Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Update on Right to Carry appeals case, Almeida Vs. Sussex Co.

Featured Replies

A retired leo is in all reality the way to go. Anyone having an issue with a hired gun walking around the schools should be a bit more receptive to it being a leo, after all its a Real Good GuyWith A Gun vs anyone else.

  • Replies 264
  • Views 22.4k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • I do not blame the voters. My 2nd amendment incorporated rights should never be in the hands of the voters! I blame the legal system that contrives every way possible to deny me my rights!

  • Thank you Deer...there are very big changes in this case. Due to the lack of actions, and other shady dealings involving 2A leadership and lawyers in NJ, in order to protect backroom deals with the EO

  • ChrisJM981
    ChrisJM981

    I'd be very hesitant to contact an attorney for representation that doesn't file an appeal as discussed, and breaks off contact without even an indication of why. Imagine if it was a criminal case?

You have to admit that a retired state cop is infinitely more qualified than somebody you pull out of a GFH training class.

How do you figure? What is the standatd firearms traing for a LEO?

Not that rigorous. Say someone takes a yraining course at GFH every month and practices weekly, Who is more trained?

 

You are either qualified or not, it doesn't matter how you became qualified.

How do you figure? What is the standatd firearms traing for a LEO?

Not that rigorous. Say someone takes a yraining course at GFH every month and practices weekly, Who is more trained?

 

You are either qualified or not, it doesn't matter how you became qualified.

I don't have an opinion one way or then other. I do need to point out that you've changed the comparison above. Newt compared a retired LEO with someone who took A GFH class. You compared that same LEO (with qualifiers) to someone who takes a GFH class monthly and practices weekly. Not the same equation.

 

I would hope an employer would evaluate all candidates on their merits. In this case that would include both the LEO and well trained civilian over the lesser trained one.

....

 

In some ways this is a good thing. The federal government already controls enough of our lives. If they feel obligated to tell NJ they must scrap our "need" requirement they can also force Vermont to do away with constitutional carry. Or tell Kentucky that their laws regarding purchasing firearms are too lenient. Instead they stay out, even if it means erring on the side of more-restrictive government.

 

...............

I dont believe for a second that Feds and SCOTUS are staying out of 2A because they like to respect states rights and leave it to states. They are staying out because the land of the law is not in their favor and doesn't serve their agenda. 

 

Feds jump in when its convenient for them and fits their agenda.  States like NJ, NY, CA serve as "pilot" for all the firearm laws that WILL become federal at some point in future, if not squashed in infancy.

 

If Feds really believed that 2A is a State matter, then there should be ZERO federal laws regarding firearms except interstate commerce.

How do you figure? What is the standatd firearms traing for a LEO?

Not that rigorous. Say someone takes a yraining course at GFH every month and practices weekly, Who is more trained?

 

You are either qualified or not, it doesn't matter how you became qualified.

One would hope that the vast majority of incidents in which these guards would be involved would NOT include shooting somebody. Being a security guard isn't the same as target practice.

 

Police are trained not only to shoot but to apprehend people, to defuse violent situations, to confront unruly individuals. On the job they do it weekly if not daily. Experience, no?

I would hope an employer would evaluate all candidates on their merits. In this case that would include both the LEO and well trained civilian over the lesser trained one.

A well-trained civilian would have had to be in some branch of law enforcement, either municipal/state/federal, or in the armed forces.

 

Why would you hire someone who only dreams of running outside and shooting someone, vs. a person with 20 years experience in the kind of work that police do, which goes much deeper than shooting?

There's more to the job than shoot/don't shoot, on this, I agree with Newtonian.

 

HOWEVER, I have personally witnessed police qualifications at The Bullet Hole.  As has been stated time and time again, not all cops are gun guys, and some of them, quite frankly, can't hit the broad side of a barn.

A well-trained civilian would have had to be in some branch of law enforcement, either municipal/state/federal, or in the armed forces.

 

Why would you hire someone who only dreams of running outside and shooting someone, vs. a person with 20 years experience in the kind of work that police do, which goes much deeper than shooting?

One answer to your second paragraph can be found in your first. In addition your second paragraph also changes the comparison by adding qualifiers (only dreams... 20 years..etc).

 

My only point is that an employer should evaluate candidates on merit and being former LEO or not should not be an automatic qualifier.

I dont believe for a second that Feds and SCOTUS are staying out of 2A because they like to respect states rights and leave it to states. They are staying out because the land of the law is not in their favor and doesn't serve their agenda. 

 

Feds jump in when its convenient for them and fits their agenda.  States like NJ, NY, CA serve as "pilot" for all the firearm laws that WILL become federal at some point in future, if not squashed in infancy.

