Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Are there any gun laws you actually agree with?

Featured Replies

(must be able to hit a 75 yard target, in the 10 ring... offhand...)

 

blindfolded, after being spun around on a bat 5 times, using sonar only, with a .500S&W Mag, 5 hits in 10 seconds.

 

Challenge Accepted!

  • Replies 105
  • Views 7.4k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • Gun laws I agree with:   Convicted felons should not be permitted access to guns.   The seriously mentally ill should not be permitted access to guns.   Habitual DUI, IMO that should make one in

  • DevsAdvocate
    DevsAdvocate

    Sorry, but mandatory training requirements are about as Constitutional as Poll Taxes and Voting Tests. The way I see it: you buy a gun, anything you do with it comes back on you, for good or for bad.

  • RecessedFilter
    RecessedFilter

    One of the first that come to my mind is that any person wanting to buy a gun should have a background check run on them.   I know some people think BGC's are pointless but I have to disagree.

If the question was, "Are there any New Jersey gun laws you actually agree with?", the answer would be NO.

 

Federally speaking, only NICS.

 

 

 

I reserved my right to change my mind at anytime.

Uh...fugg yeah that's what I'm saying. Try being a victim of one of those "reformed" felons. As if it isn't bad enough that they have the opportunity to walk the streets and have a decent life. Must they be entitled to all the luxuries of not being a felon? We all have a chance to *not* be a felon. If you can't make the cut the first go around then, yes, you deserve to lose some rights.

 

And I'm with you...just discussing. We don't need to agree. It's not personal.

 

Easy now, not every felon is an animal.

If the question was, "Are there any New Jersey gun laws you actually agree with?", the answer would be NO.

 

Federally speaking, only NICS.

 

 

 

I reserved my right to change my mind at anytime.

 

 

Good point.

Easy now, not every felon is an animal.

 

Speaking from experience?

convicted felons is a tough one.. because people really can change..

 

you have to ask yourself.. if someone does time.. real time.. and changes their life should they really never gain that right back?

i'd say depends on the crime. murder, rape, child abuse, robbery, aggravated assault, multiple drug or dui convictions are some of the crimes where i wouldn't want the convict to ever get a gun, no matter how sorry they are. If someone gets caught illegally carrying or transporting a legally owned gun and goes to jail, i have no problem with them getting their guns back when they get out.

I would be all for a FREE state provided class explaining the justifiable use of force...

I would not be for a "qualifying" portion because I find it to be an emotionally driven standard.. you have no idea how the shoot will go down.. and unless the person is trained day in and day out.. NOTHING they will learn will be carried over to an actual shoot.. in a high stress situation your most basic primitive instincts take over.. the ability to hit a static target at 10 yards while standing at a line with an instructor next to you.. on a nice sunny afternoon will mean NOTHING at 10pm in a dimly lit alley as you head to the car from the movie theater and are attacked from behind.. I am not for "law" that lacks real application.. and a range style simple class with a short shoot session at the end of it is not going to prepare you any more to defend yourself with a gun than watching an action flick on TV (granted that is an exaggeration but you get the point)..

I agree with the gun laws before 1934...

So you dont have a problem with NJ's No Concealed Firearms law???? that predated 1934

I agree with the 2nd amendment. I also agree with background checks to rule out anyone who is a criminal or mentally disturbed. Otherwise, eff those laws. Give me a new gun law that allows anyone who isn't a criminal or mental to own anything short of nukes and carry however the hell they please and I'll support the crap out of it. :icon_twisted:

I would be all for a FREE state provided class explaining the justifiable use of force...

I would not be for a "qualifying" portion because I find it to be an emotionally driven standard.. you have no idea how the shoot will go down.. and unless the person is trained day in and day out.. NOTHING they will learn will be carried over to an actual shoot..

 

I don't think that any advocates of a training requirement expect that he trainging for CCW should be for when the SHTF. Just like a driver's license test it should tell you the law, keep safe, etc. How to find cover and fire from it would be the last thing I would want from a state mandated course.

 

Just like a drivers license test doesn't try to teach the best way to handle it if two cars in fron of you crash, or if someone drives into you.

