Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Is a Speedloader/Moonclip with Ammo Considered a Loaded Magazine?

Featured Replies

Also there is a difference....

 

I see nothing wrong with saying "I would err on the side of caution and not do that"

Vs

"loaded magazines are illegal to transport" is a flat out lie and should not be stated..

 

IMO of course..

  • Replies 69
  • Views 8.1k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • "loaded" mags are "ok" if and only if there is NO gun(s) present in the car. The "loaded" mag is "ok" if and only if, it is not filled w/ "hollow point" ammo. The loaded mags are "ok" as long as the m

  • and not to "blow our own horn" as in NJGF.com... but honestly this site is comprised of some pretty knowledgeable people.. people who answer questions backed up with actual fact as opposed to anecdota

  • We as a group need to stop making this stuff up, please don't make your own rules and laws, we have it bad enough with out this stuff.   At least the 15 round count right..

Also there is a difference....

 

I see nothing wrong with saying "I would err on the side of caution and not do that"

Vs

"loaded magazines are illegal to transport" is a flat out lie and should not be stated..

 

IMO of course..

 

I have to agree. As a new shooter that has just begun to navigate the minefield that is NJ gun laws,I would appreciate the the bare facts of the letter of the laws, not the silted opinions of every yahoo who has handled a firearm in the past eon.

I know there are grey areas and interpretations to said laws but I also believe that abiding by every nuance for the sake of time or possible trouble only succeeds to water it down even further, even for the LEO's just trying to do their jobs.

The facts....just the facts and then let me ,as a thinking and reasoning entity make my own decisions.

I say that when you start to abide by laws that do not exist you are only making things worse for the gun community and screwing other law abiding citizens... You are in essence doing the entire community a disservice...

 

If you know the law.. Teach it..

 

I transport loaded magazines... Why you ask? Because they are legal as per jn law... So when you or anyone else starts a rumor that they are not... People start to listen and. Believe that nonsense.. And now let's just say an Leo hears this and assumes that is true... Again more problems.... Educate people on the law... Not random laws you make up....

 

Absolutely agreed. In my short time being part of this forum (and please, this is not intended to be disrespectful to anyone), it seems any "legal" type question I've asked, has resulted in at least 2-different answers, ranging from one end of the spectrum to the other. When legal questions are asked, if you don't know the right answer, don't say anything or at least say you're not sure. In additional, don't answer a legal-based question with an "I've been doing it that way for years and never had a problem", so it must be legal and OK to do.

 

If feel the reason that many, if not most people (I definitely fall into this group) come to this forum is because it's FOR NJ, BY NJ, etc. People have a higher expectation that NJ specific knowledge will be gained and given. When flat-out incorrect legal answers are given, it brings the integrity of the board down a notch I think.

 

I've truly appreciated the patience and time folks here have spent with me in answering my questions and providing guidance and opinion. I do agree, however, there's more inaccurate information being passed then should be.

So, I'm going to the range and bring all locked in my trunk:

1) A gun in a case so it's not just flopping around in my trunk.

2) Ammo in a bag with magazines loaded.

3) Some stuff to shoot at, oil, tools, ect..

As long as a loaded magazine, or even one bullet, is not in the case with my gun I'm fine. Correct, right?

 

To venture a guess...if someone got stopped with a gun within reach and ammo within reach that would quite possibly be considered a loaded weapon. You can't just carry a gun and drop the mag when you see flashing lights behind you and think you'll be charged with something less than having a loaded weapon.

So, I'm going to the range and bring all locked in my trunk:

1) A gun in a case so it's not just flopping around in my trunk.

2) Ammo in a bag with magazines loaded.

3) Some stuff to shoot at, oil, tools, ect..

As long as a loaded magazine, or even one bullet, is not in the case with my gun I'm fine. Correct, right?

 

To venture a guess...if someone got stopped with a gun within reach and ammo within reach that would quite possibly be considered a loaded weapon. You can't just carry a gun and drop the mag when you see flashing lights behind you and think you'll be charged with something less than having a loaded weapon.

 

To venture an answer... Just the fact that :1The pistol is not in the trunk,back seat,bed,tool box not within easy reach and proximity of ammo would mean you're screwed.

2 Just the mags unless over legal capacity,ammo boxes,loaded or not is not grounds to be arrested unless you're a disqualified person.

