Everything posted by rauchman
-
Glock vs Sig vs CZ
Have to + 1 the natural shootability of the Sig. I went shooting a few weeks ago w/ the wife and had a P226, 2nd gen G17 and 3rd gen G19 w/ me. After a couple hundred rounds of the Glocks, switched over to the P226 and it was like putting on perfectly fitting gloves. Amazingly easy pistol to shoot very accurately. At 15 yards, my 1st two 5 round groups with the P226 went into 1". With the Glocks I'm struggling to keep the groups under 2", although the G17 is easier to shoot accurately than the G19. Really really have to get a P228/P229. Although the P220 Match gives me a tingly feeling in my pants!!!
-
Damn you all to heck. =P
Count me in for a custom engraved receiver. I've been wanting to build a 18"er.
-
Long Range 9mm pistol?
You can get an Danish M49 Neuhausen for a fraction of what a SIG P210 costs. They're not as pretty as the P210 but in my experience they shoot just as well. Stick with the 147gr bullets as mentioned in the post above. "SIG M/49 Commonly known as the Neuhausen in Denmark, is the Danish military issue weapon in 9x19 mm, and is a specially marked version of the P210-1 or P210-2. This has been the standard sidearm of the Danish military for over 40 years, and is now in the process of being replaced." --Daniel P.S. The .357 SIG is a better round for long range pistol shooting Where o' where does one get one of those beauties and for how much? My wallet is looking at me in fear right now!!! The M49 / P210 are one of those holy grail pistols. Seriously, do you have a source for that pistol for purchase? Other 9mm holy grail pistols.... Steyr GB HK P9S Luger Walther P88 HK P7M8
-
Glock vs Sig vs CZ
What are you basing that on? It isn't a highly stressed part. Based on Glock's experience, the rod will last for years. Even so, it will outlast some of the springs that require changing and will probably outlast the recoil spring. Even if it does break, it will not necessarily affect the firearm's operation. Years back everyone said the poly frames wouldn't last and here we are twenty years later with those same frames still functioning fine. The one group was from a 225 in 40S&W. They were replaced and no further problems were noted. Single or multi-strand makes no difference to me. I have semi-autos in both styles and they all work. Just because a manufacturer changes a spec everyone seems to make a ton of unsubstantiated comments. They are now made a few miles away by basically the same employment pool on the same machines. Sig can keep everything the same and raise their prices up to where S&W went with their third gen. right up to the point of discontinuing the entire line. there is a point where people will stop buying. Sig is no more expensive than the other quality alloy/steel framed firearms. Do you know of any manufacturer that doesn't change any parts over the years? None keep things the same as vendors change, availability changes. You can get a new H&K handgun for less that $800? Not from what I've seen. The going rate starts at $800 and goes up from there. Pricing is almost the same for both manufacturers. Does his best Fred Flintstone face..... oh boy..... If the newer Sigs work for you, more power to ya. As mentioned (numerous times in this thread), to me it seems like Sig is cost cutting by using parts like plastic guide rods and what not. To me these cost cutting measures equal a gun that is not as over engineered to the same level as the older Sigs. And yes, the plastic guide rods won't last as long as metal... and this came from a Sig customer service rep who at first tried to dodge the answer to that question. I wouldn't rule out a new Sig, but I'd be very particular about which model and what parts are in it. You're defensiveness of Sig pistols is justified in that they are a very good pistol. I'm not debating that. They are a different pistol now than they were 10+ years ago though. I prefer the older pistols for reasons already given (numerous times). Again, I wouldn't rule out a new one, but I'd be going into that purchase w/ eyes wide open. IMHO the only thing the newer Sig P series have on the old ones are a better finish and more model variations. As for HK, was looking at a USP 9Compact and it was the same price as a P228 w/ rail = $810 at Meltzers. I guess you made a typo, but I don't think the P225 was ever made in .40.
-
Glock vs Sig vs CZ
According to their website Do you have to avoid these ammo or they are OK for your G22? I don't know about the G22, but I have had problems shooting WWB 115gr 9mm out of my G17. Zero problems when shooting Blaser ammo. I think the WWB is loaded a little light for reliable operation in some guns. Had the same problem shooting WWB .40 out of my CZ75B SA. Again, no problem w/ Blaser. I also find the Blaser more accurate than the WWB. IMHO, WWB is definitely on the lower rung of the ammo ladder.