Speaking from experience?

 

Yes

I don't think that any advocates of a training requirement expect that he trainging for CCW should be for when the SHTF. Just like a driver's license test it should tell you the law, keep safe, etc. How to find cover and fire from it would be the last thing I would want from a state mandated course.

 

Just like a drivers license test doesn't try to teach the best way to handle it if two cars in fron of you crash, or if someone drives into you.

Driving is about point a to b... Ccw is All about worst case scenario

Driving is about point a to b... Ccw is All about worst case scenario

 

All the more reason for CCW training IMO. Many people don't encounter any SHTF situations while driving, but every CCW situation is a SHTF moment. I would much prefer knowing that a person needing to draw their CCW firearm at the very least understands the basic fundamentals of a firearm than someone who just walked into a store, purchased a gun, and threw it on their hip and is now drawing it and firing haphazardly and uncontrollably. After some training you have at the very least actually aimed and fired the gun. Plus, understanding the laws regarding use of lethal force and others is necessary, just like it's necessary to know the rules of the road. Not to mention it is fairly common to walk out of a vehicle accident with no or minor injuries while it's probably not quite as common for someone to get shot and come out of it with only a few scratches and bruises.

 

I do agree that most training will mean precisely squat in a SHTF situation, but who would you trust more, someone who has had at least a little bit of training, or someone who's never fired a gun in their life?

All the more reason for CCW training IMO. Many people don't encounter any SHTF situations while driving, but every CCW situation is a SHTF moment. I would much prefer knowing that a person needing to draw their CCW firearm at the very least understands the basic fundamentals of a firearm than someone who just walked into a store, purchased a gun, and threw it on their hip and is now drawing it and firing haphazardly and uncontrollably. After some training you have at the very least actually aimed and fired the gun. Plus, understanding the laws regarding use of lethal force and others is necessary, just like it's necessary to know the rules of the road. Not to mention it is fairly common to walk out of a vehicle accident with no or minor injuries while it's probably not quite as common for someone to get shot and come out of it with only a few scratches and bruises.

 

I do agree that most training will mean precisely squat in a SHTF situation, but who would you trust more, someone who has had at least a little bit of training, or someone who's never fired a gun in their life?

 

if your concerns were so valid where are the news clips of john doe pulling out his gun in self defense and accidentally shooting up a passing school bus... it just does not happen.. it does not happen even with countless people carrying guns every day.. and the statement you make about it meaning squat in a "situation" is exactly why I refuse to support it.. I refuse to support laws that have no solid logical ground.. look at police officers who are trained vigorously.. how many negligent discharges do you hear about there? the person who training would actually help is likely the individual who is already seeking training.. the individual who you describe as the one to look out for is likely going to let the training of his one "required class" go in one ear and out the other.. I am ALL for training.. I have been to quite a few classes.. some of which I even took more than once.. I shoot pretty often.. I am just not for MANDATED training because I fail to see the logic..

 

force a guy to take one class when he would normally take none? it as you put it.. isn't going to mean anything in a real life situation..

I understand the emotional want for people to be trained.. I just do not see the logical advantage..

If the question was, "Are there any New Jersey gun laws you actually agree with?", the answer would be NO.

 

Federally speaking, only NICS.

 

 

 

 

 

I reserved my right to change my mind at anytime.

 

 

+1

When people start wettin' the bed about 'felons' having guns, people need to realize just how easy it is to become a Felon.

Driving is about point a to b... Ccw is All about worst case scenario

Thats kinda my point. CCW is point A to point B until worst case, just like driving. You will spend more time carrying than in a worst case scenario. This is IMHO, the part the antis want covered anyway,

 

In the context of what a state ccw class might look like, i would want the point A to point B covered. The "defensive driving" part is up to you.

I always thought the hollow point bullets laws were a good compromise. You can use them for any legal purpose but if you commit a crime with them the punishment is worse. It punishes criminals while not restricting law abiding citizens. If only they did that with other things rather than straight up ban them.

I always thought the hollow point bullets laws were a good compromise. You can use them for any legal purpose but if you commit a crime with them the punishment is worse. It punishes criminals while not restricting law abiding citizens. If only they did that with other things rather than straight up ban them.