I'm sure there are other opinions as there always are, but these basics is what I understand.I drive either a SUV or estate wagon both of which I have access to the cargo areas without opening a door or trunk so I transport my guns in a locked gun case and extra ammo and fully loaded mags in a range bag in the same cargo area as the locked guns. This I KNOW is legal and appropriate and not up for debate according to NJ state transport laws.

Here let's put this to rest...

In nj you can not transport a loaded firearm..

Nj defines the word firearm..

 

. "Firearm" means any handgun, rifle, shotgun, machine gun, automatic or semi-automatic rifle, or any gun, device or instrument in the nature of a weapon from which may be fired or ejected any solid projectable ball, slug, pellet, missile or bullet, or any gas, vapor or other noxious thing, by means of a cartridge or shell or by the action of an explosive or the igniting of flammable or explosive substances. It shall also include, without limitation, any firearm which is in the nature of an air gun, spring gun or pistol or other weapon of a similar nature in which the propelling force is a spring, elastic band, carbon dioxide, compressed or other gas or vapor, air or compressed air, or is ignited by compressed air, and ejecting a bullet or missile smaller than three-eighths of an inch in diameter, with sufficient force to injure a person.

 

A firearm IS a gun... Not a magazine.. Not a speedclip... But a gun.. No confusion about it...

 

Again I get the intent... To keep people out of trouble... But why spread misinformation... We have enough crazy laws as it is...

I have read of several cases (not necessarily in NJ)

 

Not in NJ == doesn't matter.

If gun is in car gun has to be cased.... If not it is violation...that is the law... So you could not have a loaded gun and just drop out mag...

 

I would not put loaded magazine in same case as gun. I think transporting loaded magazine in a separate bag from unloaded gun is legal. Although, I wouldn't do it myself.

I say that when you start to abide by laws that do not exist you are only making things worse for the gun community and screwing other law abiding citizens... You are in essence doing the entire community a disservice...

 

If you know the law.. Teach it..

 

I transport loaded magazines... Why you ask? Because they are legal as per jn law... So when you or anyone else starts a rumor that they are not... People start to listen and. Believe that nonsense.. And now let's just say an Leo hears this and assumes that is true... Again more problems.... Educate people on the law... Not random laws you make up....

I dont give legal advice... I either hire an attorney to do it for me or advise my students to search out an attorney on their own and ask their legal questions there. I quote laws I am sure of (15 round maximum capacity, interstate transportation of firearms, reciprocity of CCW, etc). Beyond that I instruct my students to err on the side of caution because of misinterpretation by the AG or LEOs. I dont start rumors, but as an instructor, Im doing my students a diservice letting them get jacked up legally because the rumors are out there. I will continue to WARN (not state as fact) against traveling with loaded magazines because of the misinterpretation by LEOs. If anyone wants to travel with loaded magazines and risk running into the wrong LEO, fine. Just keep in mind, you're going to be the test case for an out of control legal system and you better be able to afford a great legal team to get off free and clear and keep your second amendment rights. As much as we all want the laws to be black and white, they arent in NJ... they will be interpreted by LEO, presecuting attorneys, and the AG office on a whim. I dont want to be on the receiving end of someones bad day.

I dont give legal advice... I either hire an attorney to do it for me or advise my students to search out an attorney on their own and ask their legal questions there. I quote laws I am sure of (15 round maximum capacity, interstate transportation of firearms, reciprocity of CCW, etc). Beyond that I instruct my students to err on the side of caution because of misinterpretation by the AG or LEOs. I dont start rumors, but as an instructor, Im doing my students a diservice letting them get jacked up legally because the rumors are out there. I will continue to WARN (not state as fact) against traveling with loaded magazines because of the misinterpretation by LEOs. If anyone wants to travel with loaded magazines and risk running into the wrong LEO, fine. Just keep in mind, you're going to be the test case for an out of control legal system and you better be able to afford a great legal team to get off free and clear and keep your second amendment rights. As much as we all want the laws to be black and white, they arent in NJ... they will be interpreted by LEO, presecuting attorneys, and the AG office on a whim. I dont want to be on the receiving end of someones bad day.

 

I appreciate your integrity and commitment to your students but just one question.... Do you have any documented examples or instances of a NJ resident being arrested,tried and convicted of having a loaded firearm in reach based solely on a stop with a loaded mag,speed loader or half moon?

 

I'll amend the question by asking for documented instances of just being arrested and acquitted?

