatever you want. If you want to use a .22 for PD or Grizzlies ;-) for that matter, who am I to judge :-).

I made my point earlier and it's valid so not sure what you are talking about.  Then the discussion veered to Grizzlies to which I posted factual information, again not sure what you are referring too.

 

my point on the .22 was in response to what you posted about 9s in Alaska.  You referenced the .45 and then proceeded to jest at the 9mm.  I merely pointed out that a 67yr old woman killed a Grizzly with a .22 and as I said earlier, there are outliers in everything

 

Merry Christmas to you too and God Bless!

not said as dic by the way, no tone comes across on these boards::))

I made my point earlier and it's valid so not sure what you are talking about.  Then the discussion veered to Grizzlies to which I posted factual information, again not sure what you are referring too.

 

my point on the .22 was in response to what you posted about 9s in Alaska.  You referenced the .45 and then proceeded to jest at the 9mm.  I merely pointed out that a 67yr old woman killed a Grizzly with a .22 and as I said earlier, there are outliers in everything

 

Merry Christmas to you too and God Bless!

Yea, but you are comparing a rifle with pistols (we have been taking about pistols all along). There is a big difference. And do we know what kind of .22 round it was? That makes a difference also. Obviously, Granny was a great shot under stress planting 7 rounds in the Grizzly's head. Kudos, to Granny, no matter what she shot, but we want to stack the deck in our favor for PD. For some that is smaller but more rounds; for others it is fewer fatter rounds. Different strokes - this could go on forever. Thanks for the goodwishes :-).

So should I carry a Desert Eagle if I shoot .50AE well?

 

I also don't plan on shooting grizzly bears with my PPQ.

Always count on you for good logic:  I would always make that trade-off: if I shot a 9mm and a .50AE equally well, to pick the 9mm in a PD siuation. ;-)

Yea, but you are comparing a rifle with pistols (we have been taking about pistols all along). There is a big difference. And do we know what kind of .22 round it was? That makes a difference also. Obviously, Granny was a great shot under stress planting 7 rounds in the Grizzly's head. Kudos, to Granny, no matter what she shot, but we want to stack the deck in our favor for PD. For some that is smaller but more rounds; for others it is fewer fatter rounds. Different strokes - this could go on forever. Thanks for the goodwishes :-).

sorry but you've been drinking too much egg nog as that is not what I've been doing.  When discussing the pistol calibers, I referenced that.  I made a point that a few people in this thread commented on liking early on.  Then the discussion veered to Grizzlys and the natural .45 crowd (.45 can kill Zeus) needed a little education.

It occurs to me that as subjects of the Citizen Disarmament Republic of New Jersey (CDRNJ™), this whole discussion is purely academic for most of us, since we ain't carrying a damn thing.

For federal LE, going to modern 9mm HP ammo from .40S&W (the original point of the thread), seems like 6 of one, half a dozen of the other.

Meaning that the decision probably had little to do with ballistics and is likely based mainly on some other reason(s).

It occurs to me that as subjects of the Citizen Disarmament Republic of New Jersey (CDRNJ™), this whole discussion is purely academic for most of us, since we ain't carrying a damn thing.

For federal LE, going to modern 9mm HP ammo from .40S&W (the original point of the thread), seems like 6 of one, half a dozen of the other.

Meaning that the decision probably had little to do with ballistics and is likely based mainly on some other reason(s).

agree....

For our purposes (HD in most cases) if you're using a handgun you've already failed.

sorry but you've been drinking too much egg nog as that is not what I've been doing.  When discussing the pistol calibers, I referenced that.  I made a point that a few people in this thread commented on liking early on.  Then the discussion veered to Grizzlys and the natural .45 crowd (.45 can kill Zeus) needed a little education.

Again, honestly, you are all over the place not following your train of thought at all...Good luck to you and your egg nog.

Again, honestly, you are all over the place not following your train of thought at all...Good luck to you and your egg nog.

Lol

Again, honestly, you are all over the place not following your train of thought at all...Good luck to you and your egg nog.

lol, you are the one not following but that's ok....

Lol

even worse for you since you can't quote and articulate a argument with what was written.  I see you are not gonna admit to being wrong but that's ok

If one feels the need to have extra rounds to hit your target, have at it and shoot your 135 grain HP. So far the Progressives haven't outlawed it - so in that sense it is a free country.

 

 

For some, who train well, and have the confidence that they can hit their target with 12 (yes, you may purchase several different 45s that hold 12 rounds) or even 8 they might shoot 230 grain HP.

 

 

Granted 135 can get the job done if you aim well, (hum, but then why does one need 19 rounds if they can aim well :nono: ); but anyone that wants to assert that a 9mm 135 grain HP will do the same damage as a 45 cal 230 grain HP is living at least temporarily with Dorothy in the land of OZ  :haha:  .

 

Here's the point:

 

Pistol calibers suck.

 

.45 ACP sucks slightly less than 9mm.

 

This is not about my needing to compensate for low accuracy (that is not the case). Capacity is never a bad thing and I'd rather have more capacity than slightly better "punch", especially when shot placement matters equally for both rounds. I'd also rather have improved recoil properties.

 

79810d1382635613-9mm-vs-40-vs-45-acp-ima

even worse for you since you can't quote and articulate a argument with what was written. I see you are not gonna admit to being wrong but that's ok

That's because it's not worth arguing with keyboard commandos on the internet. I quoted you just fine. Good enough to prove my point. Once I proved my point there is no reason to continue.

That's because it's not worth arguing with keyboard commandos on the internet. I quoted you just fine. Good enough to prove my point. Once I proved my point there is no reason to continue.

no you didn't, apparently reading difficult for you

 

internet commando...lol   ok sport, whatever you say

huh?  this is what I said, 'One interesting note, if you do not secure your food, trash, or lodging per state wildlife rules and a bear becomes aggressive, you cannot legally kill it in Alaska."   You must be a democrat with only partial quotes...lol

 

what part of if you negligently attract a bear and it results in it's death that it's illegal to kill it are you not getting?  It's pretty black and white.  I don't know what the penalty is but the law is the law.  You leave trash around or some other stupid careless act that attracts a bear resulting in it's death, it's an illegal kill.

 

everything I've said is factual here.

2A....in case you're challenged on using the back function as well.  Should I post what your quote was as well so that you see the difference again? 

 

mind you, you only used this portion of the quote, 'I was right. In your original statement you said "and a bear becomes aggressive, you cannot legally kill it in Alaska".    Do you UNDERSTAND the difference?

 

Son, going through life always thinking you are right when you are demonstrably shown to be wrong is not a good thing.  You must be a joy for the wife

Completely off the general topic, but as a last resort, you can shoot a grizzly/brown bear in self-defense in Alaska, only you need to surrender the skull and hide to authorities after the investigation. Even Alaskan F&G recommends the .44 Mag. as an appropriate handgun caliber for bear defense. Proper rifle calibers or a 12 ga. shotgun are preferred. 

http://www.adfg.alaska.gov/index.cfm?adfg=livingwithbears.bearcountry

 

 

  • 2 weeks later...

With LE transitioning to 9mm, police and military become ammunition compatible and can share their ammunition when they work together. Think about that for a while.....

 

Sent from my SCH-I535 using Tapatalk

Except such a situation has never happened.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.