Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Thomas R. Rogers and ANJRPC v. Gurbir S. Grewal, et al

Featured Replies

13 minutes ago, diamondd817 said:

When are we going to win? I've been watching this shit show for the last 10yrs. I haven't seen 1 win for our side yet. So, exactly when will this happen, 10, 20, 30yrs from now? Ill be waiting.

20 or 30 years I'll be dead

  • Replies 167
  • Views 22.9k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • I will delightfully swim in the tidal wave of irony if the most anti-gun governor and attorney general in NJ’s recent history are forced to recognize the right to carry.

  • THE petitioner should not have agreed to this. why give the state ANY courtesy? they sure as shit don't give us any courtesy or respect.....

  • I wouldn't trust Roberts. 

Posted Images

 So when do we find out if scotus will take it.      the communists and fifth columnists throughout NJ and the US are countering every suit fairly successfully by either not appealing or by issuing a permit.      I don't see much in this one that wasn't in any of the others, are there any other "good" ones going up to SC.    NYC seemed to figure out how to keep theirs from going to scotus.

4 hours ago, revenger said:

 So when do we find out if scotus will take it.      the communists and fifth columnists throughout NJ and the US are countering every suit fairly successfully by either not appealing or by issuing a permit.      I don't see much in this one that wasn't in any of the others, are there any other "good" ones going up to SC.    NYC seemed to figure out how to keep theirs from going to scotus.

NY briefing has not been stayed yet.  In fact the petitioners have requested that the motion be denied.  Would be great if SCOTUS denied the motion and said nice try NY.

As for NJ the court will now schedule it for conference.  Should be soon.  I would think it will go to conference within next couple weeks.  Then it’s just a matter of how many conferences it takes for them to make a decision...

is there any way nj can make this one go away like they seem to have done in the past?

 

1 hour ago, 1LtCAP said:

is there any way nj can make this one go away like they seem to have done in the past?

 

Nope, too late to just grant Rogers a carry permit at this point.  Best NJ can now hope for is that SCOTUS doesn't grant cert.

On ‎4‎/‎19‎/‎2019 at 6:58 PM, Smokin .50 said:

Why not a bunch of denials?  Here's why:  Too many PUSSIES were afraid of a denial costing them the ability to apply for more P2P's!  OMG, what do I do if they ask me about a denial?

FACT:  No matter how many times Almeida was denied, he explained it all away and there was NO delay in processing P2P's.  Ever.

The Stockholm Syndrome is strong here...

I got my denial last year. It's too expensive to do again so soon. You have to do anothe Morphotrak background check ($$) and then qualify with the guns you want to carry at 50-60 rounds each (more $$). The staff at GFH blinked hard when I told them how many quals I wanted to run.

Using the wait and see argument with NY and MA is a specious one. I have tried to find out the number of CCW permits in NJ and was told that information is private.  So how we supposed to find out how limited we are.  Also Heller  was started  because WASH DC would not let you carry a handgun from room to room let alone outside. 

If the present conservative  court does not grant to hear our case with AG's weak argument, I don't know  if we ever will.

15 hours ago, drjjpdc said:

Using the wait and see argument with NY and MA is a specious one. I have tried to find out the number of CCW permits in NJ and was told that information is private.  So how we supposed to find out how limited we are.  Also Heller  was started  because WASH DC would not let you carry a handgun from room to room let alone outside. 

f the present coservative  court does not rant to hear  our case with AG's weak argument, I don't know  if we ever will.

I hate this state. When I'm at my home in Florida I can carry everyday almost anywhere. When I'm back here in NJ I can't have a gun when I leave my store late at night and drive home.  The gun laws in this state are nuts.  They really do favor the criminals.  When you visit a gun store in a free state or a gun show you really realize how crazy NJ is. 

  • Author

ANJRPC has 15 days from the date of NJ's filing to to respond if I remember correctly. I can't wait to read how they rip NJ apart... again. 

  • 2 weeks later...
13 minutes ago, njJoniGuy said:

Good reply by Schmutter et al

Yup, good example of the ANJRPC and NRA “doing nothing” in NJ...

I have a big smile on my face.  Even if cert isn't granted, I really feel like these guys did a great job.  In particular, I like the response to NJ's assertion that there is no evidence regarding the percentage of permits granted: it doesn't matter.  The law is unconstitutional on its face because it de facto differentiates between people with a special, "justifable need" and "ordinary citizens".  The footnote is a nice touch, pointing out that the percentages are likely irrelevant because most people are discouraged from ever applying and going through and onerous and expensive process because they know they will be denied.

I've been disappointed so many times, but I will venture to say that I am optimistic about this.  It seems that with Thomas, Alito, Kavanaugh and Gorsuch cert should be granted since you need 4 justices to grant-- I will actually be shocked if it isn't.  Roberts has unfortunately become rather scary, and I worry that if cert is granted he could flip, but hard to believe that a Justice who signed onto Heller and Mcdonald would let this flagrantly unconstitutional law to stand.  I could see him insisting on as narrow a holding as possible.  We will see. 

45 minutes ago, PDM said:

I have a big smile on my face.  Even if cert isn't granted, I really feel like these guys did a great job.  In particular, I like the response to NJ's assertion that there is no evidence regarding the percentage of permits granted: it doesn't matter.  The law is unconstitutional on its face because it de facto differentiates between people with a special, "justifable need" and "ordinary citizens".  The footnote is a nice touch, pointing out that the percentages are likely irrelevant because most people are discouraged from ever applying and going through and onerous and expensive process because they know they will be denied.