I dont give legal advice... I either hire an attorney to do it for me or advise my students to search out an attorney on their own and ask their legal questions there. I quote laws I am sure of (15 round maximum capacity, interstate transportation of firearms, reciprocity of CCW, etc). Beyond that I instruct my students to err on the side of caution because of misinterpretation by the AG or LEOs. I dont start rumors, but as an instructor, Im doing my students a diservice letting them get jacked up legally because the rumors are out there. I will continue to WARN (not state as fact) against traveling with loaded magazines because of the misinterpretation by LEOs. If anyone wants to travel with loaded magazines and risk running into the wrong LEO, fine. Just keep in mind, you're going to be the test case for an out of control legal system and you better be able to afford a great legal team to get off free and clear and keep your second amendment rights. As much as we all want the laws to be black and white, they arent in NJ... they will be interpreted by LEO, presecuting attorneys, and the AG office on a whim. I dont want to be on the receiving end of someones bad day.

 

I fail to see how a loaded magazine is a loaded firearm as per NJ law... You could run into misinformed Leo who thinks anything that is wrong... They could think your brake is a flash hider... Anything could happen... I respect you wanting to be overly cautious and respect your fear of the NJ legal system.. But I find the fear misplaced... I can't live in fear of things that are not actually there or I would drive myself nuts.... Good luck with what you are doing..

Because NJ doesn't have a clear and concise definition of "loaded" (none that I could find, correct me if I'm wrong), this has caused people to start making assumptions like this.

 

The guys over in California have put together some good resources around this topic as they too have encountered the "loaded mag = loaded gun" controversial assumption. Well worth a read: My link

 

Needless to say, California has beat this to death, and the article I linked above has some case law examples around it. I agree with the quote below from the article.

 

Ammunition or Loaded Magazines in locked containers

Ammunition may be carried in the same container as the gun – loose ammunition or ammunition in ammo boxes does not make a gun loaded, because the ammunition is NOT “placed into a position from which it can be fired”.

 

You may transport loaded magazines and speed loaders, so long as they are not inserted into the magazine well or cylinder of the firearm. That does not make a gun loaded, because the ammunition carried that way is NOT “placed into a position from which it can be fired”.

 

A loaded magazine is not the same as a loaded weapon, and possession of a weapon and a loaded magazine for that weapon does not, necessarily, mean you have a loaded weapon.

 

Anyone who asserts something contrary to the above 3 points is simply wrong. That does not mean you cannot be arrested by uninformed or badly trained law enforcement officer, or charged with the crime of carrying a loaded weapon by an uninformed or politically motivated prosecutor. It does mean that, if it goes to court and you have good representation, the prosecution should lose on the law. There are certain exceptions to this outlined below.

 

Your comfort level may lead you to do more than the law requires. Please also see Transport Restriction for Handguns for some important additional notes on transporting handguns in California.

 

Because NJ doesn't have a clear and concise definition of "loaded" (none that I could find, correct me if I'm wrong), this has caused people to start making assumptions like this.

 

The guys over in California have put together some good resources around this topic as they too have encountered the "loaded mag = loaded gun" controversial assumption. Well worth a read: My link

 

Needless to say, California has beat this to death, and the article I linked above has some case law examples around it. I agree with the quote below from the article.

While they do not define loaded they do define firearm...

If the firearm as defined by nj (the actual item that expels the projectile) does not have ammunition inserted in it.. Then there is no way it could be considered loaded.... The firearm either has ammunition in it (loaded) or does not have ammunition in it (unloaded)... Unless of course the state has a specific rule to the contrary... Which NJ does not...

I appreciate your integrity and commitment to your students but just one question.... Do you have any documented examples or instances of a NJ resident being arrested,tried and convicted of having a loaded firearm in reach based solely on a stop with a loaded mag,speed loader or half moon?

 

I'll amend the question by asking for documented instances of just being arrested and acquitted?

I have none, but as I said earlier, I dont want to be a test case (and dont want my students to be a test case either). Example, hunters are being stopped in the field and asked for FIDs (I have to admit this is hearsay but I personally know one who was and trust he was not deceiving me) despite the fact an FID is a permit to purchase a long arm. NJ2C:39-6f specifically states a permit to carry is not necessary when:

 

(2) A person carrying a firearm or knife in the woods or fields or upon the waters of this State for the purpose of hunting, target practice or fishing, provided that the firearm or knife is legal and appropriate for hunting or fishing purposes in this State and he has in his possession a valid hunting license, or, with respect to fresh water fishing, a valid fishing license;

 

A hunting licence precludes the need for an FID while hunting... but the AG office is interpreting the laws differently. So if this law is gray enough that the AGs office is harassing law abiding hunters, what else will they push the envelope on? My FID says "State of NJ Purchaser Identification Card" on top... many being issued now say permit to possess on top. Will a person be found guilty in a court of law for possessing a gun without an FID, who knows? My buddy had his FID and showed it but protested to the CO... who simply said, thats what he was told to do. I will error on the side of caution and continue to warn my students about he possibility of a misinformed LEO.

