April 24, 20206 yr (if this has been posted please delete) A federal judge on Thursday blocked a California law requiring background checks for people buying ammunition, issuing a sharply worded rebuke of “onerous and convoluted” regulations that violate the constitutional right to bear arms. https://www.sandiegouniontribune.com/news/california/story/2020-04-23/judge-tosses-california-ammunition-purchase-law
April 24, 20206 yr https://www.yahoo.com/news/judge-california-cant-require-background-025736990.html
April 24, 20206 yr Will this decision block New Jersey's similar bill, or will they push it forward until a judge (hopefully) blocks their specific law?
April 24, 20206 yr 7 minutes ago, father-of-three said: Will this decision block New Jersey's similar bill, or will they push it forward until a judge (hopefully) blocks their specific law? Push it now now and let the judges block it if they will.
April 24, 20206 yr 3 hours ago, FXDX said: A federal judge on Thursday blocked a California law requiring background checks for people buying ammunition, issuing a sharply worded rebuke of “onerous and convoluted” regulations that violate the constitutional right to bear arms. That is FanfrigginTastic!!!
April 24, 20206 yr just read this article and came here to post but I was beat to the punch. great news finally.
April 24, 20206 yr 1 hour ago, FXDX said: hopefully it sets a precedent... It will, and then NJ will set the opposite precedent, then it will go to the Supremes.
April 24, 20206 yr Doesn't set any precedent. It is only a trial court opinion and only on a preliminary injunction-case continues in the trial court in California. Even if it is appealed, the 9th Cir opinion and or eventual En Banc Opinion, (perhaps in 2022 or 2023) has no binding impact in N.J., and if it eventually gets to the U. S. Supreme Court and cert is granted, you are looking at 2025 at the earliest.
April 24, 20206 yr Author Understood this is just a CA verdict and there is NO bearing on NJ but I know somewhere some Pro2A NJ group is looking at this and are pleased. Any/all good news is welcomed here. What I do know is some online retailers are giving CA preference and I hope they clean out all the online dealers
April 25, 20206 yr https://reason.com/2020/04/24/preliminary-injunction-against-dysfunctional-california-ammunition-background-checks/ it looks like the judge is ok with background checks and databases just not what CA created Quote If the state objective is to make it extremely difficult, if not impossible, for its law-abiding citizens to purchase protected ammunition, then this law appears to be well-drafted. However, if the genuine object is to keep ammunition out of the hands of those who should not be able to buy it, perhaps the State could create a database (that would include persons prohibited, i.e., aliens unlawfully present, felons, and others) and simply make that information available to sellers by cross-checking with the magnetic strip on a standard driver's license and by allowing out-of-state vendors the same ability to engage in commerce as it does California vendors.
April 25, 20206 yr 1 hour ago, WP22 said: https://reason.com/2020/04/24/preliminary-injunction-against-dysfunctional-california-ammunition-background-checks/ it looks like the judge is ok with background checks and databases just not what CA created Well, at least he’s agreeing to a database of prohibited persons not a database of allowed persons. That’s a huge difference. -Jim
April 25, 20206 yr Can’t find the link but I believe the 9th circus stayed the injunction already. Ammo-week for CA didn’t even last a day.
April 25, 20206 yr 11 minutes ago, voyager9 said: Can’t find the link but I believe the 9th circus stayed the injunction already. Ammo-week for CA didn’t even last a day. I can’t find that. I did find the motion by the state to stay was denied https://www.thetruthaboutguns.com/breaking-judge-benitez-denies-californias-motion-to-stay-his-injunction-in-ammo-background-check-case/
April 25, 20206 yr 1 hour ago, Zeke said: I can’t find that. I did find the motion by the state to stay was denied https://www.thetruthaboutguns.com/breaking-judge-benitez-denies-californias-motion-to-stay-his-injunction-in-ammo-background-check-case/ I could only find the Facebook link someone posted to reddit https://m.facebook.com/permalink.php?story_fbid=1078921195820834&id=100011088912909
April 25, 20206 yr 2 hours ago, voyager9 said: I could only find the Facebook link someone posted to reddit https://m.facebook.com/permalink.php?story_fbid=1078921195820834&id=100011088912909 The struggle continues.
April 25, 20206 yr @voyager9 https://www.thetruthaboutguns.com/ninth-circuit-grants-emergency-stay-california-ammo-background-check-law-again-in-force/
April 25, 20206 yr Yep. Original judge denied the stay but then they went to 9th. So the 9th circuit strikes again.
April 25, 20206 yr Late Friday night (9:46pm), the following order came out from the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals, granting a temporary stay on the injunction issued on Thursday, April 24, in the NRA funded case of Rhode v. Becerra. This means that the same restrictions that have been previously in effect regarding ammunition in California are back for the time being, pending further order from the court.
April 25, 20206 yr So all those UPS shipments of ammo that went out during the day Friday are on their way to individuals in CA. What happens to them? Returned to sender? UPS is not a law enforcement agency. I hope the CA guys get their ammo and fire for effect when the time comes. And I think it's sooner rather than later.
April 25, 20206 yr 4 hours ago, Shepherd9 said: Yep. Original judge denied the stay but then they went to 9th. So the 9th circuit strikes again. The 9th reacted as fast as I’ve ever seen a court move. Didn’t the judge deny the stay on Friday afternoon and the circuit court was able to convene and issue orders at 10pm on f’n Friday.
April 25, 20206 yr 10 minutes ago, voyager9 said: The 9th reacted as fast as I’ve ever seen a court move. Didn’t the judge deny the stay on Friday afternoon and the circuit court was able to convene and issue orders at 10pm on f’n Friday. Seriously, it took just hours to reverse and oppress the people. But it takes months or years for the people to potentially get their basic rights back.
April 26, 20206 yr 1 hour ago, voyager9 said: The 9th reacted as fast as I’ve ever seen a court move. Didn’t the judge deny the stay on Friday afternoon and the circuit court was able to convene and issue orders at 10pm on f’n Friday. I could be wrong, but these temporary orders only require a single judge to make a ruling.
April 26, 20206 yr Interesting, the 9th changed out of their pjs and donned their masks to grant a temporary stay on the injunction Benitez issued only a few hours before? I thought they were on our side now.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.