 

If Feds really believed that 2A is a State matter, then there should be ZERO federal laws regarding firearms except interstate commerce.

Last time I looked the judicial and legislative branches are separate. If what you say is true, the Supremes would have heard Drake and upheld NJ's insane laws. That would have established near-total regulation of a constitutional right, and provided every subsequent gun-grabbing jurisdiction with something to point to for the next 240 years. 

 

By not hearing the case they essentially say it's up to us, the people. Which it is. 

There's more to the job than shoot/don't shoot, on this, I agree with Newtonian.

 

HOWEVER, I have personally witnessed police qualifications at The Bullet Hole.  As has been stated time and time again, not all cops are gun guys, and some of them, quite frankly, can't hit the broad side of a barn.

Let me take this one step further. Shooting is a ***minuscule*** part of police work. Most cops never fire their guns, even though their jobs require them to "look for trouble." Serving as a cop for 20 years is exactly the type of training you would want for a school security guard. EXACTLY. Unless you've done this, in real life, for years, you are UNQUALIFIED. 

 

I don't care if you shoot IDPA, NFL, HBO, and NJARPC seven days a week and can shoot a toothpick out of Jerry Miculek's clenched teeth while wearing a blindfold.

 

Shooting at targets is not the same as interpersonal and community relations, investigation, leadership, keeping the peace, which are 99.9% of police work.

Who do you think a school would hire first...LE with 20+yrs of verifiable work experience...or someone off the street who comes in and says "I've practiced every week on my own and I can put a 1" grouping on a Q target at 15 yards...better yet which would YOU want guarding that school and your kids ..point being theres more to it than putting a tight group on a cardboard target

My only point is that an employer should evaluate candidates on merit and being former LEO or not should not be an automatic qualifier.

I agree, but I also believe that NOT having been in law enforcement should be an automatic disqualifier. There is simply no other line of work that provides the same depth and breadth of relevant experience. 

What is the supposed purpose of putting an armed gaurd in the school?

It's not to deal with Johnny and Joey going at it behond the gym after school.

It's to deal with an armed attacker. How many LEOs have dealt with someone shooting at them? Very few.

So I put forth that an armed civilian with military training is a MUCH more effective solution to the stated problem tham a retired leo that never drew his weapon outside of twice a year quals.

Or even someone that had regularly gone thru sims training. You need someone to deal with Johny and Joey hire a gym teacher.

What is the supposed purpose of putting an armed gaurd in the school?

It's not to deal with Johnny and Joey going at it behond the gym after school.

It's to deal with an armed attacker. How many LEOs have dealt with someone shooting at them? Very few.

So I put forth that an armed civilian with military training is a MUCH more effective solution to the stated problem tham a retired leo that never drew his weapon outside of twice a year quals.

Or even someone that had regularly gone thru sims training. You need someone to deal with Johny and Joey hire a gym teacher.

i would have to agree with this, armed guards are not hired to deal with rowdy teens, and someone coming into a school with a gun looking to do harm is way past logical solutions like a retired leo talking him into dropping the gun, he will do what he intended to do, that is why we need people who can hold their own in target practice, anyone be it civilian or leo, not just a retired leo who has to fire a few rounds to qualify and other than that never touched his gun

im going to agree with newtonian here too, Its not all about shooting. Situational awareness, what to look for, may be able to talk them down without shooting, if they take a person hostage, there's many other things this "guard" will have to do. Either way you can get a retired leo and have him keep training, or get someone else and basically train them as a leo from the start. My solution is to have the school system hire a cop for each school. Have them teach D.A.R.E. and GREAT to each class. you can have them do much more than sit waiting as a guard. I had a cop full time in my middle school and high school growing up. In high school he actually taught a few other classes such as crime and courts or something similar. An active duty cop can be more than a 1 dimensional guard and serve many roles.

i would have to agree with this, armed guards are not hired to deal with rowdy teens, and someone coming into a school with a gun looking to do harm is way past logical solutions like a retired leo talking him into dropping the gun, he will do what he intended to do, that is why we need people who can hold their own in target practice, anyone be it civilian or leo, not just a retired leo who has to fire a few rounds to qualify and other than that never touched his gun

If this is the purpose of a guard then it's a waste of money. School shootings are extremely rare. I like the idea of hiring him/her as an armed teacher who can conduct all the community-based programs as well as teach classes.

im going to agree with newtonian here too, Its not all about shooting. Situational awareness, what to look for, may be able to talk them down without shooting, if they take a person hostage, there's many other things this "guard" will have to do. Either way you can get a retired leo and have him keep training, or get someone else and basically train them as a leo from the start. My solution is to have the school system hire a cop for each school. Have them teach D.A.R.E. and GREAT to each class. you can have them do much more than sit waiting as a guard. I had a cop full time in my middle school and high school growing up. In high school he actually taught a few other classes such as crime and courts or something similar. An active duty cop can be more than a 1 dimensional guard and serve many roles.

