Everything posted by Grima Squeakersen
-
NJSP REQUALIFICATION
So, this evening I got a confirmation email from Woodbine station firearms unit itself, that began, "Mr, Miller, you need to understand that this email is not monitored 24 x 7..." Yeah, no waste, Watson, my original email was sent on 12/21. There was also no mention of failing to acknowledge my earlier submission of paper in person. It ended with "I understand your concern". I expect that is as close as I could hope to come to an apology. I wonder why I was completely ignored until I mentioned the possibility of bothering Callahan's staff, and then NJSP reps from two different offices responded within 24 hours. I was tempted to reply to Woodbine FIU on "not monitored 24 x 7" by asking if taking a week to respond to a submission would be taken into consideration if the delay resulted in the arrest of a PtC holder for CCARE non-compliance, but I decided against it. Between the copious correspondence from me when they were sitting on my original application for six months in 2022, and this latest exchange, I am probably on at least one "we don't like this clown very much" list...
-
NJSP REQUALIFICATION
WTF is "Taylor Ham"?
-
NJSP REQUALIFICATION
And that is on a good day. I often wonder why I'm still here. OTOH, I have ancestors from South Jersey on both sides of family that go way, way back, and I'm also an obstinate SOB who hates to let bad guys win by default. Probably not a recipe for conspicuous success, but, oh well...
-
NJSP REQUALIFICATION
As documented elsewhere in this thread, I made two trips to Woodbine NJSP station to submit my SP182 & SP182a forms. The first attempt was stymied by a trooper spouting misinformation who refused to accept them. On my second trip, a trooper who was not on desk duty accepted the forms, and promised to get the frearms desk duty officer to call me upon his return to the office to confirm receipt. That never happened. I then sent an email to the Woodbine station firearms unit with copies of the executed forms attached, explaining the circumstances of my two attempts to drop off the physical forms, and requesting receipt confirmation. No such confirmation was received. After waiting two days, I resent that email, and added that if I did not receive a confirmation reply, I would be forced to send form copies by certified mail to Superintendent Callahan's attention in West Trenton, so that I could have confirmation that I had complied with the CCARE requirements. I copied the main NJSP firearms investigation unit (NJSP Firearms Invest Unit<[email protected]>) on that second email. This morning I received a reply from that unit, confirming me that my forms had been received, and that there was no need to send them again. So, that is what it took to get NJSP to provide a simple confirmation that I had complied with this ridiculous imposition. Gotta love Murphy, Platkin and their minions.
-
List of NJ Businesses posting 'No Guns' signs
Ridiculous enough to accurately reflect how the State of New Jersey conducts itself and views its subjects on nearly all matters, I fear.
-
List of NJ Businesses posting 'No Guns' signs
Agree. If the only standard is not getting caught carrying in a prohibited place when there is no need to draw the handgun, there is little point to the numerous discussions on this site about what is and is not legal carry.
-
List of NJ Businesses posting 'No Guns' signs
There may even be a potential complication there. We recently had dinner at an Italian restaurant in Sea Isle City. Their web site says they are BYOB, so we took a bottlie. Turns out that they also have a package license and sell bottled wine to guests. If you sit down to dinner and buy a bottle from them, the server opens and pours it (they also offer to open and pour any beverage the customer brings with). Does that constitute "serving" as defined in the regs that are currently in force? I really don't know, but I personally wouldn't assume that it would be any different from carrying in a bar. I didn't carry that night because I planned to have a drink with dinner, but had I not so planned, and gone in armed, it would have made me somewhat uneasy.
-
NJ CCW Question(s) - 2
Or Critical Defense. Depends on the situation you expect to be in should you need to shoot: https://www.police1.com/police-products/firearms/accessories/ammunition/articles/critical-defense-vs-critical-duty-clearing-up-confusion-over-hornady-ammunition-4V6a5PiYFS1DkyFN/
-
NJSP REQUALIFICATION
I don't think it does. OTOH, the SP182 attests to successful fulfillment of both requirements, and that form has only one line for instructor sign-off and date. That issue was clearly overlooked by whoever designed the form (unless they deliberately created a "gotcha", which isn't entirely implausible). The fact that both endorsements are on one form was what the Woodbine NJSP guy, Petersen, cited when he refused to accept my form when I first tried to submit it at the station. I had use of force in 2022 with my original qualification, but I had to shoot again for a different instructor last week, because my original shooting qual lacked holster draw.
-
List of NJ Businesses posting 'No Guns' signs
Do they require a sign to prohibit civilian carry? According to the web page I found for them, they serve "ice cold beer". Wouldn't that make them subject to the (insane) NJ carry prohibition in establishments that serve alcohol? Or am I confused, and that was one of the regulations that was stayed?
