Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Is a Speedloader/Moonclip with Ammo Considered a Loaded Magazine?

Featured Replies

Why not???

 

Where does it say that you have to follow the law to the letter and then add something extra?? It's not a test and you are going for extra bonus points!!

 

Also where does it say you have to follow the law and do extra to not get in trouble?

 

I just don't get this, I do understand the thought that to err on the side of caution, but why do people have to make up rules that don't exist and try and conform to them, then they say I do this on a gun forum and now it's forum law, and the next guy wants to err on the side of caution of this new forum law and so on, next you won't be able to leave your home with toy squirt gun unless it's in a locked case and also as long as you don't have a bottle of water within reach of the driver and as long as it's under 3.8 liters. :facepalm:

 

Your frustration is quite palatable, as is mine. I have a real problem with sheep ,especially when in the process of following blindly who ever they have imprinted upon this week, bleat loudly of their eroding rights.

  • Replies 69
  • Views 8.1k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • "loaded" mags are "ok" if and only if there is NO gun(s) present in the car. The "loaded" mag is "ok" if and only if, it is not filled w/ "hollow point" ammo. The loaded mags are "ok" as long as the m

  • and not to "blow our own horn" as in NJGF.com... but honestly this site is comprised of some pretty knowledgeable people.. people who answer questions backed up with actual fact as opposed to anecdota

  • We as a group need to stop making this stuff up, please don't make your own rules and laws, we have it bad enough with out this stuff.   At least the 15 round count right..

Good then use that copy to figure out that Brian has high capacity mags and thus a criminal... Most of us here are talking about NJ legal firearms.. And well since you were Leo for so long let me ask... How many times did you arrest based solely on loaded mags being transported to an exempted location?

 

 

Actually the high capacity magazines are news to me. I've never seen that mentioned before so I put Brian's name into Google. Of the 10 hits on the first page only one article mentioned the alleged possession of "high capacity" magazines and, considering the accuracy of the source (ABC news), I still don't know if he had them. The article also mentioned that hollow point bullets that Brian had were illegal but we all know that isn't true either. The fact of the matter is that Brian was convicted because the judge refused to follow the law by refusing to give the jury the information about the exemptions to the law that we all know Brian was covered by. And Brian was only put into that position because a cop may have arrested him for perfectly legal conduct (again, this is the first I've heard about that magazine thing). In any case, all reports say he was convicted possession of the handguns which we all know were legally possessed.

 

The answer to your enforcement question is - never. I've never arrested anyone on any type of gun charges. Not being the storm trooper type, whenever I saw someone transporting a gun illegaly I simply told him how to make it legal and then released him. Jailing people for innocently violating unConstitutional laws serves purpose other than tyranny.

I will ask the question again....do you have any documented incidents of a NJ resident being arrested,tried and convicted of haveing access to a loaded firearm simply by having a loaded mag,speed loader or half moon clip?

This is the pertinent question that even you as a retired LEO cannot seem to definitively answer without resorting to rambling diatribes of unrelated incidents that may or may not have happened to yourself,the next door neighbor or the next door neighbor's third cousin on his mother's side.

I don't mean to make light...or maybe I do ,but let's put aside the war stories and deal in facts .....as thin as they may be.

 

War story or not, everything I've posted is factual. You mentioned the "mythical uninformed cop". I merely posted proof that there is nothing mythical about it. Many cops are uninformed. That doesn't make them idiots. Its very difficult for us to keep track of several thousand laws, many contradictory, when hundreds of them change every year. You also need to look up some definitions as nothing that you quoted is even close to rambling or a diatribe. A I said before, I've read of cases where courts have ruled that loaded magazines in proximity to unloaded firearms have been ruled to be the legal equivalent of a loaded firearm. Can I recall any happening specifically in NJ? No. However, as we all know, if another state gets away with something ridiculous it is just a matter of when, not if, that NJ does it too.

 

I agree with the other answers in that its better to be safe than sorry. You do as you wish and hopefully you will never have the hassle of dealing with an unjustified criminal charge like Mr. Aitken and many others did.

Actually the high capacity magazines are news to me. I've never seen that mentioned before so I put Brian's name into Google. Of the 10 hits on the first page only one article mentioned the alleged possession of "high capacity" magazines and, considering the accuracy of the source (ABC news), I still don't know if he had them. The article also mentioned that hollow point bullets that Brian had were illegal but we all know that isn't true either. The fact of the matter is that Brian was convicted because the judge refused to follow the law by refusing to give the jury the information about the exemptions to the law that we all know Brian was covered by. And Brian was only put into that position because a cop may have arrested him for perfectly legal conduct (again, this is the first I've heard about that magazine thing). In any case, all reports say he was convicted possession of the handguns which we all know were legally possessed.

