Everything posted by Pizza Bob
-
Getting Started in Practical Shooting....with a Revolver
For you to consider competing with a revolver you have to have been bitten badly by the competition bug. For me, that is the case and what drives my purchasing decisions, and that is the perspective from which the following advice comes. I think there are three solid choices (indicated with an asterisk) and three alternates – here they are: S&W 686 SSR* – This gun is named such as it was built to shoot in the SSR Division (now subdivision) of IDPA. It is a pro series, rather than a PC which helps keep the cost down (although still higher than a regular 686). Only downside in my book is the fact that it’s chambered in .357 Mag. Being a purpose built gun, it should be a .38 Spl, but it wouldn’t have had wide enough appeal to sustain sales if that was the case. Just means you’ll spend more time scrubbing the chambers. Slab-sided barrel with tapered ejector rod housing makes it less nose heavy than the production gun, which means less recoil mitigation, but faster target transitions. Interchangeable front sight makes it easy to go to a fiber optic one. S&W 686 – The ubiquitous gun. Not a slam – it’s ubiquitous because it does everything well. May not excel at any one thing, but that’s what gives rise to the 686 SSR. Full underlug makes this one nose-heavy, which is great for recoil mitigation, but gives the gun momentum in transitions, making it harder to control – just the opposite of the SSR configuration. Used 686’s aren’t that much less than new ones, but the point is that there are used ones. Best of the litter is the 686-4 (my opinion). S&W 66-8 – This is the new Model 66, which solves the cracking forcing cone issue – although that would never be an issue using mouse-fart .38 Spl loads – which is what you should be using for IDPA, more on that below. This is a K-frame gun which is slightly smaller/lighter than the L-frame 686, although the grip frame is the same size so the hand/gun interface could be the same for both by virtue of grip choice. This uses a two-piece barrel system with a barrel “tube” held in tension by the outer shroud. Conventional design with just an ejector rod shroud, not a full underlug or tapering shroud. My son just bought one of these, but I haven’t had a chance to go shoot it with him. S&W 625 – Who doesn’t love a big bore handgun? These dominated both disciplines (IDPA & USPSA) until USPSA let in the 8-shot revolvers. Can still be used in both and at the lower classifications can still be competitive in both. But realistically, is now an IDPA choice. I’m speaking here of the standard 625’s with a full underlug barrel – advantages/disadvantages as noted above. Some have the interchangeable front sight – some don’t, be aware when shopping. Again, not a large difference in price between new and used – a plus if you’re selling, a minus if buying. The JM versions have a ribbed trigger, some may like that, I don’t and think that it is blister-inducing when using this gun in competition and strictly double action mode. Jerry may like it, but he probably shoots on the order of 10K rounds per month and the trigger pad of his finger is probably a half-inch thick callous. Again something to keep in mind when shopping – there are variations with smooth triggers and a smooth trigger can always be installed in place of a ribbed one, but it will add to your cost. These are the greatest guns to learn about, and be introduced to moon clips. Those that hate them are misguided and haven’t spent enough time with them and/or have tried to “cheap-out” and not utilized the proper tools. These are the least fussy moon clip guns and moons are very inexpensive (on the order of $.40 each). S&W 625PC* – The Performance Center version of the above. Differences include a tapered ejector rod housing, as opposed to a full-lug. A shorter cylinder and a smooth trigger. The shorter cylinder supposedly contributes to better accuracy since the jump to the forcing cone is less (shorter chamber throats), but personally I think that’s BS, especially for practical shooting. The downside of the short cylinder is that it makes the sight radius shorter as the barrel is set-back more in the frame – so while both the standard and the PC versions have 4” barrels, the OAL of the PC model is less (marginally so). I am not certain of the following and don’t feel like looking it up, but the PC guns use “old-fashioned” broach cut rifling, while newer production versions may be using ECM cut rifling – not sure, since the Pro series guns may also use broach cut. There are those that will tell you the ECM rifling is not cast-bullet friendly, but there are those on the other side of that argument that say it is more friendly. My opinion is that there are too many variables with cast bullets to attribute either accuracy or lack thereof solely to the rifling. Again, for practical purposes, no difference – especially since we are seeing less and less pure cast bullets being used – the move is to coated cast bullets which seem to work fine in both types of rifling regardless of the “core” bullet. S&W 929* – Another performance Center gun that is purpose built for competition – this time for USPSA. Gives you an out-of-the-box solution to what used to be exclusively a hand-loader’s realm. Lots of 8-shot 627’s out there, but to be competitive, most owners use .38 Long or Short Colt – strictly a handloading