Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

24 Hour Hold?? Required by FFL Who Received My Warranty Replacement Pistol Direct from the Manufacturer??

Featured Replies

I went to pick up my warranty replacement pistol today at the FFL that it was shipped to directly by the manufacturer. The FFL is the same shop where I bought the original (defective) gun. It was shipped via FedEx overnight and I knew from the FedEx tracking number the manufacturer had sent me, that the FFL had received it around 11AM this morning. To my surprise when I got there late this afternoon to pick it up, I was told I couldn't pick it up because they legally had to hold it for 24 hours before they could transfer it to me.

 

My question is: Have I been bullshitted?? Or is that really the law in NJ (or is it a Federal law)??

 

From what I can find on the ATF web site, in a document titled "Federal Firearm Licensee Quick Reference and Best Practices Guide", it mentions nothing about requiring "a 24 hour hold", only that the FFL must make a simple entry (seven fields) in either a manual or computerized journal indicating that they had "Acquired" the gun, before they can "Disposition" the gun to a customer (me).

 

The ATF document states the acquisition by the FFL must be recorded "no later than the close of the next business day following the date of acquisition". It goes on to state that "If the acquisition information is not entered in the A&D (acquisition & disposition) record prior to the sale or other disposition of the firearm, you must enter the acquisition information at the time of the sale or disposition".

 

It looks to me like I've either 1) been Bullshitted or 2) my FFL doesn't understand the laws under which he must operate or 3) I don't know what I'm talking about.

 

Any experienced FFL's out there that can tell me whether it's #1, #2 or #3 ? 

No law. BUT, just don't show up expecting to receive your gun. Give the dealer a day to get to it when they can. Unpacking, inventoring, logging, notifying, etc... You are not the only customer that they have no matter how important you think you are.

 

Sent from an undisclosed location via Tapatalk.

It always nice to give an FFL a heads up that you're coming in for any transfer. There is no law that says that can't do the paperwork and hand off to you immediately but it's not always feasible.

 

If they flat out told you it was the law that they had to hold it then they were either bullshitting you or themselves.

Isn't it also possible that because this is a replacement gun with a new serial number, for one previously sold, that the added 24 hours was for notification of the NJSP of the switch. I seem to recall something in the statute that the NJSP must be notified in the event of a warranty replacement - OTOH, I believe that was only a requirement if it was returned to the manufacturer by the original selling dealer and I don't believe that was the case in this event. Probably just what Paul said. :sarcastic:

 

Adios,

 

Pizza Bob

  • Author

No law. BUT, just don't show up expecting to receive your gun. Give the dealer a day to get to it when they can. Unpacking, inventoring, logging, notifying, etc... You are not the only customer that they have no matter how important you think you are.

 

Sent from an undisclosed location via Tapatalk.

PK90,

 

I didn't go there thinking I was "important". I was a guy, acting like a "child", wanting to get his toy back as soon as possible. Concerned about it being handled by others before I picked it up. It was shipped by the manufacturer, overnight, both ways to expedite things. Only to have the FFL fabricate an excuse to give him time to do his thing. The really annoying thing is after being given the 24 hour line, I was told to not expect it to be available prior to MONDAY (4days !). By the way, there was one other customer in the store in the hour I spent there.

When my gun went to the manufacturer and was replaced it was shipped to my FFL who called me the moment it came in and I picked it up within an hour of the call.

  • Author

When it became obvious that I wasn't leaving with the gun, I asked if I could at least do the NICS while I was there so I wouldn't have to waste time when I came back to pick it up. I was first told no, then told to speak to the manager. The manager said he could do the NICS check today. So I filled out the 4473, and I assume they submitted my NICS check after I left (4PM). So the trip to the FFL wasn't a total waste of time. I also did have the opportunity to handle/examine the replacement pistol, which looks pristine. If they magically call me on Saturday to pick up the gun, it shouldn't take more than 15 minutes. I've never done it, but I'm told NICS on a Saturday (or Friday afternoon) in NJ can take hours.

  • Author

When my gun went to the manufacturer and was replaced it was shipped to my FFL who called me the moment it came in and I picked it up within an hour of the call.

 

Howard,

 

Thanks for the reply. That's what I would call "customer service". I guess I was naïve to expect some.

  • Author

When my gun went to the manufacturer and was replaced it was shipped to my FFL who called me the moment it came in and I picked it up within an hour of the call.

 

Howard,

 

Can you PM me with the name of your FFL. I'm thinking I should find myself another one.

 

Thanks

  • Author

I'd rather not say right now.

 

I didn't start this thread to flame a place of business. I started it to get some advice re: NJ Gun Laws/Federal Laws from the more experienced users on this forum. Which I consider to be a great resource for someone new to firearms ownership in NJ.

I'd rather not say right now.

 

 

Same old story -- you getting a raw deal and not wanting to say who or what brand gun

 

It's thing that jumps out at me is  -- "talk to the manager" -- sounds like too big a place already -- I want to talk to the owner who is there daily -- the guy who's name is on the FFL

 

You need a new FFL

 

What zip code are you in?

