Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Mag Ban down to District Court now ?

Featured Replies

UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE THIRD CIRCUIT
19-3142
Association New Jersey Rifle, et al v. Attorney General New Jersey, et al
3-18-cv-10507
O R D E R
The mandate issued on 12/3/20 is hereby recalled in light of the U.S. Supreme Court's decision
vacating the judgment of this Court with costs and remanding the matter for further proceedings.

For the Court,
s/ Patricia S. Dodszuweit
Dated : 8/1/22
Cc: All counsel of record
 

 

US 3rd Order.pdf

What does this mean? I don't speak legalese

  • Author
1 minute ago, MartyZ said:

What does this mean? I don't speak legalese

"We got our a** kicked by SCOTUS and we are sending this a** kicking down to district court so they can swallow pride and rule the mag ban unconstitutional".

 

I am not a lawyer, but looks like its now District Court who need to rule mag ban as unconstitutional - i.e People get back to "normal" capacity mags like rest of the USA.

 

Nice explanation. I can't wait to start ordering me some 30 round mags.

I gotta say, it'll be nice to have standard capacity mags in self defense firearms again, but the biggest thing I'm looking forward to is standard capacity for my .22cal AR. The 10 round mag is a real bummer with that. Pinging steel, doing multiple targets, etc... the mag is empty just as you get going.  

Any thoughts on a time frame?

What this says is that the circuit court isn't deciding on this. They have passed the buck back down for some lower court judge to put their name on a bad decision. Then it will be sent back up. Then they will likely pull a panel of three that will say yeah a mag ban is no bueno. Then they will say but no... and call for en banc. Then they can proceduraly drag that out for years. Then they will say mag ban fine. Then it will go back to the supreme court. 

I'm hoping that's not the way it goes, but it sure it looking like it. 

California will get full cap mags before we do... cause they are doing the same thing, but that means it is going back to St. Benitez.

1 hour ago, kc17 said:

I gotta say, it'll be nice to have standard capacity mags in self defense firearms again, but the biggest thing I'm looking forward to is standard capacity for my .22cal AR. The 10 round mag is a real bummer with that. Pinging steel, doing multiple targets, etc... the mag is empty just as you get going.  

Any thoughts on a time frame?

Yes! Same for my m9-22. I'm out here trying to have some fun, not reload 50 times in 15 minutes. 

22 minutes ago, raz-0 said:

 

California will get full cap mags before we do... cause they are doing the same thing, but that means it is going back to St. Benitez.

What about pinned muzzle brakes and stocks? 

 

2 hours ago, MartyZ said:

What does this mean? I don't speak legalese

That's a great quote. :good:

1 hour ago, Bomber said:

What about pinned muzzle brakes and stocks? 

 

That’s a different suit. 

  • I'll be dead by the time these jackwads give us back our rights. Ugh

The 9th circuit just did the same thing with the CA AWB that was GVR’d back from scotus.  Remanded it to the district court to rehear the case. 

100% an attempt to delay because they have no ground to stand on.  
 

Edit:  where does this say it is the 3rd circuit remanding it back to the District?  After rereading it it sounds like the 3rd district is accepting that SCOTUS remanded it back to them and are recalling the case for additional hearings.  

1 hour ago, voyager9 said:


 

Edit:  where does this say it is the 3rd circuit remanding it back to the District?  After rereading it it sounds like the 3rd district is accepting that SCOTUS remanded it back to them and are recalling the case for additional hearings.  

You might be right

it is not clear that the 3rd Circuit is sending back down to the District Court. 
 

 

45 minutes ago, CJack said:

I aint no lawyer, but the document says "remanding the matter for further proceedings".. right ?
 

https://federalcriminallawcenter.com/2021/10/what-does-remand-for-further-proceedings-mean/

Right.  It was SCOTUS doing the remanding.. technically a Grant, Vacate, Remand (GVR) back to the Circuit.  The way I read it is that the District is recalling their previous mandate (ruling) on the case because Scotus told them to.  

On 8/2/2022 at 5:24 PM, raz-0 said:

What this says is that the circuit court isn't deciding on this. They have passed the buck back down for some lower court judge to put their name on a bad decision. Then it will be sent back up. Then they will likely pull a panel of three that will say yeah a mag ban is no bueno. Then they will say but no... and call for en banc. Then they can proceduraly drag that out for years. Then they will say mag ban fine. Then it will go back to the supreme court. 

I'm hoping that's not the way it goes, but it sure it looking like it. 

California will get full cap mags before we do... cause they are doing the same thing, but that means it is going back to St. Benitez.

Wasn't it part of the NYSRPA v Bruen Supreme Court ruling that they had a finite time to rule on this?

 

22 minutes ago, Krdshrk said:

Wasn't it part of the NYSRPA v Bruen Supreme Court ruling that they had a finite time to rule on this?

 

Not anywhere i read. There was a warning about slow walking ccw permits specifically to deny rights. 
 

The upside of the mag bag cases is that the delay can only be so long unless we ares screwed. DC has a case, and its path To scotus is shorter. 

I don't beleive the appellate courts would kick a remanded cases down to lower courts with respect to this case for 2 reasons. 