I've been disappointed so many times, but I will venture to say that I am optimistic about this.  It seems that with Thomas, Alito, Kavanaugh and Gorsuch cert should be granted since you need 4 justices to grant-- I will actually be shocked if it isn't.  Roberts has unfortunately become rather scary, and I worry that if cert is granted he could flip, but hard to believe that a Justice who signed onto Heller and Mcdonald would let this flagrantly unconstitutional law to stand.  I could see him insisting on as narrow a holding as possible.  We will see. 

I will read the response brief shortly, however, I agree with your assessment.  I'm very optimistic that the true rule of law will be interpreted appropriately.  My wish is for Justice Kavanaugh to write the opinion and stick it solely into the chest of one Cory Booker, who made a mockery of his confirmation hearing.  No way Kavanaugh forgets Booker and payback/karma will be rightfully bestowed.  

Nice job on the petitioner's reply by Dan Schmutter and colleagues.

I too would handicap SCOTUS like PDM.  The wild card is Roberts and I'm sure he is wrestling with the impact on the country, given its current state of political division, if the Court forces all the blue states to allow some form of carry outside the home.  Libturd heads would explode everywhere.

41 minutes ago, Princetonian58 said:

Nice job on the petitioner's reply by Dan Schmutter and colleagues.

I too would handicap SCOTUS like PDM.  The wild card is Roberts and I'm sure he is wrestling with the impact on the country, given its current state of political division, if the Court forces all the blue states to allow some form of carry outside the home.  Libturd heads would explode everywhere.

Agree.  However, Roberts needs to follow the Constitution.  And must do so with strict scrutiny in our case.  It is not supposed to be about wrestling with any personal views or outside noise.  The 2A is clear and States within the union that attempt to usurp it must be stopped.  

I get your sentiment and I too feel he is the wildcard, but being on the high court, Roberts need to put that stuff aside and rule based on law.  

Hopeful on my end here and for us all.

 

 

Edited by chic013
typo

How awesome would it be to win...

1 hour ago, Zeke said:

How awesome would it be to win...

Totally.  Most anti-gun governor ever gets carry restored on his term...

ok. now.....please pardon if this is jumping the gun(yea, shitty pun intended, lol) and/or stupid. 

 

 so lets presume that this goes to the scotus. scotus strikes down nj's bs. what is the next step? can/will nj appeal? if they can't, can they then impose more stupidity to still make it nearly impossible or overly difficult for us?

  • Author
3 hours ago, 1LtCAP said:

ok. now.....please pardon if this is jumping the gun(yea, shitty pun intended, lol) and/or stupid. 

 

 so lets presume that this goes to the scotus. scotus strikes down nj's bs. what is the next step? can/will nj appeal? if they can't, can they then impose more stupidity to still make it nearly impossible or overly difficult for us?

Nj probably gets a defined amount of time to rewrite their unconstitutional carry laws. IIRC that's what happened with DC. 

There is no appeal after SCOTUS. 

It depends if SCOTUS addresses the level of scrutiny with which legislation involving the Second Amendment must be examined with. If it's strict scrutiny a lot of their laws will fall. 

4 hours ago, 1LtCAP said:

ok. now.....please pardon if this is jumping the gun(yea, shitty pun intended, lol) and/or stupid. 

 

 so lets presume that this goes to the scotus. scotus strikes down nj's bs. what is the next step? can/will nj appeal? if they can't, can they then impose more stupidity to still make it nearly impossible or overly difficult for us?

There's no soaking Scotus.

However, I would expect nj to engage in massive bullshit. Like making the permits incredibly expensive or making permitted carry unlawful in so many locations as to make it useless.

7 hours ago, 1LtCAP said:

ok. now.....please pardon if this is jumping the gun(yea, shitty pun intended, lol) and/or stupid. 

 

 so lets presume that this goes to the scotus. scotus strikes down nj's bs. what is the next step? can/will nj appeal? if they can't, can they then impose more stupidity to still make it nearly impossible or overly difficult for us?

 

3 hours ago, raz-0 said:

There's no soaking Scotus.

However, I would expect nj to engage in massive bullshit. Like making the permits incredibly expensive or making permitted carry unlawful in so many locations as to make it useless.

Yes they could require certifications, classes, fees, etc., long waits. They aren’t going down easy. But there’s no appeal. Spartacus and/or the pervert could try to introduce something but not with and likely success. 

My fingers are crossed that this will loosen up the many other rediculous infringements so we can act like adults with our guns. 

One thing to remember about Roberts. He may be less firm on the gun issue. But it is clear that we have a conflict in the Circuit  Courts and he is not one to tolerate having them thumb their nose at the SCOTUS. There is also a trend among the states not to be ignored (Tennessee just passed their own law). This can affect not only NJ, but NY, Mass, etc.

Not only what happened  in DC but IL, where the 7th Circuit gave them about a 100 days or they would re-write the IL law themselves.

16 hours ago, ChrisJM981 said:

Nj probably gets a defined amount of time to rewrite their unconstitutional carry laws. IIRC that's what happened with DC. 

There is no appeal after SCOTUS. 

It depends if SCOTUS addresses the level of scrutiny with which legislation involving the Second Amendment must be examined with. If it's strict scrutiny a lot of their laws will fall. 

Theres always appeal after the SCOTUS.  Hopefully never needed but,

That is exactly what the 2nd was written for.

Is this on the conference schedule yet ?

 

  • Author
3 hours ago, PeteF said:

Theres always appeal after the SCOTUS.  Hopefully never needed but,

That is exactly what the 2nd was written for.

I meant for the leftists. 

They haven't listed an exact date yet, but they have all the documents from both sides now. Interesting that the NY case has been granted certiorari already, but that doesn't prevent them from hearing both cases and publishing oral arguments on both of them later.

Edited by drjjpdc
too much space

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.