Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Princetonian58

Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Princetonian58

  1. One can only hope that Roberts and Alito withheld their votes because of a perceived vote against public carry by Kennedy which would be the death knell for CCW.
  2. The vote against hearing the case was 7-2 with Thomas writing a short dissent with which Gorsuch concurred. From a quick read, it seems that some members of the Court want more decisions by the Courts of Appeals before deciding the case. It is troubling that Peruta was not supported by the Chief or Alito. That suggests that the votes are not there to uphold the right to public carry.
  3. Peruta is not on today's order list so it will likely be scheduled for conference on June 22 which I believe is the last conference date of the term.
  4. Peruta was distributed for conference, for the fifth time, today. If certiorari was granted or denied, the case will be listed in an Order list Monday morning at 10 am. I believe the only exception being if one or more Justices should desire to write an opinion in dissent from a denial of certiorari. In that case, the report of the disposition may be delayed. They can of course redistribute the case once again for another conference. There are three more conference sessions scheduled this term, June 8, 15 and 22.
  5. Peruta is not on today's order list so it appears it may be conferenced yet again.
  6. Latest on Peruta: Apr 17 2017 DISTRIBUTED for Conference of April 21, 2017. Justice Gorsuch will have a chance to vote on certiorari Friday. All depends on whether Kennedy is on board with the conservatives or liberals.
  7. Yesterday, Peruta was distributed to SCOTUS for conference on March 24, 2017.
  8. A person who dies without a will dies intestate. In that case, NJ statutes specify which heirs take the estate. The preference is obviously surviving spouse, if married at time of death, and children. Then parents, siblings etc. The State takes the property when no heirs exist or fail to come forward an open an estate. That is called "escheat" and is not the same as "intestacy."
  9. Agree with Golf Battery. It the use of the permits that is restricted, not the application for them.
  10. For those keeping score, application mailed 12/22/16; check cashed 2/16/17; permit received today, 2/21/17.
  11. I understand that SCOTUS hasn't decided whether the 2nd Amendment protects the right to carry outside the home. But my point is that such a right would be asserted in defense of the Hudson law when challenged by an anti-gun state/group. If that right exists, then the statute by definition protects and implements a fundamental right which trumps the state's right argument, not unlike how the recognition of gay marriage by SCOTUS forced state laws barring it to yield. I just don't see SCOTUS saying, even assuming the 2nd Amendment protects the right to carry outside the home, the Hudson reciprocity law is nonetheless unconstitutional on states' rights grounds.
  12. Heard Scott Bach on GFH Radio today and he was his usual cautious self regarding the current bill. While he also reads it as providing two way reciprocity that would allow NJ residents to carry on a Florida nonresident permit, he seems not to want this. First he claims it cannot overcome a Democratic filibuster with 60 votes. This ignores that the Senate when Democratic controlled invoked the nuclear option for votes except confirmation of a SCOTUS nominee. Republicans can and will follow suit. Second, he seems to think it's unconstitutional in any event. However, before SCOTUS could hold the reciprocity law unconstitutional, it would first have to declare there is no 2nd Amendment right to carry outside the home. Because if that right exists, then a statute that ensures states cannot deny that fundamental right to citizens of other states when in NJ, for example, would have to prevail over a NJ law to the contrary. Bach clearly wants to play the long game rather than take on the recalcitrant states.
  13. The way I see it is that NJ is a may issue state and in fact issues CCPs, albeit a ridiculously small number. The bill is not limited to shall issue or constitutional carry states. The fact that some privileged persons qualify and receive permits is enough. Will the Democrats fight it? Absolutely. Will clearly be a fast track to the SCOTUS which in itself is probably a 2-3 minimum timeline.
  14. By statute, NJ does provide for carry, just not in practice. The clarification that came out says any permit/license will suffice, resident or non-resident so it's moot.
  15. Yes, I agree but he also asked whether having NH would satisfy a photo requirement if one exists in the new bill. It would not for the reasons I gave.
