Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Update on Right to Carry appeals case, Almeida Vs. Sussex Co.

Featured Replies

All those numbers are dandy, but the reality is far from it. Good percentage of that final number is simply NOT 2A proponents. They are firearm owners for the convenience of hunting, hate concealed carry, hate "assault weapons", like to "save children from the carnage".

 

Last I checked, the OP donation page gathered total of about $1400. I will challenge everyone again, forget 150,000, get 10000 people to donate $10 each to the cause and I will match that contribution. That will show how deeply NJ gun owners care about their rights. Enough to donate $10 to OP cause ?

Part of the problem is that people are afraid that Almeida will get his permit. I just can't even begin to deal with that reasoning. If he gets his permit the door is opened, even if it's just a little. But since Nappen is challenging on 2A grounds and SAF is picking up the case, it can be ruled in our favor.

 

Almeida did something extremely important already - he proved that the definition of justifiable need in the admin code is a complete and utter farce.

They can't even hide behind it now like they hid behind muller when they granted his permit. You can't tell me that someone who has been threatened by gang members with verifiable police threats doesn't have justifiable need.

 

If you guys had seen the plaintiffs for heller before the lawsuit even took off, the responses would have probably been similar. Dick heller was a special police officer. The plaintiffs in Drake - some were law enforcement.

 

We have to look at the bigger goals here and understand that sometimes it takes an extreme case to bring down the whole system.

  • Replies 264
  • Views 22.4k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • I do not blame the voters. My 2nd amendment incorporated rights should never be in the hands of the voters! I blame the legal system that contrives every way possible to deny me my rights!

  • Thank you Deer...there are very big changes in this case. Due to the lack of actions, and other shady dealings involving 2A leadership and lawyers in NJ, in order to protect backroom deals with the EO

  • ChrisJM981
    ChrisJM981

    I'd be very hesitant to contact an attorney for representation that doesn't file an appeal as discussed, and breaks off contact without even an indication of why. Imagine if it was a criminal case?

Part of the problem is that people are afraid that Almeida will get his permit. I just can't even begin to deal with that reasoning. If he gets his permit the door is opened, even if it's just a little. But since Nappen is challenging on 2A grounds and SAF is picking up the case, it can be ruled in our favor.

We have to look at the bigger goals here and understand that sometimes it takes an extreme case to bring down the whole system.

All your suggestions, many very good ones, depend on wishin' and hopin' for a favorable judicial review. I somehow don't see that happening. Have there been any encouraging signs? Our gun laws have been in effect since the early 1920s. They have not been challenged successfully for 90 years. 

 

Heller is VERY different from what we have in NJ. Heller was about an outright ban. We don't have that, technically speaking, in NJ. We can buy handguns and keep them in our homes, which represents the Outer Limits of gun rights. Whoever concocted this legal fiction was a genius.

I provided for uncertainty at every step, to cover just about every contingency. I did not say 100% of the 1 million owners and 100% of their spouses. I know fully half the votes don't matter. By the end I was down to 250,000 total unused votes. I essentially threw 1 million putative votes into the garbage and my scenario still turned out great. 

 

What about non-gun owners who vote republican? Like my father has for the last 67 years. 

 

What I gather from your responses is that enough angry people never make a difference at the polls. That elections are bullshit, and that we will prevail if we only keep spending millions of dollars lecturing liberal judges about constitutional law, god-given rights, etc. Yesseree, that has worked great up to now.

 

May I introduce you to (soon to be former) Rep. Eric Cantor? He recently lost a primary challenge from a more conservative challenger, despite being way down in the polls and outspending his opponent 10:1. Enough angry people went to the polls and Cantor got trounced.

no as i stated i think your right and we need to win the polls also for change. but we cant give up the legislative fight. I was just pointing out i think the numbers are way less than your posting.I dont think there's nearly 1 million. And maybe half of that number is owners who bought 1 gun and it sits in a closet. So my opinion is just that the numbers are not as clear cut as you make it seem. But i agree about voting Ive voted since i was 18 every election.

no as i stated i think your right and we need to win the polls also for change. but we cant give up the legislative fight. I was just pointing out i think the numbers are way less than your posting.I dont think there's nearly 1 million. And maybe half of that number is owners who bought 1 gun and it sits in a closet. So my opinion is just that the numbers are not as clear cut as you make it seem. But i agree about voting Ive voted since i was 18 every election.