How so, is a hollow point some type of magic bullet? They are actually safer for people other than the intended target. How does a law splitting hairs on possession make any sense? I do not agree with any NJ gun laws and think we should follow federal law like all free states.

THIS is because of me last year. :icon_twisted: You are welcome.

 

I was told to pay. Did it. Then made a stink about it to corporate giving them copies of the law.

 

Thanks Paul! I always tell people you are a good guy. Some of my favorite guns came from you.

Of course as gun owners we're often against most gun "control" laws.

But are there any you actually agree with? Are there any laws, rules,

regulations you would actually agree with being passed (whether real

or something you feel strongly about).

 

 

NICS Check only for purchase.

I also think a BASIC, nationwide license to carry would be reasonable.

 

I don't want criminals carrying either but why do we punish people who are not restricted by having them have to do more than what is needed to exercise a right, the 2A should be enough.

 

I agree NICS should also be the only requirement to purchase also.

my FID, or days/weeks/months before when I get my (wholly unnecessary) P2P.

 

I also agree with training requirements to get a CCW. I don't want an untrained person carrying a firearm that could potentially harm an innocent bystander through poor/nonexistent training. Hell, I could even get behind regular re-training to ensure you're still proficient, though not if the classes will cost $500. I think a nominal fee for maybe a 1 to 2 hour class teaching the laws and a 1-hour range session showing proficiency. Then again, I'm also in favor of driver's license retraining.

 

 

WHY??? Do you have to do anything special for your 1A rights??? why should you have to for your 2A rights, It's a right, not a privilege and as long as your an unrestricted person the 2A is not a conditional right either..

It is good to have a proper safe, I agree. But what about the times when perhaps you had your gun

out cleaning or dry firing or something else and you leave it on the kitchen table or in a drawer

while you did something else and walked away. I have to admit I have left mine out when no one else

was home. I do put it in the safe though when I leave the premises.

 

I also agree for CCW there should be some required demonstration of weapon proficiency. I'm sure all

of us could think of some people who we would not want carrying a gun despite them not being criminals...

 

If you don't have minor children in the house leaving the gun out or in a draw is not an issue.

 

No as far as showing proficiency to have a CCW, NO WAY, while yes I would like to know the person who is carrying can shoot the gun they are caring I have to leave that to them. The 2A is not conditional, what next, you want to have proficiency tests to use your 1A rights, you would have towns what would only have a small percentage of the residents that were able to speak.

 

How can we as the core group of gun owners forget the 2A is a right, it's not a privilege, sounds like Anti's and please lets skip the Common Sense discussion because it's what started all this in the first place.

Gun laws I agree with:

 

Convicted felons should not be permitted access to guns.

 

The seriously mentally ill should not be permitted access to guns.

 

Habitual DUI, IMO that should make one ineligible for gun ownership. IE convicted 3x or more, no more guns. In my mind it's fair, you have three chances, if you f up 3 times you lose some rights.

 

Anyone convicted of gang activity should immediately become a prohibited person for at least 10 yrs. If they manage to stay out of trouble for 10 yrs then the right may be restored.

 

Dan this list works for me, these could be the 4 and only gun laws on the books and I would be fine with it.

 

I do have to add after reading some more of the responses, there needs to be a defined list of felonies that would make a person prohibited and not just all.

You're right, there are plenty of bad drivers causing accidents daily. But does that make the law requiring training and a test to operate a vehicle bad?

 

There is just one problem here, a Drivers License is a Privilege, the 2A is a Right, they are 2 completely different things.

I may be out of line here, but I believe that a person applying for an FID card should somehow have to prove thier knowledge of gun safety.

 

At least have to state the 4 rules.

 

I'm shocked that we don't need to prove that.

I may be out of line here, but I believe that a person applying for an FID card should somehow have to prove thier knowledge of gun safety.

 

At least have to state the 4 rules.

 

I'm shocked that we don't need to prove that.

 

Okay, so you stated the 4 rules? Are you any safer?

 

:rolleyes:

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.