Same old story -- you getting a raw deal and not wanting to say who or what brand gun

 

It's thing that jumps out at me is  -- "talk to the manager" -- sounds like too big a place already -- I want to talk to the owner who is there daily -- the guy who's name is on the FFL

 

You need a new FFL

 

What zip code are you in?

 

well if he said who the FFL was they might come onto the forums and give a very different story, I agree with PK just because the tracking says you gun that there doesn't mean its ready for pickup that day. 

get a new ffl never heard of the 24 hour wait.

Yeah i third that. Get an ffl that knows what hes doing and wants your business.

Get a new FFL.

 

The notion that you are not the only customer in the world and so on I also flawed and unacceptable. Either gun shops are something special and different then the rest of commerce in which case you work at having a special relationship with your customers and you go the extra mile, or they are nothing special and no different then Walgreens and personally I never heard HomeDepot holding my special order vanity for an extra day because its hard to do paperwork.

 

Personally I put gun stores in the car dealership category, if for different reasons. I am forced by law to do business with them if I want to purchase a product. I can't buy a new car from anyone but a cabal of lobbying car dealerships and I can't buy a new gun from anyone buy a gun dealer because so said slime balls in office.  There are good car dealers and terrible ones, and the same can be said for gun dealer, but I have yet to enter a car dealers ship that wouldn't bend over backwards to have me walk out with a car they had on the lot, or even on the track driving in later today. 

 

 

Same old story -- you getting a raw deal and not wanting to say who or what brand gun

 

What is it with being so damned tight lipped about these things. He can't just keep your gun....

When my gun went to the manufacturer and was replaced it was shipped to my FFL who called me the moment it came in and I picked it up within an hour of the call.

Well you must be SUPER important.

 

I think a prudent thing would've been to call ahead just to verify receipt and ask it it will be available for pickup, but to be given misinformation (either knowingly or ignorantly) and told it will be several days is unacceptable.

 

"You're not important enough for me to get to it" isn't an acceptable answer either.

 

Spend your money somewhere else

 

Sent from my SM-G900V using Tapatalk

I thought a repaired or replaced gun from manufacturer was shipped to your house?

I thought a repaired or replaced gun from manufacturer was shipped to your house?

I would imagine that a repair could be shipped right to your house. A replacement would probably require an FFL since the serial #

would most likely be different requiring a transfer.

jmolli- I don't know where you are located but if you are anywhere near Central Jersey I can give you the contact info for my FFL.  While I never did a repair return with him he has always provided great customer service.

I would imagine that a repair could be shipped right to your house. A replacement would probably require an FFL since the serial #

would most likely be different requiring a transfer.

I don't think so but not certain. I'm pretty sure I've known people that had replacements shipped to their house. It's the same thing, the SN record is still with the manufacturer.

My Beretta Neos was shipped from and back to my house from Beretta for repair.

What is it with being so damned tight lipped about these things. He can't just keep your gun....

Well you must be SUPER important.

 

I think a prudent thing would've been to call ahead just to verify receipt and ask it it will be available for pickup, but to be given misinformation (either knowingly or ignorantly) and told it will be several days is unacceptable.

 

"You're not important enough for me to get to it" isn't an acceptable answer either.

 

Spend your money somewhere else

 

Sent from my SM-G900V using Tapatalk

Howard's not that important :onthequiet:  I deal with the same shop and got the same treatment.

Howard's not that important :onthequiet:  I deal with the same shop and got the same treatment.

Darn it, now you burst my bubble Bruce - I thought I "WAS" that important :)

  • Author

The good news is I'm picking up the replacement pistol tomorrow (Sat AM). The bad news is, I was so pissed off last night I hardly slept.

 

I think everybody should have a copy of the ATF publication I mentioned at the start of this thread, "Federal Firearms Licensee Quick Reference and Best Practices Guide", so they can tell the bullshit from the facts if they find themselves in a similar situation. There's also a lot of other interesting reading on the ATF site, take a look.  

 

Here is the link: https://www.atf.gov/firearms/docs/federal-firearms-licensee-quick-reference-and-best-practices-guide-atf-p-530015

 

 

Thanks to everybody who contributed to this discussion thread. I learned a lot. 

Darn it, now you burst my bubble Bruce - I thought I "WAS" that important :)

Sorry Howard I hope we're still friends.

 

The good news is I'm picking up the replacement pistol tomorrow (Sat AM). The bad news is, I was so pissed off last night I hardly slept.

 

I think everybody should have a copy of the ATF publication I mentioned at the start of this thread, "Federal Firearms Licensee Quick Reference and Best Practices Guide", so they can tell the bullshit from the facts if they find themselves in a similar situation. There's also a lot of other interesting reading on the ATF site, take a look.  

 

Here is the link: https://www.atf.gov/firearms/docs/federal-firearms-licensee-quick-reference-and-best-practices-guide-atf-p-530015

 

 

Thanks to everybody who contributed to this discussion thread. I learned a lot. 

 

 

It says in there no 4473 and no NICS for a replacement firearm. You guys had me second guessing myself a bit but I'm almost certain replacements can be shipped to your house. Like I said, I'm pretty sure I know of people that did it. Perhaps not in Jersey for some reason.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.