-
Glock vs Sig vs CZ
Are you using lone wolf? Yes I am. Lone Wolf Distributors 40-9 conversion. I guess I could have just gotten a G17. I wanted something with more umph for home defense at the time. Cool setup!!! Did you have to change out the extractor for the conversion?
-
Got the new S&W mp15 so many questions..
I can't see pictures of your rifle since I'm answering this from the work computer. Make sure your gun is empty!!!! If you currently have the A2 stock ( same stock that is on a fullsize AR15/M-16), it's very easy to remove. There are a couple of screws on the back of stock where it rests against your arm. Remove the top one and slide off the stock. Push out the pin holding the receiver halves together and fold open. In the bottom receiver looking toward the stock area, you'll see the buffer. There is a small spring loaded detent pin pushing up from the bottom. Depress and release buffer and recoil spring. You should be able to twist off the buffer tube from the receiver body. If you have a fixed telescoping stock, you may have to remove the existing stock and replace w/ a new real telescoping stock, set to your desired position and pin. I remember reading that in order for a fixed telescoping stock to be BATF legal, the pin itself can only be accessable from one side of the stock body. In other words you can't just pop it out. You may have to drill it out.... hence the need for a new telescoping stock. I believe most rear sights are setup more or less to the same height. The front sight is where you might run into some small problems. If your running a standard front sight base (the kind that looks stock on an M-16 or M4), I believe they come in mil-spec "F" marked and then the other option is the commercial variants. I know my Bushmaster has the commercial front sight base. Not a big deal as the rear sight can compensate or you can get a longer front sight post. I'm running an LMT fixed rear sight and do not have problems w/ the Bushmaster front sight base. Having said that I also have a S&W M&P T that comes with Troy fold down front and rear sights. These are really nice and have a very positive lock to them. I've read a convincing thread, at least to me, that if you're not giong to be magnifying anything, use a fixed rear sight to cowitness your optic. If using magnified, then use fold down sights. You mentioned that want to co-witness an Aimpoint. Cowitnessing ability will be dependent on the mount you use. I'm using a LaRue mount that co-witnesses the irons in the lower 1/3 or the viewable area of the Aimpoint. In other words the irons will be sighting slightly below the Aimpoint dot, but still easily viewable in the Aimpoints window. My buddy runs an Eotech on his Bushmaster M-4 and it is a true co-witness where the center dot of the Eotech perfectly sits right on top of his front sight. Personal preference comes into play here. I've read pros/cons for both setups. Again, your cowitenssing ability will be determined by the height of mount you use, not the sights you use. Do you want to free float or not? Do you want to mount stuff to the handguards like a flashlight, laser, etc.? If you want basic and don't need to attach stuff, the new Magpul MOE handguards have been getting rave reviews and are really cheap.. I believe about $40 or so, maybe less. My buddy runs Troy non-free float handguards that have the rails. They ran about $140 or so and are pretty solid. He mounts a flashlight in a LaRue mount off the right side and it's a nice setup. Yankee Hill and Midwest Industries also make decent handguards in this price class. If you want free float (where the handguards are not touching the front of the barrel and allows the barrel to be free floated... better accuracy by 1/8 to 1/2 MOA depending on other factors...ammo and barrel quality), then for the better brands, you're easily over $250 or so, some are pushing over $300. Again, sorry I can't see the pic of your rifle, so I don't know what kind of gas system you're running, but they generally come in Carbine lengh (7"), Midlength (9") and Rifle (12"). The "length" is really determined by the gas system's gas tube length. Most require some assembly onto the barrel nut, some replace the barrel nut, some require the removal of the front sight base and muzzle device. Top tier brands are Troy, Larue, Daniel Defence and Knights Reed. 2nd tier brands are generally Yankee Hill and Midwest Industries (MI). Generally the top tier stuff is lighter, requires less 'smithing for install and true Picitinity rails. Don't get too hung up on which "tier" company your buying. I've never seen a legitimate argument that says Yankee Hill or MI is truly inferior. Also, other options here would be the extended rail system, where you're not using a standard front sight base but are having the rail go over the gas port and your front sight is bolted to the rail itself. Also, Daniel Defense makes a rail that has a hole for the front sight base and extends past it another inch or two.... so many choices. I will say, that any metal rail sytem will add forward weight to your rifle. You can easily turn a lighweight M4 style carbine into something weighty by adding lots of stuff. Spend some time on AR15.com and M4carbine.net. Do some searching around and you'll come up w/ more questions than you have now. Hope this helps...
