Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

First Pistol- Thinking of Buying Used

Featured Replies

Just got my pistol permit (2 actually). I'm still unclear as to which guns and even which caliber I'm going to go with, but that's something I'll figure out. I don't want to ask the "what's the best pistol, caliber?" question here. (for those that are curious though, it's down to glock compact, sig, smith M&P, 92/96 and steyr M) I got down to ShoreShot last night and shot a couple 9mm's. I'm going to rent a few more times and just make a call from there.

 

But I'm hearing about certified pre-owned guns, police trade-in's etc. Can anyone chime in and suggest where to look for them besides a gun shop's used section? Anyone have experience buying used? Certain mfg better, have a solid certified program? I thought it might be a good way to save some dough. Thanks.

For what it's worth 80% of my guns have been bought used. it's nice to buy a gun already broken in.

Buying used is fine. You will find alot of people will only buy used to keep costs down. Most guns that are sold used have very litlle rounds through them 500-1000 for the most part. If you ask what is the best used gun that is a loaded question. You cant go wrong with any of the makers you have mentioned, its just going to come down to what you like.

So far every used gun had been as trouble free and operated just as good as the new guns I have purchased. Maybe I have been lucky, but from hearing all the positive buys here, I doubt it.

Sig has a CPO (Certified Pre-Owned) program. The gun is gone through and springs and any necessary components vare replaced and they come with a one year warranty. CPO's may come from one of three sources - Police trade-ins / Salesman's samples / Warranty buy-backs, with police trade-ins being the most common.

 

Hard to find at your LGS because Sig really isn't in the "Used Gun Business". They take police trades in order to sell them new ones. If they can dispose of the trade-ins en masse, they do so. That usually means they sell them to a big box store like Cabela's, Gander Mtn or Bass Pro. They can afford to buy and warehouse large quantities and have multiple retail outlets through which to dispose of them. CPO's are found in the red Sig boxes, with red Tyvek bands on the grip.

 

Adios,

 

Pizza Bob

I've only had one "lemon" from buying used and quite frankly it wasn't difficult to fix. The vast majority of my collection is used ranging from extremely lightly used to "rode hard and put away wet".

 

Age has little to do with how well a gun works FYI.

I tried several 9MM and .45ACP at Shore Shot on two outings last year and decided on the Glock 19 for concealed carry and the G21SF for my all purpose pistol. The G19 is easy to conceal and with the Gen4 backstraps it was easy to get the right fit for my hand. The G21SF was also easier for me to grip than the regular frame G21.

 

I discovered that I could join the GSSF (Glock Shooting Sports Foundation) for $35 (renewals are $25) and that would entitle me to buy one Glock a year at the LEO discounted price.

 

I am looking at a G20SF (10MM) for this year's purchase.

Personally I would get a full sized gun for your first one in 9mm and a 22. You can always sell them later on.

 

When buying used, it helps to buy guns from companies that have a no bs warranty, like smith and Wesson, Springfield armory, or even Taurus.

 

I am sure there are others but did not deal with them directly on used guns.

 

M&P would be my choice, followed by sig 226, beretta 92 variety, glock. 19, steyer of the ones you gave above.

I say make the first purchase a good one. I will never sell my first, so I decided to get something that was uniquely attractive to me... something a bit more than utilitarian.

  • Author

Good stuff. Thanks for all of the info guys.

Seems like the only way to come across certified pre-owned (like a sig cpo) and LEO trade-ins are at the bigger stores. Wasn't sure if there was some sort of "central place" to find them.

 

Yeah I'm feeling the pressure (in a good way) on the first pistol. I thought it would take even longer than it did for my permits to come through so I didn't start renting anything until the other day.

  • Author

blksheep: I should have phrased my question better. I was wondering if anyone other than sig has a certified pre-owned program. But from what I'm gathering, an official "CPO" is hard enough to find at a local shop where I can actually handle and inspect it anyway.

I look at it exactly the same as cars, if you want to be sure of the history and have the full warranty you have to buy new. If you are comfortable with possibly fixing something out of your pocket and having some cosmetic dings buy used. A CPO gun is like a CPO car...pay a little more for the idea that an "expert" has looked it over.

 

I have about half of my collection purchased new.

 

My personal rule is buy used unless it's something specific that I can't find on the used market. Some stuff like my Springfield which was only $200 more new vs used, so in that case what the hell, go new.

I tried several 9MM and .45ACP at Shore Shot on two outings last year and decided on the Glock 19 for concealed carry and the G21SF for my all purpose pistol. The G19 is easy to conceal and with the Gen4 backstraps it was easy to get the right fit for my hand. The G21SF was also easier for me to grip than the regular frame G21.

 

I discovered that I could join the GSSF (Glock Shooting Sports Foundation) for $35 (renewals are $25) and that would entitle me to buy one Glock a year at the LEO discounted price.

 

I am looking at a G20SF (10MM) for this year's purchase.

 

Just read the details on this dicount for members. You have to have been a member for at least 1 year before you can take advantage of this discount. - Bummer, i was going to join just for the discount!

I joined last April and they changed the program on May 1, 2011. I ran out and bought the G21 before they changed the program. Now I just renewed so I should be getting the coupon for the next purchase. $491 is not bad for the G20 LEO kit with the 3 magazines.