Great ideas.

While the motivation for (finally) hiring armed guards at a school might be the media hysteria over school shootings, the reality is that such a guard WILL regualrly intervene in those other matters and will likely NEVER draw his gun, let alone have to shoot.

In fact, the mere presence of armed security will probably deter 99.9999% of would be mass shooters. Only someone absolutely committed to killing people at that specific location would choose it over a soft target somewhere else.

That said, I'd take qualified, experienced applicants in the following order:

-Institutional security work (schools, colleges, hospitals, etc)
-LE
-Other security
-Military

The first group will have the most experience dealing with the type of people they'll be working with everyday.

LEOs have a different mindset than security proffesionals. It's one that might not be the best fit for handling school kids (again, that will be what they'll end up doing daily).

Military is last, even vs other security, for the same reason as LE. But even more so. Shooting skills aside, military training is the opposite of what guards in a school will be called upon to do. The general public they'd be dealing with are NOT the enemy. NOt even the rowdy kids. They're civilians in a civilian environment. Combat experience is totally inapplicable.

As for super well-trained citizen shooters... Given the fact that school shootings occur at a rate that is statistically zero (excluding the post Newtown copycat spike, over the last 30 years there have been 3x as many high school football related deaths per year than school shootings), their highly honed skill is just one component of what would qualify someone to be an armed school guard and the least likely to be called upon at that.

Last time I looked the judicial and legislative branches are separate. If what you say is true, the Supremes would have heard Drake and upheld NJ's insane laws. That would have established near-total regulation of a constitutional right, and provided every subsequent gun-grabbing jurisdiction with something to point to for the next 240 years. 

 

By not hearing the case they essentially say it's up to us, the people. Which it is. 

If that is the case, SCOTUS would not have taken ANY 2A cases and left ALL of it to States. Its not.

Far simpler explanation is, most of the establishments HATE 2A and will either stay away from ruling on critical pieces or watch the game until it turns in their favor and then rule.

 

IF 50+ states were like NJ, Feds (and SCOTUS) would have had NO PROBLEM making more Federal laws (in favor of restriction) and not leave upto those two or three constitutional states.  Where as, when 50+ states allow concealed carry and most of them honor each others carry permits, Feds "leave upto states" as IF they honor states rights. BS.

If that is the case, SCOTUS would not have taken ANY 2A cases and left ALL of it to States. Its not.

Far simpler explanation is, most of the establishments HATE 2A and will either stay away from ruling on critical pieces or watch the game until it turns in their favor and then rule.

 

IF 50+ states were like NJ, Feds (and SCOTUS) would have had NO PROBLEM making more Federal laws (in favor of restriction) and not leave upto those two or three constitutional states.  Where as, when 50+ states allow concealed carry and most of them honor each others carry permits, Feds "leave upto states" as IF they honor states rights. BS.

They've actually heard very few 2A cases -- seven in total in 225 years. See here.

 

Heller and McDonald vs. Chicago are the most notable in that they represented total bans on handgun ownership. That's a lot different than NJ, where we're "allowed" to own as many guns as we can purchase (OGPM) and walk around our property carrying them.

 

 

And this will surely be news to you: For most of our history many if not most states WERE more like NJ today and less like today's nearly universal shall-issue environment, which began in earnest in 1987. Except for a few blips, the "Feds" have pretty much allowed the states to stew in their own broth. 

 

 

The Supreme Court is not just a higher form of small claims or traffic court. It does not exist to right every itty bitty wrong that state legislatures inflict on their citizens. Traditionally, on second amendment issues at least, they have deferred to the miserable decisions of people like Weinberg, Sweeney, and Gil, and lower court decisions. 

 

I'm going to say this until I'm blue in the face: 2A rights have been earned, for the most part, legislatively. If you think otherwise you are deluding yourself. If one day the Pennsylvania legislature decides to follow a NJ model for granting concealed carry permits, the Supremes will decline to hear that case as well. 

If this is the purpose of a guard then it's a waste of money. School shootings are extremely rare. I like the idea of hiring him/her as an armed teacher who can conduct all the community-based programs as well as teach classes.

im not against arming teachers at all, let them qualify like leo on the range and if they do let them carry to protect the class

..................

 

 

And this will surely be news to you: For most of our history many if not most states WERE more like NJ today and less like today's nearly universal shall-issue environment, which began in earnest in 1987. Except for a few blips, the "Feds" have pretty much allowed the states to stew in their own broth. 

 

 

..................