-
Non-Hollowpoint? (Long)
NM
-
NJSP REQUALIFICATION
I seem to recall a time when the NRA claimed to be unalterably opposed to any form of firearms registration...
-
NJSP REQUALIFICATION
I don't think it, and never wrote that I did. I'm sure some (probably a minority) are adamantly opposed. I would bet that there are others who favor gun rights only for their buddies and others that they personally approve of. I frequently get the sense that the latter mindset is also true of some civilians who describe themselves as 2A proponents, but who would (openly or secretly) prefer that certain kinds of people of whom they disapprove not be afforded the right to bear arms for self defense. None of them are on NJGF, of course. What I was implying with that brief disclosure about Petersen was the question of why, if he is not assigned to the firearms desk, he took it upon himself to attack the validity of my SP182 (signed off by one of his fellow troopers), and reject it on behalf of the station and NJSP.
-
NJSP REQUALIFICATION
So, I was able to submit my forms at Woodbine NJSP station early yesterday afternoon. Station was minimally staffed, I'm guessing upcoming holidays were a factor. Two troopers came to the desk after I buzzed for admittance, outfitted in tactical gear; I guess they were either drilling, or on their way to or from some exercise. I asked if Dave Petersen was available, they told me he was out for the day. They looked over my forms, then accepted them. I asked if I could have some kind of receipt, the answer was "sorry, no", which is what I expected (doesn't hurt to ask :-) They did tell me that they would put the forms in the firearms officer's in-box with a note asking him to phone me to confirm receipt on his return. After a bit more back-and-forth, it turns out that Petersen is not assigned to the firarms desk there, which makes my encounter with him a few days back seem all the more strange. Anyway, forms are in, so I am now (hopefully) good to go until my 2024 renewal, or until Matt Platkin dreams up some new obstacle course that he will force current PtC holders to navigate...
-
NJSP REQUALIFICATION
I'm making this a new, top-level post under this topic, because I think that is merited by its importance, given what I posted previously. I had another email exchange with my supplemental qualification instructor, DSM Jamell Rosario, NJSP. Jamell told me that his advice against submitting my documents to the Woodbine NJSP station applied only to me, based on my experience with Trooper Petersen rejecting them. That advice does not apply generally. He did not make that clear in his original phone call to me. It seems that in my effort to clarify by passing on current information, I actually further confused things, and for that, I apologize. In my defense, I will contend the the ultimate source of the confusion is the State of New Jersey, but I am truly sorry for making it worse. Jamell told me that he got Petersen "straightened out" and that I should now submit through Woodbine, which I intend to do ASAP.
-
Diane Feinstein dead at age 90
Not just an anti, but a prime deep state enabler and rent seeker extraordinaire (her husband was part of the defense contractor industry, and made big bucks on every conflict that Feinstein enabled). Dianne Feinstein, RIH ("R" for "roast", and "peace" doesn't being with an "H").
-
NJSP REQUALIFICATION
I will contact DSM Rosario to see if he is willing to do that, or can furnish a link to some official NJSP communication that states the required handling of SP182 forms clearly. I think I will wait a couple of days. He plainly wasn't too happy about calling me at 7 AM, although I suispect his displeasure was focused on someone other than me.
-
NJSP REQUALIFICATION
And thank you for addressing the points I raised, rather than thoughtlessly blasting out some sarcastic and dismissive reply...
-
NJSP REQUALIFICATION
UPDATE: I sent an email to Jamell Rosario (who was the instructor for my requalification) at 6 AM this morning asking for his assistance in this matter. Mr. Rosario is apparently a NJSP DSG assigned to Firearms Investigation Unit in Trenton, and as such would be eminently qualified in regard to the NJ Permit to Carry requrements. He phoned me at 7:10 AM (unbelievably quick response, imo). He told me that requalifying PtC holders who are NJSP applicants (i.e., no local PD) ARE NOT REQUIRED TO SUBMIT THEIR COMPLETED SP182 FORMS TO *ANY* AUTHORITY. He said that NJSP has no plans to proactively audit the list of PtC holders who are NJSP applicants to confirm requalification per CCARE requirements. His advice to me was to complete my SP182a (list of handguns intended to be carried) and keep that with my SP182 so that I could produce both documents in the event of an incident. He did not indicate that I should keep those documents with me when I carry, but I will probably keep the originals on file at home, and make copies to keep in my car, just in case. Mr. Rosario also told me he would give Dave Peterson at Woodbine a call to "straighten him out". It might be interesting to be a fly on the wall for that conversation... Many thanks to DSG Rosario for clearing up this matter!!!