The question is, given limited resources, do we continue to follow strategies that have not worked, or do we try something different? You guys will continue to buy into the NJ2AS, NJARPC, NRA, etc., etc. bullshit that we can win in the courts. Good luck. By the time you realize the only way to win is to elect the right people, the Lawn Ornament-in-Chief will have flooded our state with so many Mexicans it won't matter. It's happening now. Continue sitting on your fat asses, eating chips and drinking beer. Rouse up the absentee ballots that are never counted. C'mon guys, keep it going. BRILLIANT.

 

And don't forget to keep complaining. That's been remarkably successful as well. Don't forget to send Fois Gras a nice email today. Call his secretary. Be mean! Tell her about God and Constitution. Angels flying around and all that. Tell her what James Madison really, really, really fukcen meant. Yeah! Call him every day until July 7. 

 

Then, donate $$$ like I stupidly did today to court challenges. YEAH!

 

But don't get off your fat fukcen asses and vote. That's for chumps. 

Part of the problem is that people are afraid that Almeida will get his permit. I just can't even begin to deal with that reasoning. If he gets his permit the door is opened, even if it's just a little. But since Nappen is challenging on 2A grounds and SAF is picking up the case, it can be ruled in our favor.

 

Almeida did something extremely important already - he proved that the definition of justifiable need in the admin code is a complete and utter farce.

They can't even hide behind it now like they hid behind muller when they granted his permit. You can't tell me that someone who has been threatened by gang members with verifiable police threats doesn't have justifiable need.

 

If you guys had seen the plaintiffs for heller before the lawsuit even took off, the responses would have probably been similar. Dick heller was a special police officer. The plaintiffs in Drake - some were law enforcement.

 

We have to look at the bigger goals here and understand that sometimes it takes an extreme case to bring down the whole system.

 

I agree with you. And I agree with Newtonian partly. We just have to continue to explore ALL avenues. If  old blood moves out of NJ, there has to be new blood to continue the fight for the good cause. What I am debate is around the real number of people who really care. Most of us here are overestimating that number.

 

We need to donate and keep legal pressure while working the political angle in parallel. 

The question is, given limited resources, do we continue to follow strategies that have not worked, or do we try something different? You guys will continue to buy into the NJ2AS, NJARPC, NRA, etc., etc. bullshit that we can win in the courts. Good luck. By the time you realize the only way to win is to elect the right people, the Lawn Ornament-in-Chief will have flooded our state with so many Mexicans it won't matter. It's happening now. Continue sitting on your fat asses, eating chips and drinking beer. Rouse up the absentee ballots that are never counted. C'mon guys, keep it going. BRILLIANT.

 

And don't forget to keep complaining. That's been remarkably successful as well. Don't forget to send Fois Gras a nice email today. Call his secretary. Be mean! Tell her about God and Constitution. Angels flying around and all that. Tell her what James Madison really, really, really fukcen meant. Yeah! Call him every day until July 7.

 

Then, donate $$$ like I stupidly did today to court challenges. YEAH!

 

But don't get off your fat fukcen asses and vote. That's for chumps.

 

I dont think you understand, we cannot give up one end of the battle to fight another. You have to do both. You can't say let's all focus on voting only because what happens when we don't win the elections and give up the legal fights? Then we lose, we wont have a leg to stand on and we'll be worse off than we are now. As I said I always vote I think it's important to vote and agree with you about winning there. But we cannot stop the legal fight because then we will lose. And as I stated several times I don't believe the number of caring gun owners willing to vote solely on that issue is anywhere near what you estimate. Plus you need to figure out how many that care already vote? Which is likely almost all of them and if that's the case we do not have the numbers. We need to get more people involved in the sport. And not just involved as in going to the range one time. Involved as we are. As emotional about it as all of us. Last year we had it handed to us with all the law that passed but luckily Christie vetoed. And the upcoming election I think what 1 senator got the boot and a few assemblyman? If the gun owners who "care" didn't vote then, then it's official that means they don't care.