I have none, but as I said earlier, I dont want to be a test case (and dont want my students to be a test case either). Example, hunters are being stopped in the field and asked for FIDs (I have to admit this is hearsay but I personally know one who was and trust he was not deceiving me) despite the fact an FID is a permit to purchase a long arm. NJ2C:39-6f specifically states a permit to carry is not necessary when:

 

(2) A person carrying a firearm or knife in the woods or fields or upon the waters of this State for the purpose of hunting, target practice or fishing, provided that the firearm or knife is legal and appropriate for hunting or fishing purposes in this State and he has in his possession a valid hunting license, or, with respect to fresh water fishing, a valid fishing license;

 

A hunting licence precludes the need for an FID while hunting... but the AG office is interpreting the laws differently. So if this law is gray enough that the AGs office is harassing law abiding hunters, what else will they push the envelope on? My FID says "State of NJ Purchaser Identification Card" on top... many being issued now say permit to possess on top. Will a person be found guilty in a court of law for possessing a gun without an FID, who knows? My buddy had his FID and showed it but protested to the CO... who simply said, thats what he was told to do. I will error on the side of caution and continue to warn my students about he possibility of a misinformed LEO.

 

Wait... The AG has issued a statement regarding this? Or are you drawing that conclusion based on the incorrect harassment of those hunters? You are right fid is not needed when using a gun for hunting... As far as I know.. But again wondering if these are isolated instances... A story of a story of a story... Or if they are some AG directive? I'd be interested to read the statement that FID is required if there is in fact one..

I have none, but as I said earlier, I dont want to be a test case (and dont want my students to be a test case either). Example, hunters are being stopped in the field and asked for FIDs (I have to admit this is hearsay but I personally know one who was and trust he was not deceiving me) despite the fact an FID is a permit to purchase a long arm. NJ2C:39-6f specifically states a permit to carry is not necessary when:

 

(2) A person carrying a firearm or knife in the woods or fields or upon the waters of this State for the purpose of hunting, target practice or fishing, provided that the firearm or knife is legal and appropriate for hunting or fishing purposes in this State and he has in his possession a valid hunting license, or, with respect to fresh water fishing, a valid fishing license;

 

A hunting licence precludes the need for an FID while hunting... but the AG office is interpreting the laws differently. So if this law is gray enough that the AGs office is harassing law abiding hunters, what else will they push the envelope on? My FID says "State of NJ Purchaser Identification Card" on top... many being issued now say permit to possess on top. Will a person be found guilty in a court of law for possessing a gun without an FID, who knows? My buddy had his FID and showed it but protested to the CO... who simply said, thats what he was told to do. I will error on the side of caution and continue to warn my students about he possibility of a misinformed LEO.

 

Please forgive my impertinence but if I understand correctly you have chosen to basically perpetuate a myth with second or third hand stories on the unlikely occurrence that one of your students meets up with an equally mythical "bad,uninformed" cop while abiding by the letter of the law?

And by doing this, they in-turn pass along your conjectural opinions to their counterparts and them to theirs......there by perpetuating the myth even further. and you're OK with this?

This is NJ not some other state. And the courts cannot make up stuff. A judge can interpret a law, but he can not just make something up that doesn't exist. NJ does not define a loaded mag as being a loaded firearm(the magazine is not part of the gun). The Magazine must be in the firearm.

 

You need to read the NJ laws, stop reading crap out there on the internet. Cali, defines the magazine is part of the gun, hence if its loaded,the gun is loaded. that is written in their state law. NO SUCH LAW EXISTS IN NJ.

 

The difference is when the magazine is defined as part of the gun, it opens up interpretation when its loaded. If no such definition exist, there is nothing to interpret.

 

 

 

"And the courts cannot make up stuff."

 

Tell that Brian Aitken!

 

 

"NJ does not define a loaded mag as being a loaded firearm"

 

That's the point! They don't define "loaded firearm" so some courts/prosecutors may feel free to use their own definition. I don't recall if it has happened here but it has happened! If it has happened somewhere else its just a matter of time until it happens here.