-
Got the new S&W mp15 so many questions..
I find myself in a similar dillemma in that I'd like something other than the A2 stock that came on my Bushmaster. I currently have an ACE stock on it and find the strap stud a little lacking in robustness. Any idea how long the length of pull is w/ the Skully? I've also got the ACE entry stock and find it too short where the regular ACE stock is too long.
-
Glock vs Sig vs CZ
Didn't know this, good to know. Never claimed to be an expert. But do own Sigs, have shot many Sigs including newer ones. Have not shot any post 2006, so can't comment on them. No argument that the plastic guide rods work. However, they won't last as long as steel. To me it seems to be a cost cutting measure that takes away from the quality of the gun. Interesting. Do you know which calibers were affected by the multistrand springs? It would be interesting to know, since between my buddy and I, we have/had multiple Sigs in 9mm, .40, .45, 357 Sig, and have never experienced a problem related to the recoil spring (buddy had a trigger spring go on his P220). Sig was known for outstanding attention to detail in their engineering, the multistrand spring to counter the extreme cold being one of those details. By not putting in that spring, along w/ a metal guide rod and who knows what else, it brings the Sig down a notch. I'm sure they still work fine, but in my mind the Sig name is losing its luster as compared to what it once was. It starts becoming more in line w/ the more main stream brands and has less of that mythical status that was once shared with HK. Again, all these things add up to cost cutting and take away from the allure of the Sigs of old. Sort of like having a BMW w/ Chevy parts in it. As I mentioned, the CPO models are worth the money. It is a question in my mind as to whether the newer ones are worth over $800 new. For that money, I'd easily get an HK and be very content with that purchase. Having said that, the idea of a P228 railed, P229 Elite and/or P220 Match does stir my loins.
-
S&W MP15
I picked up one of these last summer from Bullet Hole. Ashamed to say, it's only been fired once, but I do like it considerably more than the Bushmaster 16" carbine I have. Hand guard is free float and it comes with Troy fold down sights front & rear. Since that one shoot, the gun is smoother when cycling the bolt than the Bushmaster also. I wish it came w/ the 1/7" or 1/8" twist though. Surprised that it doesn't have a target crown on the end of the barrel.
-
Long Range 9mm pistol?
Regardless of the pistol, I would try heavier loads (147gr). You would have more drop, but I have to believe these would buck wind a little better at 100 yards.
-
Long Range 9mm pistol?
How much do you want to spend? If you can afford it, the Sig P210 shooting 147gr bullets, is arguably, one of the, if not the most accurate 9mm pistol you can buy. The pistol is capable of sub 2" groups at 50 yards and come with a target from the factory proving it. You are going to pay for it though. I believe the pistol was designed in the 50's for the Swiss military. You have to love the Swiss and their affection for an accurate weapon. They went off the market for a while, but Sig brought them back to market w/, I believe, 8 variants in 2002 or so. I believe new, they start at about $1800 or so and go up quickly from there. There are models w/ extended barrels and adjustable sights. Past that, probably the best buy out there are the used HK P7's being sold as West German police trade in's. They are running $650ish. Exceedingly accurate pistol and also very unique. Barrel is fixed to the frame, vs. the typical Browning (think 1911) or Browning modified (think Sig, Glock, and most other modern pistols) system where the barrel unlocks from the frame. The pistol works more like a gas operated semi-auto rifle than a typical pistol in that it uses the expanding gas from the cartridge to cycle. If you want new and a realistic price, go w/ some variant from CZ. The CZ75/85 series are designed like the Sig P210 in that the slide rides inside the frame, rather than outside the frame like just about every other auto does. I have a CZ75B SA (single action) in .40 and it is a tack driver. I wish the 9mm was available when I purchased this pistol. With the right ammo, you can easily do sub 2" groups at 25 yards.... rather the pistol is capable of it cause I sure as hell can't shoot that well.