Exactly. The fight in the courts is NOT over with yet. There is still Peruta hanging over California and once that becomes final it could impact NJ.

These judges are criminals and traitors and should be dealt with as such by the People. Using the tools the Founders gave us, the 2nd Amendment.

 

Does anyone here think that if a state decided to limit or severely restrict their residents 1st, 4th, 5th, 6th, 7th or 8th Amendment protected rights that the SCOTUS would refuse to hear the case?

 

F*cking corrupt cowards.

I think the point about voting is a mixed one. I live in a Republican portion of Burlington county. My reps I believe are pro-2nd amendment. I do my part and vote in every election since I was 18. The problem lies within other democratic stongholds in the state. I do not live in a district that can get rid of Sweeney in the south, nor do I live in a district in the north that can get rid of Cryan, Sarlo, Lesniak, Weisnewski, Greenstein, et al. We have to target and focus our efforts into those areas. Educate the locals at churches, schools, malls, wherever that being a gun owner and having CCW in NJ does not make you bad person. Convince them to stop being victims and take back their streets and neighborhoods from gangs by protecting themselves because the police cannot always be there.

 

Conversely, we cannot give up the court battles either. They may take years to work there way through the legal system, but that is the fault of lawyers and judges.

Sweeney could have been gone.   His district is filled with hunters who don't really care very much about gun rights as long as it doesn't effect their hunting.  Most of my closest friends fall into this category.   They just had no idea that Sweeney had turned on them.  There was a plan to put up billboards that targeted hunters to let them know what had happened.  Funds were collected based on some preliminary billboard designs focused on "sportsmen".

 

After the funds were collected and there was enough to purchase multiple billboards, the plan changed to boring old, "support Niki Trunk" billboards.   Nothing mentioned about Sweeney's turning on gun owners and nothing targeting hunters and gun owners, just a smiling picture of his opponent.

 

I really believe that if an effort was made to reach out to hunters, Sweeney would not be in office now and a powerful message would have been sent to Trenton. We blew it and here we are facing more anti gun legislation and it will be that way year after year.

Sweeney could have been gone.   His district is filled with hunters who don't really care very much about gun rights as long as it doesn't effect their hunting.  Most of my closest friends fall into this category.   They just had no idea that Sweeney had turned on them.  There was a plan to put up billboards that targeted hunters to let them know what had happened.  Funds were collected based on some preliminary billboard designs focused on "sportsmen".

 

After the funds were collected and there was enough to purchase multiple billboards, the plan changed to boring old, "support Niki Trunk" billboards.   Nothing mentioned about Sweeney's turning on gun owners and nothing targeting hunters and gun owners, just a smiling picture of his opponent.

 

I really believe that if an effort was made to reach out to hunters, Sweeney would not be in office now and a powerful message would have been sent to Trenton. We blew it and here we are facing more anti gun legislation and it will be that way year after year.

 

Then we have a chance, come next year, to "recall" Sweeney. In Jan. 2015, he'll be eligible to be "recalled." It will take signatures of 25% of the voters in his 3rd district to validate a recall petition and get it on a ballot.  Hopefully, if CC vetoes A2006/S993, they'll think it unwise to re-introduce *this* year, again.

 

Are we up for it?

I dont think you understand, we cannot give up one end of the battle to fight another. You have to do both. You can't say let's all focus on voting only because what happens when we don't win the elections and give up the legal fights? Then we lose, we wont have a leg to stand on and we'll be worse off than we are now. As I said I always vote I think it's important to vote and agree with you about winning there. But we cannot stop the legal fight because then we will lose. And as I stated several times I don't believe the number of caring gun owners willing to vote solely on that issue is anywhere near what you estimate. Plus you need to figure out how many that care already vote? Which is likely almost all of them and if that's the case we do not have the numbers. We need to get more people involved in the sport. And not just involved as in going to the range one time. Involved as we are. As emotional about it as all of us. Last year we had it handed to us with all the law that passed but luckily Christie vetoed. And the upcoming election I think what 1 senator got the boot and a few assemblyman? If the gun owners who "care" didn't vote then, then it's official that means they don't care.

