Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Vlad G

Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Vlad G

  1. I said no such thing Ray. In fact you should have a leg up on me having gone through bootcamp. The only thing that interests me here is IF I have bad habits that you do not because of my involvement in competitive shooting.
  2. Well apparently my threat worked, and people actually filled in the score sheets somewhat correctly. I should try acting menacing more often.
  3. Actually I MIGHT be able to make the 11th, give me a day or two to see if I can move my schedule around. 18th is completely out.
  4. Sure, because we are all lairs and cheaters now. At this point my only worry is not if I win or lose, but if it proves anything. I'm suspecting that whatever challenge will be presented at this point will be more of the "We'll show those competition guys!" then actually testing if presumed bad habits acquired in competition are actually going to get me killed. But whatever .. pick a different date please, the ones suggested don't work for me, and I'll show up.
  5. Neither for for me. On the 11th I have a family event, on the 18th I'm shooting the Team 3gun match in Topton. I made pretty friking clear what I meant by that statement. Don't try twisting what I said.
  6. Not a problem Joel, and we completely agree. I don't think any USPSA shooter should have false confidence that their gun skills will solve every problem, never stated anything like it. My ONLY issue is that somehow the skills you do acquire in competitive shooting are DETRIMENTAL. I never maintained they are complete, ideal, or even a good idea, but I object to the theory most people can't tell the difference and they will somehow hard wire themselves to make mistakes. The human race doesn't work that way, it never has. Evolution pretty much says that so far we are the MOST adaptable species and that by enlarge we react appropriately to new stimuli, even those outside our comfort zone and experience, otherwise we would slave labor for the cows, not the other way around.
  7. and 24 hour access to the indoor range, and being able to use the outdoor range when YOU want, not when there is a match, and paying less for the matches, and supporting on of the few places left in new jersey where you can actually shoot, etc.
  8. Good point I guess, I'm just not sure our political leadership is that smart, though I suppose they can stumble into it by sheer incompetence.
  9. To be honest I don't need to know what gun killed him. If that bit of information tells the enemy even the smallest bit of information about how the guys that go in harms way are armed or act, it isn't worth it. In all honesty I wish all the news (and senators, and VP's) would be a bit more quiet about all the various details involved. I don't need to know this ****, even if I want to, and it may endanger someones life later.
  10. Scores are up. See what happens when you guys actually fill the score sheets?
  11. Well Shane I don't pick up my brass as shoot and neither does any USPSA shooter I've ever seen. I guess why I'm having this conversation is because thorough this thread there have been quotes like this one from Tosser: He didn't say "might", he didn't say "will get you killed, unless you think about it", he didn't "will get you killed unless you also trained professionally". He didn't provide an example where that ever happened. That right there is a very dangerous quote. We all know that the average shooter will never attend a training class, nevermind the number of classes that it would take to achieve true competency. By your admission you agree that the gun games sharpens one's gun skills, and I'll add the ability to be SAFE or at least safer with a firearm. When average Joe reads "gun games will get you killed" and avoids participating in them while at the same time does not ge any former training, average Joe is less competent, less safe, and all around less prepared. The reason I take a strong issues with these statements is because they are a grave disservice to the average shooter, potentially endangering his life or that of those around him at a later point. My goal here is to provide a response to a blanket statement, an unsubstantiated one to my point of view, even if it is based on some sound theory. It sounds good in that theory, except you can't prove it happens. And then there was this: So I took up the offer. Not because I have anything to prove to anyone in particular and because frankly I plan to cheat. Yes I said CHEAT, because I have no intention to run a shoot house like I shoot a USPSA match. The implication from you and Tosser is that my muscle memory and the things I do in competition are so stuck to my brain that I can't do anything else. I'll like to test that theory. I've already offered that I mostly a USPSA shooter, with no formal training, not even informal training, and all my shooting skills come from USPSA. I am the IDEAL test subject for this theory. I should fail with resounding boom when my a** hits the ground. If you wish to retract the offer, so be it. I won't be running around reminding you about it, as long as you don't make blanked statements like the ones above. I walked half way the down the path here, stating that USPSA is not tactical training, and people who are interested should seek actual training. I even went and said that a lot of USPSA shooters do is not a good tactical plan. You guys walk the other half of the path and stop asking loaded questions like "Can gun games get you killed?" in which you state that they will without providing a single example, and admit that there aren't many other places the average Joe go can learn basic shooting skills and safe behavior and we part as "internet buddies".
