I agree with Griz. In my area (Flemington/Raritan, etc.) we live in pizza heaven. If you can't find a pie around here you like then you aren't really looking. 

And I don't understand all the love for Chimney Rock Inn pizza. Is it good - yes. Is it great - no.  I've had it twice at their Flemington location and it was good - but I can name 5 other places within 10 miles that are as good or better.  

I am a Joe's fan in Flemington https://joespizza.biz/ , but Luna in three Bridges http://www.njlunapizza.com/ makes what they call "Traditional Neapolitan Pies". I love them, but they are a little different, so not everyone will be a fan. 

 

L&B'S in Brooklyn,NY...Brother's in Staten Island,NY ...in South Jersey East Ridge Pizza in Willingboro,NJ (Brooklyn Boys Owned)

The major problem IMO with thin crust pizza is its a fine line between crisp and burnt crust.

1 minute ago, GRIZ said:

The major problem IMO with thin crust pizza is its a fine line between crisp and burnt crust.

Pete - you say that like it's a bad thing? Pizza done in a wood fired over with a hint of char is the best.........

 

 

Millers in annandale had the best bar pies. I loved that place, a little dive bar with great pizza and great fishing in the creek next to it. 

2 minutes ago, fishnut said:

Millers in annandale had the best bar pies. I loved that place, a little dive bar with great pizza and great fishing in the creek next to it. 

Do the have a "No Waders" sign inside?

7 minutes ago, JT Custom Guns said:

Pete - you say that like it's a bad thing? Pizza done in a wood fired over with a hint of char is the best.........

 

 

A hint of char is good.  Burnt is bad :).

16 minutes ago, CMJeepster said:

Do the have a "No Waders" sign inside?

Nope. I went in several times while in my waders. Someone bought the place and cleaned up and changed the name and the pizza is not the same anymore. So sad. 

2 hours ago, GRIZ said:

Not so in my area.  There's at least a dozen pizza places within a few miles of my house.  I haven't eaten them all but those I have are at least pretty good.  Schiano's the best and one Domino's at the other end of the spectrum. I've actually got a pizza from Domino's once.  That's because I got a coupon for a free one.

 

At least you got your money's worth.

9 minutes ago, fishnut said:

Nope. I went in several times while in my waders. Someone bought the place and cleaned up and changed the name and the pizza is not the same anymore. So sad. 

There's a no waders sign at the deli by the gorge.

In New Jersey, Joe's in Belle Mead. Three cousins own it and they are from Naples where Pizza was invented. Great pies, Brooklyn is their best!

3 hours ago, CMJeepster said:

There's a no waders sign at the deli by the gorge.

Yeah, I know. I'm not a fan of that place. They want 15 bucks for prosciutto sub and it's not like it's really good prosciutto or anything like that. Only reason they are in business is the tewkesbury residents. 

For a tomato pie I go to Palermo's outside Bordentown. 

The mustard pie at Papa's in Robbinsville sounds weird, but tastes great.

16 hours ago, Theron said:

For a tomato pie I go to Palermo's outside Bordentown. 

The mustard pie at Papa's in Robbinsville sounds weird, but tastes great.

Ok. What’s in a mustard pie?

14 minutes ago, Zeke said:

Ok. What’s in a mustard pie?

And must it lie flat in the crock pot, or can you ball it up and boil it?

1 minute ago, 10X said:

And must it lie flat in the crock pot, or can you ball it up and boil it?

Not your best work 

17 minutes ago, Zeke said:

Ok. What’s in a mustard pie?

It is a tomato pie which has a smear of golden mustard with the red sauce. I was skeptical, but it works. (If You like mustard)

2 minutes ago, Theron said:

It is a tomato pie which has a smear of golden mustard with the red sauce. I was skeptical, but it works. (If You like mustard)

Thanks Charlize

When I lived in Kendall Park, there was a place named 4 musketeers on Rt 27 that had awesome pies.  I think maybe its gone since the local demographics have changed quite a bit in the last decade.

I do spend a  fair amount of time in Delaware and you would be amazed how bad their pizza is.  And Papa Johns and Dominoes are considered a local treat.  Barf.  When they used to advertise about their new and improved pies, I wondered if it was actually worse than it is today.  I swear the frozen stuff in Walmart is actually better.

 

Have yet to step foot in DeLorenzos after  all these years, even though I could drive there in 5 minutes.  Not a big fan of the thin crust variety.  Always wondered why Chicago deep dish has never made it this far east.  Looks mighty good on the Food Network has a segment about it, but never have I seen any in Jersey.

22 hours ago, brucin said:

At least you got your money's worth.

Like the line in Crocodile Dundee, "It'll keep you alive but it tastes like shit".

4 hours ago, AlDente67 said:

I do spend a  fair amount of time in Delaware and you would be amazed how bad their pizza is. 

The best pizza in Delaware is Grotto Pizza at the Delaware shore - of course it had its origins in NE PA.

DiFara pizza. Ave j and 15th st. Look up barstool. 

Awesome

VIP in Bayside, Queens.

Man this thread is really making me miss good pizza. If anyone wants a free place to stay in white mountian national forest all you gotta do is bring me a good pepperoni pizza! Lol

On 6/18/2019 at 9:55 PM, JT Custom Guns said:

L&B Spumoni Gardens in Brooklyn

Talula's in Asbury Park

Luigi's in Pt. Pleasant

Vic's in Bradley Beach

Pete & Elda's in Neptune

 

 

 

 

L&B is my son’s fave.  He brought one home tonight.

On ‎6‎/‎22‎/‎2019 at 9:44 AM, fishnut said:

Man this thread is really making me miss good pizza. If anyone wants a free place to stay in white mountian national forest all you gotta do is bring me a good pepperoni pizza! Lol

Tempting.

On 6/22/2019 at 9:13 AM, bry@n said:

DiFara pizza. Ave j and 15th st. Look up barstool. 

Awesome

I went to Di Fara in High School. The Man is a genius.

Pepe's New Haven Ct

John's on Bleeker NYC

Naples Barnegat NJ

Robertos Metuchen NJ

Ray's NYC 12th & 6th (Closed)

Not in any order.