I'm not saying we should give up one for the other. However, the average forum poster is barely doing anything on either front. Maybe, like me, donating a few dollars. We're not actually in court, or footing the huge legal bills like the plaintiffs. Or having our lives disrupted. We just sit here posting.

 

Let the litigators litigate. But let's come up with some kind of plan for the next legislative elections, and target some of those vulnerable seats. THAT would actually be doing something. 

Today I was at the bullet hole and someone was outside handing out papers with the.number for Christies office and saying to tell them you oppose s993. We need to do this on a large scale. Election time, and for upcoming bills. Go to all ranges and hang out giving out flyers talking to people.

Today I was at the bullet hole and someone was outside handing out papers with the.number for Christies office and saying to tell them you oppose s993. We need to do this on a large scale. Election time, and for upcoming bills. Go to all ranges and hang out giving out flyers talking to people.

 

That's the right idea. 

 

Listen to GFH radio this week. We are on the show talking about what we need to do.

Ryan I planned on listening and am excited to hear it monday morning.

Today I was at the bullet hole and someone was outside handing out papers with the.number for Christies office and saying to tell them you oppose s993. We need to do this on a large scale. Election time, and for upcoming bills. Go to all ranges and hang out giving out flyers talking to people.

This is what has to be done. There are a lot of people out there that need to be led to water.

 

People complain about fuds, or antis, or whomever, but everybody overlooks the simple fact that there is a huge untapped potential out there and they have no idea what we could achieve if we tried or what might be about to happen to us if we don't fight back. Gun owners that could easily be encouraged into some meager support have no idea about any of the stuff we talk about here on a day to day basis.

 

I have a friend in PA that is politically active and works with his state rep regularly. He is in Harrisburg every year, at least once a year, and he and I have traveled around talking to legislators on gun issues on tours of their home offices as well. I was over his house today and he had no idea that Kane had changed all of our reciprocity agreements. THIS guy had no idea. The guy who is actually involved and actually shows up. But he knows she wouldn't prosecute Philly state House members that took bribes for political reasons.

 

The gun community is NOT NJGunforums. The low-hanging fruit has not been exploited hardly at all. It's not about the antis and it's not about the fuds that don't give a crap. It's about (a) the people in Jersey that don't realize guns are normal around the country and nobody died, and (b) the majority of gun owners in NJ that would be willing to help but have no idea what is going on.

 

Everybody complains about the people that want to hurt us or won't help us when we clearly haven't exploited our potential allies and educated the fence sitters.

This is what has to be done. There are a lot of people out there that need to be led to water.

 

People complain about fuds, or antis, or whomever, but everybody overlooks the simple fact that there is a huge untapped potential out there and they have no idea what we could achieve if we tried or what might be about to happen to us if we don't fight back. Gun owners that could easily be encouraged into some meager support have no idea about any of the stuff we talk about here on a day to day basis.

 

I have a friend in PA that is politically active and works with his state rep regularly. He is in Harrisburg every year, at least once a year, and he and I have traveled around talking to legislators on gun issues on tours of their home offices as well. I was over his house today and he had no idea that Kane had changed all of our reciprocity agreements. THIS guy had no idea. The guy who is actually involved and actually shows up. But he knows she wouldn't prosecute Philly state House members that took bribes for political reasons.

 

The gun community is NOT NJGunforums. The low-hanging fruit has not been exploited hardly at all. It's not about the antis and it's not about the fuds that don't give a crap. It's about (a) the people in Jersey that don't realize guns are normal around the country and nobody died, and (b) the majority of gun owners in NJ that would be willing to help but have no idea what is going on.

 

Everybody complains about the people that want to hurt us or won't help us when we clearly haven't exploited our potential allies and educated the fence sitters.

 

 

A thousand million billion percent this.

 

More to come, based on what we talked about today with Anthony and others. 

