Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Are there any gun laws you actually agree with?

Featured Replies

  • Replies 105
  • Views 7.4k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • Gun laws I agree with:   Convicted felons should not be permitted access to guns.   The seriously mentally ill should not be permitted access to guns.   Habitual DUI, IMO that should make one in

  • DevsAdvocate
    DevsAdvocate

    Sorry, but mandatory training requirements are about as Constitutional as Poll Taxes and Voting Tests. The way I see it: you buy a gun, anything you do with it comes back on you, for good or for bad.

  • RecessedFilter
    RecessedFilter

    One of the first that come to my mind is that any person wanting to buy a gun should have a background check run on them.   I know some people think BGC's are pointless but I have to disagree.

I think it should be more involved. They don't even make you do that.

 

While I agree anyone who choses to own a firearm should know how o safely handle it there is nothing in the 2A that states that you should know the 4 rules of safe gun handling and we should not make additional requirements to what is written.

I guess that's where we differ.

 

I guess so, I just feel the 2A is not conditional and we don't need the "Common Sense" BS added, thats how we got into all these BS gun laws that do absolutely nothing to prevent crime or people who are prohibited from having them.

 

I am for stricter punishment for a commission of a crime with a firearm, and I don't mean proper capacity mags (+15) or assault weapons, or how about the best one, a bayonet lug, can anyone tell me the last time a bayonet was used?? :banghead:

I guess that's where we differ.

 

Sorry, but mandatory training requirements are about as Constitutional as Poll Taxes and Voting Tests. The way I see it: you buy a gun, anything you do with it comes back on you, for good or for bad.

 

Then again: look at the games Chicago is playing with their training requirements... you can get training on the 1st full moon night of the month in the City Hall Janitor Closet if you can apply and reserve one of the 3 spots available... oh... and there's a $500 service fee for that...

 

I know folks who ask for this mean well, but the second you get the Gov't involved, they tend to mess things up... kinda like what NJ is doing with the FPID and PP process. Why do we even need those? PA manages just fine with a DL and a NICS check... but we need to go above and beyond and just short of an anal probing to buy a neutered handgun that can't hold more than 15 rounds. F- That.

Sorry, but mandatory training requirements are about as Constitutional as Poll Taxes and Voting Tests. The way I see it: you buy a gun, anything you do with it comes back on you, for good or for bad.

 

Then again: look at the games Chicago is playing with their training requirements... you can get training on the 1st full moon night of the month in the City Hall Janitor Closet if you can apply and reserve one of the 3 spots available... oh... and there's a $500 service fee for that...

 

I know folks who ask for this mean well, but the second you get the Gov't involved, they tend to mess things up... kinda like what NJ is doing with the FPID and PP process. Why do we even need those? PA manages just fine with a DL and a NICS check... but we need to go above and beyond and just short of an anal probing to buy a neutered handgun that can't hold more than 15 rounds. F- That.

 

this..

 

I would not empower someone who can not even balance a check book to create logical rules...

Laws that make it clear that there cannot be laws restricting the right to bear arms. I agree with those.

I just feel it would be safer (for those who are truly interested in shooting sports) if we get rid of the FID/PP program, and just require a safety course and a background check. And the course can be subbed out just like the fingerprinting.

 

Of course the folks that mean harm to others will always be out there. But accidental discharge can be avoided.

 

I understand the folks that talk about no restrictions under 2a, but you've all seemed to agree on the proving mental stability, not allowing convicted felons. That would constitute a restriction. There are folks out there, probably next to you at the range, that don't mean you harm, but are remiss in their responsibilities as a gun owner.

I just feel it would be safer (for those who are truly interested in shooting sports) if we get rid of the FID/PP program, and just require a safety course and a background check. And the course can be subbed out just like the fingerprinting.

 

Of course the folks that mean harm to others will always be out there. But accidental discharge can be avoided.

 

Why even need a background check? They do one when you go buy the gun anyways... seems redundant and pointless if your rid yourself of the FPID/PP system...

 

As for a safety course, 43 other states manage just fine without mandating them... Don't see why NJ is any different.