I joined last April and they changed the program on May 1, 2011. I ran out and bought the G21 before they changed the program. Now I just renewed so I should be getting the coupon for the next purchase.

 

Guess you are one of the lucky's one. So just curious, what's the discount?

If a CPO is what interests you, you may want to give Jim Flynn a call. He sells a lot of Sigs and for a private dealer (as opposed to a big box) they would be more predisposed to giving him one than most LGS's. He may not be able to either, but it's worth a phone call and he would be more likely than most.

 

Adios,

 

Pizza Bob

Guess you are one of the lucky's one. So just curious, what's the discount?

 

The Glock 20 on the internet without shipping and tax is about $550. The GSSF price is $491 and instead of 2 magazines with the regular kit, you get 3. I sent out a notice last spring that they were changing the program so those who had PP's could purchase one before the program changed.

I have bought one new handgun so far, the other 11 were purchased used. If you laid them all side by side it would be very difficult to tell which pieces were purchased used. The gun I bought new has seen less than 200 rounds through it, some of the others have seen a few thousand since I bought them.

Generally speaking, how much cheaper are used handguns compared to new? For the ones I am looking at, they are only about a hundred cheaper than a new one. This is also a challenge when you buy online as it can be difficult to ascertain the condition of the gun just by the pictures or if it is going to feel right in your hands. I suppose you can go to a local store to see how it fits though.

For some reason I buy almost always new and I get lemons. Most who buy used get great guns. Go figure.

Generally speaking, how much cheaper are used handguns compared to new? For the ones I am looking at, they are only about a hundred cheaper than a new one. This is also a challenge when you buy online as it can be difficult to ascertain the condition of the gun just by the pictures or if it is going to feel right in your hands. I suppose you can go to a local store to see how it fits though.

 

Really it depends. If you're buying used at a local gun store, they're making more money in general on a used gun than on a new gun. Many of us do private party sales (ie sales between forum members) and there are some guys on here who buy high and sell low (and they know who they are). 1/4 of my collection was obtained direct from private parties. Just to note, 1/6 of my collection was bought new...

 

How much can you save used over new? Well, I bought two guns separately on gunbroker.com for under $20 each. Yes, they were 22 cal rifles, however, they were under $20. In general you're looking at between 50 and 150 bucks savings, unless you come across a huge deal which sometimes occurs. That said, I know I've got at least two guns for 50% of retail that were very good condition guns.

For some reason I buy almost always new and I get lemons. Most who buy used get great guns. Go figure.

 

Just to clarify what Ray is saying here is that he has bought new and bought new lemons, and has had to send them back to the manufacturer (sometimes multiple times) to get them "right" (or in his case "left").

If you have a knowledgeable friend to go with you to check out a used gun, it's a good way to save a few bucks. If not, I'd go new. If you don't know what to look for when buying a used gun, your chance of getting someones else's headache increase dramatically. Not saying a new one is gonna be perfect, but there should be no wear or abuse issues.

I buy mostly used from a dealer who warrentees the gun for a year and have their own gunsmith. Never had a problem.

Just to clarify what Ray is saying here is that he has bought new and bought new lemons, and has had to send them back to the manufacturer (sometimes multiple times) to get them "right" (or in his case "left").

 

It's happened on other guns too.

  • Author

All of the advice is appreciated. Gotta get back to the range and rent some more before deciding which 2 I'm going with.

 

btw- does anyone on here have an M&P 9mm? Is it just me or is that mag hard to load? I was shooting one at shore shot and that 10th round did not seem like it wanted to get in there!

If you have a knowledgeable friend to go with you to check out a used gun, it's a good way to save a few bucks. If not, I'd go new. If you don't know what to look for when buying a used gun, your chance of getting someones else's headache increase dramatically. Not saying a new one is gonna be perfect, but there should be no wear or abuse issues.

This. Or you can educate yourself. I assume the gunstore youre renting from can show you what to look for.

btw- does anyone on here have an M&P 9mm? Is it just me or is that mag hard to load? I was shooting one at shore shot and that 10th round did not seem like it wanted to get in there!

 

New double stack mags are sometimes difficult to load until they're broken in. In any case, an UP-Lula is a great device to help you load and will make the job of loading mags (almost) enjoyable.

Since there's no CCW in NJ I would get stainless steel.

Do you like plastic?

Do you like westerns?

Do you want something that can accept a 22LR slide?

Do you like recoil?

Do you like loud bangs?

My general rule for buying used or new is if I have to save at least $150-200 bucks or around 20% whichever is

greater to make it worthwhile. If the difference is not that much then it kinda makes sense to buy new. That being

said I have seen stuff that is maybe only 50-100 bucks cheaper used, however, it's pretty much in pristine condition

so in that case I think it's worth it.

 

Honestly most used guns are not really that used. Depends on your standards. To me 1000 rounds is broken in.

Even a 5000 round count doesn't bother me. All the parts you have to replace around there are cheap like recoil

springs and it's not a must that you have to.

 

I'd stick with 9mm only cause it's easy to shoot and it's cheap to shoot. If you get a 45 it's considerably more, pretty

much double to shoot which usually means you will only shoot half as much as you would in 9mm.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.