  12. Joel, I don't strongly disagree with any particular point in great detail, but some in small detail. That however I think is besides the point, my position is testing 3ft defense against knives is besides the point in testing those issues. Yes I shouldn't quit until the attacker is dead, but as I refuse to actually shoot you with real bullets if you try to stab me in a mock fight, that isn't a particularly good way to test if I quit early or not. The assumption made here is that I can't break those habits, and I can't adapt. I won't for a second disagree with you that USPSA doesn't give a crap about concealment and I never said that is a good idea in a fight. But what Shane and Tosser, and I guess you, are saying is that because I don't use concealment or cover in a game I won't do it real life, or in a scenario approximating real life. You are saying that I will only shoot twice, so mix up your targets with the kind that fall after a number of rounds I'm not aware of. You assume I quit because I flub a stage, and boy is that not me, so lets try it out. You are saying that skills taught by gun games are completely unrelated to real life. Are you saying that shooting fast and accurate is not related to real life? Come up with a shooting test of your choosing (not a wrestling one, as that has nothing to do with my supposed bad habits) that test that theory. Shane said he shoots informal matches designed to stress those points. I'm interested in shooting those, with real guns or guns that recoil like real guns, not airsoft pistols, or wrestling matches, they don't answer the question posed.
  13. That wasn't me. Shane and Tosser said that I must have them because I'm a competition shooter. I want to test that theory. Those are the bad habits I refer to.
  14. Those are GREAT questions Joel, but the hell do they have to do with my bad habits? I may LACK certain skills related to self defense, and I never claimed I had them. The question is are bad habits specifically inherited from competition shooting a DETRIMENT? I'm not arguing that competition shooting is not training, never have. The question we are trying to resolve here is one of my bad ingrained habits getting me killed. Odds are you take someone not trained in fighting against knifes they will lose regardless of a competition background or not. What does your test prove exactly in the context of this question?
  15. For the record this is about gun games, not knifes. I'll take experience with anything, but I'm not sure this is the point of this exercise. The question here is IF my bad USPSA habits will get me killed. Presumably this is about bad habits with a firearm, not about my skill in deploying a pocket knife. While that sure is an interesting training topic, lets keep this to a test of firearm use, including cover, etc, or whatever is supposed to get me killed. Shane and Tosser (or maybe just Shane) mentioned that they made up their own rules for firearm practice which are more realistic then the games are play. I'm interested how I perform at those tests, not in how fast I can punch or stab someone. The topic here is about bad habits from gun games, not about my 3 herniated disks, I'm not really sure what that would prove in context of this conversation.
  16. BTW, I wont entertained much conversation of Top Shot, just like won't discuss a hypothetical performance of Les Stroud on CBS's Survivor, so lets keep this on the topic at hand.
  17. Sure, whatever and whoever, just not whenever as I do have a life. Lets make this happen. Although I though competition was going to harm me, so why would Ray be at a disadvantage for not having any competition experience.
  18. In my experience the top dogs are extremely stressed at that level of competition. Not only are they driven people who want to win and who have serious competition to contend with, they often have to also worry about representing their sponsors. They are however good at dealing with stress.
  19. Ok, and I will grant that I am not a shooter at that level. JJ could beat me any day with a muzzleloader, with a broken knee, and a hand in a cast, so presumably I also can't change gears like he can, my habits should be well engrained after 10 years of USPSA. Tosser offered an experiment and I think it is a useful one. By your rules, with you and him as judges, lets find out if equally untrained by professionals shooters are going to be harmed more because of the USPSA skills or lack thereof. If my bad habits will get me killed, then Ray should "score" better by whatever standards you establish. I would fully expect that professionally trained people such as yourself and Tosser would perform better, I've never debated they usefulness of training. Your point here and in other threads is that my bad habits will be an DISADVANTAGE.
  20. When did I ever say that? Go back and read all my posts and quote where I EVER said it does? You are changing the subject towards a point I took as a given: gun games are not training. The topic however is if my game bad habits will get me killed.
  21. I think his point is that their USPSA bad habits don't automatically cause bad habits in IDPA, which you hold as more realistic.
  22. Just in case anyone thinks I'm some sort of ace trying to stack the deck here, I'm not. I'm a decent USPSA shooter but far from a top shooter, I'm basically a B class shooter who stumbled into A class, I'm an overweight, middle aged computer programer, with NO formal training. I'm not offering to undergo this test because I'm hoping to show off to Shane and Tosser in a vain hope to humiliate them at their own game. I'm genuinely interested in this experiment, and gladly post the results here afterwards.
  23. I have no hard feelings towards anyone Ray, no worries. My point is the original statement, in its essence, is that my bad USPSA habits will get me killed. My position is that while I have no doubt that train professionals will perform better then me, given the choice between shooting USPSA and not shooting USPSA, by the professionals rules, which one of us will get killed MORE in a scenario of their choosing. I think that would be an interesting experiment.
  24. How about it Shane and Tosser, I have no formal training, and I don't know if Ray does or does not. I have bad USPSA habits, he doesn't. Do you want to run us both through the same shoot house, score us fairly, and see who is better or worse? If my bad habits get me killed more then his lack of bad USPSA habits? I have no doubt that both you are better then me, after all you train at this specific scenario all the time, where I don't. But lets compare a non-USPSA shooter to a USPSA shooter.
  25. Oh, I have no doubt I'll get my a** kicked, I would expect nothing else in someone elses house, me with no formal training. The question is how badly. I'm used to having my a** kicked by better shooters so that doesn't scare me.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.