Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Are there any gun laws you actually agree with?

Featured Replies

Of course as gun owners we're often against most gun "control" laws.

But are there any you actually agree with? Are there any laws, rules,

regulations you would actually agree with being passed (whether real

or something you feel strongly about).

  • Replies 105
  • Views 7.4k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • Gun laws I agree with:   Convicted felons should not be permitted access to guns.   The seriously mentally ill should not be permitted access to guns.   Habitual DUI, IMO that should make one in

  • DevsAdvocate
    DevsAdvocate

    Sorry, but mandatory training requirements are about as Constitutional as Poll Taxes and Voting Tests. The way I see it: you buy a gun, anything you do with it comes back on you, for good or for bad.

  • RecessedFilter
    RecessedFilter

    One of the first that come to my mind is that any person wanting to buy a gun should have a background check run on them.   I know some people think BGC's are pointless but I have to disagree.

One of the first that come to my mind is that any person wanting to buy a gun should have a background check run on them.

 

I know some people think BGC's are pointless but I have to disagree.

No sales tax on gun safes.

 

+1

 

I do NOT like the idea of punishing innocent people.. and my statement of punishing those who are victim of a theft is not a good one.. yours is by far better.. in which we reward those who do purchase things to secure firearms.. maybe even allow them to write the purchase off on taxes as well..

 

I also can appreciate the need for a background check prior to purchasing a firearm.. it makes no sense to just hand a criminal a gun.. but all this buyer ID card nonsense does nothing to actually help.. you do a quick simple background check at point of sale.. pass you get the gun immediately.. fail you do not..

 

most other laws are the bi product of some knee jerk reaction to a situation that occurred... NFA stuff.. hicap mags.. flash hiders.. lack of CCW.. that stuff does nothing to actually curb violence... and should all fall away...

I agree with NICS, assuming its run legally with no record retention and also if its not run like NJ NICS where they rip you off $16.05.

 

I also think a BASIC, nationwide license to carry would be reasonable. Something like a NICS check at the PD or gun shop and then you get a card. No frills. I dont want criminals carrying guns around.

I agree, background checks are necessary, especially since they're "instant" with NICS in place. I don't agree with the 3 required in NJ. They should be at the point of sale only, not years before when I get my FID, or days/weeks/months before when I get my (wholly unnecessary) P2P.

 

I also agree with training requirements to get a CCW. I don't want an untrained person carrying a firearm that could potentially harm an innocent bystander through poor/nonexistent training. Hell, I could even get behind regular re-training to ensure you're still proficient, though not if the classes will cost $500. I think a nominal fee for maybe a 1 to 2 hour class teaching the laws and a 1-hour range session showing proficiency. Then again, I'm also in favor of driver's license retraining.

I agree, background checks are necessary, especially since they're "instant" with NICS in place. I don't agree with the 3 required in NJ. They should be at the point of sale only, not years before when I get my FID, or days/weeks/months before when I get my (wholly unnecessary) P2P.

 

I also agree with training requirements to get a CCW. I don't want an untrained person carrying a firearm that could potentially harm an innocent bystander through poor/nonexistent training. Hell, I could even get behind regular re-training to ensure you're still proficient, though not if the classes will cost $500. I think a nominal fee for maybe a 1 to 2 hour class teaching the laws and a 1-hour range session showing proficiency.

 

you have drivers all over the nation who were forced to "train" and yet they cause accidents on a daily basis.. you have countless individuals carrying without any forced training and you do not hear about botched self defense shootings on a daily basis... understanding this tells me that even if you did FORCE some kind of class or training it would do little to improve safety.. as just like with driving.. people would limp through the class.. take little away from it.. and develop bad habits anyway (if that is the kind of individual they were)... further to emphasis driving.. even with requiring training.. and a test.. AND daily reinforcement (you drive almost every day) we STILL have tons of problems.. so why would firearms be any different? not saying you are wrong.. but when you look at the situation logically I don't see any actual positives..

No sales tax on gun safes.

 

+1

 

I do NOT like the idea of punishing innocent people.. and my statement of punishing those who are victim of a theft is not a good one.. yours is by far better.. in which we reward those who do purchase things to secure firearms.. maybe even allow them to write the purchase off on taxes as well..