 

I understand the folks that talk about no restrictions under 2a, but you've all seemed to agree on the proving mental stability, not allowing convicted felons. That would constitute a restriction. There are folks out there, probably next to you at the range, that don't mean you harm, but are remiss in their responsibilities as a gun owner.

 

I disagree with those as well. They're infringements. If there are people walking the streets who have been deemed to dangerous to own a gun, there is nothing stopping them from getting one. They can beat up a cop (not difficult to do) and steal his, they can steal one from a family member, use a straw purchaser, or black market it. The mere fact that felons are constantly arrested on weapons charges means that the restrictions set in place to keep them from buying guns are completely and utterly useless.

 

As for the mental issue, this is a matter of confidentiality on the behalf of the patient. Not to mention: how is this even tracked? Most mentally ill folks can go most their lives without seeing a doctor about it or getting arrested for it. Heck, that Loughner kid and the VT Shooting Kid managed to get guns just fine. If all else fails... they can steal one, straw one, or black market it.

As an addendum:

 

I like to take a very methodical and engineering approach when it comes to trying to correct any major societal issues. The VAST majority of gun laws are supposedly designed to fight the concept of 'gun crime' (which is utterly ridiculous since we don't have 'car crime' or 'knife crime'). Crimes involving guns are no different than ones involving baseball bats, knives, brass knuckles, etc. Yet none of those items are heavily restricted, are they? Furthermore, does having the gun make the criminal? Or does the criminal just use the gun to carry out the act? This logical distinction is ultimately the reason why all gun laws are simply pointless. If the former is true, then we're all criminals waiting to happen, or we're all just normal people with weapons for any and all practical purposes.

 

Fighting crime is not done using petty little laws, it's done via economics that provide jobs, money, and quality of life easily.

 

Perversely, less laws also equal less crime. The thinking there being that the less you enforce, the less you need to punish.

I just feel it would be safer (for those who are truly interested in shooting sports) if we get rid of the FID/PP program, and just require a safety course and a background check. And the course can be subbed out just like the fingerprinting.

 

Of course the folks that mean harm to others will always be out there. But accidental discharge can be avoided.

 

I understand the folks that talk about no restrictions under 2a, but you've all seemed to agree on the proving mental stability, not allowing convicted felons. That would constitute a restriction. There are folks out there, probably next to you at the range, that don't mean you harm, but are remiss in their responsibilities as a gun owner.

 

Yikes, listen do the member with the New Jersey devil in his avatar.

And to devsad. I've never known a baseball bat to swing with deadly force at the slip of a finger. You may think so, but a bat or knife is not the same as a gun.

And to devsad. I've never known a baseball bat to swing with deadly force at the slip of a finger. You may think so, but a bat or knife is not the same as a gun.

 

It doesn't matter. The state has no say in the matter. If some poor schmuck buys a gun and doesn't take the time to read the safety manual or seek instruction from someone who knows a thing or two about guns, and shoots himself, then that's his fault.

 

I will not be inconvenienced for the stupidity of others.

And to devsad. I've never known a baseball bat to swing with deadly force at the slip of a finger. You may think so, but a bat or knife is not the same as a gun.

 

Of course not, because that isn't how a bat works. Have you know a gun that was as easy to load, be aimed, and then shot as easy as slip and a fall while holding a knife? I am not sure I get your point. If your argument is that it is easy to accidentally point a loaded gun and shoot someone and hard to swing a bat at them, then shouldn't you actually be more worried about the person with the gun and not the gun itself? That person probably shouldn't own a bat or a knife either...

Yes, that is exactly the point. The more dangerous the weapon, the more care In allowing the ownership of it.

 

And at devsad, you may feel that way about someone shooting themselves, agreed by the way, but what about when you are next to them at the range. Irresponsible gun owners do not just affect themselves. They affect anyone within a 2 feet to 1000 yard or more radius.

Yes, that is exactly the point. The more dangerous the weapon, the more care In allowing the ownership of it.

 

And at devsad, you may feel that way about someone shooting themselves, agreed by the way, but what about when you are next to them at the range. Irresponsible gun owners do not just affect themselves. They affect anyone within a 2 feet to 1000 yard or more radius.