 

The answer to your enforcement question is - never. I've never arrested anyone on any type of gun charges. Not being the storm trooper type, whenever I saw someone transporting a gun illegaly I simply told him how to make it legal and then released him. Jailing people for innocently violating unConstitutional laws serves purpose other than tyranny.

 

 

"man arrested with illegal gun accessories" is not news..

"innocent man sentenced to 7 years in jail" is news..

understanding the media it is not shocking that the high capacity magazines flew under the radar of MOST news sources..

Why not???

 

Where does it say that you have to follow the law to the letter and then add something extra?? It's not a test and you are going for extra bonus points!!

 

Also where does it say you have to follow the law and do extra to not get in trouble?

 

I just don't get this, I do understand the thought that to err on the side of caution, but why do people have to make up rules that don't exist and try and conform to them, then they say I do this on a gun forum and now it's forum law, and the next guy wants to err on the side of caution of this new forum law and so on, next you won't be able to leave your home with toy squirt gun unless it's in a locked case and also as long as you don't have a bottle of water within reach of the driver and as long as it's under 3.8 liters. :facepalm:

 

I'm on board with this sentiment.

here right from the source..

 

he was going from his relatives house to his new home.. or so the story goes..

NOT an exempted location... so therefore gun and ammo are prohibited.. you can only have handguns to and from exempted location.. also he was WITH high cap mags..

 

you can not posses hollow nose ammunition unless it is used in conjunction with a legal activity.. illegally possessing a gun is not a legal activity..

 

it is unfortunate that the gun community fell for this bit.. he was a criminal.. he didn't deserve 7 years.. but he clearly broke the law.. good for him he was released.. but to complain that he was so innocent without gathering the facts on your own.. is foolish IMO..

 

https://www6.state.nj.us/DOC_Inmate/details?x=1451486&n=0

 

1 count of :

2C:39-3F*4 Weapons/Devices Proh:Dum-Dum/Pen.Bullt/4

 

January 2, 2009

 

August 27, 2010

 

Burlington

 

BUR-09-03-00217-I

 

None

 

9 Months

1 count of :

2C:39-3J*4 Weapons/Devices Proh:Magazines /4

 

January 2, 2009

 

August 27, 2010

 

Burlington

 

BUR-09-03-00217-I

 

None

 

9 Months

1 count of :

2C:39-5B*2 Weapons/Unlawful Possession:Handguns /2

 

January 2, 2009

 

August 27, 2010

 

Burlington

 

BUR-09-03-00217-I

 

3 Years

 

7 Years

 

follow the law.. to a T.. and you will not have an issue.. give them an inch of rope.. even an inch.. and you will find yourself hanging from it.. IMO of course..

War story or not, everything I've posted is factual. You mentioned the "mythical uninformed cop". I merely posted proof that there is nothing mythical about it. Many cops are uninformed. That doesn't make them idiots. Its very difficult for us to keep track of several thousand laws, many contradictory, when hundreds of them change every year. You also need to look up some definitions as nothing that you quoted is even close to rambling or a diatribe. A I said before, I've read of cases where courts have ruled that loaded magazines in proximity to unloaded firearms have been ruled to be the legal equivalent of a loaded firearm. Can I recall any happening specifically in NJ? No. However, as we all know, if another state gets away with something ridiculous it is just a matter of when, not if, that NJ does it too.

 

I agree with the other answers in that its better to be safe than sorry. You do as you wish and hopefully you will never have the hassle of dealing with an unjustified criminal charge like Mr. Aitken and many others did.

 

So in essence the answer is No? Yet again you elude to reading something, somewhere, about someone...... but even so ...it's just a matter of time before something,someone ,somewhere,in another state perhaps.......

So in essence the answer is No? Yet again you elude to reading something, somewhere, about someone...... but even so ...it's just a matter of time before something,someone ,somewhere,in another state perhaps.......

 

 

 

 

Whatever...

Whatever...

 

... yet another concise and compelling answer...

... yet another concise and compelling answer...

 

+1

 

sometimes you reach a point.. where even when confronted with fact.. after fact.. after fact.. (or in some cases LACK of fact) people will just believe what they want to.. I say let them.. just don't poison everyone else with that paranoid nonsense... as in want to think loaded magazine is a gun? want to think a barrel is a gun? want to think that new AR railed hand guard is a gun? go for it.. but stop telling others that nonsense unless you can support the statement..

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.