  • Author

I will likely catch **** for this.. but this is how I feel.. while gun ownership IS a RIGHT.. that right comes with an enormous amount of responsibility.. I think that people who have guns stolen that make NO effort to secure them (I keep my gun in my dresser drawer) should face some form of consequence.. maybe even just civil liability and not criminal... I don't think there should be a LAW that says you have to lock up your guns.. but I think not doing so is negligent.. and should be punishable.. while I understand that you home should not be broken into to begin with.. we live in a shitty world.. and a decent heavy duty safe is not that expensive when you consider how much a lot of people have tied up in their gun collection... this does not mean they would have to be locked up at all times or anything.. it just means if you leave your home unattended.. having your firearms secured by more than just the window in your bedroom.. seems like common sense..

 

 

It is good to have a proper safe, I agree. But what about the times when perhaps you had your gun

out cleaning or dry firing or something else and you leave it on the kitchen table or in a drawer

while you did something else and walked away. I have to admit I have left mine out when no one else

was home. I do put it in the safe though when I leave the premises.

 

I also agree for CCW there should be some required demonstration of weapon proficiency. I'm sure all

of us could think of some people who we would not want carrying a gun despite them not being criminals...

Why require a safe? Not everyone has the ability to buy a several hundred pound safe and get it into their house. What if you live on the 4th floor of a place with no elevator and it's a rental, so you can't bolt it down to anything? Gun stores have their guns laying out all over too. Yes, they're generally locked up but not in a safe.

Gun laws I agree with:

 

Convicted felons should not be permitted access to guns.

 

The seriously mentally ill should not be permitted access to guns.

 

Habitual DUI, IMO that should make one ineligible for gun ownership. IE convicted 3x or more, no more guns. In my mind it's fair, you have three chances, if you f up 3 times you lose some rights.

 

Anyone convicted of gang activity should immediately become a prohibited person for at least 10 yrs. If they manage to stay out of trouble for 10 yrs then the right may be restored.

Why require a safe? Not everyone has the ability to buy a several hundred pound safe and get it into their house. What if you live on the 4th floor of a place with no elevator and it's a rental, so you can't bolt it down to anything? Gun stores have their guns laying out all over too. Yes, they're generally locked up but not in a safe.

 

gun stores have bared windows and steel doors.. do you?

 

I lived on the 3rd floor and have a pretty heavy duty safe.. it was a nightmare to get it up the steps.. but I got it there.. and no one said it had to be a several hundred lb safe... or even bolted down.. if you live several floors up and get a reasonably sturdy safe.. once your guns are in there that thing is going to be pretty heavy and awkward to steal.. good luck stealing it without causing a scene.. I own a safe and ALL of my guns are in it when I am not home.. I could not personally live with the fact that I just let someone bust in my door and steal my guns.. and while a safe may not keep out every criminal.. I know for less money than MOST AR15 builds I have done everything I can reasonably afford to do to secure my guns..

convicted felons is a tough one.. because people really can change..

 

you have to ask yourself.. if someone does time.. real time.. and changes their life should they really never gain that right back?

 

and further.. if they have not changed their lives is baring them from over the counter gun sales really protecting anyone? if they are still criminals they will just obtain a gun illegally?

 

I think that if you do your time.. and can prove you have reformed your life... there is no reason you should not eventually be able to own a gun again.. it should not be an easy process.. but Don't you think there should be a point where someone is is genuinely reformed can obtain a sense of normality?

 

NOT saying I am right.. just discussing..

convicted felons is a tough one.. because people really can change..

 

you have to ask yourself.. if someone does time.. real time.. and changes their life should they really never gain that right back?

 

Uh...fugg yeah that's what I'm saying. Try being a victim of one of those "reformed" felons. As if it isn't bad enough that they have the opportunity to walk the streets and have a decent life. Must they be entitled to all the luxuries of not being a felon? We all have a chance to *not* be a felon. If you can't make the cut the first go around then, yes, you deserve to lose some rights.

 

And I'm with you...just discussing. We don't need to agree. It's not personal.

Background checks... though I would eliminate any reference to the firearm being transfered. I don't understand why an FFL needs to keep track of which gun was sold to whom. Any records should be kept on the FFL side of things in the form of logging out the gun and having the NICS reference number next to it. The gun was sold, the person it was sold to passed the check. End of story.

I think that if you do your time.. and can prove you have reformed your life... there is no reason you should not eventually be able to own a gun again.. it should not be an easy process.. but Don't you think there should be a point where someone is is genuinely reformed can obtain a sense of normality?