Today I was at the bullet hole and someone was outside handing out papers with the.number for Christies office and saying to tell them you oppose s993. We need to do this on a large scale. Election time, and for upcoming bills. Go to all ranges and hang out giving out flyers talking to people.

 

Chris,

 

Can I quote you on this? I want to spread this around. This is exactly what we need to be doing.

Ryan your more than welcome to quote me on it. But can you fix my grammatical errors. Was typed on the phone and don't want to look like an idiot. Just curious what do you plan on quoting it for?

Might want to add also that we need to get minority, inner city, and youth, college kids and early to mid twentys. Most people portray gun owners in nj as 60year old hunters. Im 25 and theres not that many other young shooters I see at a normal range trip.

Might want to add also that we need to get minority, inner city, and youth, college kids and early to mid twentys. Most people portray gun owners in nj as 60year old hunters. Im 25 and theres not that many other young shooters I see at a normal range trip.

 

Yes, that is part of the plan and actually one of the key reasons C4SNJ exists. 

Yea I know they are to aim for inner city's. But all over we need to get more younger people involved.

another strategy to employ is one the democrats have used successfully in the past,  That is to change party affiliation to "undeclared" and vote in the democratic primary and choose their candidate for them.    since the republican primary's really don't matter that much to us we can do more by keeping the democratic  incumbents out .   If in a democratic primary there is a challenger to an anti vote against the anti in the primary.      since all we do anymore is vote for the "lesser of two evils"  I don't see much harm being done to us.

I'm no expert but here is some advice I generally give people on these things:

 

- Not everybody is a champion. Don't bite off more than you can chew, or you'll stop being active. Do one thing that takes 5 minutes each week and one thing that takes an hour every month. Or something like that. Every little bit does count in this business.

 

- In order for you to count, you have to get two other people to count. Your minimum goal for every effort be it lobbying, phone calls and letters, or rallies is to convince two people to help and try to get them to do the same.

 

- Do try to do something to get a lot of people involved, such as delivering a pile of fliers to a gun range (that's where our best allies are found) or a gun store.

 

Make it simple for them to do something - have the email, phone, and mailing address for the likely representatives for the area on a sheet of paper and see if you can get the range to ask people to agree to make one phone call and send one email. Include some boilerplate text. I have gone as far as putting postage on envelopes with representative addresses and including a canned letter. For $30 and 2 hours of your time you can get 5 people engaged and 20 people to actually mail something and send an email.

 

Put a flyer on the corkboard, photograph it, email it to the area reps.

 

- Keep it short. I don't care if you have a PhD in literature, are a lawyer, and a NYT Best Seller. No staffer is going to read your page of pro-gun ramblings. They don't give a shit. They are just putting a tick mark on a piece of paper or in a computer. If you can say something impactful in 3 sentences you have a 5% chance of making a point with the staff and/or rep. If you can make it indisputable with a page of text your chances have gone down to 0.0000005% and you just spent an hour masturbating and didn't even climax. There is even a possibility your message won't be counted at all because it takes to long to figure out your position.

 

This applies to gun owners as well. You can get a lot more people to read 3 lines than a page.

Your not going to change the mind of an anti-gun/2A person any more than one of them will change your mind. And NJ is a liberal/dem/anti-gun state. And NOTHING is going to change that. I agree that it should be persued 100% no matter how unattainable. But I am with the group that wants to go the legal as the primary goal.... I think that's the best means to the end. Like I said           we have as much chance of changing a liberal duche bags way of thinking as they would with us.

 

PS   the people who don't have an opion on guns/2A aren't going to be swayed either ...... They don't give a damn about "our" rights or the antis "right to be safe" or what ever BS they are using...... No matter what either side pushes on them ..... They are going to persue and vote for the agenda be it jobs.... pensions.... don't let your dogs crap on my lawn or Chistie knew about Ft Lee and is in league Satin...... Like I said .... We need to fight in court!

 

Your not going to change the mind of an anti-gun/2A person any more than one of them will change your mind. And NJ is a liberal/dem/anti-gun state.

Nobody has suggested trying. Why would you?