  16. I agree. If it gets through the Senate, Trump will sign it. The problem will be litigation by the gun grabber states like NJ/NY/MD/CA and the like to block it via injunction. A main weakness is that the legislation effectively forces all states to be subject to the standards for issuance of a carry permit by the least stringent state, such as Utah. FL and other states require proof of completion of a firearms training class. That requirement would be circumvented by simply obtaining a Utah non-resident permit. Thus, I can see even some of the free states having some objections and concerns about the bill as currently drafted. Then again, some states have a more rigorous procedure to obtain a plenary driver's license than others yet one state's license is as good as any for travel through the entire country. Will be interesting to watch.
  17. Utah and Florida require submission of a passport sized photo and the license will carry the photo. New Hampshire only requires you to fill out their form and mail a check; no photo.
  18. To fight this you will have to go to court. The way to handle this is to bring your proofs and come early. Almost all municipal courts have private attorneys that work as municipal prosecutors as part of their practice. They do not work for the Prosecutor's Office. They will typically sit in an ancillary office about an hour before the scheduled court starting time and essentially negotiate plea deals, ordinarily with persons who have engaged lawyers to defend them. If the municipal prosecutor is fair, and a lot of them are, he may agree to move before the court to dismiss the summons/complaint against you without forcing you to the trial after you show him your proofs why a mistake was made. If you are forced to try the case, however, you'll likely be there for hours since municipal judges go through their spiel about how the court operates, guidelines etc, and then they process all of the guilty pleas, one by one. Each one will take about 10 minutes. Then, the judge likely will take contested cases, those that must be tried, by those defendants who have lawyers present since the lawyers most often work on a flat fee and the judge knows that they will lose money for each minute they have to sit there waiting to be heard. Then, lastly, they try the contested cases like yours, against defendants without lawyers. The Rules of Evidence apply so don't expect to have the judge allow an affidavit from your employer to be admitted and considered since the prosecutor cannot cross-examine the affidavit. It's what they call hearsay. Good luck.
  19. I have a Springfield XDS chambered in .45. Recently, when the action is closed, the end of the guide rod protrudes about a quarter inch out from the slide vs. being flush. Had the gun sent back to the factory for review and repair if necessary. Factory claims that this is normal and will not impair the firearm's function. Anyone out there encountered this before? Any ideas why this has occurred? Thanks.
  20. I read the language immediately before the bold type as providing an alternative: "who is carrying a valid license or permit which is issued pursuant to the law of a State and which permits the person to carry a concealed firearm or is entitled to carry a concealed firearm in the State in which the person resides...." A NJ resident who has FL or UT CCW "is carrying a valid license or permit which is issued pursuant to the law of a State and which permits the person to carry a concealed firearm." The next clause begins with the word "or" which signifies the alternative ground: having a resident CCW. If NJ is forced by federal law to allow CCW holders from other states to carry in NJ, regardless of what NJ allows for its own residents, what is the point of continued insistence on "justifiable need"? It may also open NJ to an equal protection challenge by NJ residents. I also agree with GRIZ that 60 Senate votes are only necessary to avoid a filibuster. However, since the Dems took the nuclear option on filibusters when they had the hammer, except for SCOTUS confirmation votes, the GOP can force a vote if they want to which would be a simple majority.
  21. Here's the scenario. Uncle lives in Virginia and owns several handguns that belonged to his father, my grandfather. Uncle, who is not a FFL, wishes to give me one of my grandfather's handguns. No consideration, just a pure gift. Must I have the firearm sent to a NJ FFL and obtain a permit for the transfer; or can the firearm be legally acquired in Virginia as a gift and transported under FOPA to residence in NJ?
  22. I bought a Walther PPQ M2 in 9mm from Bud's earlier this summer and could not be more satisfied with the transaction. First of all, the firearm was about $70 cheaper than what I could find locally and no sales tax which would have added another $40 to the transaction in NJ. I paid by providing bank authorization which expedited the sale; it took about a week for the funds to be withdrawn and credited. No service charge. The gun shipped the day after the funds cleared and there was no charge at all for shipping (FedEx). I opted for the $5 insurance. I had the gun sent to Monmouth Arms and Steve there could not be more pleasant and efficient. $25 FFL transfer and $15 NICs. Highly recommend.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.