 

NOT saying I am right.. just discussing..

 

Don't disagree entirely. However the recidivism rate is astronomical... I would even be willing to make a distinction between non-violent crime and violent crime.

I would even be willing to make a distinction between non-violent crime and violent crime.

So those who embezzle money that leave the elderly destitute should be entitled simply because it's not a "violent" crime? Have to disagree. If there's a victim to the crime then there should be a loss of rights. That's just my opinion though. My position is of that of a form of punishment, not necessarily the chance of a future violent crime.

+1

 

I do NOT like the idea of punishing innocent people.. and my statement of punishing those who are victim of a theft is not a good one.. yours is by far better.. in which we reward those who do purchase things to secure firearms.. maybe even allow them to write the purchase off on taxes as well..

 

Is this applicable?

 

54:32B-8.50. Short title; receipts from sales of firearm trigger locks, tax exempt

1. a. This act shall be known and may be cited as "The Firearm Accident Prevention Act".

 

b.Receipts from sales of firearm trigger locks and other devices that enable the firearm to be made inoperable by anyone other than an authorized person are exempt from the tax imposed under the "Sales and Use Tax Act", P.L.1966, c.30 (C.54:32B-1 et seq.).

 

L.1999,c.253.

 

54:32B-8.51. Short title; receipts from sales of firearm vaults, tax exempt

1. a. This act shall be known and may be cited as "The Secure Firearm Storage Act".

 

b.Receipts from sales of firearm vaults providing secure storage for firearms are exempt from the tax imposed under the "Sales and Use Tax Act", P.L.1966, c.30 (C.54:32B-1 et seq.).

 

L.1999,c.254.

Uh...fugg yeah that's what I'm saying. Try being a victim of one of those "reformed" felons. As if it isn't bad enough that they have the opportunity to walk the streets and have a decent life. Must they be entitled to all the luxuries of not being a felon? We all have a chance to *not* be a felon. If you can't make the cut the first go around then, yes, you deserve to lose some rights.

 

And I'm with you...just discussing. We don't need to agree. It's not personal.

 

but does not allowing them to legally purchase a gun actually make you any safer when guns can be had hand over fist in down town camden?

 

while I think that people who do time should be able to restore their rights..

I also think our justice system is entirely screwed up..

 

nonviolent offenders (simple drug possession of something)should not serve a day behind bars.. it is just a waste of space and tax payer dollar..

violent criminals should serve FAR MORE SERIOUS sentences..

and jail should not be a "gang hangout" even if that means it needs to become more solitary and less social...

 

there are plenty of things that HAVE to be changed about our prison system.. but I just have a hard time punishing the people who really do try to fix their lives.. because of the few that don't.. I have a friend who was arrested and served time possession with intent to distribute.. he was dumb.. NO violence.. NO gangs.. NO weapons.. just stupid drug addict.. well now.. he is a good person.. in NA.. stays clean.. has a job and all that.. but because of his history his life will forever be severely limited.. and I dont think that is fair since he is a genuinely good person who paid his dues and HAS moved on..

Is this applicable?

 

54:32B-8.50. Short title; receipts from sales of firearm trigger locks, tax exempt

1. a. This act shall be known and may be cited as "The Firearm Accident Prevention Act".

 

b.Receipts from sales of firearm trigger locks and other devices that enable the firearm to be made inoperable by anyone other than an authorized person are exempt from the tax imposed under the "Sales and Use Tax Act", P.L.1966, c.30 (C.54:32B-1 et seq.).

 

L.1999,c.253.

 

54:32B-8.51. Short title; receipts from sales of firearm vaults, tax exempt

1. a. This act shall be known and may be cited as "The Secure Firearm Storage Act".

 

b.Receipts from sales of firearm vaults providing secure storage for firearms are exempt from the tax imposed under the "Sales and Use Tax Act", P.L.1966, c.30 (C.54:32B-1 et seq.).

 

L.1999,c.254.

 

so wait.. should I not have paid tax on my safe? nuts.. very interested if you could explain this?

So those who embezzle money that leave the elderly destitute should be entitled simply because it's not a "violent" crime? Have to disagree. If there's a victim to the crime then there should be a loss of rights. That's just my opinion though. My position is of that of a form of punishment, not necessarily the chance of a future violent crime.