-
Glock vs Sig vs CZ
Don't short change yourself by totally dropping Sig from your list. Granted, with brand new factory models, there are potential QC problems. Again, going w/ a CPO or used model might work for you, in addition to saving a couple hundred $. If you are in a gun store and see a Sig with a blue stripe around the grip, this is a CPO and they generally run in the $600+ range vs. the $800+ range of new ones. I've seen them at the Bullet Hole and Meltzers. Last time I was at the Bullet Hole (month or so ago) they had a couple of used P228's. This gun is on my short list to buy. Kind of like a Glock 19 to the Glock 17, the P228 is a more compact version of the P226. AFAIK, all P228's are German made and still use the sheet metal slide. The P226 I own was purchased used in '99 or so. I sent it to Sigarms and they replaced all springs for free. The P226, as w/ most P models, are hell & back reliable, extremely easy to shoot very accurately, mags can be gotten relatively cheaply from CDNN, and have arguably one of the best DA/SA triggers out there. Having said that, the CZ is a great handgun as well. I bought a CZ75B SA in .40 back in 2000 or so, and it is a tack driver. Back then, I paid under $400 out the door (including tax and NICS) from Bullet Hole. Incredible deal at the time. They have gotten considerably more expensive since then. I was shocked to see they are running in the $600+ range now.
-
Is AR10 really as accurate as good 308 bolt action rifle
I have an AR-10 w/ 20" non-free float tube. W/ mil-surp, I was doing just over 2" averages for 3 shot groups at 100 yards. Better groups were floating around 1.5" at 100 yards. I totally agree w/ the comments made by the other AR-10 owner as to what parts can be changed out to get a tack driving rifle. I bought the AR-10 used, but if buying new, would prefer a DPMS pattern rifle as it seems that this is going to be the "standard" for .308 AR type rifles. I think Armalite makes a slightly higher quality rifle than DPMS, but Knights Reed, DPMS, I believe LaRue, and possibly others are all patterned on the same type receiver w/ mag interchangability. DPMS has a bolt assist where Armalite does not. DPMS style uppers and lowers are now available through CMMG. CMMG also makes an Armalite pattern lower. Magpul is making DPMS pattern mags as well. In Armalite's favor, they do make factory 15 round mags for us NJ'ers. I don't believe 15 rounders exist in the DPMS format. Also, there are good aftermarket parts available for both Armalite and DPMS.... free float tubes, triggers, barrels, etc. Utimate achievable accuracy between the DPMS and Armalite are a wash.
-
Glock vs Sig vs CZ
Is German made better than others? Not necessarily, but for Sigophiles,the W German/German made ones are more desirable. In the P226, the originals up to about '95 or so, had a folded sheet metal slide w/ a firing pin block (not a firing pin safety block, but rather a piece of carbon steel that held the firing pin group) held in by a roll pin. When production began in NH, they went to a milled piece of forged stainless steel slide with the firing pin group milled into the slide. I've read that this was done to give more corrosion resistance to the pistol as requested by the SEALS. Whether this is true or not, I don't know. Also, the older ones were known to have a finish that was not the most durable and you'll read about Sig's rusting. In theory the stainless slide sounds great. I've shot some of the newer P226's and, at least from the samples I've fired, there seemed to be more slop in the slide to frame fit vs. the older German ones with the sheet metal slides. Does this affect accuracy, I don't think so. It's more of a pride thing for the owner. The older sheet metal slides have this feeling of finesse that the newer ones are missing.... at least in the few that I've shot. If I wanted a full size .40, I'd go new P226 or P229 in a heartbeat, as I think these 2 pistols are the nicest/most comfortable shooting .40's I've fired. In 9mm, I'd hunt down an older one. Other things.... I read a thread that's currently on AR15.com that concerns the quality of late model Sigs. I was very surprised to read that the guide rods are sporadically coming in plastic vs. metal. The braided recoil spring has sporadically come as a single nonbraided spring. It seems there is an effort to cut corners for cost. This is also reflected in the now 1 magazine that comes w/ the pistol and the cheaper case. I recently looked at a railed P228 that only came w/ 1 10 round mag vs. the 2 13 round mags it should come with. I very recently read though, that Sig is back to 2 mags. Also, I was very surprised to learn that the former CEO of Kimber is now Sigarms (Sig America). This concerns me as I've read I don't know how many stories of Kimber's lack of QC. If I didn't have to have a brand new Sig, I'd opt for a CPO (Certified Pre Owned) model or hunt an older one. Hope this helps.