 

the people who don't have an opion on guns/2A aren't going to be swayed either ...... They don't give a damn about "our" rights or the antis "right to be safe" or what ever BS they are using...... No matter what either side pushes on them ..... They are going to persue and vote for the agenda be it jobs.... pensions.... don't let your dogs crap on my lawn or Chistie knew about Ft Lee and is in league Satin

This is absolutely not true. I have brought dozens of NJ residents from neutral but perhaps fearful of guns to supportive of gun rights, some full blown supporters now but most just guaranteed to not vote AGAINST us on some emotional gun control nonsense.

 

I have met very few actual antis in NJ. I have met many people who thought they tended anti that were simply not educated. NJ is not an anti state. NJ is a state with a lot of people that think guns are unusual, abnormal, and serve no purpose.

 

...... Like I said .... We need to fight in court!

We almost always lose in court, and that will not change. It's worth it to try when it makes sense but sometimes it does more harm than good.

I disagree a little with both of you (mipafox and fslater).

First of all, most people lose in court. Take something like same sex marriage. A good many of the cases died out and were denied cert. before they got to the two cases last year - which struck down DOMA and gave plaintiffs standing to sue to overturn prop 8 in CA. States have been now legalizing same sex marriage case by case.

 

I don't think the fight in court is over yet. I don't think it's going to end yet either. There are a good few cases still in the pipeline, especially Peruta and its associated cases in California and the 9th circuit. Recently some other states/territories have gone shall-issue as well - Illinois, Guam and Puerto Rico. We all know about Illinois. But the others, maybe you didn't know about yet. Guam passed a law and cited the Peruta decision. Puerto Rico's supreme court struck down may-issue based on Heller. So I think it's only a matter of time before every state goes shall-issue, including NJ and NYC.

 

But even before that, I think if Republicans take the Senate in November, the NRA and others will push for national CCW reciprocity. And the version of national reciprocity that could pass may not even ask for a permit from one's own state. Nappen thinks that once this happens, NJ's may-issue/no-issue system won't have a leg to stand on. You're saying Obama won't sign it. But he may not have a choice. It might be stuck inside some other piece of legislation that he wants badly, perhaps an increase in the federal minimum wage, or maybe an appropriations bill. It has happened before. This is how we got carry in national parks, and the last amendment for national CCW reciprocity failed by 2 or 3 votes (can't remember how much exactly). 

 

 

As for swaying people, I don't want to waste time trying to sway hardcore antis. I want us to concentrate on people who may not be for or against anything, or people who are in the middle. I think also that the 2A movement has to be a big tent. It can't just be stereotypical gun nuts, and now we are seeing that changing dramatically - women, minorities, LGBT, immigrants etc. It has to be everybody, and yes it has to cross party lines. 

 

There's a lot of work to do, but it will take willing people for it to happen. We plan to recruit as many people as we can to help...

 

As for swaying people, I don't want to waste time trying to sway hardcore antis. I want us to concentrate on people who may not be for or against anything, or people who are in the middle. I think also that the 2A movement has to be a big tent. It can't just be stereotypical gun nuts, and now we are seeing that changing dramatically - women, minorities, LGBT, immigrants etc. It has to be everybody, and yes it has to cross party lines. 

 

There's a lot of work to do, but it will take willing people for it to happen. We plan to recruit as many people as we can to help...

 

Just curious Ryan...  What's your thought on us investing in some kind of MSM presence to reach the "neutrals/undecideds..." whether we negotiate for greater control with existing MSM channels, or we invest $$$ into building our own?  Is that something worth attempting? It's just that I see all this "anti" karma on the MSM trying to reach the very people we need to reach, and being a whole lot more successful at it because of the control the antis have over the MSM.  If we had our own MSM channels (or were able to gain better control over an existing ones), we could ensure that *our* message gets out to the very same audience, only with our spin on it. Right now, we have a very limited presence on some cable and/or streaming media channels, but that's a very small audience compared to the big MSM broadcast networks.

 

Would you think that investing some time/$$$ in to gaining a greater MSM presence worth the effort?

 

Thanks.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.