1. Both Appellate and District court rulings were the same. To remand the case again, to an even lower court would suggest the appellate decision was wrong in some respect, but they already ruled on it... that ruling is what's being challenged. I don't beleive a case that's already been ruled on can be struck and remanded. If for example the lower district court reversed opinion, the appellate courts decision still takes precedent because it's a higher court. 

2. SCOTUS remanded the case which explicitly states for the appellate court to rehear the cases under Bruen.. 

8 minutes ago, JackDaWack said:

I don't beleive the appellate courts would kick a remanded cases down to lower courts with respect to this case for 2 reasons. 

1. Both Appellate and District court rulings were the same. To remand the case again, to an even lower court would suggest the appellate decision was wrong in some respect, but they already ruled on it... that ruling is what's being challenged. I don't beleive a case that's already been ruled on can be struck and remanded. If for example the lower district court reversed opinion, the appellate courts decision still takes precedent because it's a higher court. 

2. SCOTUS remanded the case which explicitly states for the appellate court to rehear the cases under Bruen.. 

Cool belief. Too bad they already did.  It’s literally the op this thread.  That’s what that says. The circuit court (i.e. the federal appellate court)  is remanding it back to the federal district court. 
 

Scotus gvred the case. The only thing the Sprite court is compelled to do is to not stick with their original ruling and reasoning. 

9 minutes ago, raz-0 said:

Cool belief. Too bad they already did.  It’s literally the op this thread.  That’s what that says. The circuit court (i.e. the federal appellate court)  is remanding it back to the federal district court. 
 

Scotus gvred the case. The only thing the Sprite court is compelled to do is to not stick with their original ruling and reasoning. 

I find it hard to beleive they would vacate an opinion, and then restate it. Which is a good indicator they would be flipping. 

It was remanded to district in a month? That's a good timeline. The district court will now hear it. It's less "reaching" which is probably why they did it. This is legal damage control. I wouldnt be surprised if it wasn't appealed. It would apply to all of NJ though.

On 8/2/2022 at 4:17 PM, CJack said:

"We got our a** kicked by SCOTUS and we are sending this a** kicking down to district court so they can swallow pride and rule the mag ban unconstitutional".

 

I am not a lawyer, but looks like its now District Court who need to rule mag ban as unconstitutional - i.e People get back to "normal" capacity mags like rest of the USA.

 

sorry if this sounds stupid.....but did we ever have normal capacity here in nj?

27 minutes ago, 1LtCAP said:

sorry if this sounds stupid.....but did we ever have normal capacity here in nj?

Yes!  I had 30 round mags for my Mini 14 before the 1st assault weapons ban.

On 8/2/2022 at 5:24 PM, raz-0 said:

What this says is that the circuit court isn't deciding on this. They have passed the buck back down for some lower court judge to put their name on a bad decision. Then it will be sent back up. Then they will likely pull a panel of three that will say yeah a mag ban is no bueno. Then they will say but no... and call for en banc. Then they can proceduraly drag that out for years. Then they will say mag ban fine. Then it will go back to the supreme court. 

I'm hoping that's not the way it goes, but it sure it looking like it. 

California will get full cap mags before we do... cause they are doing the same thing, but that means it is going back to St. Benitez.

No one thought (A) SCOTUS would give us the decision we got. Read some of the comments in the forums, they are laughable now, ha and (B) the NJAG would send out a directive the very next day. Judges do not like to be overturned, it's like being publicly humiliated. They have the cover they need now to keep their progressive creds in tact. This may move faster than we think, we should be hopefully optimistic.

If this happens, it will be nice to reunite with a box of mags that I had to exile out of state. 

22 hours ago, raz-0 said:

Cool belief. Too bad they already did.  It’s literally the op this thread.  That’s what that says. The circuit court (i.e. the federal appellate court)  is remanding it back to the federal district court. 

That’s not how I read the notice.  The circuit court is recalling their prior decision for further proceedings because scotus vacated and remanded it back to the circuit court.   It never mentions the district court.  

14 hours ago, 1LtCAP said:

sorry if this sounds stupid.....but did we ever have normal capacity here in nj?

Yes, and unneutered AR's.  Flim-Flam Florio gave us N.J.'s AWB in 1990 (four years before the Clinton AWB).

He got bounced out on his ass after one term but the AWB remains. (Dems didn't have ballot drop boxes and voting that went on for weeks back then).

6 hours ago, Bomber said:

Yes, and unneutered AR's.  Flim-Flam Florio gave us N.J.'s AWB in 1990 (four years before the Clinton AWB).

He got bounced out on his ass after one term but the AWB remains. (Dems didn't have ballot drop boxes and voting that went on for weeks back then).

Think about that…….that’s 32 years ago. Some members on this forum weren’t born yet! 

9 hours ago, voyager9 said:

That’s not how I read the notice.  The circuit court is recalling their prior decision for further proceedings because scotus vacated and remanded it back to the circuit court.   It never mentions the district court.  

What do you think remand means? It means to be sent back. You can't send the case back to yourself. It's been remanded to the district court. 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.