 

 

"You need to read the NJ laws, stop reading crap out there on the internet."

 

Having been "gun people" for most of my life, and having spent 29 years as a NJ cop, I'm quite familiar with NJ's gun laws. In fact, a complete copy of the criminal code sits right next to this computer on my desk.

Please forgive my impertinence but if I understand correctly you have chosen to basically perpetuate a myth with second or third hand stories on the unlikely occurrence that one of your students meets up with an equally mythical "bad,uninformed" cop while abiding by the letter of the law?

And by doing this, they in-turn pass along your conjectural opinions to their counterparts and them to theirs......there by perpetuating the myth even further. and you're OK with this?

 

 

"Uninformed cops" are not mythical and anybody who thinks so is living in a fantasy world. I have stopped several other officers from making arrests for perfectly legal conduct that they "thought" was illegal. When I was in college I was personally stopped while enroute to Thunder Mountain Trap & Skeet Range because the officer "thought" my cased shotgun had to be in a locked trunk and that having it strapped to the back of my motorcycle seat was illegal. Fortunately for me, his backup had a copy of the statute book and I was proved right and released.

"And the courts cannot make up stuff."

 

Tell that Brian Aitken!

 

 

"NJ does not define a loaded mag as being a loaded firearm"

 

That's the point! They don't define "loaded firearm" so some courts/prosecutors may feel free to use their own definition. I don't recall if it has happened here but it has happened! If it has happened somewhere else its just a matter of time until it happens here.

 

 

"You need to read the NJ laws, stop reading crap out there on the internet."

 

Having been "gun people" for most of my life, and having spent 29 years as a NJ cop, I'm quite familiar with NJ's gun laws. In fact, a complete copy of the criminal code sits right next to this computer on my desk.

Good then use that copy to figure out that Brian has high capacity mags and thus a criminal... Most of us here are talking about NJ legal firearms.. And well since you were Leo for so long let me ask... How many times did you arrest based solely on loaded mags being transported to an exempted location?

If gun is in car gun has to be cased.... If not it is violation...that is the law... So you could not have a loaded gun and just drop out mag...

 

It does not have to be cased if you have a carry permit. These are almost impossible for handguns but a Firearms Purchaser Identification Card allows you to purchase and carry long guns (2C:39-5c). If you have a FPIC you can carry uncased (and unloaded) long guns in your car or on your person but you can be sure that you'll be harassed about it.

"And the courts cannot make up stuff."

 

Tell that Brian Aitken!

 

 

Brian Aitken had high capacity magazines in his possession. Show me how the courts made that up??

"Uninformed cops" are not mythical and anybody who thinks so is living in a fantasy world. I have stopped several other officers from making arrests for perfectly legal conduct that they "thought" was illegal. When I was in college I was personally stopped while enroute to Thunder Mountain Trap & Skeet Range because the officer "thought" my cased shotgun had to be in a locked trunk and that having it strapped to the back of my motorcycle seat was illegal. Fortunately for me, his backup had a copy of the statute book and I was proved right and released.

 

I will ask the question again....do you have any documented incidents of a NJ resident being arrested,tried and convicted of haveing access to a loaded firearm simply by having a loaded mag,speed loader or half moon clip?

This is the pertinent question that even you as a retired LEO cannot seem to definitively answer without resorting to rambling diatribes of unrelated incidents that may or may not have happened to yourself,the next door neighbor or the next door neighbor's third cousin on his mother's side.

I don't mean to make light...or maybe I do ,but let's put aside the war stories and deal in facts .....as thin as they may be.

Why do many of you argue so vehemently that we should follow the absolute minimum legal requirements? It just doesn't make sense to me. If the penalty for speeding was prison time and the speed limit is 55 you seem to be arguing that driving 55 is legal while others are advising to not exceed 54 just to be safe.

 

Bottom line reality is that I don't want any legal issues. If that means padlocking my zipper pulls and loading my magazines at the range that is what I'm doing. Please enlighten me how this affects my fellow gun owners.

Why do many of you argue so vehemently that we should follow the absolute minimum legal requirements? It just doesn't make sense to me. If the penalty for speeding was prison time and the speed limit is 55 you seem to be arguing that driving 55 is legal while others are advising to not exceed 54 just to be safe.

 

Bottom line reality is that I don't want any legal issues. If that means padlocking my zipper pulls and loading my magazines at the range that is what I'm doing. Please enlighten me how this affects my fellow gun owners.