 

That's up to the shooting range (private citizens owning private property) to decide, not the state. Simple as that.

sigh..

 

if you have to FORCE someone to take a safety class for something as serious as a gun... that class is useless to them..

if someone is actually going to absorb something from a gun safety class they are intelligent enough to seek said class on their own without the government holding their hand..

 

and at the end of the day.. that is really the bottom line..

sigh..

 

if you have to FORCE someone to take a safety class for something as serious as a gun... that class is useless to them..

if someone is actually going to absorb something from a gun safety class they are intelligent enough to seek said class on their own without the government holding their hand..

 

and at the end of the day.. that is really the bottom line..

 

I agree to a point. Through my Army and occupational life I have to say that sometimes hearing something once can stay with you for a lifetime. I have seen it time and time again. Example, I read a Mayoob article that said something along the line of "practice dry firing, but before each trigger pull check the breach and make sure it is clear. If you wait more than 2 seconds after to pull the trigger, check it again."

 

That was a great idea. It was a great habit to build. Now I always do it. No one forced me to do anything, I just had information presented to me that made sense and I did it.

 

I have used that and other things to spell out actions and concepts to my squads and Platoon. I use it at my job. I can't force anyone to learn, but I need to put out the information. If it isn't put out, it might never be heard. In the case of CCW instrucion, using your situation, now the only people getting the information are the ones seeking a class. Those that don't may never get any information.

 

That's just the NCO in me - Information has to be put out.

I agree to a point. Through my Army and occupational life I have to say that sometimes hearing something once can stay with you for a lifetime. I have seen it time and time again. Example, I read a Mayoob article that said something along the line of "practice dry firing, but before each trigger pull check the breach and make sure it is clear. If you wait more than 2 seconds after to pull the trigger, check it again."

 

That was a great idea. It was a great habit to build. Now I always do it. No one forced me to do anything, I just had information presented to me that made sense and I did it.

 

I have used that and other things to spell out actions and concepts to my squads and Platoon. I use it at my job. I can't force anyone to learn, but I need to put out the information. If it isn't put out, it might never be heard. In the case of CCW instrucion, using your situation, now the only people getting the information are the ones seeking a class. Those that don't may never get any information.

 

That's just the NCO in me - Information has to be sought out.

 

Only those willing to learn and practice new information will benefit from it. Force it on people, and it's less likely to stick.

 

Frankly, it's not my problem if someone buys a gun and doesn't know how to use it. I'd rather let them learn the easy way or the hard way... on their own.

 

Lord knows, the same people who think mandatory training is a good idea also thought FPIDs and Pistol Permits were brilliant thoughts as well. They also think AWBs are effective, and that Automatic and Silenced weapons are just plain evil. This is where the whole "our own greatest enemy is ourselves" kinda comes in.

Someone buy this man a beer! Well said!

 

As an addendum:

 

I like to take a very methodical and engineering approach when it comes to trying to correct any major societal issues. The VAST majority of gun laws are supposedly designed to fight the concept of 'gun crime' (which is utterly ridiculous since we don't have 'car crime' or 'knife crime'). Crimes involving guns are no different than ones involving baseball bats, knives, brass knuckles, etc. Yet none of those items are heavily restricted, are they? Furthermore, does having the gun make the criminal? Or does the criminal just use the gun to carry out the act? This logical distinction is ultimately the reason why all gun laws are simply pointless. If the former is true, then we're all criminals waiting to happen, or we're all just normal people with weapons for any and all practical purposes.

 

Fighting crime is not done using petty little laws, it's done via economics that provide jobs, money, and quality of life easily.

 

Perversely, less laws also equal less crime. The thinking there being that the less you enforce, the less you need to punish.

and this man as well! Beers for everyone who grasps simple logic!

 

 

sigh..

 

if you have to FORCE someone to take a safety class for something as serious as a gun... that class is useless to them..

if someone is actually going to absorb something from a gun safety class they are intelligent enough to seek said class on their own without the government holding their hand..

 

and at the end of the day.. that is really the bottom line..