proposition. The 929 allows you all the benefits of a short cartridge, moon clip gun with the ability to use inexpensive store-bought ammunition. The idea was to make this a competition gun that you can just buy and take to a match. That’s seldom the case. Revolver shooters are “fiddlers” by nature and they will always find some problem, real or imagined, that will call for a little fiddling to correct. Some of the early 929’s had some problems with sticky chambers and ejection. Some were picky about ammunition. These things happen with competition revolvers – they are like Ferraris – they are a thing of beauty when they work 100%, but getting to that station and maintaining it, maybe a costly enterprise. Moon clips for these are also expensive, and finding the right ones can be a trial & error nightmare – although at this point, most know what works and what doesn’t – using factory ammo may complicate this process somewhat. AMMO – If you are just venturing into revolver shooting, one assumes the use of factory ammo that won’t break the bank. A wise consideration as the amount we spend on ammo and/or components far exceeds the actual cost of the gun and that happens in short order when we are talking about competition guns. The 9 mm obviously wins this battle – but there is only one gun that I’ve recommended that utilizes the 9 mm round and it is probably the most specialized – single purpose – gun of the lot. A consideration. .45 ACP and .38 Special are about equal as far as cost (factory). However, a consideration of what gun to choose based on caliber has to look at more than just cost. A .45 ACP revolver competes in the Revolver division in either USPSA or IDPA. In the latter it competes in the ESR subdivision. The power factor for IDPA is 155 and for USPSA is 165 – factory ball ammo (the optimum for fast reloads) far exceeds those PF’s and thus handicaps the shooter by doling out more recoil to deal with. Also, marginally harder on the gun. The .38 Spl guns compete in the SSR subdivision of IDPA (while they can be used in USPSA also, it is pretty impractical) which has a PF of only 105 – real mouse-fart loads – but you can obtain factory ammo loaded almost down to that level. Another consideration is ammo brand. In order to optimize trigger pull in a revolver, Federal primers are a must – and if you are using factory ammo, that means sticking to Federal brand ammo – not too much of a hardship since Federal American Eagle ammo is both low-priced and high quality. The above guns would range in price from about $600 to $1100 with the low-end being used 686’s and the upper end would be a new 929. When considering costs there are all those ancillary items like holsters, speed loaders, moon clips, holders for either of the preceding, tools for moon clips, etc. So there you have it. Hope to see more wheelgunners out there trying their hand at something new and challenging. Adios, Pizza Bob
-
TX CHL - carry rules in PA?
Interesting. It appears the PA/TX agreement recognizes the respective licenses without regard to the holders state of residency. If you look at the PA/FL agreement, for example, it specifically states that PA will honor FL licenses held by residents of FL - which precludes all non-resident holders, even though FL has only one license (there is no such thing as a resident/non-resident license). Haven't been doing my homework and relying too much on the MSM for my info. Sorry. I'd still tread carefully. Adios, Pizza Bob
-
TX CHL - carry rules in PA?
If you go to the PA AG website and find the page for firearm reciprocity agreements, you will find that it is blank.
-
TX CHL - carry rules in PA?
This is very much still a gray area. The PA AG - Kathleen Kane (under investigation / lost her law license) - rescinded all reciprocity agreements. The purpose was to prevent PA residents who were denied a PA LTCF, from carrying using a reciprocal state's license. Quite common in Philly as the Philly PD usually over-reached on their authority. So there are those that say it only applies to PA residents and those that say it applies across the board. I don't really want to be the one that defines that via a court case. If Kane resigns or is eventually voted out of office by the legislature (it is an elected position so they can't just fire her - fortunately she has already said that she won't run for re-election) then the reciprocity issue can be revisited by the new AG. You can open carry in PA - but not in Philly without a LTCF (or previously, a reciprocal permit). You cannot get into a car open carrying, as they consider that concealed. However, you can carry in a car provided that you have a carry permit from any state, regardless of reciprocal agreements - this would be the only thing your TX license would be good for at this point. Adios, Pizza Bob
-
Quickest permit turnaround time?
As pointed out previously - you can't use it until 7 days from date of application
-
Heritage Guild (Easton)
If the set screw is missing replace it. Take a center punch and make several punch marks on the bottom of the sight (this assumes the sight is steel) - this will create small craters and the raised edges will improve the fit in the dovetail. When you reinstall, use blue Loc-Tite liberally in the dovetail. Adjust sight to correct position, use a drop of blue Loc-Tite on the set screw and tighten same. Allow Loc-Tite to cure. Adios, Pizza Bob
-
Easton now three gun only as of march.