 

Most every crime has a victim. If someone is guilty of committing tax fraud (victim is the US Govt/citizens), should they loose 2A rights for the rest of their life? A line has to be drawn. The broad brush of "prior convicted felon" is well...., too broad for me. There should be more guidelines around this. In my mind 2A rights are as just important as 1A and 4A, and its restriction and circumstances to be taken away for life needs to be weighed very carefully with specific set rules.

 

Trespassing could be a 4th degree crime in NJ, does that warrant a lifelong revocation of 2A rights?

so wait.. should I not have paid tax on my safe? nuts.. very interested if you could explain this?

 

According to that code, I suppose not. I remember finding it when looking around all of NJ's wonderful gun related laws. I have no idea how to actually use it. I suppose the merchant is responsible, as sales tax is applied at the time of purchase. Trying to get a merchant to follow this law... not sure how to do thatx Maybe there is a way to get it refunded as part of income tax. Any accountants out there!?

Both my safes came from Lowes, no sales tax, they actually knew about it too, I didn't have to tell them.

Both my safes came from Lowes, no sales tax, they actually knew about it too, I didn't have to tell them.

 

THIS is because of me last year. :icon_twisted: You are welcome.

 

I was told to pay. Did it. Then made a stink about it to corporate giving them copies of the law.

you have drivers all over the nation who were forced to "train" and yet they cause accidents on a daily basis.. you have countless individuals carrying without any forced training and you do not hear about botched self defense shootings on a daily basis... understanding this tells me that even if you did FORCE some kind of class or training it would do little to improve safety.. as just like with driving.. people would limp through the class.. take little away from it.. and develop bad habits anyway (if that is the kind of individual they were)... further to emphasis driving.. even with requiring training.. and a test.. AND daily reinforcement (you drive almost every day) we STILL have tons of problems.. so why would firearms be any different? not saying you are wrong.. but when you look at the situation logically I don't see any actual positives..

 

You're right, there are plenty of bad drivers causing accidents daily. But does that make the law requiring training and a test to operate a vehicle bad? How many more accidents would there be if there were no required training and everyone was allowed on the road unsupervised for their first time? Just because a law doesn't work 100% of the time doesn't make it a bad law. EVERY law on the books has been broken at some point by someone, so should all of them be repealed because they obviously aren't working? And don't bother introducing logic into the laws, we all know that politicians and legislators are required to denounce all logic when they take their oath. What logic is there in limiting my magazine capacity to 15? When I have only 15 rounds am I controllable but with 16 rounds I'm a dominating lethal force that cannot be stopped? Do they forget that I know how to reload?

 

As for the whole convicted felon thing being discussed, the problem is that if you had a chance to be an upstanding citizen and made the decision not to go that route. Does it suck for the people that honest to goodness do change for the better afterwards? Of course it does. But how do you REALLY know that they have changed completely and will never ever ever do anything bad again? Can you completely 100% trust someone that you know has made those bad decisions in the past? How do you know that they don't still have those thoughts and may one day act on them? Now having said that, I could potentially be on board with a probationary period, where, say, if you go 5 or 10 years showing that you're turning your life around (like the person vlad mentioned) and you have a stable job, can prove you're staying clean and out of trouble, then you can begin to earn (being the key word since you lost them) your rights back.

 

That's what I think at least, and as someone else mentioned, you don't have to agree with me, just discussing.

I think just about everybody would agree to the background check law.

 

I agree with having to be 18 years old to purchase weapons and ammunition as well.

 

I'm going to say one aspect I would agree with is a training requirement for CCW. It's not that I'm afraid people can't shoot, it's that I want them to be darn sure they know what constitutes deadly force. The only problem I can see is that if NJ ever got "shall-issue," I could see the training requirement becoming so onerous that it becomes the new unreachable "justifiable need" standard (must be able to hit a 75 yard target, in the 10 ring... offhand...)

I have no issues with the background check. Even futher, I have no issues with the call with each and every firearm purchase. A consumer could have been fine purchasing a firearm last month or last year, but **** happens that could have disqualified him/her now. I also have no issue with some type of waiting period. Not sure how much time needs to pass, a day, a week, a month.................... who knows, but I have no problem with this waiting period, especially if it's a 1st time firearms purchase. Needing to wait 5 to 10 business days seems reasonable to me.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.