-
Platking now going after JSD Supply and Eagle Shows
While that is an attractive slogan, I think it's a little more complicated than that in practice. "Loser" pays wouldn't help in this instance unless the loser (e.g. Platkin) had to pay out of his own pocket. And I believe that there are a number of laws that indemnify public officials against being held personally responsible for damage done in the course of their duties, no matter how egregious and unjustified that damage might be. I am also a little apprehensive about that principle where it might affect some little guy who got massively screwed by a big corporation, when litigation was his only recourse. I'm also uncertain how it would apply in class actions.
-
Platking now going after JSD Supply and Eagle Shows
Only if they threatened to key La Pierre's Corniche...
-
NJSP REQUALIFICATION
I have this odd habit of reading beyond what someone has highlighted in a quote :-) That entire paragraph you quoted is chock full of weasel words; "encourage" is just one of them. That word actually means to try to persuade someone to do something that they have discretion to not do. "Chief law enforcement officer of the state" doesn't carry much real meaning without a lot of supporting detail, and "general supervision" does not help at all on that regard. Do you seriously believe if it came down to court challenges and appeals, that ultimately it would be decided that Matt Platkin can, at will, entirely and completely usurp the authority of local administrators to direct the policing of their jurisdictions? I'm not even certain I believe that Matt Platkin himself would indulge that fantasy.
-
On Guns, What's Good for Police Is Good for Us
I can read it at this simplified url: https://bearingarms.com/tomknighton/2023/12/14/on-guns-police-n78433 However, I have JavaScript disallowed by default in my browser. When I allow JS, the site wants me to sign up to read past the teaser. Looks like the webmaster at Bearing Arms either lacks fundamental understanding of how to restrict access to web pages, or doesn't really care about anyone who isn't browsing via smartphone (pretty common). If you can turn off JS for that site, you should be able to read the entire article. If you cannot, here is a link to the article at Reason that Knighton refers to (which is unrestricted): https://reason.com/volokh/2023/12/11/law-enforcement-officers-are-part-of-the-people-not-above-them/
-
I'm not sure what this means, exactly, wanna weigh in?
If all Federal and State governments fully acknowledged and recognized the Constitutional right to keep and bear arms, the raison d'etre for those groups would largely appear to vanish. Of late I have been reflecting on the idea that they may be more acutely aware of that than I previously suspected... A much more succinct expression of what I posted :-)
-
NJSP REQUALIFICATION
Regarding submitting SP182 to NJSP for NJ PtC requalification. I went to Shooters on Tuesday evening, 12/12/2023, to recertify to comply with the CCARE requirements. In my case, my original qualification did not inlcude holster draw. The instructor was Jamell Rosario. The instructor for my original training and qualification in 2022 was Dave Cope (also done at Shooters). I took my completed SP182, signed off by Mr. Rosario, to Woodbine NJSP station this morning to submit it. The trooper on the firearms desk, Dave Peterson, refused to accept it. He gave me two reasons. First, he told me that NJSP Firearms Division is regarding the submission of form SP182a (list of firearms intended to be carried, which I did not yet complete) with SP182 as mandatory. I think that's ridiculous, but it is nothing I can't easily deal with. The second reason is because the instructor who signed my original certification in 2022, Dave Cope, is not the same instructor who signed my SP182 on 12/12/2023. His reasoning was that SP182 also certifies that use of force training was completed, and Mr. Rosario does not have first-hand knowledge that I did that. Trooper Peterson told me that I would either need to get Mr. Cope to sign my recertification SP182, or get Mr. Rosario to furnish me with a copy of his NRA instructor's certificate to submit with my SP182. Presumably, that leaves Mr. Rosario on the hook for certifying my use of force training as well as my shooting, but that isn't my direct concern. He also told me that I will need to furnish a copy of my original qualfication certification that was signed off my Mr. Cope with my other forms. I have contacted Brielle at Shooters to see if Mr. Rosario will furnish a copy of his NRA instructor credentials to me. Hopefully that will resolve the issue. Trooper Peterson claimed to be a 2A supporter (he even claimed that he conducted civilian training classes) but to me, his actions here call that claim into question. How about presuming that, since I do hold a current NJ PtC, that I had successfully completed the use of force training that was required to obtain it (as far as I know, the use of force training requirements have not changed over that period of time)? If I ever entertained any doubt that there are multiple official forces and actors in NJ government who are looking to see that as few permit holders have the legal right to carry in NJ as they can possibly ensure, by maximizing the number of bureaucratic hoops that must be jumped through, this incident has completely dispelled that. Any holder of a current NJ PtC who needs to submit SP182/SP182a to NJSP to meet the additional requirements of CCARE might want to keep my experience in mind.