Vlad - With the IDPA matches there, Ken (the MD) usually didn't open registration until the week of the match. You will probably have to check on the EFGA web site for when registration opens. Once you have registered and shot a match, you will be on Ken's mailing list and you'll be notified by e-mail about upcoming matches and registration. At least that's how it worked with IDPA. Adios, Pizza Bob
-
Easton now three gun only as of march.
Giving credit where credit is due - this was e-mailed to Golf Battery, who then forwarded it to me. He's still working for a living, so in the interest of speed, I thought I'd go ahead and post it. This will posted on the EFGA website shortly. From the MD for Easton 3-gun: Easton 3 Gun 3 Gun is an exciting sport and one of the fastest growing shooting sports in America. Competitors use a rifle, shotgun and handgun to complete courses of fire. 3 Gun Nation is one organization promoting the sport. 2016 will be a trial year for 3 Gun at Easton Fish and Game. We will use 3 Gun Nation Rules, and if the year goes well, we plan to become an affiliated club. The 3 Gun Nation rules are here - http://3gunnation.com/club_series/rules and these rules will be used at Easton. Please read the rules to avoid being disqualified after travelling to a match. Matches will be on the third Saturday of the month. Setup will begin at 8am, check in at 10:30 and match briefing at 11am. Equipment: At this time, we will only be running Practical and Factory divisions. Shooters will require an AR type of rifle chambered in 223 Remington/5.56 NATO. Please note rule 4.1 and 4.1.1. No steel core or steel cased ammunition will be allowed. Neither EFGA or the match directors want their steel targets damaged. (Rule 4.1.1 levies a $100 fine per steel target damaged by steel core ammunition) For club series matches, pistol caliber carbines are also allowed. The handgun will be 9mm minimum caliber and will be carried in a belt holster. We plan to use Newbold self-healing targets and therefore do not allow hollowpoint bullets as they shorten the life of the targets. Shotguns will be 20 or 12 gauge using lead shot size 7 ½, 8 or 9, 00 buckshot and/or slugs. Shooting a shot target with a slug or buckshot will result in a match disqualification. Also see rule 4.4. Practical shotguns will start with no more than 9 shells loaded. Factory shotguns will never have more than 8 shells in the gun. As all three guns could be used on a stage, the competitor will have to carry ammunition for all three guns on their belt. Stages and Round Counts There will be four stages per match. A stage will be in each of the two Special Events bays, one in the Training bay and one on the Rifle Range. The Training bay stage will be handgun and/or shotgun only. It is unlikely that more than 30 rifle rounds will be required per stage, however a mandatory magazine change could be required. No more than 100 rifle rounds should be required for a match. It is unlikely that more than 20 pistol rounds will be required per stage. No more than 100 pistol rounds should be required. It is unlikely that more than 20 shotgun shells will be required per stage. Slug and buckshot targets may be used on the rifle range in addition to shot targets. No more than 100 shotshells, 10 buckshot shells and 10 slugs should be required. Stage Design Stages will almost always require use of more than one gun and the competitor will have to decide how to engage the targets. Targets will be designated to be engaged with certain guns in the stage briefing. We plan to use 3 Gun Nation cardboard targets for pistol and rifle. Rifle only Newbold targets will be red. Rifle Range steel rifle targets will be white. Shotgun only shot targets will be orange and will include stationary orange clay birds, orange Newbold shotgun targets and orange steel. Pistol only Newbold targets will be yellow. Steel targets for pistol or shotgun will be white. Once a competitor has engaged all of targets for one gun, that gun will be grounded, see the rules, and another gun will be used for the appropriate targets. "Dump buckets" will be provided for grounding a gun. The stage briefing will be specific but generally if there are no shooting positions down range of a dump bucket, the gun will have to have the safety engaged before grounding. If there is a shooting position down range of a grounding location, then the gun will have to be empty before grounding. Guns may be staged in pickup locations or carried with slings as specified by the stage briefing. Match Registration Match registration will be online pre-registration only on www.shootnscoreit.com . As we do not have time to teach new shooters safety while setting up the stages, shooters will be required to be classified in a shooting sport. 3 Gun Nation classification will be preferred, however we will accept ICORE, IDPA, IPSC or USPSA classification as well. If time permits, we will keep one Special Events bay stage setup after a match is complete and qualify new shooters. This will not be available at the March match.
-
Anyone Else BBQ Today?
Just about to throw two filets and a couple of baking potatoes on the grill.
-
Boy Scouts, Forestburg Scout Res. Rifle Shooting merit badge?