-
Glock vs Sig vs CZ
The OP was comparing a G17 to a Sig P229. I think a more fair comparison would be a G17 to a Sig P226 or G19 to a Sig P228/9. Anyway.... If you want a slim and high capacity 9mm, check out a Browning High Power or, if you can find one, a Browning BDM (don't think they are made anymore, but it was a 15 round 9mm DA/SA pistol that was exceedingly slim and very underrated). HK P7 series & Walther P5 are very slim as is just about any 1911 I've seen. I understand the new Ruger LC9 ( not sure of model name, but it's the new 17 rounder w/ Glock type trigger. I have a 9mm Sig P226 (last year of the German made ones), G17 2nd gen, G19 2nd gen, G19 3rd gen (w/ finger grooves & light rail), SA 1911 Loaded, SA XD9 Tact & XD45 Tact, Beretta 92FS, CZ75B SA in .40, HK USP45F .... and the list goes on. Ultimately, find one that fits you well. Everyone's hand is different. I will say that I do believe that any reputable handgun manufacturer (HK, Glock, Sig, etc.) that uses the Sig designed modified Browning locking block design is more or less equally mechanically accurate. After that, it's how well it allows the user to consistently use that accuracy. I do find that the G17 is easily capable of equal accuracy that the Sig P226 delivers, it's just that the Sig allows the shooter to do it a lot easier. For me, I really have to concentrate to shoot tiny groups w/ the Glocks as compared to the Sig. I've also learned that if you practice enough w/ any gun, you will become proficient on it.
-
Anyone in NJ (near NYC) that will do FFL transfers, always?
I've used Police Products a few times in Midland Park (it might be Wycoff). Guys name is Craig. I haven't used him in a couple of years, but IIRC, he charged about $35 or so. Nice guy with a small shop and easy to deal with.
-
Tenafly Pistol Club
Sorry, being the dufus I am, I posted this in Events & Meetups by accident... Greetings, Anyone a member there or have experience at this club? Thinking about joining a club of some type as the public ranges have become nuts. I'd like to find something that offers some kind of competition to take my shooting up a notch. Does this club have any affiliation w/ Cherry Ridge? I live in Teaneck, NJ and Tenafly is a couple of towns over. Does anyone know costs involved in membership at this club? I'd be looking to sign up my wife and I. Thanks, Ken
-
Tenafly Pistol Club
Greetings, Anyone a member there or have experience at this club? Thinking about joining a club of some type as the public ranges have become nuts. I'd like to find something that offers some kind of competition to take my shooting up a notch. Does this club have any affiliation w/ Cherry Ridge? I live in Teaneck, NJ and Tenafly is a couple of towns over. Does anyone know costs involved in membership at this club? I'd be looking to sign up my wife and I. Thanks, Ken
-
Hornady Progressive or Dillon 550B
Greetings, Have an itch to get into reloading. My uncle gave me an RCBS Rock Chucker that is over 20 years old and pretty rusted. This did get the reloaded juices flowing though. After doing some research I want to get either a Hornady Progressive Press or a Dillon 550B. Any thoughts as which is better. Which would require less ancillary equipment? Is one a better value? Which would be cheaper to get a complete setup? I plan on reloading 9mm, .45ACP, .223 & .308. Maybe somewhere down the line, reload for .40 S&W and .260 Rem.
- Glock 30?
-
9mm ammo in stock on Natchezss...
I just got their catalog in the mail a couple of days ago and called to order a case of Blaser 9mm 115. The ONLY 9mm they had in stock was the aforementioned American Eagle at $24.99 per 50. Couldn't believe it!!!! I think .22 conversions are in order. All recreational shooting of centerfire pistols have ceased for now.
-
For the Glock guys & gals
Thanks for the info. I bought the G17 used during the AWB. It came w/ night sights, trigger job and 4 10 round mags. It is surprisingly accurate and very low recoil. I'd consider a newer one w/ the finger grips and rail, but it pisses me off to no end that I can't have a higher than 10 round capacity in a gun that should hold 17 rounds. Back to the GSSF, would the 147gr bullets be better at putting the plates down or lighter weight bullets?
-
Which Pistol to purchase???
I've gotten to shoot a USP9C once at the Bullet Hole. Guy in the port next to me was shooting one and was kind enough to let me take 5 rounds on it. It's really rare I pick up a pistol I've never shot before and be able to pull a 1" group at 10 yards. I REALLY liked that pistol. And I do think the USP has the ultimate control setup.
-
Which Pistol to purchase???
I picked up my CZ in 2004 or so at the Bullet Hole for $375. I can't believe that these guns are now over $600. I've always liked the P-01 (I think that's the model designation.... the compact model w/ light rail).