Curious, which states had NJ like laws up until 1987s... ?  FPID cards, Permit to purchase pistols, State level Background and mental health checks, BB guns & air being firearms, OGAM, AWB, "justifiable need" for carry.......

Curious, which states had NJ like laws up until 1987s... ?  FPID cards, Permit to purchase pistols, State level Background and mental health checks, BB guns & air being firearms, OGAM, AWB, "justifiable need" for carry.......

I'm talking only about concealed carry. I don't know the details on the less onerous provisions of our law. OGPM is more of an inconvenience than anything. We can get air guns, no? This is a complete guess: I'd bet that at least half the states had some kind of silly stuff. 

 

Edit: I meant to write that for ME OGPM has been more of an inconvenience than anything. It involves making multiple trips to my FFL. But it has probably prevented at least one rash purchase.

47 other states allow CCW.  48 allow their citizens to pump their own gas.  The madnesss has to stop.

Curious, which states had NJ like laws up until 1987s... ?  FPID cards, Permit to purchase pistols, State level Background and mental health checks, BB guns & air being firearms, OGAM, AWB, "justifiable need" for carry.......

I just found an article that implies that OGPM is relatively new. It appears the asshole profiled in this article was at least partly responsible. He's also behind the .50 caliber ban.

 

Does anyone know when OGPM was passed? My instincts tell me between 1990 and 1995.

If this is the purpose of a guard then it's a waste of money. School shootings are extremely rare. I like the idea of hiring him/her as an armed teacher who can conduct all the community-based programs as well as teach classes.

Do you own a fire extinguisher?  Had a house fire? 

Do you have air bags in your car?  Have they deployed?

Do you own a firearm? Have you NEEDED it?

 

All very unlikely occurrences but it's called being prepared.  You need someone to make sure Suzy is cutting class?  You need someone to break up a fight?  Don't need an armed guard for that.  Basically you are saying hire an ex-cop to do nothing except in the extremely rare occurrence of ARMED violence.  This is stupid and nothing other than pension padding.  It doesn't take a lot of situational awareness to spot the kid with a gun or a knife.  I have yet to here of a case where a weapon was concealed and then was pulled and used.  An armed teacher or two does the trick, without adding any overhead.  And the odds are really good the teacher/custodian/principal has no police training.  But yet somehow everyday non police trained people stop armed attacks.

Do you own a fire extinguisher?  Had a house fire? 

Do you have air bags in your car?  Have they deployed?

Do you own a firearm? Have you NEEDED it?

 

All very unlikely occurrences but it's called being prepared.  You need someone to make sure Suzy is cutting class?  You need someone to break up a fight?  Don't need an armed guard for that.  Basically you are saying hire an ex-cop to do nothing except in the extremely rare occurrence of ARMED violence.  This is stupid and nothing other than pension padding.  It doesn't take a lot of situational awareness to spot the kid with a gun or a knife.  I have yet to here of a case where a weapon was concealed and then was pulled and used.  An armed teacher or two does the trick, without adding any overhead.  And the odds are really good the teacher/custodian/principal has no police training.  But yet somehow everyday non police trained people stop armed attacks.

A fire extinguisher  costs $15. Air bags I have no choice about, but I would pay for them anyway. I own numerous firearms :) But none are deployed defensively for reasons i choose not to explain in a public forum.

 

You're right. You're talking about insurance, basically. Having armed guards at every school in the U.S. would be fine if we weren't paying for 1 million other ridiculous things. 

 

"Security" is about more than the worst case scenario, about shooting people. It is, as you and others have mentioned, about preparedness, awareness, leadership (I said that) and much, much more. Maybe a former LEO would be better at defusing social problems at schools than the idiot administrators who suspend kids for biting quasi gun-shaped forms out of pop tarts. Maybe not.

 

I'm not completely sure why we're arguing. I totally agree with the proposition of shooting assholes who come on campus with guns. But as you know that's a 1:100,000 proposition. My point was there is a lot more we could gain by having ex-law-enforcement guys at schools. 

I'm not completely sure why we're arguing. I totally agree with the proposition of shooting assholes who come on campus with guns. But as you know that's a 1:100,000 proposition. My point was there is a lot more we could gain by having ex-law-enforcement guys at schools. 

Retired cops willing to sit in a school all day for free?  I am sure there are a few, especially ones with kids / grandkids in the school but for the most part they would want to be paid.

That's where we disagree.  I believe ANYONE wiling to try and stop a lunatic is a good thing and doesn't need to be a cop with and extra salary and benefits.  Protection instincts will kick in.  Like the gym teacher in the last school incident, the principal at Newtown, if they were armed situation would have been over after first 1 or 2 victims tops not after 20.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.