Perhaps a Winchester Model 67? One of the most prolific boy's rifles. Single shot and had to manually pull the cocking piece after chambering a round. Adios, Pizza Bob
-
See All open sight
I bookmarked this some time ago, as it did look interesting. I see that they have now come out with a tritium added version also. While it piqued my interest, I'd like to try one on a gun before I committed to it. Here's their website... https://seeallopensight.com/ Adios, Pizza Bob
-
Quickest permit turnaround time?
Paul: Is it illegal to issue in less than 7 days from date of application, or just illegal to use it in less than 7 days from date of application? Adios, Pizza Bob<------too lazy to look up the statute
-
New Grips
Aha! It was you. Thank you - never would have found these if I hadn't been looking for stocks for you. You make me feel guilty for not giving up a set of S&W stocks, but like you, at some point I may want my gun(s) to revert to original equipment. Besides, I'm naturally a hoarder. Good luck. Adios, Pizza Bob
- New Grips
-
New Grips
I forget who it was on here that I have to thank for these, but someone was looking for some S&W OE target grips for their N-frame. I was searching for some to link them to when I ran across these. If these look familiar to some of you, it is because they are knock-offs of the high-priced brand. But unlike most knock-offs these exude quality in fit and finish at less than half the price. They may be just enough different that they may be able to avoid any legal entanglements. They come from Turkey and are made by a company called KSD Grips. I think they are just getting started with revolver grips, but have a wide variety of grips for various semi-autos. I can't wait to try them out at Shongum USPSA on March 5th. Adios, Pizza Bob
-
First reloaded 38 special rounds
That's fine if you're shooting USPSA with an 8-shot 627, but if you want to shoot IDPA with a 6-shot revolver and speed loaders, you only have to make a 105 PF. Two slots left for March Somerset on 3/20. We had five revolver shooters there last Sunday. Adios, Pizza Bob
-
First reloaded 38 special rounds
Don't listen to him - LOL. A roll crimp is fine, actually preferable, especially with slower burning powders or heavy recoiling guns - neither of which yours is, but still. Too much roll crimp bulges the case right behind the crimp, to the point it won't chamber. You could back off just a FRC. Adios, Pizza Bob
-
.45 ACP question
^^^^^^^^ This Beretta PX4 is essentially the same gun. Full size or Compact both use the rotating barrel system (Sub-Compact does not). Adios, Pizza Bob
-
Tactical Training Center Range Flemington, NJ
Matters not - same applies
-
Any local place to have a gun engraved?
If you are looking to have your AR receiver engraved, this place used to do it - don't know if they still do but worth a call... Donley's Gun Shop Phone:(215) 529-6578 They're in Quakertown, PA Good luck. Adios, Pizza Bob
-
Tactical Training Center Range Flemington, NJ
They just lose all credibility when they make statements like that. If that's their policy, fine - their house, their rules - but own it, don't try to deny responsibility for your policy by claiming it's the law. Adios, Pizza Bob
-
24 Hour Hold?? Required by FFL Who Received My Warranty Replacement Pistol Direct from the Manufacturer??
Isn't it also possible that because this is a replacement gun with a new serial number, for one previously sold, that the added 24 hours was for notification of the NJSP of the switch. I seem to recall something in the statute that the NJSP must be notified in the event of a warranty replacement - OTOH, I believe that was only a requirement if it was returned to the manufacturer by the original selling dealer and I don't believe that was the case in this event. Probably just what Paul said. Adios, Pizza Bob
-
Mission Style Furniture
I did a quick Google search and came up empty. If you are interested in the real deal (as opposed to reproductions), David Rago Auctions in Lambertville has Arts & Crafts Auctions several times a year. Here's his website... https://www.ragoarts.com/ Didn't see anything upcoming in the near future, but you could contact them and see when the next A&C period auction will be - or tell him what you are looking for and maybe he can steer you. Good luck. Adios, Pizza Bob
-
686 Grip Question
If you hold the gun with the muzzle up and tilted to the side to which the cylinder opens, there is less likely hood that you will have a case hang-up on the grip. When I reload on the clock (with a speed loader) I almost never have a hang-up occur. But at the end of a COF when I am unloading to show the SO an empty cylinder, the round closest to the frame of the gun hangs-up considerably more often. I concluded that the SO is looking over my right shoulder, or around the right side of my body (I'm right-handed) and thus I tend to tip the gun in that direction, resulting in more frequent hang-ups. So when can we expect you at an IDPA match - revolvers are getting more popular. Adios, Pizza Bob
-
shooting mat
Here's a new, improved mat from Midway... http://ads.midwayusa.com/product/276544/midwayusa-pro-series-competition-shooting-mat?cm_mmc=pf_ci_ebay-_-Shooting+-+Shooting+Mats-_-MidwayUSA-_-276544&sdc_id=eBay