 

 

Because in NJ your rights are already so limited giving even another inch is an inch too much

 

Also

 

Furthering these made up rules creates confusion and those of us following the minimum may be viewed as breaking the law because the myth gains so much ground...

"And the courts cannot make up stuff."

 

Tell that Brian Aitken!

 

 

"NJ does not define a loaded mag as being a loaded firearm"

 

That's the point! They don't define "loaded firearm" so some courts/prosecutors may feel free to use their own definition. I don't recall if it has happened here but it has happened! If it has happened somewhere else its just a matter of time until it happens here.

 

 

"You need to read the NJ laws, stop reading crap out there on the internet."

 

Having been "gun people" for most of my life, and having spent 29 years as a NJ cop, I'm quite familiar with NJ's gun laws. In fact, a complete copy of the criminal code sits right next to this computer on my desk.

 

First, Aiken was a double whammy, mags over the limit, and the moving exemption which permits the transportation of a handgun. Nothing was made up... and that judge has already been removed from his seat due to being a douche, another case might have possibly been a better example.

 

The point is what is specifically noted in the statues, what A) constitutes a firearm and B)what constitutes a loaded firearm. NJ defines what a Firearm is, a magazine is no where in that definition. So hence cannot be interpreted as a firearm, if its loaded it is a loaded magazine not a loaded firearm. One can only interpret from the statutes that a firearm, as defined by nj law, must have ammunition located within to be considered loaded.

 

Some states include this within its statues, A firearm is loaded if the firing chamber, magazine, clip or cylinder of the firearm contains a cartridge. That leaves interpretation open to the location of the mag, (in the gun or loose). In NJ they don't define loaded, so we can only interpret that cartridges must be in what NJ defines as a firearm.

Why do many of you argue so vehemently that we should follow the absolute minimum legal requirements? It just doesn't make sense to me. If the penalty for speeding was prison time and the speed limit is 55 you seem to be arguing that driving 55 is legal while others are advising to not exceed 54 just to be safe.

 

Bottom line reality is that I don't want any legal issues. If that means padlocking my zipper pulls and loading my magazines at the range that is what I'm doing. Please enlighten me how this affects my fellow gun owners.

 

Because it's not driving 54, it's the guy coming along driving 50 and then someone else saying that he knows a guy who knew a guy who got his a** beat by some bad radar cop when he was going 50 so you should only go 45.

 

Capice?

Its really easy.

 

What is a firearm? It is the frame/reciever of a "gun". That is the LEGAL firearm.

 

Is the magazine a firearm? NO.

If you have just a barrel sitting on the front seat of your car and a round sitting in the chamber, is it a loaded firearm? NO, a barrel is not the firearm therfore it is not a loaded firearm.

 

If the magazine is in the frame of the firearm, it is a loaded firearm, and it is illegal.

Why do many of you argue so vehemently that we should follow the absolute minimum legal requirements? It just doesn't make sense to me. If the penalty for speeding was prison time and the speed limit is 55 you seem to be arguing that driving 55 is legal while others are advising to not exceed 54 just to be safe.

 

Bottom line reality is that I don't want any legal issues. If that means padlocking my zipper pulls and loading my magazines at the range that is what I'm doing. Please enlighten me how this affects my fellow gun owners.

 

I understand that, and have no problem if you choose to do something in caution as long as you know that those actions are not a legal requirement.

 

We are simply trying to inform on what is legal vs. illegal, and NOT what is legal vs. practical/reasonable/smart, etc.

 

You are absolutely right and fine if you want to do more than you have to. I'm right there with you. I don't think that there is a whole lot of arguing going on. I think most agree with each other, they/we just might be arguing different things.

Why do many of you argue so vehemently that we should follow the absolute minimum legal requirements? It just doesn't make sense to me.

 

Why not???

 

Where does it say that you have to follow the law to the letter and then add something extra?? It's not a test and you are going for extra bonus points!!

 

Also where does it say you have to follow the law and do extra to not get in trouble?

 

I just don't get this, I do understand the thought that to err on the side of caution, but why do people have to make up rules that don't exist and try and conform to them, then they say I do this on a gun forum and now it's forum law, and the next guy wants to err on the side of caution of this new forum law and so on, next you won't be able to leave your home with toy squirt gun unless it's in a locked case and also as long as you don't have a bottle of water within reach of the driver and as long as it's under 3.8 liters. :facepalm:

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.