I actually don't agree with the FID or the PP. I also wish we could use suppressors, and wish I could go blast some targets with a full auto. I think it's nuts that we can't have a 17 round magazine, but 15 is fine.

 

I just think it would make more sense to have a mandatory safety course IN PLACE of the current program. IMO it would be better than what we have now. I understand the concept of people not absorbing as much when they are forced to hear something. But at least they would pick up a few key safety concepts before going to the range and hurting someone else because of ignorance.

I actually don't agree with the FID or the PP. I also wish we could use suppressors, and wish I could go blast some targets with a full auto. I think it's nuts that we can't have a 17 round magazine, but 15 is fine.

 

I just think it would make more sense to have a mandatory safety course IN PLACE of the current program. IMO it would be better than what we have now. I understand the concept of people not absorbing as much when they are forced to hear something. But at least they would pick up a few key safety concepts before going to the range and hurting someone else because of ignorance.

 

I know you mean well Jim, and this is as far as I will agree with you on mandatory firearms training: we should definitely have it. In our schools, as early as possible, and reinforced every year. We should have kids 12 and up learning basic marksmanship on shooting ranges outside of school. We should have school shooting teams competing against one another, and womens' shooting teams as well. That's how training should be done if you want a safe and polite firearms society.

 

However, it should not be a direct requirement to purchase a firearm, or to be eligible for one. I'm sorry, but it's our right to keep and bear arms, and I'll be damned if I will trust the politicians or their dogs in law enforcement to ensure my rights are not infringed. Like I mentioned earlier, any state or even Federal Gov't can take a mandatory training requirement and turn it into a means of blocking firearms ownership. Just like Southern states used poll taxes and voter eligibility requirements to dissuade blacks from taking part in the democratic process, anti-gun politicians will use qualification requirements as a means to curb gun ownership.

 

Sorry man, history (even recent US history) is rife with examples of the Gov't doing crap like this. You can't give em the inch, or they'll take you for the whole mile.

Good points everyone. Food for thought. I guess I'll just be happy if the range I choose requires people to have some basic safety orientation before they can join.

Good points everyone. Food for thought. I guess I'll just be happy if the range I choose requires people to have some basic safety orientation before they can join.

 

Good luck finding one like that.

If there are people walking the streets who have been deemed to dangerous to own a gun, there is nothing stopping them from getting one. They can beat up a cop (not difficult to do) and steal his, they can steal one from a family member, use a straw purchaser, or black market it. The mere fact that felons are constantly arrested on weapons charges means that the restrictions set in place to keep them from buying guns are completely and utterly useless.

 

 

I just want to elaborate on something. Not directed at you DevsAd. Some people, especially those in restricted states like NJ, often think that the way a felon gets a gun is to go to a shady spot in the ghetto and buy one off a gang member in some run down crack house. That you need underworld connections to get a gun as a convicted felon.

 

There is absolutely zero, zip, zilch, nada, nothing in 40+ states to keep a felon from walking right into a gun show, or meeting someone off an online forum in their state, from a guy they work with, and buying a gun face to face - ten feet from a cop car, right next to a table where an FFL is filling out a 4473 for someone, right there in plain sight.

 

Because felons don't have a giant F painted in big red letters on their forehead. They're not all covered in Neo Nazi or MS13 tattoos. They're not always flying gang colors. They often look just like you and I. Because they are often regular people. And there is NO requirement for a private seller, in 40+ states, to verify if the person is a felon or not. How could they, even if they wanted to?

 

This is why prohibition on felons owning guns is pointless. If someone is too dangerous to be trusted with a gun, they should still be in prison. If not, they're going to get one anyway.

Good points everyone. Food for thought. I guess I'll just be happy if the range I choose requires people to have some basic safety orientation before they can join.

 

Good luck finding one like that.

 

FYI, if you're a new shooter at RTSP at Randolph, they make you watch a 10 minute long(NSSF? NRA?) range safety video before allowing you to use the range. Even if you bring a guest, they have to watch the video. After that, you can just walk on in and go shoot anytime (if member or if you pay for a single session).

 

So there ARE ranges that mandate safety orientations prior to shooting.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.